We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

Banking inquiry and mortgage rates

Summary

Senators criticise Jean-Claude Trichet’s appearance before the banking inquiry and discuss the burden of high variable mortgage rates. The inquiry’s work and its forthcoming questioning of Mr. Trichet are welcomed.

I quote from The Scarlet Pimpernel:

They seek him here, they seek him there

[They] seek him everywhere

Is he in heaven or is he in hell?

That damned elusive Pimpernel

Today, we see the very elusive Scarlet Pimpernel of European banking, Mr. Jean-Claude Trichet, appear, but not appear, before the banking inquiry. He is in Kilmainham and will answer some questions from members of the Joint Committee of Inquiry into the Banking Crisis. It is quite amazing that the European Central Bank is displaying such arrogance and disregard for the Irish Government and Irish people. We were told it did not appear before national parliaments, but it does. It appeared before the Italian finance committee and answered questions from and yet it refused to appear before our inquiry. That is the arrogance of the European Central Bank and the Scarlet Pimpernel of that institution, Mr. Jean-Claude Trichet.

The Government has been given, to put it diplomatically, the two fingers not only by the European Central Bank but also by the Irish banks, some of which have said they will not reduce the variable mortgage interest rate despite the Government's promise to deploy the four horses of the apocalypse if they did not. The Bank of Ireland and Ulster Bank have said they will not do so. The Government's mettle is now being tested. It is being asked again to stand up for the Irish people and impose the levies or bring in the legislation that would force the banks to reduce the rate. Will the Government do it? The track record shows that it probably will not.

A leading bank CEO is getting paid €365,000 per year, or €7,000 per week or €1,000 per day, for doing a job in the same bank he was in charge of when the whole thing fell apart. We will not name him.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the Senator.

Comment on this

I did not want to be ruled out of order for naming Richie. Individuals with a variable rate mortgage of €200,000 must pay an extra €6,000 per year because of the variable rate and because the Government will not stand up for them. Would they not love one week's wages of that bank CEO to pay back the money he is robbing from them because the Government will not stand up for them?

Will the Government-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator should not use the word "robbing" in relation to a person he has already identified.

Comment on this

All right. He is not robbing it; he is taking it legally. The Government said he should not do it, so I hope it will bring in legislation to ensure this activity is regarded as robbing.

I praise TG4 for an excellent documentary it showed last night on the life of Tom Barry, an extraordinary gentlemen whose father was in the RIC. He was in the British Army himself and was serving in Iraq when he heard about the 1916 Rising. He was involved in the War of Independence and had such regard for Michael Collins that Mr. Collins's family asked him to give the speech at the unveiling of a monument to Mr. Collins. He spoke about the tragedy of the Civil War. TG4's excellent documentary was a great exposé of information regarding the famous ambush at Kilmichael. Mr. Peter Hart, the author of what could only be described as a tissue of lies and a book of fraud, should apologise to the families of those involved in the Kilmichael ambush for making up what has now been revealed to have been an absolute falsehood. He did an extreme disservice to Tom Barry and the boys of Kilmichael. The record was put straight last night, thanks to TG4.

Comment on this

Sing the song.

Comment on this

I would not invite Senator Daly to sing a song.

Comment on this

The Senator obviously heard me singing previously. I do not want to clear the Seanad. My singing voice has the same effect as tear gas.

Comment on this

The Senator said it. We do not want to see the Seanad cleared for any reason.

I commend the members of the banking inquiry. Like everybody else, I am looking forward to the question and answer session with Mr. Jean-Claude Trichet this afternoon. I am delighted, as we all should be, that the members of the banking inquiry will get an opportunity to question Mr. Trichet on his role in the events surrounding the bank guarantee and subsequent bailout. That is very important. Anyone who heard Senator Susan O'Keeffe on the radio this morning discussing this will understand why the format being adopted is being adopted. It is very welcome.

I join with other colleagues who spoke yesterday to condemn the executions for drugs offences of a number of individuals which were carried out in Indonesia, and I also condemn capital punishment more generally. Ireland has been a leader on this, as has the Council of Europe. It is very distressing to see executions continue to be carried out not only in Indonesia but across some US states and in Russia and China, the other countries in which we see the largest numbers of people executed.

I ask the Leader for a debate on enhancing the amenities of Dublin as a capital of culture and a city to which people are drawn from all over the world. I ask for that in keeping with a number of developments. There have been a good deal of resources devoted by the Government to developing Dublin's amenities, particularly in the lead up to the centenary commemorations next year. I am particularly pleased to see reports in today's newspaper about 14 Henrietta Street, which will be opened next year as a museum of tenement life and to which €1.5 million has been allocated. I know Senator Norris will have a particular interest in this.

Comment on this