We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

Leader’s responses to Senators

Summary

The Leader says the Government will continue seeking British bombing files and responds briefly to requests concerning social media, childcare, health-accountability oversight and other matters.

The Leader of the Opposition, Senator Darragh O'Brien, and other Senators raised the all-party motion on the Dublin and Monaghan bombings that was passed in the other House six years ago. The Government has sought on a number of occasions - as did, I presume, the previous Government - the relevant documentation from the British Government and the Taoiseach has sought it from the British Prime Minister. The Government will continue to try to obtain the relevant documentation, which the British Government is not currently releasing. I assure the House that the Government will continue to press this matter with the British Government.

A number of Senators raised the question of the negative publicity arising from the Garth Brooks debacle. Short-term, knee-jerk reactions, especially regarding planning legislation, will not provide a viable solution to the problem. In light of the current controversy, it appears that certain aspects of the current regulations require review, in particular, the timeline requirements for the submission of applications by event organisers, the deciding of such applications by the relevant planning authority in advance of an event or a series of events, and the absence of a specific appeals mechanism in respect of decisions on event licences, which is an issue a number of Senators raised. Judicial review is an avenue that can be pursued.

In light of the current controversy, the Taoiseach has requested the Minister for the Environment, Community and Local Government to conduct a review of the planning regulations with a view to preventing a scenario arising in future similar to that which has arisen with regard to the Garth Brooks concerts. A great deal of time and effort has been put into bringing this event to Ireland, including by businesses such as hotels and bars, and large numbers of people from abroad had planned to attend the concerts. A great deal of work is invested in trying to attract this type of business to the country, and in that respect it is an absolute disgrace that this has happened.

A number of Senators raised the current conflict in Israel and Palestine and the unacceptable atrocities that have taken place in recent weeks. I will accede to the request to invite the Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade to the House to set out the Government's position on the conflict and outline the European response.

Senator Darragh O'Brien called for a report on the progress made in the pyrite remediation scheme. As the quarterly review of the scheme is due soon, we will probably arrange to discuss the matter in September.

Senator Bacik raised some of the same issues as Senator O'Brien and called for a debate on child care. She also welcomed the announcement that after-school child care is to be extended and commended all the individuals involved in the Advocacy Initiative.

Senator Zappone raised the report of the Seanad Public Consultation Committee on human rights. I compliment the Senator on her input into the report and I will ask the Minister for Justice and Equality to comment on it. It is good that United Nations publications note that the Seanad has spoken on this matter. I will request the Minister's attendance for a debate on the concluding observations of the United Nations when they become available.

Senator O'Donovan referred to the removal of the SOLAS training allowance and spoke about advocacy services for deaf people, as did a number of other Senators. I will not amend the Order of Business to have a Minister come before the House to discuss this issue today as it can be addressed at any time, with a Minister present, if the Senator raises it on the Adjournment.

Senator Hayden referred to the necessity to implement the recommendations of the report on mortgage arrears. I fully concur with her and hope it will be possible to have the relevant Minister come before the House to discuss the report and its recommendations.

Senator Quinn spoke about the possibility of having information provided online to notify people of where tax revenue is spent. I recall the Senator raising this matter with the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Brendan Howlin, last year. He also noted that a significant number of job vacancies are not being filled, despite the fact that 400,000 people are unemployed.

Senator Comiskey welcomed figures on investment in farm buildings, which augur well for the future of farming.

Senator Cullinane referred to hospital waiting lists. While some people have been waiting for up to two years, the position has improved significantly since the Minister for Health, Deputy Reilly, took office. One need only recall the waiting lists in place when he took office. A difficulty has arisen in filling consultant posts. While the Senator argues that consultants are paid too much, consultants argue that they are not paid enough and suggest that this explains the failure to fill 20% of posts.

I agree that something must be done to address the matter.

Comment on this

They are paid 52% more than their counterparts.

Comment on this

Senator Leyden spoke about the Data Protection Commissioner warning about social media content and I agree with his remarks. Senator van Turnhout spoke about child care and after-school care, and she also gave her views on the next person to fill the portfolio of EU Commissioner. I am sure the Government is working on that as we speak. Senator Colm Burke referred to the €3.7 billion paid to various health organisations and the health committee not being allowed to examine these. That is a matter for the Committee of Public Accounts and the health committee, and I have no wish to get involved in the arguments. I am sure they can sort it out between themselves.

Senator Mullen spoke about the television licence fee. The Minister has indicated that information should be used by An Post to identify licence fee evaders, and licence fee evasion is an ongoing scourge, as we know. We estimate the proportion of people not paying their television licence fee is running at over 15%, and that is more than three times the rate of our nearest neighbour. That means approximately €25 million to €30 million of potential revenue for RTE is lost annually, as the objective of the television licence system is to fund public service broadcasting. The revenue lost through fee evasion has an immediate impact on the quality of service which can be provided and it also creates inequality between compliant licence holders and evaders. As long ago as 2004, the Comptroller and Auditor General highlighted the fact that there was no legal obligation on cable or satellite television service suppliers to inform An Post of the names and addresses of persons availing of services. Given that ComReg estimates that over 73% of television households have such services, this measures should significantly reduce the level of evasion. An Post will have access to the information solely for this statutory function related to television licence fee collections and the commercial confidentiality of the information will be safeguarded. With this proposal, the licence fee inspection and collection system can enter the 21st century.

The remaining Senators raised matters which I have already addressed. Senator Bradford spoke about the political position in Northern Ireland and I will endeavour to have the Taoiseach come here to discuss the matter in early course. Senator Heffernan spoke about the work of the Leader organisations, which should certainly be lauded for their past work. I am sure the work will be continued by the local development organisations with an input under the local authority umbrella. We have had comprehensive debates in the House on this matter over the last year and when the appropriate Bills came before the House.

I must mention my colleagues, including Senator White. Fianna Fáil has a bit of a brass neck to speak about cuts.

Comment on this