Bus Éireann and Expressway cuts
Senators Gavan and O'Mahony warned that Bus Éireann and its Expressway routes faced insolvency, route cuts and job losses, especially harming rural communities. Senator Humphreys also used the moment to praise the forthcoming climate statements and ask for adequate time for the Minister's reply.
Yesterday the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport warned that Bus Éireann was facing insolvency within two years unless "difficult decisions are made."
This begs the question as to who will be obliged to make those difficult decisions. The Minister is talking about axing between six and eight of the least profitable routes and we know that Bus Éireann wants to separate the Expressway service from the rest of the firm. We also know who will suffer as a result. It will be the people of rural Ireland, for whom these bus routes are a lifeline. The staff will suffer through further job losses and pay cuts. This is part of a very worrying bigger picture when it comes to public transport. We know Iarnród Éireann faces insolvency unless it receives a much-improved subvention. All three public transport companies have seen the level of State subvention reduced by approximately one third in recent years. To make matters worse, last year the National Transport Authority unilaterally took €2 million from Dublin Bus because it deemed the company's profits to be excessive. I question the role of the National Transport Authority, which seems to be pushing for outsourcing and privatisation at every opportunity.
At the heart of the issues affecting public transport companies is the inability to plan their budgets, particularly their expenditure more than 12 months into the future. The Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport must commit to agreeing and implementing a multi-annual plan for the entire public transport system as a matter of extreme urgency. I find it very difficult to believe that nine months into his role as Minister, he is still floundering on the issue of subvention for public transport companies. At yesterday's meeting of the Joint Committee on Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, we discovered that, nine months into his tenure, the Minister, Deputy Ross, has yet to meet his opposite number in the North, the Minister for Infrastructure, Mr. Chris Hazzard. I just cannot understand it. What is the man doing?
It is time to have an adult conversation about public transport. As my union, SIPTU, has pointed out, we can have a sustainable public transport system that provides a world-class service to the public and decent jobs for employees but this Government does not have the will to make it happen. Once again, it is down to ideology. We know Fine Gael has been the driving force behind the plan to hive off profitable routes from Dublin Bus and that it would rather continue to cut the subvention, outsource services to the private sector and undermine our public services in the process. Fine Gael Members then stand up in the Chamber and bemoan the fate of rural Ireland.
I ask the Leader to invite the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport back to the Chamber. Perhaps the Leader could persuade the Minister, when he does return, to spend less time speechifying and a little longer dealing with issues of concern.
Comment on this
I thank the Leader for the work he did in inviting the appropriate Minister to make a statement on climate action and low-carbon development. I hope and believe this will be a landmark day for the House, as we will see - for the first time - real and positive action on how Ireland can show leadership when it comes to climate change. I ask the Leader to ensure there is adequate time for the Minister to respond to contributions from Senators. When the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport, Deputy Shane Ross, came before the House recently, it was unfortunate that he spent too much time talking about rugby and not enough speaking about his policies. I ask the Leader to ensure that there is adequate time for responses to contributions from the Senators. I compliment the Leader and his staff on ensuring this debate is taking place today.
Comment on this
I join others in referring to Bus Éireann, particularly in the context of the Expressway service that seems to be under threat. It is important that the Minister comes before the House as a matter of urgency in order to deal with the matter. We can all jump up and down and the blame game has already started. Ultimately, we need solutions and something does not add up. In the past couple of years there has been much investment in a modern fleet for the Expressway service, providing Wi-Fi and toilets and so on. These are really brilliant buses. Bus Éireann has told us that there have been increases in passenger numbers. However, this may only be on certain routes and it, in turn, would increase the pressure in the context of other routes. We can all jump up and down, blame each other and politicise the matter but there is a window of opportunity in terms of doing something about this. Could we tweak the system, perhaps in rural areas? Could services be maintained with smaller buses rather than 53-seaters? We have all seen half-empty buses. There is also the issue of "use it or lose it", etc. We do not want to be here on a Wednesday, seeing strikes tomorrow or the next day. There is a window of opportunity to do something about this. We should work in a calm and collaborative fashion. In order to start that process, the Minister should come before us and outline his plans rather than just saying that the company will be insolvent in two years. What can be done in the immediate future to resolve this matter?