Transparent State board appointments
Senator Ivana Bacik seeks a debate on democratic and public-sector reforms, especially the new transparent system for State board appointments, while acknowledging it is overdue. Members exchange accusations over past appointments, political hypocrisy and the McNulty controversy; Bacik also seeks discussion of lobbying regulation, parliamentary inquiries, Ombudsman powers and the proposed ethics legislation.
Last week I requested a debate on delivering democratic reform in the light of the revised models for appointments to State boards which had been agreed to by the Cabinet and the subject of widespread approval.
Comment on this
They are belated. Following 14 years of Fianna Fáil in government, they certainly are belated.
Comment on this
Ministers will still have the final say, so what is proposed will not make any difference.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil was in government for 14 years and did not take action. Those opposite said nothing during that entire period.
Comment on this
I entirely agree that what has been brought forward is belated.
Comment on this
Those in government told us it was wrong, but they continued to do it.
Comment on this
It is ironic that members of the political party that has been in power the longest during the lifetime of the State are arguing that these measures are belated. That party did nothing in respect of this matter.
Comment on this
Those in government did not appoint a sufficient number of people.
Comment on this
I would like an opportunity to make my point, which is uncontroversial. This is the first time in the history of the State that there will finally be a need for Cabinet approval for an objective and transparent system of appointments to State boards.
Comment on this
These are panic measures for the by-elections.
Comment on this
Saying we were worse is not much of a defence.
Comment on this
The Senator's party took no action at all.
Comment on this
I think Mr. McNulty would disagree entirely with what is being said.
Comment on this
Fianna Fáil has never been very good when it comes to free speech.
Comment on this
Slow learners. Some people never learn; that is the truth about Fianna Fáil. I urge colleagues on both sides of the House to look at the website stateboards.ie which, for the first time, is to provide a one-stop shop to ensure transparent appointments to State boards and which will detail candidate specifications, including relevant experience and other criteria. It is hugely important that we will see this reform.
I have expressed my own concerns about the appointment of Mr. McNulty. As such, I do not want to go back over that issue.
Comment on this
However, it is hugely important and significant that we now have in place a proper and transparent system for appointing the members of State boards. If we are having this debate, we should look at the other reforms the Government has brought forward, for example, extending the Ombudsman's jurisdiction and powers and reforming the system of parliamentary inquiries, even in the wake of the defeat of the referendum in 2011. We will regulate lobbying through the Registration of Lobbying Bill which is going through the Oireachtas. Again, for the first time in the history of the State, it will introduce a register of lobbying. This is hugely important and something which has been called for by NGOs for many years. We have restored freedom of information legislation and reversed Fianna Fáil's attempts to dismantle the freedom of information system, about which my colleagues on the other side have probably forgotten. They sought to dismantle a system which had originally been introduced by the former Labour Party Minister of State, Ms Eithne Fitzgerald. We have put in place protected disclosures legislation to protect whistleblowers and are preparing an ethics Bill to overhaul ethics legislation.
Comment on this
This is a party political broadcast.
Comment on this
Does she have a question for the Leader?
Comment on this
Yes, I do. I had asked the question of the Leader, but some Members were shouting too loudly.
Comment on this
I ask the Senator not to respond to Members across the floor. Does she have a question for the Leader?
Comment on this
I asked the question of the Leader at the start, but I was drowned out.
Comment on this
Who were the judges appointed today? We have not yet heard their names.
Comment on this
I asked the Leader for a debate on the democratic reform process being brought forward, including some aspects that had already been introduced and, in particular, items such as the ethics Bill, which is yet to be brought before the House. We should have a debate on all of these reforms. It would be very useful to have the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, Deputy Brendan Howlin, in the House to discuss this broad ranging programme of public reform that he is leading.
Comment on this
Would he be able to explain how he had appointed so many people to jobs on his own State boards without advertising them? There were 14 appointments and no advertisements.