Drink-driving conviction disparities
Senator Burke questions why drink-driving conviction rates vary from below 20% to above 68% across the country and calls for investigation.
An article in today's edition of The Irish Times on drink driving convictions states that in some parts of the country the conviction rate is below 20%, while in others the average conviction rate is higher than 68%. This raises very serious questions about how summonses are prosecuted, including whether there is a defect in the manner in which they are presented by the Garda, whether there is a defect in how they are being dealt with by the courts or whether we have an extremely efficient and hardworking legal profession in some parts of the country and not in others. There are serious questions that need to be asked about this matter. It is appropriate that it be debated in the House. I acknowledge that there are some changes proposed in this area, but there are questions about this issue that need to be answered quickly. I have defended cases successfully in the District Court because that is my job. However, it must be borne in mind that in many road traffic accidents a person may have lost a mother, a father, a son or a daughter because the driver of one car was over the legal alcohol limit. We must address this matter in the fastest possible way to ensure appropriate penalties are imposed on persons caught driving while above the legal alcohol limit. As we approach Christmas, the current message is that the risk is worth taking.
That is the one concern I have. We are approaching that time of the year when people need to be more careful and should not be taking risks. While I have no objection to them having a drink, I have a problem with people drinking and driving. It is something of which we need to be conscious. We should have a debate with the Minister for Justice and Equality who should give some explanation for the wide variation in conviction rates across the country.