Apple tax dispute
The Leader defended the Government's position on the Apple tax decision, saying it disagreed with the Commission, was appealing to the Court of Justice, and had not accepted any final penalty. Senators Devine and Ó Clochartaigh continued to object until the Cathaoirleach asked for no interruption.
Let me make it quite clear. Senator Máire Devine does not want to hear good news. I accept that she would rather see Apple not doing well. That is her prerogative.
Comment on this
Let us not cast aside good news. The Government has made its position clear. It disagrees profoundly with the European Commission's analysis and is appealing the decision to the European Court of Justice to have it annulled. I will not go into the reasons again, but the Government has been forceful and clear that we do not do deals. There has been no final penalty levied against the State. It is an historical issue. The correct amount of Irish tax was charged and no selective advantage was given. In September over 70% of the Members of the Dáil voted to support the Government's appeal. Let us not have the debate reopened, but if Senator Rose Conway-Walsh wants to have that debate, let us have it and she can face the men and women who are gainfully employed in Cork, benefiting the local economy and able to pay their taxes and mortgages.
Comment on this
Let Apple pay its full taxes.
