We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

Order of Business wrap-up

Summary

The Leader thanked Members, grouped the Waterford cath-lab contributions, replied on health access and the Defence Forces, and agreed further debate where appropriate before the sitting concluded.

I thank the 22 Members who have contributed to the Order of Business. Senators Ardagh, Boyhan and Conway-Walsh all raised the issue of the cath laboratory in Waterford. In last week's debate, Senator Coffey made reference to health apartheid. Senator Conway-Walsh, in her remarks, posed a very good question which we can use as a starting point. Irrespective of where we are from, the provision of services and the need to ensure that people can access services must be an overarching principle of our health system, whether we are in Castletownbere, Connemara, the Donegal-Derry border or wherever else. It is important to be able to access services. I will begin today by offering my sympathies to the Power family on the tragic death of Thomas. It is important that we understand that this is not about an individual person but a health system working for all members of society. The briefing today and the debate around the cath laboratory in Waterford is one that has been to the fore for a long time. It is emotive and highly charged and is an issue of absolute importance and of grave concern to both the Minister and to the Government as a whole. That is why the Government, through the Herity report, had an independent review. The Minister for Health, Deputy Harris, has given a commitment to look at it again along with the issue of primary care and other types of health provision. It is important that this be allowed to take place and I would be happy to have the Minister come to the House. We had the debate in this House last week. It is an important issue and one that we should continue to have investment in. We should all read the Herity report. If it is to be challenged then let us do it on the basis of clinical fact and evidence. I hope that would be the policy of Government in the future.

Senator Ardagh also made reference to the issue of housing prices and housing supply. The Government, through Rebuilding Ireland, is committed to ensuring that we solve and address the legacy issues to which it had to face up in respect of housing supply and the housing crisis. Rebuilding Ireland is the Government's policy and the vehicle within which we will drive change in the construction sector through the provision of housing in various different strands. The Minister for Housing, Planning, Community and Local Government, Deputy Eoghan Murphy, has been asked by the Taoiseach to review the plan, to report on progress under the plan and to identify measures that are required. I am quite confident he will do that. It is important that we live up to the needs of people and meet the demands that are imposed upon us in the provision of housing, whether it is in private housing, affordable housing, the supply and demand, and social housing.

I join with Senator Ardagh in commending Dr. Geoffrey Shannon, the independent Government rapporteur, on his report. I fully subscribe to Senator Ardagh's view that the Government must work with Dr. Shannon in implementing the recommendations around the protection of children. We have seen Dr. Shannon play a pivotal role in the past in this area and we hope he will continue to do so. The Minister for Children and Youth Affairs, Deputy Zappone, has been a very proactive Minister in her brief and I am sure that she will again rise to the challenge of completing this. I hope that we will have the Minister to the House.

Senator Boyhan referred to the open day in Moorepark, which is on the Cork-Dublin road. It is a huge centre of excellence in the agricultural sector, and I commend all involved in the different facets of Moorepark, including research, innovation and the development of our food sector. Senator Boyhan is correct that our diary sector is a pivotal part of our agricultural community, and I would be happy for the Minister to come to the House. He also made reference to people in direct provision.

I look forward to the day we allow people to work. The Senator referenced people working in the food and agriculture sector and I hope we can address the issue. There was a recent court ruling and the Government is working to implement the judgment.

Senators Boyhan, Paddy Burke, Butler and Craughwell referenced the importance of Brexit and the report of the Seanad Special Committee on the Withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union. I congratulate Senator Richmond, Chairman of the committee, as well as all Members for their input and contributions. It was a pleasure to attend and to watch some of the hearings and Senator Richmond's chairmanship did a service to the House. Over 50 hours of work went into the plenary sessions, which is not to mention the research and the work done behind the scenes. This shows that the committee system of this House and the Houses of the Oireachtas is a fantastic catalyst for change and a forum for suggestions to be brought to the Government and Departments. Senator Ó Donnghaile was also a member of the committee and I apologise for not mentioning him. We will have a debate on a motion before the House next week. Brexit is of importance to all of us and I hope the committee report will not just gain media attention but will be read by people because it is a serious and substantive piece of work on the issue of Brexit.

Senator Conway-Walsh made reference to the raids on Irish-based insurance companies today. It is important that we understand the independence of the different arms of the State in investigating matters. This case concerns competitiveness and consumer protection in the financial services sector, specifically insurance companies. I hope there is a thorough investigation but I do not want to pre-empt the outcome. If anything is unearthed it is important that it benefits the consumer and it is important that we do not find anything that is anti-competitive in the practices in this industry. If sufficient evidence is unearthed action must take place. I very much welcome the first public session of the Charleton inquiry and I hope the tribunal concludes its work in a thorough and professional manner.

Senators Humphreys, Kieran O'Donnell and Wilson made reference to regional development and I will come back to their points about State airports. Senator Humphreys said Government was interested in rebalancing away from Dublin but I do not think that is the case at all. The previous Minister, Deputy Coveney, commissioned Ireland 2040, which had a huge and impressive consultative process. He was committed, as is the current Minister for Housing, Planning, Community and Local Government, Deputy Eoghan Murphy, to Ireland 2040 being completed and published. It is a highly ambitious plan for Ireland and involves a national planning framework to ensure the people of Ireland are recognised as being from the four corners, the four provinces, of Ireland. It is not about region but people and having development on an all-Ireland scale. The importance of balanced regional development will be seen when the report is published. If there is a choked capital and nothing anywhere else, it is not a balanced country. It is not about Dublin versus the rest of the country but is about allowing for a different model of economic development. It is about ensuring we can attract investment into many parts of the country, whether Cork, Cavan, Galway, Limerick, Waterford or wherever. It is about the opportunity to work, investment in local areas and a flourishing country, not just a flourishing region. I look forward to having that debate. Ireland 2040 is about targeted, focused growth and, as the report outlines, is about urban gateways and hubs across the country.

I very much look forward to having that debate in due course.

Senator Noone referred to tackling obesity. She has been a champion of the issue in her contributions in this House since I have come back here. She is right to outline the statistics and the fact that Ireland has 70% fewer 11 to 15 year olds drinking sugar-sweetened soft drinks, while at the same time daily fruit consumption increased by 26% and sweet consumption decreased by 49%. That proves the Government's Healthy Ireland policy is working but we need to do more work. I very much commend her on the work she does.

Senators Gallagher, Feighan and Murnane O'Connor referred to ambulances. I would be very happy to have the Minister come to the House to discuss the National Ambulance Service and the ambulance service plan which is part of the HSE's service strategy. HIQA has outlined deficiencies in some service provision. What we must have is a strategy that recognises the importance of timely access for people to ambulances.

Senator Gavan raised the issue of private ambulances but what he failed to mention in his contribution is that in the North, where I hope his party will be part of the soon-to-be restored devolved Government, private ambulances were used 561 times in the month of January at a cost of £1 million. It is not a black and white issue in terms of ambulances only being public. A balance needs to be struck. It is not the way forward to say private ambulances are always the wrong approach. It is about ensuring that all people have timely access to health care, in this case ambulance services. The people who availed of private ambulances do not care whether they are public or private once they can receive treatment.

Senator Gallagher referred to the delay in the delivery of broadband in rural areas. It is important that we acknowledge the Minister, Deputy Naughten, is committed to the delivery of broadband in rural areas. We all wish we had better broadband speed and access in many parts of the country but I am confident the Minister will deliver.

Senator Craughwell paid tribute to staff in the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, in particular to Ambassador Collins. I join with him in commending all diplomatic staff across the world who represent Ireland. I pay tribute to the retiring ambassador in Washington D.C., Anne Anderson. Having met her on a number of occasions I can say she is a first-class public servant who has represented her country with distinction.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I thank her for her many years of service and wish her well in her retirement. I do not mean retirement as she is a young woman, but in the next phase of her life. I wish Dan Mulhall every success in taking up the baton in Washington D.C.

Senator Craughwell also made reference to payments in regard to the Defence Forces. I would be happy to have the Minister of State, Deputy Kehoe, come to the House. It is extremely important that we recognise the contribution of the Defence Forces at home and abroad. I will be happy to have a further debate on the issue of pay and we should be able to have it before the summer recess.

Senator Hopkins referred to a meeting in Kilbride, County Roscommon, last night. She is right to articulate the early years sector and the issues that need to be addressed, such as those raised by the early years alliance, in terms of investment and the rate of pay for staff. I would be happy for the Minister, Deputy Zappone, to come to the House. It is a matter that exercises people across the country. I have attended a number of meetings on the issue in Cork and I would be happy to have the Minister come to the House. I thank Senator Hopkins for raising the matter.

Senator Gavan made reference to the political centre. I remind all Members that it is the political centre that governs this country. It is about having responsibility and living up to it, not being populist or catch-all to all people but about ensuring that we have a Government that delivers. I hope we will all aspire to that aim.

I thank Senator Butler for raising the issue he mentioned in terms of his trip to Berlin and the importance of the co-operation and dialogue across Europe. It is only through dialogue and communication that we will see the Brexit negotiations achieve success for Ireland.

I hope that will happen during the negotiating period.

Senator Maria Byrne raised the issue of the emergency department in Limerick. The Government has invested in the emergency department there. We must continue to invest to address the issues of people on trolleys and waiting times. I would be happy to have the Minister come to the House to debate the matter and discuss the strategy.

Senator Alice-Mary Higgins referred to the meeting today between the Taoiseach and Prime Minister Trudeau, who I welcome to Ireland. As the Taoiseach said, the visit is about ensuring that we forge a relationship with Canada. Senator Higgins referred to that type of relationship. I am sure, from the bilateral meeting today and the conversations we have had in the House and across Departments, that the relationship will focus on what is good for us in the context of employment, attracting investment and business. It is about what is best for Ireland. It is not about us being an inferior partner in the relationship, it is about us being coequal. We can certainly have that necessary debate in the House.

Senators Lombard, Gallagher and Feighan referred to the decision of the British Government to change its fisheries policy as announced at the weekend. As the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Deputy Michael Creed, said, the decision is unhelpful and a very serious matter. It will form a central part of the Brexit negotiations in regard to our maritime sector and coastal communities. I commend all of those involved the seafood and maritime sector regarding Seafest in Galway at the weekend, which was a phenomenal success. The UK Government's decision is important and serious and we must be very proactive in respect of it. The Minister is and will continue to be proactive. Our ocean economy is worth €5.7 billion and employs 30,000 people. We must forge an alliance and a relationship with our friends and allies in Europe to promote our policy and ensure our access to waters is not hindered and that such waters remain open to us.

I join Senator Ó Domhnaill in hoping we see a positive resolution to the talks in the North. The Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade, Deputy Coveney, has been very clear regarding the Government's ongoing need to see the Irish language Act form part of the talks. Special status for the North has been Government policy for a long time, as the former Taoiseach, Deputy Enda Kenny, made very clear in his remarks and work. As we enter the 11th hour in respect of the North, it is critical to re-establish the power-sharing government at Stormont and avoid direct rule, which none of us wants to see return. I wish all involved in the talks well. We will all work in whatever capacity we can to see that happen.

Senator Paul Coghlan referred to opening of Killarney House, on which I congratulate him. He referred to Lord Castlerosse and the home of the Earls of Kenmare. I suppose we could call Senator Paul Coghlan "Lord Killarney". With the house opening for the first time, it is a great day. I do not mean to be partisan in noting that the Senator has been a champion of Killarney House. As Senator O'Donnell said, he could become a one-man band for all of the tourism bodies involved in the promotion of Killarney. He has been a champion of both the town and the house and I congratulate him and all involved on the project. I also thank the Government for providing the funding to open the house. I am sure Senator Paul Coghlan will say that there is more work to be done, but this is a positive development. It will add a huge tourist attraction to the town, joining those which already exist there. I hope to have better days in Killarney unlike last Sunday, which was a very poor day for Cork people. We will come back to that.

Senators O'Donnell and Wilson made reference to our State airports. I join Senator O'Donnell in welcoming the investment by Norwegian Air in both Shannon and Cork airports. It is not about these airports today; it is about investment in Ireland. I was at Cork Airport last Saturday to watch the first Norwegian Air flight taking off while the first flight landed there today. As both Senators said, we must examine how our State airports can be utilised to promote the country, attract investment both in business and in the tourism industry, and ensure value for money. I will try to facilitate a debate in the autumn, if not before the summer recess, on our airports and the need for regional development, as Senator Wilson said. That is not an anti-Dublin point; it is about being pro-country and using a collective approach.

Senator Colm Burke raised the issue of the HSE's decision on support services for women with breast cancer. I join him in condemning the HSE for the callous nature of what it did the weekend. It was appalling, first, that an announcement was made on a Friday afternoon; second, that nobody was told; and, third, that the Minister had to intervene to ensure the policy was changed and stopped. It is not good enough that women in a vulnerable position, either undergoing or awaiting treatment, were subject to such an announcement. It is important that the Minister comes to the House to discuss the matter.

Senator Paddy Burke also made reference to Brexit and fisheries and I have responded on that.

I sympathise with the Hanafin family on the death of former Senator, Des Hanafin. I join all Senators in paying tribute and offering sympathy to the family of the late Austin Deasy whose son, John, is a Member of the Lower House. He was a fine parliamentarian and Minister. He was a man who stood his ground. As a former Minister for Agriculture, I recall him coining the great phrase, "There will be no capitulation" in his talks with the EU when I was a teenager. Perhaps that is a fitting epitaph. For us, there should be no capitulation in our Brexit talks. I would be happy to schedule expressions of sympathy on the sad passing of both men in the coming months.

Senator Ó Clochtartaigh referred to a youth work scheme in Galway. If he gives me the details, I will be happy to either have the Minister for Children and Youth Affairs debate the matter with him in the House or to approach him privately.

On a personal level, I thank all Members for their good wishes. It was great to see unanimity in respect of a matter of good news. I am happy that we, as a country, can allow all of us to get married.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I congratulate the Leader.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator.

Comment on this