We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

Debate on historical child abuse

Summary

Senators support a debate on credible abuse allegations, urging ministerial accountability, proper reporting channels and State support for survivors.

I will begin by supporting Senator Darragh O'Brien's request for a debate on child abuse. This is something that is better discussed in the open. It is something that unfortunately I know too much about, being from County Wexford and from the diocese of Ferns. The natural instinct for every institution is to cover it up. That is always the wrong thing to do. I support the call for the Minister for Justice and Equality, or the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs, whomever is the appropriate Minister, to come to the House and for that debate to be held. It could be worthwhile for us to do so.

Water is the issue of the moment, about which there is no question. I am a little perplexed at the fact that we are looking at a net figure for water of €175 million. This is on top of other charges and on top of the pain that has come previously but, as Senator Darragh O'Brien has discussed on many occasions, the VAT reduction to 9% for the hospitality sector was paid for out of people's pensions. That amount of money was multiple times the amount that will be taken for water but it got no coverage. Fine Gael did say before the general election that we intended to do that which, again, Senator Darragh O'Brien has acknowledged on a number of occasions in the past. However, I am amazed and perplexed at how an amount of money several times more than that required for water can be taken per annum with no conversation whatsoever about it.

I also wish to raise the issue of the desecration of the grave of a former Taoiseach, Mr. W. T. Cosgrave. Not alone was he Taoiseach but his son was also a Taoiseach and his grandson was a Member of this Chamber, formerly Cathaoirleach and also a Member of the Dáil. I cannot condemn this enough. It is disgusting and scandalous that anybody would do that to anybody's grave. Being a politician is somewhat irrelevant, but given that this man was one of the giants of 20th century Irish history, this act should be condemned in the most severe manner. It is a scandal for that to have happened and even worse, to some degree, on the same occasion that the Taoiseach is launching a book about W. T. Cosgrave.

Comment on this

The recent allegations of child abuse are not allegations at all, as they are very credible. I am concerned to hear Maíria Cahill talking about taking calls from other survivors and victims of abuse and that she is being put in this position. I ask the State to clarify where information should be brought. We all know it should be brought to the Child and Family Agency and to the Garda, but this question must be addressed, particularly in the context of abuse that has happened in the past, and what supports will be provided by the State to survivors of such abuse.

Yes, we need to talk about an inquiry, but we also need to talk about immediacy. We know when every one of these events happens that there are people who are hurting all over this State and who need to given clear direction in terms of where they should go.

Where is the stalled Children First Bill? It has been on Committee Stage in the Dáil for the past year. As I am a member of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Health and Children, I know it is not in the plan. We have an obligation to ensure we put the child protection code into our statutory system.

I wish to mention the forthcoming publication of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Bill 2013, particularly in the context of initiatives that I have been working on since my appointment to the Seanad, such as tackling the proliferation of child abuse material, legislative guidance on the disclosure of children's confidential sexual assault counselling notes - it was promised in the House that this would be included in the Bill - and measures that might be taken to reduce the demand for human trafficking of adults and children. On the latter point, I commend the Minister for Justice and Equality, Deputy Frances Fitzgerald, for her comments and the commitments she made at the EU Anti-Trafficking Day organised by the Immigrant Council of Ireland in the Mansion House last Friday. On that occasion she said she would examine very carefully the potential of legislation criminalising the purchase of sex. I particularly welcome her commitment in light of the Seanad motion that we, the Taoiseach's nominees, tabled back in October 2012 calling on the Government to criminalise the purchase of sex in Ireland in order to curb prostitution and trafficking. The same express recommendation was made by the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Justice, Defence and Equality in its comprehensive report on prostitution law in Ireland published in June 2013. The general scheme of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Bill was due to be published in January 2014. More recently we have been told that it will be published this session. I ask the Leader for clarification on when exactly the Bill will be published. Has the general scheme of the Bill been approved by the Cabinet? Since I have come to this House I have been told that all the answers to my queries will be in the Bill and I await its publication.

Comment on this