Planning and Development (Housing) and Residential Tenancies Bill 2016: Committee Stage (Resumed)
Contributions 176–360 of 360. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 92 of 2016 ›
The Minister of State may not see it in terms of ideology, but what we are talking about here is analysis. We have been very co-operative but I am now far more concerned than I was at the beginning of the debate or even 25 minutes ago on the rental strategy because I have heard the analysis the Minister of State is putting forward and it does not stand up.
What he is telling us is not accurate. The analysis is not correct, which makes me worried about the rental strategy.
Comment on this
The Minister of State said there is a concern. First, he said it is all about supply. It is about supply but it is also about opportunism. What we have seen in the rental sector is opportunism.
Comment on this
The Minister of Sate said he believes that if we were to look at something like rent certainty we would suddenly have-----
Comment on this
The Minister of State said there is a danger that they would leave the market.
Comment on this
No. I said that we need a complete package. I ask the Senator not to misquote me.
Comment on this
To quote the Minister of State, he said the concern in terms of the market closing is that fewer properties would become available for rent if we were to introduce measures in this regard. That does not stack up, given that those who are making money from the rental sector are making money at a different level from any other business in Ireland.
Comment on this
Many benefits have been put forward and there are landlords in economic difficulties who may have over-stretched themselves in other areas, but what we are talking about are the returns from the rental sector in Ireland which are outsized. I would add, for clarification, that we have mortgage interest relief for landlords in a way that we do not have for those who wish to purchase houses. Banks have seen the opportunity and they are also offering interest only mortgages. Mortgage interest relief is being offered at a high percentage, up to 80% - I would have to check that but I believe that is the percentage - and interest only mortgages are being granted. Let us be realistic about the position when talking about those who want to buy houses. In Dublin 1, a person would pay €709 per month on a mortgage but would pay €1,300 per month in rent. Those who are speculating in the rental market are in a far better position to get mortgages. The measures provided in terms of first-time buyers are tuppence worth compared with the benefits that have been given to those who wish to purchase, from the capital gains tax waiver right down to mortgage interest relief.
The Minister of State is now giving us the same line we have seen cited by those advocating for landlords, the few honest ones, as my colleague said, who admit they feel sorry for the people they are fleecing, and that is why I became concerned about this. They are large operators and many of them will be leaving town in four years' time when they claim their capital gains tax relief, and we will come to deal with this aspect later. They can afford to be honest. The Minister of State suggested that rent certainty or some system of managed rent increase would jeopardise the availability of property in the market. What will we do then? Will we have rent increases of 10% to 14% for the next few years? We will increase the housing assistance payments and rent supplement. We will have everybody protesting on the streets because they cannot rent a house. They will not be able to book their children into schools or plan their lives. People in Ireland are managing a 10% to a 19% increase every year. I was willing to work with the Minister of State. We have withdrawn all our other amendments. We have not pressed amendments to a vote. I heard him say this is a hugely complex issue. If he wants to improve on our proposal, he can do so. We hear about the wonders of Dáil Committee Stage and the fabulous changes that can be made on it. Will the Minister bring this Bill through the Dáil and improve on it as it proceeds? We cannot let this legislation out of this House in the condition it is in.
Comment on this
We need the Minister of State to indicate his position on this; we have had no indication from him on rent certainty.
Comment on this
I will call the Senator next. The Minister of State just wants to answer Senator Higgins's point. I ask him to be brief.
Comment on this
Is the Leas-Chathaoirleach impartial or will he give way to the Minister of State on every occasion?
Comment on this
I am impartial here but I am in the Chair. I call on the Minister of State to be brief in answering that point.
Comment on this
To be helpful, in case Senator Higgins misinterpreted what I said, this is about the overall package. We do not want to do anything which on its own might or might not affect supply. I mentioned supply and having supply would solve all our problems. We have a shortage of houses.
Comment on this
So the Minister of State will give landlords what they want.
Comment on this
That is not what I am saying. We need more houses. We do not want to affect supply.
Comment on this
What I am saying to the Senator who put forward the amendments is that we believe in a package that deals with all these issues. One or two measures in a toolkit will not suffice; we need a full toolkit, a full package, that deals with all the concerns. The point I made was that this is not coming from an ideology, rather it is to make sure that we do not affect supply. It is to get the balance right in the package. We accept that involves increased security and that it involves increased services around the rental sector, and choice and options. This is about bringing forward a package in its entirety, and that is what the rental strategy will do. That is what I am asking the Senator to allow, just in case she picked me up wrong on that.
Comment on this
I wish to take this opportunity to welcome two special guests, Jackie Foy and Patrick O'Gorman, who are in the Gallery. They are very welcome here.
I want to ask the Minister of State a number of questions. He has talked about asking us to wait. I have asked him four times since I came in here two hours ago to go into some detail on what he intends to bring in on rent certainty. He mentioned that in excess of 240 submissions were received. Can he tell us from where they came because it seems they have come from the lobby that represents landlords?
Comment on this
They came from the Members of this House.
Comment on this
From where did the rest of them come? Of course, submissions came from us; we are politicians. That is the first question I want to ask the Minister of State.
The second point I want to make is that the Minister of State answered very unclearly every question that was put to him today. He is obviously well trained by Vincent Browne. He is probably one of the people who appears on his programme most often, so this must be a walk in the park for him. What we are saying is not influencing or impacting on him in any way because he is not answering any questions we have asked him.
Comment on this
We cannot have Second Stage speeches now. I remind the Senator that we cannot mention people who are outside the House.
Comment on this
I can make whatever statement I like as long as I am not calling anybody out.
Comment on this
The Senator cannot mention people outside the House. I ask the Senator to deal with the amendment.
Comment on this
If the Minister of State is not going to deal with what is proposed in the three amendments grouped together, in terms of the consumer price index, CPI, he should at least tell us how he will deal with the issue. We cannot be expected to not put amendments to a vote if he is not going to tell us at least what he intends to do. With respect, he should do that as a matter of courtesy.
Comment on this
The Minister of State asked us to trust and believe him. I believe him to be a decent man. A year and half ago when dealing with the Betting (Amendment) Bill, I was asked by a colleague of his to believe that there was other legislation coming forward, which I did, but it is now a year and a half later and I have not seen that legislation. I am not questioning the Minister of State's bona fides but it does not always follow that he has the authority or the ability to bring forward what he says he will. We are talking about this affecting supply. Will we see 90% of landlords in the country run to the hills because they can no longer make their super normal profits or will they be happy to take the profits they currently have and add the rate of inflation in the consumer price index to them? They are creaming it at the moment.
Comment on this
Yes, but that needs to be clarified.
Comment on this
I believe I have the floor. The bottom line is that we have a number of different amendments all dealing with the same issue. The Minister of State can choose any one of them and, as suggested by Senator Higgins, he can take this Bill to the Dáil, modify it and make of it what he wants, but one way or the other I plead with my colleagues to put this amendment to a vote today because it needs to be put to a vote.
Comment on this
For clarification, as a public representative and a Senator, I know people who have been renting from particular landlords for years who are quite happy to stay renting. People have come to my clinic and told me that they are happy to continue to rent because they have good landlords.
Comment on this
That needs to be considered but it is not being considered. There are good landlords who look after their tenants. There is some confusion over that.
Comment on this
Nobody is suggesting otherwise.
Comment on this
Rent certainty is important. That is a definite; there is no doubt about that. Having, as a councillor for years, dealt with people who were looking for houses, the only forward is to build and buy. Rent certainty is not the biggest issue here; rather it is the lack of supply. The amount people are paying needs to be addressed. We need to buy houses and if we do not, we will not be going anywhere. We need to buy and build - that is the problem. Rent certainty is an issue, but renting all the time and not building or buying will not solve the problem; that is only taking money from the Department and putting it towards rented accommodation. As we go forward-----
Comment on this
I will let Senator Murnane O'Connor finish her point.
Comment on this
Senator Higgins has made her point about five times.
Comment on this
I agree with Senator Murnane O'Connor about rent and buying. That is all I want to say.
Comment on this
Senator Higgins will have an opportunity to contribute further if she wishes. I have been here for the past hour. I observed the debate for the hour I was not here. Some Senators are interrupting others when they are trying to make their cases. Everybody is getting an opportunity to contribute. I ask Senators to give the person in possession of the floor an opportunity to make his or her point. I ask Senator Murnane O'Connor to finish.
Comment on this
Dealing with local authorities all the time and having clinics to which people come, I see in Carlow, on Wednesday mornings, when we have our homelessness clinic, people sleeping in cars. I set up a food kitchen with the local priest and a few members of a committee - there is a crowd of us - to make sure that people are getting fed, so I understand what is happening. However, there definitely are landlords who provide a great service. Rent certainty is definitely needed, but the only way and the only answer to the housing crisis and homelessness is to build and buy. Until that is sorted, we will not get the housing crisis sorted.
Comment on this
I proposed the amendment causing all the trouble. I fully agree that the only way we will solve the housing situation in this country is through supply. That is why we were all very supportive yesterday. I voted with the Government. I can understand why we have to fast-track planning applications in order that the supply side issue is dealt with, but we cannot forget the thousands of people living in the rental sector. They are young people, older people and families. Rent certainty is an important measure to address their present and probably continued conditions. I apologise to the Minister of State. I would love to be able to support him but I have heard about the rental strategy, I know it will be published in two weeks, but I have seen no detail on the rent certainty measures contained therein. If I had, I might be able to support him. Therefore, I am, with reluctance, being awkward about this because he has not outlined any specifics and has not been able to convince me.
Comment on this
That is fine. I totally accept that the Senator must press her amendment. I am only setting out the position as it stands. With respect, I always answer questions. That is one thing I will do. Be it Senator Kelleher or anybody else, I will answer to the best of my ability. If I do not have the answer, I cannot give her the answer. With respect to our process-----
Comment on this
I think the Minister of State has the answer.
Comment on this
We are involved in a process of consultation. More submissions came in today.
Comment on this
That is fine. I am not trying to convince the Senator not to press the amendment. She can do so. I am just informing her of the progress of the process. I give her my commitment that the strategy will be published in a couple of weeks' time. However, I will not announce policy decisions that have not been made. I cannot do that. I can just tell her that that strategy will bring forward a package which should deal with all the concerns she has. I share those concerns, we share them, the Minister, Deputy Coveney, shares them, and the Department shares them. However, I cannot ask her to believe in something I cannot give her, so it is fine for her to press the amendment. I can only tell her the processes we underwent. The latest figure for submissions to have come in is 475. More have come in since then. As of today, everybody - all stakeholders - are still e-mailing their thoughts and views. We made sure that people from all parties and everybody from all spectrums of the argument would be invited to the first workshop day for stakeholders, and they came to it. I sat at some of the tables. Landowners and people fighting for tenants' rights were all at the one table discussing the issues and trying to thrash out how we can best deal with them. The only way we can do this right is with a package and a toolkit that addresses many concerns. I am not holding these back from the Senator. I do not have them. We have not worked out the best ones yet. We have ideas and notions, but there is a decision to be made about the policy, which must be formulated. As soon as it is put together, the Senator will hear about it. It is best that it comes out as a package because we have had drip-feed over the years of ideas about rental security and everything else which has not helped the market, tenants or landlords.
This is a package that deals as best we can with all the concerns. That is what will come forward in a couple of weeks' time. I will not give the details of it to the Senator today because I do not have them. If I did, I would give them to her. I ask her to trust me. If I had the details of it, it would save me two hours of debate. The strategy is a genuine attempt to deal with the issues raised. I have repeatedly said that I do not expect the Senator to accept something I cannot give her. I therefore have no issue with her pressing her amendment. I totally accept that she has to do so. I can only explain to her what we are trying to do. I believe that we will be in agreement on publication of the strategy, but that is a few weeks away. I cannot bring her there just yet although I wish I could. We understand we must address all the issues surrounding the rental sector because we accept that many people, either by choice or lack of choice, want to rent. When I say by choice, I mean a desire to rent and to continue to do so because of one's job, the way jobs move around and flexibility. We therefore want to encourage much more purpose-built housing to rent which will improve the service received in rental properties. We want to encourage more investors into building. Others do not have a choice and must rent. We must accept that as well. People want more security of tenure. They want to know the bigger picture for their families. We accept all that and believe a rental strategy will deal with it. The publication of the strategy is a couple of weeks away.
Our concern was that these amendments are only part of what could be an overall package. The provisions they make might be in the strategy but they do not form the full strategy. We therefore cannot accept the amendments in this legislation, but the strategy will be published before the legislation is completed. That might help the process, but by all means the Senator can press the amendment. That is not being awkward; that is democracy. She is doing the right thing. I have no issue with that at all. I can only inform her of our position as best I can. It is a genuine attempt to try to bring everyone together. With all the stakeholders involved in the process, and as with any strategy in which I have been involved, it is best that one sees out the process, that the voice of anybody who took the time to make written submissions, come to meetings and follow on with further meetings is heard, that all their thoughts are processed and that we formulate a policy on such a basis. There are people in this room who made submissions for the strategy. Every submission is being considered and analysed, and we will pick the best when we bring the strategy forward in a few weeks' time. We cannot accept amendments today. That is our position.
Comment on this
I want to make a few points about the landlord-tenant relationship. I see the Minister of State being pounded on the basis that he has ideological objections, and this by people in this House to whom the term "ideology" is not exactly a stranger. I support what was said a few moments ago about the landlord-tenant relationship. I have been a landlord in respect of one property. I remember reducing the rent in the immediate aftermath of the crash because I thought it was the just thing to do. I believe that the great majority of landlords want certainty too.
Comment on this
They want decent tenants. They do not want people regularly going in and out of their properties. They do not want turnover of tenants. If one defines "rack rent" as the most one can charge in the market, most landlords will seek to let properties at 20% less than that for a no-hassle, predictable existence. That is the first thing about landlords. They do not all exploit tenants. The great majority of landlords I know of want to have a good, stable relationship with the tenant which is satisfactory to both sides. In this day and age of advertisements on the radio and television asking who repairs the boiler when it breaks, who repairs the washing machine when it breaks down and who carries the can when the dishwasher breaks down, landlords and tenants must have give-and-take relationships, not ones in which they are at each other's throats.
Secondly, there is a sense - this is the ideology about which I get worried - that people want to turn landlords into building societies. In other words, they want the property to be provided at a particular rent because it is a home and because they believe the positions of a mortgage ower and a tenant are more or less the same. They are qualitatively different. Most landlords do not want to be in the position of a building society. They do not want simply to take a defined benefit over 30 or 40 years in respect of providing a home to a family. There is a delicate balance between the model of the person who owes the mortgage and credit provider, to which many people aspire, and the tenant-landlord relationship, and they are not the same relationship. Each case is a different animal. I only mention this because landlords have particular rights. Building societies can sell off or refinance their mortgages. They are effectively just legal instruments.
For most landlords, however, it is not simply a matter of a paper transaction with money coming in. It involves management, care of the property, deep concern for how it is being looked after and worries about all the issues that arise from being a landlord. Therefore, it is not the same thing. Anybody who believes it is the same is deluding himself. The relationships are radically different.
Bearing in mind the various amendments now under discussion, saying that the CPI is to be the determinant in respect of a tenancy is not fair, in a number of ways. The rate is currently approximately 0.5% or 1%. Using the CPI is not fair to a landlord who is asked by the tenant to invest in the property. It is not fair to ask somebody in this position to redecorate the house and take 0.5% or 1% extra the following year. It is not fair to a landlord who has to replace the cookers, washing machines, etc., that CPI applies to him because people believe other people are currently being exploited. I have absolutely no doubt that some people are being exploited so I am not saying there is no force in the argument for rent certainty of some kind. Given that we are talking about the rate of inflation, to simply say all rents are effectively frozen for three years, an indefinite period or a period that a Minister can extend indefinitely is simply not the way to attract more money into the rental market.
For every home that is let at present, the landlord always faces the option of continuing to be a landlord or cashing in his chips and selling the property to somebody else. That is a choice that every landlord makes. He must ask whether it is worth the candle. A landlord reaching 70 or 80 years of age might ask whether he or she wants to continue to be a landlord or sell the property. These are the kinds of issues on which people have to make up their minds. In that context, to say to them that their rent levels are frozen is not the correct way to determine whether the purchaser of the property will be a family moving in or a person who desires a buy-to-let arrangement. We have to examine the dynamics of the market and ask what kind of money will come into it.
Consider the circumstances if Joe Soap has two apartments in Dublin and decides to cash in his chips because he is getting old, wants certainty in his life, wants to provide for himself, or wants to emigrate, for example. If that person's property is put on the market, the people buying it will be asking whether they are buying it to live in it or buying to let. People making an investment in that context are going to look to what is the law. If the law implies one should forget about any rental increases and that one is stuck with CPI if one lets the property, it will have an adverse effect on the number of people willing to put money into property for the purpose of letting it out to others. One can have an ideological objection, based on the view that everybody should own his own home or be able to mortgage his own home and live in it as a buyer–occupier, for example, but the real question about a measure of this kind is whether it will do more damage in two to three years in terms of money going out of the property market owing to a lack of investment by landlords.
This country is filled with good intentions. Some time ago, some bright sparks in Dublin City Council or the Minister of State's Department came to the view that they would wipe out the scandal of people living in bedsits in Dublin.
Comment on this
That created more problems than it prevented.
Comment on this
Those concerned believed they knew better than others and that they would decide it is sub-standard housing. Some 8,000 to 12,000 people were thrown out of their homes. I have never heard anybody stand up and say, "I am sorry; that was a mistake and I got it wrong." I am saying the same about this measure. If we introduce a rent freeze, who will stand up in five years and say it was a bit of a mistake, with money having fled the property investment market as time went by and things getting worse rather than better?
If the Senators put this to a vote, I will be voting against their amendment. I just wanted to put my rationale on the record rather than having to explain it afterwards over a cup of tea with my good friends who are proposing the amendment.
Comment on this
We need to conclude because I am conscious of the many other areas we need to address. While we have heard the stories and many of us know landlords who are excellent - I have not derided landlords in any way - what I have spoken to was not ideology; I stated the facts. I am sure there are wonderful landlords making fabulous and considered responses to the market but we have seen an average increase of almost 12% in one year. That is the fact. This is not to say all landlords hiked their rent by 12%. It is the average and that is the fact, and the fact that it is the average is worrying because it means that for every good landlord, there is a landlord who is increasing above 12%. Mr. David Ehrlich, Ireland's biggest landlord, said his company has never seen rental increases like these in any jurisdiction of which he is aware. Such individuals believe there are no brakes.
It was said we want to have a balance but my point is that the balance does not exist at the moment. We put forward two proposals, one immediate and one long term. If one wants to debate whether the CPI should be used and the nature of the appropriate indicators, one should note we have been begging the Government to come forward with a statement as to where it believes the markers or indicators might be. We have not heard anything in that respect. There is nothing allowing a different indicator to be added.
Senator Michael McDowell referred to the CPI being low but the GDP figures are also not a very good indicator. Admittedly, we need to find the right indicators but this sets the idea that there is predictability. If one wants to amend it further, one could do so at a later stage. We have a time limit. It is the same time limit that has been estimated as the period needed for supply. The date 31 December 2019 has been stated as the date on which the Government believes we will have moved out of the emergency context in terms of supply. We have a void and opportunism in the meantime. It is not from all landlords based on a view that landlords are evil but from those who are seeing and taking an opportunity. It is creating social instability in the State.
We will not press all our amendments in the House today but we will press one. I urge the Minister of State to return on Report Stage with a proposal. It is not enough to say "rental strategy". He needs to give us his indicators. He can change them as the legislation proceeds. We are in unsafe circumstances.
We will withdraw amendment No. 22.
Comment on this
We will address that in a moment. Two of the Senator's colleagues are offering to contribute.
Comment on this
I am very conscious of time and I would not normally speak when we are having such a long debate on one section. I welcome the balance that has been brought to the debate by Senator Michael McDowell. I am a landlord by default. I rent out a property in respect of which I reduced the rent by way more than 20% during the crash. It is also in negative equity. Last week, the boiler was broken. I am not on the kind of wage that could sustain huge costs on a property.
Comment on this
I know many people like me. I am serious. There is a perception in the debate that all landlords are creaming it and trying to take advantage of tenants. I welcome the balance that has been brought to the debate and agree with the sentiments that have been expressed. There are some that would take advantage but this is the case in any business. There is a perception that all lawyers are earning a fortune but some are doing well just to make ends meet.
We must have a little bit of balance in the debate.
Comment on this
With permission, I want to use the "C" word in the Chamber.
Comment on this
The word I was going to use is "class". What we have in here, and I welcome it in one respect, is a debate between the interests of the different classes in our society. I must hand it to my colleague Senator McDowell - who is a gentleman, to be fair - who made a very good case for the landlord class, for the people who have wealth in this country and for the people who have done very well through the ten years of austerity.
Comment on this
A lot of them have other sorts of debt.
Comment on this
I acknowledge, and am glad to see, that those of us on the left in this Chamber are united again today. Now I turn to Fianna Fáil who, before the last election, described themselves as a centre-left party. We have spoken about rent certainty and I heard my colleagues - for whom I have great respect - say that we need rent certainty. There is, however, no point in talking about it. We must do something about it and this Chamber is where we have to do it. It is funny how, whenever we actually have to do something about rent certainty, the response is always "We are not ready now". I do not like to be unpleasant to the Minister of State, because on a personal level he is an absolute gentleman, but we cannot believe him because Fine Gael's record is appalling and it is a landlords' party. Senator McDowell is proud to be a landlord, and fair play to him. Fine Gael is a landlords' party but I want to tell a different story. This is a true story from my Monday clinic in Limerick. Two people are being evicted as we speak with their three young children. They will have nowhere to live at Christmas. They happen to be Travellers. They are the very best of people whose neighbours are gutted to see them being forced out onto the roads. They will never get a house through HAP because landlords do not rent houses to Travellers, unfortunately. This is one thing the landlord class never does in this country. We need rent certainty and protections for people like that and we cannot afford to wait a few weeks until the Minister of State is ready. Let us be frank, in the 90 years of the existence of this State, there have never been decent rights for tenants here.
Comment on this
The reason is that we have always had conservative government of one type or another. Let us not have crocodile tears on rent certainty and "We will get there in a few weeks", because the Minister will not. We know he will not. This issue is one of class. I am proud to see everyone here on the left standing together. Clearly the Minister of State, Deputy English, Senator McDowell and the others from Fianna Fáil are standing together also. They are landlord parties and they have no interest in tenants and they should be ashamed to be rejecting this amendment on rent certainty.
Comment on this
Rather than go back over the whole debate from the last hour, for those who have only just joined us-----
Comment on this
Senator Higgins asked for a Government response and said Senators were begging the Government for a response. I have said that the Government did not want to bring forward its response based on a whim, an ideology or any kind of class. Our response will be a full policy, worked out and thought out and produced in a couple of week's time. There will be the full package, a toolkit and regulation to go with it.
Comment on this
I have said repeatedly that I do not expect people to wait for that. Senators can make their own decisions today. The Government's response will be within a full policy and not just giving one idea or one notion. It will be a full package and policy. People ask what Fine Gael is as a party. I can tell them that we are solutions-focused and driven.
Comment on this
For whom? Solutions for landlords.
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy Coveney, has been very clear that the strategy should be focused and solution driven. Most Senators in this House have genuinely wanted to approach this from a solution perspective. Whether one is a landlord or a tenant, all of us here want to end the situations where people do not have permanent accommodation.
Comment on this
I will say it one more time. It can only be achieved through a balanced package and by bringing forward informed policy that tries to bring with us as many stakeholders as possible with this agenda to get it right and to get backing for it. That is what we are doing. It will be published in a couple of week's time. That is as much as I can tell Senators today. I have told Senator Craughwell previously that the Minister and I have said the strategy will happen in a couple of weeks - the full policy response with solutions focused across the board. It is about a balance. We do not come to this from any ideology or any class - that is not us. As a party we represent many people from all across society-----
Comment on this
Fine Gael believes in the free market.
Comment on this
Do not try to put us into a box. That is not what we are about.
Comment on this
It is important that this Bill goes through. I have been a Senator for seven months and not once has Sinn Féin agreed to anything. They have looked for a votáil on everything. They have disagreed on everything-----
Comment on this
-----that has come up here. I have been sitting at the front beside the Sinn Féin Senators, and I am very fond of you by the way-----
Comment on this
-----but Sinn Féin have absolutely agreed on nothing. We have an emergency housing crisis and if Sinn Féin was interested, as are other parties, then we would be trying our best here today to make sure that we get everything sorted for these people in the housing crisis.
Comment on this
No. I represent everybody. As a councillor and Senator I am proud to say that I represent everybody-----
Comment on this
-----as does Fianna Fáil. I ask the Minister to get solutions here today. Can we move forward to make sure that we get this housing plan passed so the people of Ireland, the people who come to my clinics, who are living in cars-----
Comment on this
Will Senator Murnane O'Connor support the amendment?
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy Coveney, is back in the chair and he makes the decisions. This would depend on my vote, if a vote were called. Can the Minister commit that this rental strategy will be published no later than February? There is a sense of urgency in the debate. I refer to two or three weeks to let the Minister decide if time has to be done. I have constantly come in to this House and said that rushed legislation is bad legislation. Let us deal with it within a month. Give us a deadline and a time and we will decide then.
Comment on this
I was getting texts from the Minister of State, Deputy English, encouraging me not to get involved in this debate-----
Comment on this
-----or to extend it for another half an hour, but when I started to hear the Sinn Féin mantra that Fine Gael is the landlord party, I-----
Comment on this
-----I texted him back to say I will be making a contribution. We had the same mantra on social housing and then we produced a housing strategy that will add 47,000 social houses to our social housing stock. We had the same mantra on homelessness and even people such as Fr. Peter McVerry would say that the current strategy is the most comprehensive that has ever been put in place. Now it is about the implementation. I approach the current housing challenge and pressures from a pragmatic perspective where we try to make evidence-based decisions. The truth is that if we simply approach the pressures and strain faced by many tenants today with a view to protecting them but ignoring how the market functions and how State intervention in the market functions, then we are only solving half of the problem. The key issue is that we are dramatically short of supply. We have many vacant properties that we need to get back into use. We have many sites that have planning permission and zoning that can help to alleviate the problem. We have spent nearly two days discussing how we can put in place a streamlined planning process to encourage a lot more large-scale development, much of which will be social housing. In my view, however, the most difficult balance to get right in the housing strategy is the rental sector. This is why we did not rush it in the first 74 days when we produced the housing strategy. We made very clear in that strategy - although some chose to ignore it - that what is in the strategy with regard to rent is not the full picture because we needed more time to consult with people to get the balance right. Believe me when I say some momentum is now starting to build in the construction sector that over time can help to solve a lot of these problems that are linked to a deficit in supply. We must ensure that we do not undermine that momentum and the appetite for investment in projects right across this city and the country.
At the same time, I do accept that many tenants are under extreme pressure and at the sharp end of that we are seeing families being driven into homelessness, which I have spoken about earlier today.
We need to do more to prevent the unsustainable level of rent inflation that is happening because of a dramatic supply shortage. It is not easy to balance those two. People have made pretty coherent arguments on both sides today. We have invited all sides to make written submissions during a consultation process that will produce a new rental strategy by the middle of next month, not February. If we can use the Committee Stage of this legislation in the Dáil to accommodate any legislative change that may come with that, I intend to do that. If we do that, the change will have to come back to the Seanad before the Bill can be finalised and Senators will have an opportunity to debate and discuss it then. I am not willing to support amendments that are well-meaning but may not fit into the difficult balancing act that I have to achieve in the rental strategy we will launch in three weeks' time. I made this approach clear on Second Stage and I am consistent about this. When we launch a rental strategy, if legislative change is required, we will use this legislation to do it straightaway. We do not want to create a long time lag between stating an intention to intervene in the market and not do so for three or four months because we need to bring new legislation forward and to have the market compensate and adjust for any intervention that may or may not take place. We need to ensure that anything we do takes effect quickly, which is why this legislation is the appropriate way to do that. However, we are not ready yet. We will be in a few weeks’ time and I ask people to recognise that. We are working with other parties to find a compromise that is sensible, will not undermine supply and will protect tenants in vulnerable and pressurised situations.
Comment on this
I appreciate that the Minister is giving us a lot of time in the Seanad. This is a very important Bill. In the first part of the debate yesterday, there was much pressure to get the legislation through because we needed to enact it immediately. At the same time the Minister says that he will propose amendments in the Dáil and change the legislation which will have to come back to the Seanad.
Comment on this
I said if that happens, it will have to come back to the Seanad. The Senator should not twist what I am saying.
Comment on this
I understand the procedure but therefore the legislation before us is half-baked. We are putting forward proposals to change it. We are suggesting that rent certainty be included as part of the legislation. If, after the consultation process and debate on what has been proposed, the Minister decides to tweak, amend or change that, he can bring in amendments to tweak the ones we have put forward, so why not accept the principle of rent certainty at this stage to give people an indication that we are thinking seriously about this? In my opinion, the Minister is ideologically opposed to rent certainty. If he is, he needs to tell us that now.
Fianna Fáil needs to get off the fence and tell us whether it is in favour of rent certainty, rather than issuing press releases to the media. This is the Parliament. It has been half-indicated today but is it party policy or not? We will push these amendments to a vote because we have called for this several times and we have seen Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael oppose attempts by Sinn Féin to bring rent certainty Bills through these Houses. The Minister either is or is not considering rent certainty as part of the solution. He should tell us now which it is, stop wasting our time today, withdraw the legislation and bring it back when it is ready. We will support the Minister if it is up to scratch when he comes back to us in four or six weeks’ time with the new amendments, based on what has been said in the consultation process. If it seems to do what it says on the tin and if it lives up to the promises and the rhetoric of the Minister of State that this will be an all-encompassing solution to the rental crisis, we will support it.
It was said that Sinn Féin has not supported measures that have come through the Houses. The Minister knows that is not true. He has worked very well with Deputy Ó Broin on legislation and he has supported the positive elements of it. Our party has done that and will continue to do that. Where we are critical we will make the arguments and the points because people come to our offices day in, day out and tell us how much the spiralling rent increases, of up to 10% to 13% in Galway, are costing them. It will continue unless something is done immediately so the Minister should either do it immediately or rescind it.
Comment on this
I want to support the Minister. I believe what he has just said and that he wants to bring back something which will solve all our problems. There is a danger these amendments will be pushed to a vote, which I would prefer did not happen because it would give the Minister a chance. I do not subscribe to the ideology nonsense. There are as many working class members of Fine Gael as there are of the landlord class.
I believe the Minister is trying to do something right. If a vote is not called on this today, is there any chance the Minister could come back and offer a fig leaf on this next Tuesday on Report Stage, to give people some degree of confidence that there will be certainty? This has gone on for two hours and could go on for another two. I do not want to see that happen. The ball is at the Minister’s feet.
Comment on this
Everybody is entitled to his or her opinion and we have heard strong arguments on all sides of this debate but we need to distil this legislation to one thing: increase the housing supply in a short time. I have no doubt this will have a positive impact and will house many of the people we talk about in this House and in other chambers. It will also have a positive impact on the rental sector. The market needs more housing to have a normalised rental sector. The pressure is building because we do not have enough houses.
I respect Senators on all sides making their cases but I reject totally the Sinn Féin accusation that my party represents only the landlord class. I come from a working class area and family and I have always represented working class people and I make no apology for that. Sinn Féin’s accusations are wrong.
The proof is in the pudding, in this Government and Minister, who is not only bringing in this legislation to intervene in a positive way but is providing increased funding for housing, which is unprecedented in the history of this State. He is providing increased funding to support the rental sector and the homeless sector. We need to work together. I do not want to accuse parties of playing games but that is how it seems to me. If we are serious about increasing the housing supply we should work together however we can to bring this legislation forward. It is temporary. It will last only three years with a possible extension of two years. Let us bring it forward to see how it works and evaluate it then with whatever Minister is in place. I appeal to all parties to work together to bring this legislation forward. We have been debating this amendment for almost two hours and there are many more amendments to go. I agree with the Fianna Fáil Senator who said let us bring this forward in a positive way. There will be Report Stage, and the Minister can speak for himself, but I appeal to all sides. There are people watching this and it is becoming farcical.
Comment on this
The proof is not in the pudding. It is in rent certainty and that is not there.
Comment on this
Colleagues have spoken at least half a dozen times and then they make the point that we have been here far too long. We would not be here far too long if the points could be made once or twice. While colleagues feel it necessary to speak again and again I have no option but to allow that happen. This is a democracy, not a dictatorship. I am in the hands of my colleagues. If they want to speed it up they should speak once and make their point and maybe come in once more to make a supplementary point. If they want to continue, that is fine.
Does the Minister wish to make a comment?
Comment on this
I wish to make a clear point on my own behalf. I am doing what I said I would do. On Second Stage, I said if the rental strategy we will launch in a few weeks' time gives rise to a legislative requirement, we will try to use this legislation - whatever Stage it is at when we launch - to ensure that can take effect quickly. That is what I said and that is what I am saying now.
Unless a majority decides to vote me down, I will not accept an incomplete approach to rent certainty, rent predictability, intervention in the market or whatever one wants to call it. I am not into the ideologies of it. I am trying to fix the rental market which is fundamentally broken. People are suffering every day because of that. They are coming to all our offices as a result.
There are two sides to this story and we have to try to get the balance. Without landlords and without investment, we do not get increased supply unless the State is to provide homes for everybody in the private rental market, which is not going to happen. We need to ensure we have a functioning market. We also need to respond to the fact that what is happening in the rental market in parts of Ireland now is making life impossible for some people. We need to respond to that and we will.
I will not make an effort to try to please people in the short term. At the start, I said I could not accept an amendment in this area until we have a complete picture. We will have a complete picture in a few weeks and that will be the time to amend this legislation. The only reason I mentioned that if we do that it will come back to the House was to try to be helpful to the Senator. The Senator tried to spin that into a negative and suggested we should just stall the process until then. We are trying to get emergency legislation through. This is emergency legislation. The reason I brought it to this House was to try to get emergency legislation through. There is a load of stuff in this legislation that needs to happen, one way or the other. If we decide to use the legislation to try to facilitate something around the area we have been talking about for the past two hours, let us also do that; but let us not delay the process in an effort to do that. I cannot be clearer on that. That is consistent with what I said at the start and I hold to that position now.
Comment on this
The emergency is in the households that are paying the increased rents. In places such as Galway we have had increases of 13% in the past year.
Comment on this
We have moved to the other section; this is the previous section.
Comment on this
Senator Higgins, I have already explained that while there are colleagues who wish to contribute to this amendment and this section, there is nothing I can do other than allow them to do so. That is what Senator Ó Clochartaigh is doing and he is entitled to do so.
Comment on this
Hold on, Senator. Irrespective of whether he is, that is open to him. The only person who knows that is himself.
Comment on this
As long as there are colleagues who want to contribute, I will not prevent them from doing so. We have an hour and five minutes left, based on the order of the House. When it comes to the time, I do not want the same people complaining that we have run out of time.
I ask Senator Ó Clochartaigh to continue without interruption.
Comment on this
The Acting Chairman's intervention is very important. Nobody is trying to prolong the debate in any way, but we are trying to argue the case of the people who have asked us to argue the case. We will continue to do that.
Comment on this
I asked the Minister a very direct question. Does he believe in rent certainty? Is it a policy he would buy into? This is something that has happened a number of times over the past six years while I have been in this House. We are being asked to put our intention into legislation that will come down the road which does not deliver. To me that is buying a pig in a poke. We need to adjudicate on the legislation before us. I suggest that we put rent certainty into the legislation and the Minister can subsequently amend it in the Dáil if he is not happy. We really need to do that because the emergency is in those households tonight, not next week or next month.
Comment on this
Basically, I do not believe the question has been answered. The Minister has said this is emergency legislation. Our amendment No. 24 is also an emergency measure. I do not intend or do not want to press amendments Nos. 22 and 23. However, I know that it is co-signed so I am not sure what the protocol on that is.
Comment on this
I will withdraw amendment No. 22, reserving the right to reintroduce it on Report Stage. Amendment No 23 states-----
Comment on this
We need to deal with amendment No. 22 first. Is the Senator pressing amendment No. 22?
Comment on this
I will withdraw and reserving the right-----
Comment on this
On a point of order, as co-signatories, can we press the amendment?
Comment on this
That is fine. I have to ask the first name first. Senator Higgins does not wish to press amendment No. 22.
Comment on this
I will not press amendment No. 22, but I reserve the right to reintroduce it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Question put: "That amendment No. 22 be withdrawn."
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 23:
In page 33, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
“Amendment of section 19 (setting of rent above market rent prohibited) of Act of 2004
27."
The Act of 2004 is amended by the insertion of the following new section after section 19:
“19A. Any subsequent increases in the level of rent under the tenancy of a dwelling shall not be greater than the rate of inflation, as provided for by the Consumer Price Index as issued by the Central Statistics Office.”.”.
We will withdraw this amendment and reserve the right to reintroduce it on Report Stage. I urge the Minister to give us further assurance in this area.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In page 33, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
"Amendment of section 19 (setting of rent above market rent prohibited) of Act of 2004
27. The Act of 2004 is amended by the insertion of the following new section after section 19:
"19A. (1) Any subsequent increases in the level of rent under the tenancy of a dwelling shall not be greater than the rate of inflation, as provided by the Consumer Price Index as issued by the Central Statistics Office.
(2) The provision outlined in subsection (1) will remain in effect until 31 December 2019 at which point the Minister may by order extend the specified period which this section will continue to apply."."
I regret the time pressure under which we are operating. I would like to press this amendment as it specifically addresses an emergency measure timed to coincide with the emergency measures on planning. However, given the exigencies of time I will withdraw it and reserve the right to reintroduce it on Report Stage as I believe this is an essential measure. I urge that action be taken on it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 33, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
"27. The Act of 2004 is amended by the insertion of the following new section after section 19:
"19A. Any subsequent setting of the rent under the tenancy by way of a review of that rent shall not be greater or less than the level of inflation as indicated in the Consumer Price Index as calculated by the Central Statistics Office at the time of the rent review.".".
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?
Question put: "That section 27 stand part of the Bill."
Do you agree with this result?
Amendments Nos. 26 to 39, inclusive, are related. Amendments Nos. 33 to 37, inclusive, are physical alternatives to amendments Nos. 26 to 39, inclusive. Amendments Nos. 26 to 39, inclusive, may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 26:
In page 33, between lines 28 and 29, to insert the following:
"28. The Act of 2004 is amended in section 28(2)(a) by the substitution of "for an indefinite period from" for "for the period of 4 years".".
Amendment No. 26 concerns changes to the duration of a standard tenancy from four years to a period of indefinite duration in order to provide tenants with real security of tenure. We are asking for this change to be made to the 2004 Act. In light of tenants' concerns that they could be asked to leave their homes after a four-year period, we are looking to insert a provision relating to indefinite duration as opposed to four years to give more security to people in private rented accommodation. I will speak about the other amendments at a later stage.
Comment on this
I will speak about section 30. There are a number of amendments in this area. We have tabled a number of amendments that identified our concern, which I believe is shared, and has been expressed, by Fianna Fáil and others in the House, about the definition of a medium-sized dwelling. We understand that section 30, to which these amendments relate, is designed to deal with concerns such as the situation we saw in Tyrrelstown where people received notices of eviction en masse. We have suggested that five might be a more reasonable determination of that medium-sized dwelling. We have also put forward ten and a number of other numbers but our main number of five, which is where we find agreement with our colleagues in Fianna Fáil, because we know that only 6% of landlords would have properties with five or more dwellings. We are only tackling the larger landlords if we talk about units of five or over. These are situations where those landlords are selling their properties and transferring them for remuneration. Unfortunately, this is being used as a loophole and opportunity to give summary evictions.
In respect of the other constructive proposals we have put forward here, while section 30(2) seems to protect people from these mass evictions, we believe section 30(3) undoes all the good work of section 30(2). Section 30(2) seems to say that tenancies should not be terminated at a point of sale but one could drive a coach and four through the provisions in section 30(3) and we believe any landlord could do so. One of the provisions relates to where there is a 20% increase in the price if a landlord sells it with vacant possession. We put forward a number of amendments in that regard. Do we at least talk about 30% or withdraw that entire subsection? I will not go into the detail of our proposals here but I reserve the right to reintroduce them and possibly further amendments to tighten up section 30(3) on Report Stage.
Landlords will always be able to say that they can show that they would get 20% more if they sold with vacant possession. When one has 10% to 12% increases in rental prices, putting this provision in creates a contravening factor that will damage the possibility of introducing rent certainty in the future. The Minister of State talked about balance. This provision will be used to justify rent increases because it would be said that otherwise, there would be a 20% gap between what people are paying and what someone in the open market would pay and that could be used as a justification for evictions down the line. If we are really being careful, we need to be careful about this exception as it is put here. In respect of the exception that suggests that undue unfairness or undue hardship on the landlord is a key concern, we feel the term "undue unfairness" is not specific enough. It is too vague. If one looked at the large-scale professional investors who are in Ireland, we feel they will be able to match that.
We need to be realistic about the scale. I have reports from Hooke and McDonald which say that at the end of 2014 alone, under the capital gains tax waiver, more than 3,000 residential units were purchased by international investors. They explicitly say that they are purchasing them to hold for seven years. We will see mass expiration of that rate in three years' time. The measures ran from 2012 to 2014. As the seven years expires, many of those vulture funds will move to other territories such as the UK or the US - anywhere that is in crisis - and find the opportunities. They will be selling on a large scale and there will be a huge transfer of assets. I know the Minister has spoken about professional landlords. If there are professional landlords or international landlords who want to move in, they are welcome but let them take houses with tenancies intact because the vulture funds which will be leaving town care nothing for public reputation. Only legislation will constrain them and the legislative constraints here are ineffective and meaningless. I cannot think of a single fund or a single situation in which they would not be able to meet these standards, get their exemptions and get the right to evict en masse. It is a very urgent and pertinent issue. I realise the Government intends to deal with it but we need to show serious action. I reserve the right to reintroduce all our amendments to this section on Report Stage. I would also flag that we may introduce amendments which relate to section 42 and Part 4 tenancies on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I am speaking to my amendment, which is amendment No. 30.
Its purpose is to highlight the fact that section 34 of the 2004 Act sets out the unlawful grounds for terminating a tenancy by a landlord. Our amendment deletes paragraph 3 of the table which permits a landlord to determine a tenancy simply on the grounds that he or she intends to sell the property within three months. This ground is often relied upon by receivers to gain vacant possession of a property.
It is worth noting that the National Economic and Social Council has recommended that Ireland adopt the same approach to allow tenants to remain in houses that are being sold. The council has stated that removing sale as a reason to end a lease would significantly improve secure occupancy and recommends that this measure be adopted for Ireland. The council notes that while one view is that this could reduce the price those selling rental properties could achieve compared to the price of vacant possession, the more the Irish rental system is driven by long-term yield rather than changing asset prices, the higher the value purchasers will put on properties with an existing secure rental stream.
We have all received correspondence from concerned citizens writing on behalf of Focus Ireland. The correspondence points out that other countries have found solutions to this problem of the desire of landlords to vacate houses they intend to sell. In Northern Ireland, for example, banks that repossess on foot of buy-to-let mortgages are prohibited from evicting the tenant and must sell the property with the tenant still in place. This seems fair. The loan was offered specifically to create a buy-to-let home and it is wrong for the bank to dispossess a tenant because its investment did not make the money. Many such houses were included in section 23 tax relief in this country.
We do not subscribe to the idea that a landlord needs five, ten or more than 20 houses to be brought in under the legislation. If I went onto daft.ie this minute, I would not have any way of knowing whether a property I wanted to rent was owned by a professional landlord or a landlord with one property. If that landlord decided to sell the property in 12 months, I would be excluded from the protection of the legislation if he did not have 20 or more properties. That is as daft as the name of the website. It makes no sense. We have to protect all tenants, not just those who happen to be tenants of landlords with five, ten or more than 20 houses. I will be pressing the amendment.
Comment on this
We welcome the amendment of the Residential Tenancies Acts to enable tenants to remain in situ if they live in developments that are being sold. The lack of security for tenants is a major issue inhibiting the development of a strong, reliable rental market in Ireland. Unlike the European norm, Irish leases are primarily short-term, which generates great uncertainty for families and other long-term renters, and limits the appeal of renting for those for whom home ownership is not a preferred option, in particular families with children who require stability and certainty rather than the current situation where tenancies can be brought to an abrupt end. That is the major issue here.
Why should householders in larger developments enjoy greater security of occupancy than other tenants, however? We believe the criterion of 20 units should be reduced to five units. The Bill is all about security for families and children. It is not about landlords. We have a duty to the children and families of Ireland to ensure they have a secure home. To do so, we must ensure we can provide them with a rental scheme that will make them secure and that they are not worried every year about whether they are going to be evicted. I ask the Minister of State to reduce the number of units from 20 to five to assist those in rural parts of counties like Carlow. This needs to be addressed.
Comment on this
The purpose of amendment No. 28 from Sinn Féin is to prevent any landlord who bought a property with a buy-to-let mortgage or who availed of a section 23 tax relief to purchase a property for the purposes of renting or who is a professional landlord with three or more properties from issuing a notice to quit on the grounds that the property is to be sold. This amendment would have two benefits. First, the tenant gets greater security of tenure and, second, it would ensure that the property would remain in the private-rented sector, which is an important point. I echo the sentiments of Senator Landy and others that this is about protecting the rights of tenants. We have seen situations like Tyrrelstown where vulture funds have bought up swathes of property and then evicted people almost immediately. We are trying to stop that happening. It is important that tenants are not only allowed to stay but that they stay as part of the private-rented sector. I hope the Minister of State will be open to accepting these amendments.
Comment on this
I will deal with the amendments in one go. On security of tenure, including the termination of tenancies for the purpose of sale, the strategy, as I said earlier, will examine all options to improve security of tenure for tenants. This will include scope for a move to indefinite leases to replace the Part 4 four-year tenancy and incentives for landlords to waive their right to terminate a tenancy in the event of the sale of a property. For that reason, we cannot accept amendments Nos. 26 to 29, inclusive, as they pre-empt the proposals in the strategy relating to security of tenure. I went through a lot of that earlier and will not go back through the whole thing again. As I said, the strategy will be a toolkit to deal with the various issues. I ask Members to please wait for a couple of weeks, although it is up to them.
Amendments Nos. 30 and 31 propose to reduce the number of dwellings in the Tyrrelstown amendment from 20 to five or 20 to ten, respectively. We have not been of that view that these should be accepted, but to be fair it is an issue all sides are raising. Report Stage is on Tuesday and it is something we can look at between now and Tuesday. The whole idea was that anything above 20 was definitely in the medium to large area. We can look at the figures around the five or ten before Tuesday. I am not promising to accept the proposals but we will take a real look at it and come back to the House before Report Stage on Tuesday given that it is an issue most Members are raising. We acknowledged that the amendment proposed was limited in scope, but that it was right to send some message to the market in that regard. We want to deal with this in the overall rental strategy also. We do not want a repeat of what happened in Tyrrelstown.
Amendments Nos. 32 to 37, inclusive, relate to the exemption in the Tyrrelstown amendment. Amendment No. 32 proposes to delete section 33A entirely. Amendment No. 35 proposes to delete that part of the provision relating to hardship. Amendment No. 36 proposes to remove the words "undue unfairness". We then look at the breakdown. Section 30 relates to constitutional issues in respect of property rights due to the restrictions in place in circumstances where landlords seek to sell a property. There are a couple of issues we can look at there in terms of the wording of the amendments on Report Stage. Amendments No. 33 and 34 relate to the figure from 30% to 40% and I am not accepting them. To make them would not be fair. We will listen to the arguments again on Report Stage but we are not on for accepting them now or for lifting that figure. The figure of 5% is quite high. I understand that it is argued that the daft.ie report showed an average of 10% or 12% but that is probably over the last year. I am not sure it would be as easy to show a 20% loss as Senator Higgins thinks but we might listen to the argument again on Report Stage. We will look at it over the weekend. We will also look at the wording.
Amendment No. 37 relates to the definition of "market value" for the purposes of the section and proposes that it be determined by an independent State body. I am not accepting the amendment because where a tenant is served with a notice of termination under the section and does not believe the exemption in sections 3A or 3B applies, he or she may refer a dispute to the Private Residential Tenancies Board. The board is an independent statutory body with quasi-judicial powers. Any order made by an adjudicator may be appealed to a tribunal which holds an oral hearing for that purpose. The tenancy may not be terminated during the dispute process. No other body could provide such a robust and independent assessment of the market value of a dwelling in these circumstances and, as such, I do not propose to accept the amendment. In short, it is unnecessary, which I hope people understand.
The Private Residential Tenancies Board is quite sufficient to do that job.
Amendment No. 39 would require compensation to be paid to tenants where their tenancies are terminated. If compensation were to be granted in these cases, assuming lawful notification and all other requirements had been met by the landlord, there would seem to be no reason a tenant in a Tyrrelstown situation should receive compensation while a tenant in any other tenancy where the Tyrrelstown situation did not apply should not also be eligible to be compensated if a tenancy were terminated on the ground of sale of property. In other words, the measure would be unfair on other tenants. As such, I cannot accept this amendment. It is not something that one could have for every tenant, so it would not be fair to bring it in for anybody. We are not prepared to accept that amendment.
On the other suggestions, we will look at tightening up the exemptions around that and the wording. We will come back to the Senator before Report Stage on Tuesday next, if that is okay.
Comment on this
I will be brief. I thank my Seanad colleague, Senator Coffey, for allowing me in. I wanted to speak to amendments Nos. 30 and 31.
Comment on this
I will not speak to them. I merely want to mention I support-----
Comment on this
Sorry, with respect, a Leas-Chathaoirligh, if you do not interrupt me, I will be one minute. If you keep interrupting me, we will be standing here for five minutes, back and forth.
Comment on this
We will not, because I am in the Chair, it is 6 o'clock and I am going to the Order of Business as agreed by the House.
Comment on this
I will be standing and you will be sitting. All I want to say is that I very much appreciate the sentiment behind this, that tenants need security and they should not be victims of the sale of properties. We understand and accept that there those who buy properties, and I object to some of the language used by Sinn Féin Senators earlier when they spoke about this being a class issue. If one considers two retired nurses who invest in a home for one of their children later in life and a bit an investment in terms of their pension to be a class set aside, I reject that out of hand.
Comment on this
There are many who, because of the paucity of their pensions, look to pensions in houses. I want to see and hope the Minister of State will consider some reduction in the number of 20 units, but I would not tie his hands.
Comment on this
As it is now 6 p.m., I am required to put the following question in accordance with the order of the Seanad of this day: "That amendment No. 26 is hereby negatived, that section 28 is hereby agreed to, that the Government amendments undisposed of are hereby made to the Bill, that in respect of each of the sections undisposed of, the section or, as appropriate, the section, as amended, is hereby agreed to, that the Schedule, as amended, is hereby agreed to, that the Title is hereby agreed to, and that the Bill, as amended, is hereby accordingly reported to the House."
Comment on this
Question put
Do you agree with this result?