We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

Commencement replies and selection

Summary

The Chair explains that only four of many Commencement matters can be selected, while Senator Burke proposes written ministerial replies for matters that cannot be taken.

Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

The Order of Business is agreed to every day. If the Senator has an issue, he can object to it. That is a matter for the Leader.

In respect of the point raised by Senator Colm Burke, I have the responsibility for choosing Commencement matters. It is probably not a matter for the Leader but the multiplicity of Commencement matters is extraordinary. An average of 12 or 14 are received and I am only allowed to pick four. At one stage, I thought that we could manage five, but given the way they roll on, it would conflict with the Order of Business, which cannot be permitted. I was quite happy for us to take five instead of four. It used to be three. The difficulty I have is that I must try to be fair to all groups. Some Members come in every week and if somebody comes in every two months or has an important issue, I must give them preference also. I try to be fair, but it does not always pan out. I will never have the ideal, but I am cognisant that the situation was difficult today. The way it panned out was that two Fine Gael Senators were chosen because there was nobody from Fianna Fáil who had tabled a Commencement matter. I tried to balance it and try to be fair. There is no utopian solution. I will take responsibility, but I will talk to Senator Colm Burke privately about it.

Comment on this

This is not a criticism of the Cathaoirleach in any way. I am just saying that if there is a large volume of Commencement matters, procedure needs to be looked at in order that we can receive ministerial replies in writing rather than having to wait for a reply.

Comment on this