We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

Leadership contest and other issues

Summary

The Leader rejected claims that public money was being used in the Taoiseach contest and addressed points on social welfare fraud, the help-to-buy scheme, Jadotville, farm thefts, the right to strike and the Arts Council. He repeatedly said he would pursue meetings or debates on the substantive issues, while pushing back on the leadership-related accusations.

Senator Ó Ríordáin made reference to the Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Varadkar, in his presentation. Neither of the Fine Gael leadership candidates is spending public money on their campaigns. Senator Ó Ríordáin's remarks are mischievous, misleading and should certainly be clarified because the Minister is not expending any public moneys on any campaign. Social welfare fraud is a different issue. All of us recognise that we need to address all issues in this area, whether they relate to white collar crime, social welfare fraud or whatever. We commend the Revenue Commissioners when they publish a list of tax defaulters and pursue them. Equally, those who abuse the State's social welfare programmes should not be allowed to get away with it. I do not know whether the Senator disagrees. I am not seeking his endorsement, but that is a fact of life.

I was not quite sure what Senator Devine was seeking, to be honest. I am not being disingenuous, mischievous or trying to provoke her politically but I did not know what she was looking for in her contribution. If she wishes to tell me afterwards I will endeavour to talk to her.

Comment on this

The Leader was not listening.

Comment on this

The Senator went on about 40 different tangents-----

Comment on this

The Leader should open his ears.

Comment on this

-----and I did my best to try to follow her.

Comment on this

The Leader was doing his very best.

Comment on this

I could not get her specific request. I am pleased that Senator Murnane O'Connor is interested in the Fine Gael leadership contest. The €17 million help-to-buy scheme is very positive.

Comment on this

It is a very good scheme.

Comment on this

What the Minister, Deputy Varadkar, said was that it would be looked at. The Senator's leader in the Seanad was critical of the scheme's lack of take up a couple of weeks ago in the House.

Comment on this

No, it has been taken up.

Comment on this

There is a need to promote it more. I certainly think that we should be incentivising and helping people to get on the property ladder, in this case first-time buyers.

To address Senator Mac Lochlainn's contribution, I have spoken to Senator McFadden about Jadotville and I have also met with the Minister of State, Deputy Kehoe, in that regard. The Senator might not think we are trying to progress the matter but we actually are. I share the Senator's view on this, as he knows quite well. I am trying, as Leader of the House, to arrive at a positive conclusion for everybody. If the Senator can give me a bit more patience, I will be happy to try to get him a meeting with the Minister of State on that issue. To be fair to Senators McFadden, Craughwell and Senator Mac Lochlainn himself, we need a commonality and unity of approach in order to see this matter resolved positively for the families and the men who served, in particular.

Comment on this

Is it possible to get a meeting with the Minister of State for the four of us next week?

Comment on this

I will endeavour to do that. To be fair, I know the Minister of State was away on Government business relating to the Defence Forces because I had asked for a meeting this week. He has just returned this morning. I met him this morning. I will endeavour to get that meeting.

Comment on this

A meeting for the four of us Senators along with himself.

Comment on this

I will try to deliver. I am being genuine in that.

Senator Mullen raised the very important issue of farm thefts and the need for vigilance and proactivity in rural Ireland. I certainly agree with him. We have seen a decline in burglary across the country. I have not got the figures to which the Senator referred, but it is worrying that we have seen an increase in theft at this time of the year. I was travelling to Cavan last night for a particular event and I was struck by the amount of activity in rural Ireland. The Senator made his point well. I would be happy to have the Minister come to the House in that regard.

Comment on this

I thank the Leader.

Comment on this

I believe the right to strike was the predominant issue which Senator Gavan raised in his contribution. There is nobody who wishes to prevent members of a union from going on strike.

Comment on this

That is not being proposed by anybody.

Comment on this

Deputy Varadkar is proposing it, as is Deputy Coveney.

Comment on this

No, he did not say that actually. Neither of the candidates has said-----

Comment on this

-----he would withdraw the right to strike, to be fair. As somebody who was a member of a union, I recognise the importance of the right to strike. Equally, we need to have a debate about making resolutions of the Labour Court binding. I am only posing a question. Should some public workers not be allowed to go on strike, for example our gardaí, our Defence Forces and people who provide key essential services? I am only posing the question. That is a debate we could have and which I would be happy to have.

Comment on this

We would not have it in the context of the Fine Gael leadership contest.

Comment on this

Oh God, no.

Comment on this

I welcome the Senator's interest in that contest, but we would have the debate in the context of our society.

Senator Warfield raised the issue of the importance of the Arts Council of Ireland. I did not know that this matter of the productivity of artists was being put forward. The Senator's presentation of the Colm Tóibín piece was a very good example of members of the arts community going through fallow phases, if that is the right phrase to use. It certainly poses a good question in terms of productivity and what a positive and productive outcome is. That is something that we need to look at and I would be happy to have the Minister come to the House in that regard.

I will take Senator Ó Clochartaigh's amendment and I would be happy to take Senator Ruane's Bill next week, but I will not be accepting the other amendments.

Comment on this