We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Legal Services Regulation Bill 2011: Committee Stage

Contributions 110–238 of 238. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Legal Services Regulation Bill 2011
Enacted

No. 58 of 2011 ›

Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 61 to 67, inclusive, and 93 are related and may be discussed together, by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I wish to go through these amendments. Basically, these are the Parts of the Bill that deal with the range of areas concerning the efforts the authority will make to facilitate resolution of complaints. For example, amendment No. 61 permits the authority to seek resolution of complaints relating to inadequate service. Amendment No. 62 allows the authority to consider excessive costs. The purpose of amendment No. 63 is to set up a mechanism within the regulatory authority to enable a review committee to consider reviews requested by a party to a determination of the authority under sections 51 or 52 and it lays down the membership of that review. Amendment No. 64 allows the authority the power to offer assistance where it is considered that the conduct of the legal practitioners could constitute misconduct. In this regard, I note that I may table a further amendment on Report Stage with regard to the definition of misconduct that will apply and perhaps in respect of some related matters. For the information of Members, I also intend to table some further amendments on Report Stage to deal with the legal issues regarding the precise transition arrangements, new regimes and cut-off dates as to when the new definitions of misconduct etc. will apply. I will deal with this on Report Stage. Amendment No. 66 is about the admissibility of various statements and amendment No. 67 inserts a new section 57, which specifies that the authority shall prepare and publish guidelines on the manner in which the resolution of complaints by informal means may be conducted.

I stated at the outset of this debate that when it comes to considering complaints, there will be a form of triage system. In the first instance, one must establish whether the complaint is admissible and I have said quite a bit about that. Second, there will be a triage system and then there will be the assessment of the complaint. This may or may not go to the disciplinary tribunal and this section is to describe how the resolution of complaints by informal means will be conducted. Senator Barrett will appreciate why I cannot accept his proposed amendment No. 93. As it is set out, it would defeat access to the informal resolution of excessive fee complaints it is intended to make available to the public under the current text of the Bill. The purpose of the informal complaints track is to provide an alternative to the taxation of costs, as this can be a costly or cumbersome option for members of the public to pursue. This informal option does not prevent a legal practitioner from being subject to a complaint of misconduct about grossly excessive fees. I hope that clarifies matters.

Comment on this

As Minister stated, this pertains to setting up the procedure to deal with the costs aspects. If there is a known referee, the Taxing Master as was, and the chief legal costs adjudicator, it might help the process to be able to state that while the two parties can continue having this argument, the adjudication is that costs were X amount. It is a suggestion to the Minister that it may be useful to have a referee present. Would this prevent prolonged discussions, if the two parties could identify a person who can give them a verdict on this matter and could decide to not use up valuable legal time having debates about it? It would be great to have a referee who would be available to be frequented, were the parties to so desire, and it is a question of whether to point them in that direction. I will not press the amendment but that which I have outlined is the idea behind it. We have a service that can solve these disputes by stating the bill is X and has been independently adjudicated and this might short-circuit longer debates and arguments. However, I will not move the amendment and I thank the Minister for her response.

Comment on this

It might be helpful were I to inform the Senator that the legal services regulatory authority, LRSA, will have the potential to refer directly. Consequently, this can be done to the new body that replaces the Taxing Master.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

I wish to ask a question of the Minister. Members are being snowed under with paper and, in that context, I hope I am reading the amendment booklets correctly. Amendment No. 63 provides for the make-up of the review committee and outlines the work it will do. Will it be necessary to make provision for a reporting timescale for such reviews? The amendment makes provision for who will sit on the review committee, its make-up and so on. Is there an indication here or elsewhere as to a timeframe for the review committee to make a recommendation? Could such a timeframe be considered?

Comment on this

I would be inclined to leave that to the management of the legal services regulatory authority. Obviously, these reviews could vary in terms of substance in that some could be relatively straightforward whereas others might be more complicated. It will consist of three members, two of whom shall be lay members. Where the complaint refers to a solicitor, one member of the committee shall be a solicitor, while where the complaint relates to a barrister, one member shall be a barrister. The eligibility is also outlined. In respect of the range of tasks with which this body must deal, I must state my reluctance to consider changes. Perhaps this matter should be examined as part of the two-year review, when one will be able to see how many cases were referred, what was the scale involved, whether there was a question of reviews backing up or something similar and whether a new method or more people were needed on the review committee. I suggest this might be best done after the two-year review.

Comment on this
Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 68 to 73, inclusive, and Nos. 94 to 96, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

This group of amendments deals with the establishment and procedures of a new complaints committee. Amendment No. 68 is a key provision which obliges the authority to refer a complaint to the complaints committee where it has determined that the complaint is an admissible complaint, and we have already discussed the range of areas where a complaint can be made or where the matter has not been resolved in accordance with the informal procedures. This amendment deals with the way that will be handled. The membership of the complaints committee is outlined in detail.

Amendment No. 70 inserts a new section 60 relating to the investigation of complaints referred by the authority to a divisional committee. It gives details of the exact procedures that must be followed when referring the authority to the divisional committee and the duties of a divisional committee regarding an investigation. Where the committee considers that the complaint could be resolved under sections 51 or 52, it shall refer the complaint to the authority for further action. The options available to the divisional committee are spelt out in the legislation also. There is also a subsection that provides that where the committee considers that the act or omission warrants the imposition of a sanction, it may issue a direction to the legal practitioner to take such measures as the committee considers appropriate. It goes into all the details of how complaints will be dealt with, the sanctions that can apply, the action that can be taken and the way the committee will work.

There is a list of measures which may be imposed by the committee. I would bring the attention of Senators to those, a number of which I will read out. They include a direction to the practitioner to perform or complete the legal service concerned; a direction to arrange for the completion of the legal service; a direction to complete specified modules of continuing professional development, which is looking at the professional development issue; a direction to the practitioner to put aside all fees that were associated with the legal service; a direction to the practitioner to refund all or some of the fees already paid for the legal service; a direction to the practitioner to take any other action in the interest of the complainant; a direction to withdraw or amend an advertisement; a direction to pay a sum not exceeding €5,000 as compensation; a direction to pay to the authority a sum to cover the costs of the investigation; and a direction to pay to the authority an additional sum where the practitioner did not co-operate with the committee. A range of issues are dealt with in those measures. There is also the section that deals with appeals to the disciplinary tribunal by legal practitioners against determination of the divisional committee or a sanction imposed by a divisional committee.

Section 63 provides that the authority shall, every six months, which I believe is an appropriate timeframe, publish a report outlining the number and type of complaints received, which is why I said there is transparency in this Bill; the nature and outcome of the complaints; the number of complaints referred to the complaints committee; and the number of those complaints which were determined by the complaints committee, including details on sanctions imposed.

While I appreciate the intentions behind Senator Barrett's amendments, I do not propose to accept them because the number of members and the divisions of the new complaints committee of the Regulatory Authority is intended to facilitate the efficient processing of the thousands of complaints that will come before the Regulatory Authority based on current caseloads. Halving the committee's membership along the lines proposed would immediately create a backlog about which I would be concerned. This section goes into detail on how complaints are being dealt with, the responsibilities of various committees, the issues that can be dealt with and the sanctions that can be imposed. It deals with all the relevant issues around those provisions. As Senator Barrett can see, this list of issues and sanctions is strong and supportive of consumers who may have concerns about the kind of legal service they have received.

Comment on this

On amendment No. 68, under the new complaints regime, and I may have misinterpreted the Minister, there will not be 27 people hearing the case. Do the 27 divide the work among them? Is it the case that the 27 people handle all the complaints but do not hear them all? Is there a smaller committee to do the work because 27, including eight solicitors and four barristers, seems a cumbersome body.

Comment on this

The complaints committee consists of 27 members, the majority of whom will be lay people. The law society shall have eight members. The Bar Council have four. Members are appointed for a period of four years and shall be eligible for reappointment. Lay members must be independent of the professional bodies but have some expertise or knowledge of the provisions of legal service or maintenance of standards in an organisation.

Comment on this

Is it intended that all 27 will be there?

Comment on this

No, just available.

Comment on this

That is not the intention.

Comment on this

To answer the Senator's question in more detail, I should have said that the Bill provides that the complaints committee shall act in divisions of not less than three and not more than five members but must have an uneven number and a majority of lay members.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this
Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

I thank the Minister for that clarification.

Comment on this
Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 74 to 92, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

This is a long series of amendments which relate to a core aspect of the complaints and discipline elements of Part 5 – the legal practitioners disciplinary tribunal.

A new section 64 is inserted by Amendment No. 74. That is providing for the establishment, in law, of the new legal practitioners disciplinary tribunal. Unlike the existing disciplinary framework where each legal profession has its own disciplinary tribunal, the new tribunal will deal, from the enactment of the Bill, with the professional conduct of both solicitors and barristers.

Amendment No. 75 inserts a new section 65 into the Bill. The new section being inserted under this amendment largely replicates the existing section 63 of the Bill. It increases the threshold of membership and that better reflects the combined workload of the existing tribunals under which each panel of three averages ten meetings per year. The initially proposed membership of 16 would have been inadequate to deal with the new disciplinary tribunal's anticipated workload and I would have been afraid that would have led to a backlog of cases.

Another key change made under this amendment is that each division of the disciplinary tribunal shall be not less than three persons. The existing text of the Bill had provided in addition that each division should not be more than five members. However, having considered this aspect further, it was decided that for the sake of consistency of procedure and fairness all divisions of the tribunal should be of three persons.

Amendment No. 76 is similar to what was in place previously. It corresponds to section 64 of the Bill as passed by the Dáil and Second Stage of which was passed by the Seanad.

Amendment No. 77 inserts a new section 67 which expands the existing two-line provision in the Bill as passed by the Dáil to take account of additional functions - the ones I have outlined - that will now be carried out by the disciplinary tribunal. These will include, for example, appeals from the regulatory authority or from the Law Society to the tribunal in relation to determinations or sanctions, about which we have just spoken, that the complaints committee might put in place.

It will also include appeals by a legal practitioner against a determination or sanction made against him or her by the complaints committee. For its part, the complaints committee will also be able to refer matters to the disciplinary tribunal where it considers this appropriate.

Amendment No. 78 inserts a new section. This amendment is necessary to allow for the fact that the legal services regulatory authority and the Law Society will present evidence to the new legal practitioners disciplinary tribunal grounding the contention that there has been misconduct by a legal practitioner. Whereas the legal services regulatory authority will do so in relation to public complaints, including those where it requests a financial report about a solicitor from the Law Society, the Law Society will do so in relation to matters that have come to its attention in overseeing the solicitor accounts regulations. They will deal with different elements.

Section 69 is with regard to the regulations that will need to be made for an effectively functioning disciplinary tribunal, with some slight adjustments to allow leeway for parties besides the regulatory authority and the legal practitioner concerned to make submissions to the disciplinary tribunal.

Amendment No. 80 is quite long but is largely the same as its precursor, which is section 69 of the Bill as passed by the Dáil. It contains a suite of supporting powers which enable the legal services regulatory authority to enforce attendance at its hearings, to compel the discovery under oath or affirmation of documents and to sanction obstructive or unco-operative behaviour, including by imprisonment or fine. However, there is one new subsection, which enables the Law Society to come within the remit of the disciplinary tribunal in the prosecution of financial infringements which come to its attention under its retained financial regulatory role.

Amendment No. 81 reflects section 69 of the Bill and sets out the steps to be taken by the disciplinary tribunal in holding an inquiry, with regard to how it deals with witnesses, takes evidence and takes advice. There are new additional provisions in the new version of the section, which cover those cases in which the legal services regulatory authority will make appeals to the tribunal against determinations or sanctions imposed by a division of the complaints committee. In other words, the additions to the original section 69 now found in section 71 are there to facilitate the new and additional appellate functions of the disciplinary tribunal.

Amendment No. 82 inserts a new section 72 into the Bill. This reiterates what was in the Dáil in section 70. It sets out the range of sanctions that can be applied by the legal practitioners disciplinary tribunal. One can see as we go through the Bill that in each case one must describe how each body deals with complaints, the complaints it can handle, the sanctions it can impose and whether there is the possibility of the decisions of one body being appealed by another. This section examines the role of the disciplinary tribunal which, as I have stated, will take over from the two committees which previously dealt with disciplinary issues. We will now have one body, namely, the legal practitioners disciplinary tribunal.

Amendment No. 83 deals with appeals against a decision of the disciplinary tribunal.

Amendment No. 84 relates to appeals to the High Court, and leaves the menu of sanctions that can be imposed through the High Court to a separate section. In its new configuration, the section deals with the High Court’s ability to hear appeals by persons so entitled under the new section 73, which we have discussed.

Amendment No. 85 provides that where the legal practitioners disciplinary tribunal decides to pursue a case for High Court sanction and the legal practitioner takes an appeal against this, the court is first to consider that appeal. In so doing the High Court can either confirm the disciplinary tribunal’s determination that the matter is for sanction before it or determine that the act or omission by the legal practitioner was not misconduct.

The new section inserted by amendment No. 86 mirrors that which was in Bill as passed by the Dáil, and merely sets out how the jurisdiction vested in the High Court under the preceding sections we have discussed shall be exercised by the President of the High Court as he or she may direct.

Amendment No. 87 inserts section 77, which mirrors that previously contained in the Bill save for the fact that it updates relevant references to cite the Court of Appeal rather than the Supreme Court, as would have applied prior to the establishment of the new Court of Appeal, which has been up and running for the past year.

Amendment No. 88 inserts a new section 78 which sets out the way in which orders made by the High Court or determinations made by the disciplinary tribunal are to be furnished to the Registrar of Solicitors in the case of solicitors, and to the Honorable Society of King's Inns with regard to barristers.

Amendment No. 89 is a short provision regarding the various documents involved and the legal privilege that applies.

Amendment No. 90 allows for a High Court order to be made on application of the regulatory authority where it is shown that a legal practitioner or any other person has refused, neglected or otherwise failed without reasonable cause to comply in whole or in part with a determination made by the legal practitioners disciplinary tribunal.

Amendment No. 91 is a transitional provision, and amendment No. 92 makes it clear that the authority in the performance of its functions where a complaint refers to a solicitor may exercise all the powers conferred on the Law Society under the Solicitors Acts.

Comment on this
Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

Amendment No. 97 has been ruled out of order due to a potential charge on the Exchequer.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 98:

In page 71, to delete lines 10 to 15.

The issue is how we determine the costs. The key point is whether the costs will be averaged over all the members or whether more of the costs will be paid by those about whom the most complaints are made. If the costs are averaged then a moral hazard arises since everybody pays but those who perform least successfully, according to their clients, can share the bill with others. I find that difficult. Subsection (10) states "the amount of levy payable by the professional body or person concerned". Will the Minister clarify the principles? Will the people about whom most complaints are made pay bigger levies or will it be averaged over all the people, including those about whom no complaints are made?

Comment on this

Amendment No. 98 as proposed by Senator Barrett would prevent the new regulatory authority from raising a levy on those barristers who will be regulated by it and who choose to practise outside the Law Library model. It would also prevent the authority from issuing the relevant notice to those practitioners or professional bodies which would give rise to its regulatory costs each year. I am not sure if that was the Senator's intention but this would be the impact of the amendment. I would be concerned about this. The complaints and the work that arises from them in respect of each branch of the profession will determine the levy which is payable on the basis of the actual costs incurred by each branch the previous year. It will be ongoing and the levy will be calculated on the previous year's costs of the work that needed to be done by the authority and the number of complaints incurred by each branch.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for her clarification. It seems that if a barrister is employed by a company and satisfies all the duties the company requires him or her to discharge, then that barrister may face a levy because somebody else is dealing in an unsatisfactory way with his or her own clients. The general principle should be that those who give rise to the complaints should bear the costs rather than having them averaged over people about whom no complaints have been made.

Comment on this
Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

I thank the Senator. Is he pressing amendment No. 98?

Comment on this

No, I was glad to have the opportunity to explain to the Minister what I had in mind.

Comment on this

It is ironic that section 80 is about the levy, and when we try to amend the section, we are not allowed to do that because we are told it would incur a cost to the Exchequer. I find this strange and it seems like a technicality to try to kick it to touch. The amendments are a genuine attempt to improve the legislation because we have said that we are very positive about this legislation. We believe the Minister may need to look once more at the levy. We wish to raise the concerns of people in the Bar Council in particular that the levy is a fair one and that it reflects the volume of complaints against barristers. They have also expressed concerns that the levy is too high and could negatively impact on many barristers who are at the earlier stage of their career or who are struggling financially with their practice. It might affect rural barristers also and those who may work in less lucrative practices. This is why we tabled our amendment. It is unfortunate that it has not been taken into consideration but perhaps the Minister might take on board the sentiment which we put forward and she might consider it for Report Stage. We may consider trying to amend on Report Stage in a way that might not incur a cost to the Exchequer.

Comment on this

The Senators should keep in mind that the practitioners are just responsible for a block of 10% of costs. The remainder is divided between other bodies.

Comment on this
Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 99 to 111, inclusive, are related and will be discussed together.

Comment on this

The Bill allows for the introduction of a range of new business models. These include legal partnerships which are partnerships between solicitors and barristers or between barristers only and multidisciplinary practices and which allow for the provision of legal and other services by one firm. As a result of amendment No. 99 and other amendments tabled, the Bill will provide for the introduction of limited liability partnerships in respect of both solicitors partnerships and legal partnerships.

I will deal with the contextually minor amendments in this grouping before discussing amendment Nos. 100 and 101. As per amendment No. 102, complaints relating to the proposed business models will be handled by the authority. Under amendments Nos. 103 and 105, a small fee may be charged by the authority concerning the notification of a legal partnership or a multidisciplinary partnership that is about to commence business. Obviously, such partnerships will have to have strict indemnity insurance. A further amendment in this grouping aims to bring the Bill into line with the new personal insolvency culture whereby a person should no longer be prevented from operating within a business environment merely because he or she has entered into a formal debt arrangement.

I will now deal with amendments Nos. 100 and 101. The relevant sections currently provide that no professional code which is a code of practice drawn up by a legal professional body such as the Law Society of Ireland or the Bar Council shall prevent a legal practitioner from providing legal services within a legal partnership or a multidisciplinary practice. Senators will be aware that a legal partnership is a partnership between either solicitors and barristers or between barristers only. It is a new creature of this Bill which has been prohibited up to now under professional rules. Multidisciplinary practices are firms that will be able to provide both legal and other services together under one roof. These are also currently prohibited under professional rules and the Bill provides for their introduction, subject to the outcome of a formal public consultation process under Part 8. I was advised by the Attorney General that the approach in the Bill, as published, which seeks to directly interfere with the professional codes of the legal professional bodies is at high risk of vulnerability to legal challenge on the grounds of undue interference with the professional bodies' constitutional rights of association. The original sections would, in effect, dictate to the legal professional bodies whom they may include and exclude from their membership and it is this, in particular, that opens up the provisions to the possibility of successful legal challenge. As it is understood that such a legal challenge is not unlikely and in the interests of achieving the overall goal of the Bill, I am tabling these amendments because these new provisions still provide, as a matter of law, that barristers and solicitors may provide their services through one of the new business models, that is, they will have a statutory right to do so but the provisions have been reworked so as to avoid the risk of undue interference in the legal professional bodies' control over their own membership. In effect, this will mean that any lawyers who want to work through legal partnerships, multidisciplinary practices or limited liability partnerships or as employees will be able to do so. It will clearly remain the right of the legal professional bodies to decide whether such lawyers can also become members of their associations, such as, for example, the Law Library. However, Senators should note that subsection (2) of both revised sections explicitly prevents any legal professional bodies from preventing their own members from doing business with other lawyers who choose to operate within the new business models. These are very important provisions.

Comment on this

On this section and all of those sections relating to multidisciplinary practices, the Minister and I have a difference of opinion from a philosophical point of view. The amendments that the Opposition has tabled relating to the sections which deal with multidisciplinary practices are based on our opposition to those practices where solicitors, barristers and accountants operate under the same roof and for the same company. Our understanding is that this model has failed internationally and our fear is that the best and brightest of the legal profession will be secured by the wealthiest companies in society, namely, big businesses and large corporations, to the detriment of the average citizen seeking legal representation. Sinn Féin wants a level playing pitch for all citizens and is particularly concerned that those in rural communities will be able to access - through the offices of local solicitors and as is generally the case at present - the services of barristers with the appropriate skills to represent them. We fear that corporatisation will happen with the multidisciplinary practices and that we will see a centralisation of the most skilled in the area so that when people with less money in their pockets seek top-quality representation, they will find it difficult to access. Sinn Féin will be opposing the elements of this Bill that relate to multidisciplinary practices for this reason.

Comment on this

A significant number of qualified solicitors and barristers do not work as solicitors or barristers but work for the firms to which Senator Ó Clochartaigh has referred. They work for accountancy firms, multinational companies, financial services organisations and so forth. If this provision makes any difference it all, it will allow them to compete with such firms on a more level playing field. As a qualified solicitor with some experience of this area, I welcome this provision.

Comment on this

Section 84 is related to section 86. The former defines a contentious matter as "a matter that arises in, and that relates to the subject matter of, proceedings before any court, tribunal or other body or person before which the respective legal rights and obligations of two or more parties are determined, to which the person instructing the barrister concerned is a party". Section 86 provides that "No professional code shall operate to prevent a barrister from providing legal services in relation to a matter, other than a contentious matter where his or her instructions on that matter were received directly from a person who is not a solicitor." Almost everything can be defined as a contentious matter unless one wants to ask a barrister for a tip for the races at Leopardstown, for example. Section 84 undermines the recommendation of bodies such as the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission to the effect that consumers should be able approach a barrister without having a solicitor involved.

Comment on this

For the reasons I outlined earlier, I am opposing the section.

Comment on this

This is David versus Goliath. There was an access through country solicitors to sole trader barristers. I disagree with my learned friend, Senator Hayden. Corporatisation holds dangers for the average citizen facing these corporate law firms. It will also be David versus Goliath in the courts.

Comment on this

This section is all about contentious matters. One can talk to one’s barrister without a solicitor being there, provided the matter is not contentious. That seems to retain the prohibition that I have been against since the debate began some hours ago.

Comment on this
Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

Acceptance of amendment No. 101 involves the deletion of section 87.

Comment on this
Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

Acceptance of amendment No. 104 involves the deletion of section 89.

Comment on this

In subsection (7), unqualified person means a solicitor not qualified to practise within the meaning of the Solicitors Act. I am confused. The person is either qualified or not. What is this intended to convey?

Comment on this

Which amendment is the Senator referring to?

Comment on this

We have acknowledged that the person is a solicitor. That is a qualification.

Comment on this
Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

We are on section 91.

Comment on this

This essentially states that one cannot be a partner in a multidisciplinary partnership if one is unqualified which is defined elsewhere.

Comment on this

I do not wish to delay this, but we grant that he or she is qualified. Perhaps this is something we can return to on Report Stage.

Comment on this

When somebody becomes a qualified solicitor they are eligible to be registered on the Roll of Solicitors but to practise as a solicitor they must hold a practising certificate. As Senator O'Donovan knows, they may have their name struck off the Roll of Solicitors or be suspended for practising because they do not hold a practising certificate. However, the fact that they do not hold a practising certificate does not mean that they are not a qualified solicitor. I believe this section is attempting to distinguish between persons who are qualified solicitors, as such, and those who are unqualified pursuant to the section.

Comment on this

I understand why the Senator raises this, but subsections (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e) of the section outline the circumstances in which somebody who was a solicitor now comes under the term "unqualified person" under the Solicitors Act because they had been struck off the Roll of Solicitors, been suspended from practising, had the issue of a practising certificate to him or her refused under section 49 of that Act, and so forth. Once one reads the definition of "unqualified" under the Solicitors Act that makes sense.

Comment on this

To be helpful, would the word "disqualified" be more appropriate and cause less confusion? Disqualified indicates that for whatever reason, be it suspension or being struck off, one is disqualified. It is similar to a person being disqualified from driving. It would read more easily and make more sense if the word "disqualified" was used instead of "unqualified".

Comment on this

In terms of definition, that word has been there since 1954 and there is precedent in that regard. It is the definition in the Solicitors Acts. We are amending those Acts but there is no information available to me that it has led to any problems. I will check it out, but I do not believe it has.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister would examine it and we can discuss it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Senator O'Donovan is correct. One qualifies the day one graduates, but one can get oneself disqualified afterwards.

Comment on this

It is just a technical description.

Comment on this
Marie Moloney Acting Chairman Labour Party

Amendments Nos. 112 and 113 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 112 obliges the managing legal partner in a multidisciplinary practice to manage the practice in such a way as to ensure that the provision of legal services is in accordance with the provisions of the Bill and adheres to the professional principles set out in the Bill. Amendment No. 113 places positive obligations on the managing legal partner to ensure this happens.

Comment on this

As previously outlined, we are opposed to multidisciplinary practices and we therefore oppose this section.

Comment on this

Is it envisaged that there could be a person managing a multidisciplinary practice who is not a qualified barrister, solicitor or accountant, such as a CEO who has experience of management? I understand that is prevalent in some of the practices at present; there might be somebody who is good at getting people together.

Comment on this

The managing legal partner will manage the legal services.

Comment on this

That person must be a qualified solicitor or barrister.

Comment on this

Yes, on the legal side.

Comment on this

Due to our previously outlined opposition to multidisciplinary practices, we oppose this section.

Comment on this

We oppose this section due to the principle of multidisciplinary practices being included.

Comment on this

I worry about subsection (5) and the Chinese walls. There are some law and accounting firms in this city of which it is said that there are so many Chinese walls that there are rickshaws parked outside. The subsection provides that a legal practitioner who is a partner in, or an employee of, a multidisciplinary practice shall not in the provision by him or her of legal services for a client disclose the affairs of the client to a partner or employee of the practice who is not engaged in the provision of legal services to that client without the express consent of the client. There will be the coffee corner and the drinks fountain, so there is a risk there. I agree with Senator Ó Clochartaigh on this.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 114:

In page 79, between lines 35 and 36, to insert the following:

“(f) specify the cost to the client of the services specified at (a) to (e) inclusive”.

The letter of engagement provides for many worthy things, such as specifying the services to be provided, specifying the services referred to in paragraph (a), specifying which of the services are services other than legal services, specifying the services under various sections, and providing such additional information as may be prescribed. I propose that it also specify the costs. One of the major problems consumers have is that the bill gets out of control and they are not told in advance what it will cost. It would be a pro-consumer step to insert this. The person must know what this costs. They might decide there are other ways to resolve the matter or they might decide to drop it. Specifying the costs in advance must be part of the engagement. One of the complaints traditionally made about the legal profession is that it does not do that, and the clients are at a disadvantage thereafter in the transaction.

Comment on this

If I accepted the new subsection proposed by Senator Barrett in amendment No. 114 it would create confusion about the letter of engagement, which is intended to clearly delineate for a customer which services are being provided by a legal practitioner in a multidisciplinary practice by making it simultaneously a bill of costs. This would clash with the extensive legal costs transparency obligations now being placed on legal practitioners elsewhere under the Bill.

Legal obligations are now being placed on practitioners in respect of cost. That is very consumer friendly. Under Part 10 all legal practitioners will be required, under section 123, to issue a notice to clients, written in clear and understandable language, which will set out the legal costs that will be incurred or are likely to be incurred when they take on the work. That addresses the precise point the Senator made. Section 123(4) sets out in great detail what the notice must contain. The purpose of that section is to oblige all legal practitioners to disclose likely costs up front or, where this is not possible due to complexity, to give detailed and meaningful estimates. The Senator is correct that this matter has frequently been the subject of complaint in the past. Clients will also be given the option of a cooling-off period before they finally agree with the notice of costs.

There are substantial provisions in the Bill relating to costs. There is the move from the Taxing Master to the new adjudicator, and there are detailed provisions relating to costs, how they are done at present and how that must change.

There are those sections I have just read into the record as well. There are many initiatives to give greater transparency and clients being more aware of the likely costs before they embark on any legal course. That is a very important part of the Bill. It takes us from the Taxing Master situation completely to a new office of adjudication costs.

Comment on this

Section 124 on agreement regarding legal costs, etc. states, "A legal practitioner and his or her client may make an agreement". I have asked for "shall" to replace "may". As the Minister has said, it is necessary that those costs be stated upfront given the level of complaints. I am inclined to agree with the Minister providing that the amendment to section 124 is acceptable but we have not reached that one. We might come back on Report Stage. I agree with what the Minister has said but the costs must be brought upfront. The Minister cannot rely on section 124 and it might be necessary to look at the word "may" the next day.

Comment on this

I will accept the word "shall" in a later amendment. That is not a problem.

Comment on this

As we are opposing the multidisciplinary practice model, we oppose the section.

Section 96 deleted.

Comment on this

As we are opposed to the principle of multidisciplinary practices, we are opposed to the section.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 116 to 120, inclusive are related and may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

This is a technical amendment reflecting that we now have the Court of Appeal so the references to the Supreme Court are changed to references to the Court of Appeal.

Comment on this

As we have noted, we are in opposition to multidisciplinary practices, so we are in opposition to the section.

Government amendment No. 119:

In page 83, line 19, to delete “maintained by a legal practitioner” and substitute “maintained (or cause to be maintained) by a legal practitioner”.

Comment on this

Owing to our opposition to multidisciplinary practices, we are opposed to the section.

Question, "That section 102 stand part of the Bill", put and declared carried.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 121:

In page 85, line 2, after “operation” to insert “concentration ratio”.

Among the matters that need to be discussed is the increasing concentration of power in a small number of firms in the sector. That is the reason for the amendment.

Comment on this

I believe there will be sufficient leeway afforded by the current provisions for this and many other relevant aspects to be raised and taken into account in the reviews.

Comment on this

The Minister is talking about the establishment regulating the operation. Concerns about monopoly or oligopoly are important. I know the Minister has expressed that sentiment several times in this debate. I will not press the amendment.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 122 and 123 are related and may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 122:

In page 85, line 33, after “engage” to insert “within one year following the establishment day”.

Section 104 states:

(1) The Authority shall engage in a public consultation process on—

(a) the extent, if any, to which the restriction on legal practitioners, other than solicitors, holding the moneys of clients, as provided under section 36, should be retained,

This has been another of those long-standing grievances along with the ones we mentioned of not providing bills upfront and having a conveyancing monopoly. In fact, I believe solicitors have a cheaper rate of probate than non-solicitors. It is an issue we need to discuss urgently to ensure this profession lives up to all our aspirations of efficiency.

Comment on this

I am concerned that this amendment would compound the burdens of reviewing and reporting of the new authority in its first year of operations. We have put considerable thought into this and I have made some changes to it, as the Senator knows. It has been carefully laid out and sequenced under the Bill so as to make them realisable within achievable timeframes. I do not want to upset the timeframe that has been carefully thought through. We want to see the legal partnerships coming into operation in 2016. We want work done on the multidisciplinary partnerships within a certain timeframe. I have told the Senator that I would look at the issue of conveyancing and come back to him on Report Stage to see if I could suggest or accept anything specific in that regard. I will not accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister. I do not wish to press the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 124:

In page 86, line 36, to delete “4 years after the commencement of section 85, and every 5 years” and substitute “2 years after the commencement of section 85, and every 2 years”.

I will not press the amendment. The Minister has been most patient when we have discussed having certain things done faster. We should aspire to do things faster and meet the public's wish for reform in the sector.

NEW SECTIONS

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 125 to 135, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

Amendments No. 125 relates to the insertion of a new Chapter 3 of Part 8. The new Chapter provides for the introduction of an option for solicitors' firms and legal partnerships to operate with the benefits of limited liability within a limited liability partnership business model with protection for the consumer in the form of both professional indemnity insurance and ongoing regulatory oversight by the authority. The amendments include the introduction of an option for both ordinary solicitors' firms and legal partnerships which are partnerships between solicitors and barristers or between barristers only, as provided for under Part 8, to operate with the benefit of limited liability within a limited liability partnership model. It is proposed to allow such firms, subject to certain safeguards, to limit the personal liability of the individual partners of the firm for its debts, obligations and liabilities. This is in line with precedent in several other comparable common law jurisdictions in which partnerships have been changed to allow for LLPs.

On amendment No. 126, it should be noted that the LLP provisions are not at this stage being extended to cover multidisciplinary practice provisions. As it is considered that the business forms which may be assumed by MDPs when they come into being and, in particular, whether they should be able to operate in full as LLPs when some of the professions participating may not be otherwise entitled to avail of such partnerships, is something which should be covered in the research and consultation process. The specific features of the new regime for LLPs include a system of authorisation and registration subject to appropriate fees through the LSRA of those partnerships that wish to become an LLP and the maintenance of a publicly available register of these. Protection will be provided for the consumer in the form of an obligation on the firms to have substantial professional indemnity insurance. We discussed the PII earlier. The authority will have the power to set higher limits for the personal indemnity insurance if it sees fit in respect of the legal firms operating as LLPs as opposed to traditional partnerships. The authority will be required to maintain a register of limited liability partnerships. It provides for automatic loss of the shield from personal liability for partners who are found to have committed misconduct or crime in certain circumstances.

There is a clawback provision where a partner takes money out of the business when its assets exceed its liabilities, ongoing oversight by the legal service regulatory authority with an option to direct compliance and enforce by recourse to the High Court as necessary to enforce compliance. LLPs will be required to notify clients and creditors upon registration and commencement as an LLP. In the event of an insolvency of an LLP, the property of the partnership will be available to the creditors. In addition, there is a new section 113 which outlines the procedures involved in the cessation of operations as a limited liability partnership. Amendment No. 133 inserts a new section that permits the authority to make regulations on the operation of limited liability partnerships.

Amendment No. 134 disapplies section 3 of the Registration of Business Names Act 1963 with regard to partnerships operating in this Bill. Instead, anyone changing name as such a partner will be covered by the relevant provisions of the Bill.

The final amendment in this section makes it clear that although section 27 of the Companies Act 2014 prohibits the use of the description "limited" in business names, in certain circumstances under the Bill, the description can be used for limited liability practices.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 136:

In page 89, to delete lines 16 and 17.

This is something that arose before and Senator O'Donovan has made a suggestion on it. The section refers to an "unqualified person" and goes on to say "notwithstanding that he or she is a qualified barrister" but they are qualified if they have qualifications. I think disqualified was the meaning that Senator O'Donovan stressed. It requires clarification because it declares people not qualified yet the same legislation says they are qualified.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 137:

In page 92, to delete lines 28 and 29.

This relates to the chief legal costs adjudicator and the wish to have a pro-consumer element in this. It says at subsection (b) that the adjudicator will not operate where "the adjudication relates to an application for adjudication of legal costs as between a legal practitioner and his or her client". That is the opt-out clause. I would have thought that from the consumer point of view that is when we want the chief legal costs adjudicator to adjudicate on legal costs between a legal practitioner and his or her client. If we are not going to apply it here, where is the adjudication to apply? That is part of the earlier problem we referred to, the fear that clients have that legal bills get out of control. The word "unless" used here withdraws the ability of a client to go to the chief legal costs adjudicator.

Comment on this

I will have that provision looked at again in case there are any unintended consequences. I will come back on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 138:

In page 100, to delete lines 9 to 12.

This concerns the prohibition on no foal, no fee. Section 122(1) states: "A legal practitioner shall not charge any amount in respect of legal costs if ... they are legal costs in connection with contentious business expressed as a specified percentage or proportion of any damages (or other moneys) that may be or become payable to his or her client, other than in relation to a matter seeking only to recover a debt or liquidated demand". Is it not a good idea for there to be a bit of price competition in this area? That is why I have tabled this amendment.

Comment on this

With this amendment, the Senator wishes to remove a basic principle of the Bill whereby legal costs are prohibited from being expressed as a specific percentage or proportion of damages or other moneys payable to a client. The Senator mentioned this earlier. That would be the impact of this amendment so I cannot accept it.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 139:

In page 102, line 31, to delete “may” and substitute “shall”.

As this is a point of agreement between the Minister and me, we will reconsider the matter on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 140:

In page 103, line 30, after “explanation” to insert “in writing”.

This is the explanation of what is happening in the matter of legal costs.

Comment on this

We want to make sure the explanation that has to be provided for a client of the procedures available to deal with a dispute about legal costs will have to be in writing. As I accept the Senator's point that it might be somewhat ambiguous, I will also look at that issue.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 141:

In page 104, line 30, to delete “14 days” and substitute “28 days”.

When a client disputes any aspect of a bill of costs, he or she shall within 14 days of the bill of costs being provided for him or her set the machinery in motion. I wonder whether there is a need for more time because of the imbalance between the client and the solicitor. I put the matter to the Minister for consideration. People from a legal background and with legal qualifications said they would like a client to have more time in that instance.

Comment on this

The only point I make in that regard is that it would have implications for other periods of time that will apply under the Bill in relation to legal costs and where they are in dispute. I am taking all timeframes into account. I will consider the 14 day period and see whether it is feasible to make it a little longer without impacting too much on the other carefully calibrated sections in relation to time periods.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 142:

In page 108, to delete lines 7 to 9.

The amendment relates to holding hearings in public. As I would like to think about the matter adgain between now and Report Stage, I will not press the amendment today.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 143 to 145, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together, by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 143:

In page 109, line 33, to delete “less than 15 per cent”.

As it stands, the Bill reads,

Where an adjudication concerns only legal costs as between a legal practitioner and his or her client, and the Legal Costs Adjudicator has determined that the aggregate of the amounts to be paid is less than 15 per cent lower than the aggregate of those amounts set out in the bill of costs, the party chargeable to those costs shall pay the costs of the adjudication.

Does that mean that if I cannot secure a 15% reduction, I must pay the costs of the adjudication? That is why I am seeking the change. If one can secure any reduction, does that not justify the adjudication process, in particular, with its general pro-consumer emphasis? The Minister is setting the barrier high if one has to negotiate a 15% reduction.

Comment on this

The 15% margin is fair. It is fairly well accepted that one can have spurious and nebulous claims in relation to bills of cost. Determining bills of cost is very expensive and it is a well established legal precedent, not just in the area of law but in other areas also, that one does need to have some margin where there has to be some justification established to pursue very expensive procedures put in place. That is reasonable. The idea that one might secure a 5% reduction does not justify the level of administration involved in such instances. A figure 15% is, therefore, reasonable. However, I will leave it to the Minister to make her point.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 143 to 145, inclusive, are not acceptable as they would take the one sixth rule out of the equation in relation to who would pay the bill for a legal costs adjudication. As section 122, as passed by the Dáil, provides that a legal practitioner shall not charge any amount in legal costs in the circumstances set out in the section, I do not see the need for amendments Nos. 144 and 145 to be accepted in this instance. I refer Senator Sean D. Barrett to the section.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 144 was an attempt to deal with the matter of disclosure. The wording is, "provided that no client shall be responsible for costs incurred by the practitioner where the said practitioner has not disclosed the legal costs that will be incurred in relation to the matter concerned irrespective of whether the said practitioner has set out the basis on which the legal costs are to be calculated". We do ask for it in writing and quantification earlier, the purpose being to remove a defence. I will not move the amendment today, but I will think about it between now and Report Stage.

Comment on this

Section 146 makes statutory provision for the awarding and revocation of "patents of precedence", which are more commonly known as the title of senior counsel. This title is typically awarded to barristers with considerable experience and expertise in their field. It is a form of recognition for high-end legal skills and depth of legal knowledge – a quality stamp of sorts. In the interests of both transparency and fairness, this section places on a statutory footing a committee, consisting of the persons listed in section 145(2), to consider applications for the granting of this title in accordance with a range of balanced criteria. Traditionally, this title has only been accorded to barristers, but for the first time it will soon be available to solicitors also.

The original text needed some changes as it was considered to have missed the requirement for excellence in the granting of the title. That is the only amendment being proposed. In order to gain the honorary title of senior counsel in the future, a solicitor or a barrister will have to demonstrate a track record of competence and professional independence, as well as excellence in advocacy or in specialist litigation or a specialist knowledge of an area of law. The section, as it stands, merely requires "a capacity for" rather than "excellence in" these things. The amendment, therefore, brings the section more into line with what we intuitively know the title should stand for. It is a slight amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 147:

In page 120, line 23, after “exercised” to insert “solely”.

The purpose of the amendment is to have a right of access to a barrister without a solicitor being present. We discussed this matter, which is why I have suggested the following wording: after “exercised” to insert “solely”.

Comment on this

The current wording covers both barristers and solicitors, whether they are acting solely or together.

Comment on this

This is a technical amendment which is designed to bring clarity. The section provides that employee barristers will be able to act on behalf of their employers in court. Senator Hayden spoke on a related point. They are currently prohibited from doing so under Bar Council rules. The section also provides that the legal professional representative bodies will not be able to prevent their own members from working with such employee barristers. The essence of the proposed new section has not changed. Instead, it has been reworked to ensure it is clear and coherent in the overall context of the Bill. It is an important provision. As Senator Hayden explained, many barristers work as employees in various organisations including financial institutions and NGOs. They will have the possibility of being in court and representing their employers.

Comment on this

The Bill creates the conditions for a new type of barrister to emerge, namely, one who chooses to provide his or her legal services outside the traditional Law Library model. In that context, the amendment provides that the Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010 will be amended to allow the legal services regulatory authority to become the designated authority in monitoring for money laundering compliance regarding that new group of barristers. The Act of 2010 will remain unchanged in all other ways and, appropriately, the Law Society’s and Bar Council’s functions regarding money laundering compliance for their own members will also remain unchanged.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 150 to 152, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 150:

In page 124, line 35, after “may” to insert “not”.

I am concerned that the authority may, by regulation, declare people qualified. In this day and age, people should acquire the qualifications. Particular emphasis is placed on experience. If we are trying to upgrade to a smart economy and a society of well-qualified individuals, then people who want to be solicitors should be qualified as solicitors, people who want to be barristers should be qualified as barristers and people who want to be both should be qualified as both. We have educational institutions and law schools which can provide this education, rather than doing it by regulation by an administrative body as proposed in the Bill. With a fair amount of common ground, we need a very well educated legal profession and it requires the traditional way of acquiring qualifications rather than just experience.

Comment on this

The Senator's amendments would negate an intended regulatory power of the new regulatory authority regarding movement between the professions of solicitor and barrister. The proposed references to “qualifications” are considered unnecessary in light of the fact that the question of being duly qualified to practise as a solicitor or barrister is already comprehended by the definitions of solicitors and barristers who are entitled to practise under the Bill.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendment No. 153 and amendments Nos. 1 to 4, inclusive, to amendment No. 153, may be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1 to amendment No. 153:

In section 158(1), after “No professional code” to insert “or regulation”.

Comment on this

The amendment proposes the insertion of a replacement section 158 which deals with the advertising of legal services. A key purpose of the amendment is to bring the State into compliance with Article 24 of the EU services directive. That EU directive requires, in general terms, the elimination of any rules, practices or regulations that are unreasonably restrictive on a lawyer's right to advertise. The European Commission had expressed a view that some advertising practices in Ireland, particularly those regarding barristers, are too restrictive and had issued a letter of formal notice in October 2014 to the effect that infringement proceedings for a breach of the directive could be taken at any time. In this context, my Department worked with the Commission, and, later, with our own draftspersons at home, to ensure the new wording of section 158 would bring Ireland’s legal services advertising regime up to date and into line with the directive.

The new section begins by providing a general entitlement for legal practitioners to advertise their services, whether as individuals or as lawyers, working within the range of partnerships that will be created by this reforming Bill. It goes on to provide a regulation-making power for the new authority to make advertising regulations that will be applicable to both solicitors and barristers. As a matter of common sense, the section provides for some consultation on the making of the regulations with the legal professional bodies or with any other bodies the authority considers appropriate but it is the authority that will have the ultimate say in what the regulations will contain.

Subsection (4) provides, in line with Article 24 of the EU services directive, that the regulations shall not impose any restrictions on the advertisements unless such restrictions are necessary both for the protection of the independence, dignity and integrity of the legal profession and for an overriding reason relating to the public interest. Any restriction must be both non-discriminatory and proportionate. These caveats clearly impose a high threshold regarding the imposition of restrictions, so the overall message is clear, namely, that all lawyers will be able to advertise freely and widely and across an unlimited range of media. This is in line with the Commission and the EU directive.

As a matter of public policy, and given the need to ensure high standards will still prevail, subsection (5)(d) sets out that it will not be permitted for lawyers to advertise in a way that, in the opinion of the authority, is in bad taste or materially false, or offers an inducement to any person to make personal injuries claims. The clause on personal injuries advertising is considered essential for the continued avoidance of the ambulance-chasing culture that is in evidence in some other jurisdictions. While lawyers will still be able to advertise the fact that they handle personal injuries cases and have an expertise in the area, the prohibition in place since 1994 on specific inducements to make personal injury claims will stand. In a similar vein, it will remain prohibited to advertise in inappropriate locations such as hospitals, funeral homes and cemeteries. It will bring us into full compliance with the directive.

A small amendment will be made to the Solicitors Acts on Report Stage to strengthen the existing and necessary prohibition on non-solicitors operating inappropriate, so-called "legal harvesting" websites which can avoid any requirements for accuracy or good taste and refer potential clients on to solicitors, for a referral fee, in full contravention of the Solicitors Acts. Senators van Turnhout and Heffernan have proposed some amendments to the amendment regarding legal services advertising. The insertion of the word "regulation" after "professional code" is unnecessary due to the fact that the definition of "professional code" in section 2 of the Bill already comprehends "regulations". It would be an unnecessary duplication.

I cannot accept the second amendment, which proposes the deletion of subsection (5) because this is a crucial "principles and policies" provision without which the authority's regulation-making power would be utterly without boundaries and without meaning. The authority must be able to specify what types of advertising are acceptable and Senators will please note that the subsection is prefaced with the word "may" as opposed to "shall", so it does not mean that the authority will necessarily confine itself in these ways. In this instance, it is given flexibility. It will have a menu of criteria from which to draw when drafting the regulations. Some might think that such advertising should not be restricted in any way at all, but I have sought in the drafting process to maintain a very careful balance between allowing lawyers to advertise completely freely, while maintaining certain balances around what those advertisements contain, which I believe are in the public interest. We do need to maintain standards. As I have said, the wording of section 158 has met with the approval of the European Commission. Governments had not complied with the directive, so there were threatened infringement proceedings, but if we accept this section 158, they will disappear, so I would be very slow to undo the section, given that this section is fully compliant with the European directive and has the agreement of the Commission in that regard.

The switching around of the wording in the third amendment seems to make no difference in the intended meaning, so I do not think it is necessary. On the final amendment, the definition of "inappropriate location" has long been on the Statute Book without controversy and it gives clarity to the overall intention to maintain certain standards in advertising. It has long been public policy not to allow lawyers to engage in "ambulance chasing" or to prey upon distressed or bereaved persons in order to gain work and I see no good reason for that to change now or for standards to drop in that regard. I hope I have addressed the various relevant points regarding whether 158 meets the directive and why I do not believe the amendments being proposed are necessary, because most are already comprehended within the existing definitions, and, in the case of the final one, the definition of "inappropriate location" has long been on the Statute Book and has not given rise to any particular problems.

Comment on this

On the section, Senator van Turnhout was very au fait with many of the deliberations involved and asked me to give her some cover in the Chamber today as she is unable to attend for various reasons. On section 158, I am glad the Minister has clarified that it was under direct threat from the European Commission. I was a little concerned about whether fines had been issued but she has clarified that is not the case.

On section 158(5), Senator van Turnhout has asked me to put it on the record that she feels this subsection should be deleted as it serves no justifiable purpose that section 158(2) does not already cover. Section 158(2) provides for the only permissible purposes under the services directive that restrictions can be put on advertising. All the extra specifications in subsection (5) will leave the State open to enforcement and litigation. They also illegally restrict competition for legal services to the detriment of customers and the competitive market. I have been asked to put this on the record and I thank the Cathaoirleach for allowing me to do so.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3 to amendment No. 153:

In section 158(8)(b), to delete “electronic address or any information provided by the legal practitioner that is accessible electronically” and substitute “any advertisement provided by the legal practitioner that is accessible electronically”.

On that-----

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

We have discussed them already.

Comment on this

Has it been discussed already?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Yes, they are all discussed together.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is amendment No. 3 to amendment No. 153 being pressed?

Comment on this

Is it possible for me to make a number of points on some of the points that emerged for Report Stage?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Minister can do it after the next part.

Comment on this

I wanted to make a point in respect of a number of amendments that I want to bring on Report Stage. We have discussed some of them today. Some relate to pre-action protocols in clinical negligence cases and some transitional provisions which we discussed earlier. There is also an amendment to update the protected disclosure section of the Bill in light of the Protected Disclosures Act of 2014 with some cross-references and to provide for some repeals and amendments to the solicitors Act. Quite a number have been suggested by various Senators, including one in respect of non-residence in the State and the inconsistencies between sections 17 and 19. There is a question here on the disclosure of information by the authority and its interchange with the principle of legal privilege.

An amendment may be inserted to require consultation with the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission by the authority when it is conducting the review and to give clarity around the timeline policy for the administration of complaints, which continues to be three years as a matter of policy. Another amendment may clarify how appeals from claim amounts on the compensation fund will be handled and there may be a reference for information to be passed to the Chief Justice if and when a barrister is struck down from the role of practising barrister due to serious misconduct. Another amendment will ensure the authority proves in regard to its resolution of complaints regarding excessive fees. There may be an amendment to section 153 to make a small distinction between solicitors and barristers to take account of their slightly different roles, as well as an amendment to the definition of "practising barrister" to ensure all barristers, like solicitors, have to complete a period of apprenticeship before offering legal services to the public.

Some improvements may be required to clarify Part 5, the complaints section, in regard to timeframes and there may be more consequences for Parts 9 and 10. There may also be an amendment to section 1 to deal with some of the issues that have arisen in regard to competition. Many issues have arisen from today's discussion, but they relate to amendments and issues I will deal with on Report Stage.

Comment on this

It would be helpful if the proposed amendments for Report Stage were provided to us as soon as possible.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for her patient and courteous responses to the many questions raised today. We are indebted to her.

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

When is it proposed to take Report Stage?

Comment on this
Paddy Burke An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

When is it proposed to sit again?

Comment on this

At 2.30 p.m. next Tuesday.

The Seanad adjourned at 6.15 p.m. until 2.30 p.m. on Tuesday, 24 November 2015.

Comment on this