We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Public Health (Alcohol) Bill 2015: Report and Final Stages

Contributions 1–187 of 356. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Public Health (Alcohol) Bill 2015
Enacted

No. 120 of 2015 ›

Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I welcome the Minister for Health, Deputy Harris, to the House. Before we commence, I remind the House that a Senator may speak only once on Report Stage, except the proposer of the amendment who may reply to the discussion on the amendment. On Report Stage, each amendment must be seconded. Amendments Nos. 1, 5 and 29 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this
Simon Harris Minister for Health Fine Gael

We are starting with technical amendments that are straightforward. As I indicated on Committee Stage, I am proposing to amend section 1, which necessitates consequential amendments to sections 5 and 30. The proposed amendments are strictly technical and do not change any of the commencement dates in section 1 or make any substantive changes otherwise.

Amendment No. 1 will replace section 1 of the Bill as adopted on Committee Stage. The amendment to section 1 is necessary to correct a numbering reference in the Bill, as amended, which in error provides for two commencement dates for section 19 and none for section 20. Therefore, I am proposing to change one of the two references to "section 19" to "section 20", as originally intended. I am also proposing to reformulate this section for easier reading and understanding, but with no changes being made to the effect of the provisions.

The effect of an identical numbering error in section 30 with regard to sections 19 and 20 is corrected by amendment No. 29. Section 5 deals with the power of the Minister for Health of the day to make regulations and orders. Amendment No. 5 inserts a reference to section 1(5) into section 5(3). The effect of this amendment is that commencement orders made under section 1(5) will be exempted, along with all other commencement orders made under section 1. I commend these three technical amendments to the House.

Comment on this
Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

As amendments Nos. 2 to 4, inclusive, 6 and 15 are related, they may be discussed together.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I seek the guidance of the Chair regarding the six amendments to the Intoxicating Liquor (Amendment) Bill 2017.

Comment on this
Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We are dealing with the Public Health (Alcohol) Bill 2017. It is a different Bill. The amendments to the Bill before the House can be found in the ante-room. One of the ushers will get them for the Senator. Does Senator Higgins wish to move amendment No. 2?

Comment on this

I will leave it to my colleague, Senator Black, to speak on it.

Comment on this
Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

It would be better if Senator Black were to move the amendment, given that the mover of an amendment has the right to reply.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 7, between lines 22 and 23, to insert the following:

" "Audiovisual Media Services Directive" means Directive 2010/13/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 10 March 2010 on the coordination of certain provisions laid down by law, regulation or administrative action in Member States concerning the provision of audiovisual media services;

"audiovisual media service” has the same meaning as it has in Article 1 of the Audiovisual Media Services Directive;".

I welcome the Minister to the House. I am speaking in support of amendments Nos. 2 to 4, inclusive, amendment No. 6 and amendment No. 15. Amendments Nos. 2 to 4, inclusive, and amendment No. 6 are purely technical and propose definitions to facilitate amendment No. 15. For example, "information society service" is the technical term used in EU law to cover services like Facebook, YouTube and Twitter. The proposed definitions facilitate the substantive amendment in this grouping, amendment No. 15, which deals with online advertising of alcohol targeted at children.

One of the main aims of the Bill before the House is to limit children's exposure to relentless alcohol advertising. Several advertising provisions in the Bill relate specifically to children. For example, the Bill proposes to restrict advertising within 200 m of schools, playgrounds and crèches or at children's sports events. Thanks to an amendment we secured on Committee Stage, this legislation's focus on child protection has been made very clear and is now explicitly stated in the Long Title of the Bill.

When we seek to address alcohol marketing in legislation, we are clear that we are focusing in particular on children. I thank the Children's Rights Alliance and other children's organisations that have supported us in our efforts. However, there is a significant gap in the Bill as it stands, in so far as it does nothing to address the growing problem of children's exposure to alcohol advertising online, especially through social media. This is really the most important means of reaching younger audiences today. My amendment would fill that gap by requiring advertisers to take "all reasonable steps" to ensure their online advertisements are not targeted at children. It provides guidance on what such reasonable steps might be. For example, there must be regard to whether "age verification controls" and "demographic targeting" have been used. Such mechanisms can be used to ensure particular Facebook advertisements do not appear on the timelines of users who are under a certain age.

This reasonable and workable measure draws on the current capacities of social media. Twitter, for example, has an age screening feature which requires each user to enter his or her date of birth before he or she can follow the account of an alcohol company. This amendment simply proposes that alcohol companies will be required to use such features where they exist. It does not relate to the content of advertisements, which is covered elsewhere in the Bill. It relates solely to alcohol advertisements that seek to target children. Importantly, the amendment merely asks companies to take "all reasonable steps" to prevent such targeting. It takes account of the cost of such measures, as well as the current state of the technology. This means that alcohol companies will not be asked to do anything unreasonable or disproportionately costly. They are simply being asked to use the normal tools that are available to exclude children from their advertisements. This is not a big request. It fills a really important hole in the Bill.

There is precedent for this proposal around the world. Facebook's advertising policies section gives information on the restrictions it uses in various countries. As a result of legislation like the Bill before the House, Facebook advertisements in Sweden, for example, are not targeted at people under the age of 25. We should seek to emulate this pretty simple measure here. I do not think it is unreasonable to ask companies to make an effort not to market alcohol to children on their smart phones. Such marketing practice is a reality today. I hope the Minister and Senators on all sides of the House will support this proposal.

Comment on this

I second the amendment. We welcome and support all the amendments in this group. As Senator Black has outlined, they relate to the issue of child protection, which is now covered under the heads of the Bill. Facebook, Twitter and Instagram are all owned by Facebook. Social media, which is an endless and all-pervasive means of communication, is the way of the future and is replacing one-to-one interaction. We have proposed these amendments, which seek to strengthen the child protection elements of the Bill with specific reference to online exposure, because we are responsible and we want to be protective of our children's futures.

When representatives of Facebook appeared before the Joint Committee on Children and Youth Affairs last week, we asked them to strengthen their protocols for dealing with cyberbullying, etc. I was not too convinced by their answers. I am not convinced that they have sufficient numbers to deal with Facebook's 1 billion members. While Facebook's child protection policies seem to be decent enough on the face of it, they are not doing the job they need to do. Facebook has said it will employ an additional 10,000 staff members around the world, many of whom will be involved in policing child bullying, in particular. I suggest these companies need to consider employing more people to ensure children who access Facebook, Twitter and Instagram on their phones can be protected. I welcome this important legislative proposal.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The central amendment is amendment No. 15. All of us share the objective of protecting children because children are the most vulnerable group and are easily targeted. They are also deliberately and specifically targeted by the drinks industry and there is an intention to introduce children to alcohol.

The proposed new section in amendment No. 15 includes the following paragraph: "A person shall not advertise, or cause to be advertised, an alcohol product by means of an information society service unless all reasonable steps are taken to ensure that the advertising cannot be viewed by children." I am curious to know who will monitor this provision. Will an agency do so because without monitoring, it will be useless verbiage?

I do not use social media and I am glad to say I am a complete computer virgin and hope to go to my grave as such. However, I understand the powerful impact of social media, particularly on young people. Wherever one sees young people, whether on the street, on a bus or in a restaurant, they are always checking things on their telephones. The measures provided for in amendment No. 15, including checks on whether age verification controls and demographic targeting have been used and whether an advertisement has been labelled or registered in a way that permits it to be blocked, are all important and practical. I commend the other Senators in the group which tabled the amendment. I hope it will be accepted by the Minister.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party group will support amendment No. 15 which is, as Senator Norris pointed out, the substantive amendment in the group. Enforcing its provisions will be a much harder task, however. I ask the companies in question to erect the barriers provided for in the amendment. There is very little we can do if young people provide a false date of birth on a website. A child of 11, 12, 16 or 17 years could indicate on a website that he or she is 18 years old. While the amendment is well intentioned, I do not know how effective it will be. It is fair to require that a mechanism be provided on a website, even if someone can enter false details to obtain access to information.

Comment on this

I oppose amendment No. 15 because the proposed measures are impractical and could not be policed. If one considers its implications, an advertisement placed on an Internet service abroad which then becomes available in Ireland through the Internet simply cannot be policed. If we accept the amendment, we will create a criminal offence punishable by the courts which no one can police. It is not practical to provide that all reasonable steps be taken to ensure children do not have access to a particular Internet medium. If, for instance, a site such as Netflix had an advertisement for Coors beer attached to a film, what could we do about it? Who would we prosecute and what court would sit and listen to the case? I note amendment No. 15 refers to "a jury". What jury will waste its time listening to such a case?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

If a jury is empanelled, its members must listen to the case.

Comment on this

They would be better at home.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Juries cannot choose what they listen to.

Comment on this

That is the point. They should not be asked to waste their time on futile prosecutions.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

That is a different point from the first point the Senator made.

Comment on this

Let us be practical by not inserting in legislation provisions that we know will not and cannot be enforced.

Comment on this

I believe we can monitor these measures. We should look forward to many discussions in the House on how we engage with online platforms and advertising. The reality of the modern world is that the online sphere, the data sphere and the way in which consent and access are managed are all part of people's everyday lives. As such, they fall into our realm, as legislators, and we cannot shirk the issue. This area is not an amorphous wilderness. Many of these advertisements are commercial in nature and are purchased through commercial platforms.

The previous speaker referred to Netflix. There are many mechanisms already in place to prevent people from watching certain films within certain jurisdictions. We all encounter cases of films being variously blocked or not blocked within certain territories. What is broadcast online and via the Internet is already affected by geographical jurisdiction and regional area. It is not a simple empty space but a space which we, as regulators, will have to consider more and more in order that we can provide protection and empowerment to citizens as they engage in it.

I will bring forward legislation in the near future to address the way in which citizens' data are used or targeted online. We must be clear that this is not a mysterious world but the world in which citizens, including children, operate. We have responsibility in this area and the proposed measures are highly practical. They provide for simple mechanisms such as age verification controls and how an advertisement is targeted once purchased. Advertising, as a commercial practice is an appropriate realm for regulation. The way in which an advertisement is targeted once purchased is a concrete, commercial, regulatory decision which falls within our realm. Legislators and the Judiciary will have to upskill in this area. The amendment is a good step forward and I will strongly support it.

Comment on this

Two issues arise regarding amendment No. 15. While most people will agree with the sentiment behind it, as Senator McDowell stated, the issue of enforceability arises. The amendment has probably started a conversation. We must ensure, however, that legislation is practical and works. We must not suddenly find that certain measures are unworkable because it is virtually impossible to unwind them. While the sentiments behind the amendment are good, we may need time to examine how the proposed measures could work in practice.

Comment on this

While I also support the sentiments underpinning the proposed amendment, I also share Senator McDowell's view on the issue of enforceability. There is no point including measures which cannot be enforced. It would be difficult to enforce these measures because much of the advertising involved is international in nature. We could seek to make progress in this area at European level. The problem with the amendment is the enforceability of the proposals.

Comment on this

As several previous speakers noted, the issue is one of enforcement. While we all agree that the sentiment behind the amendment is positive, there is no point including in legislation measures that cannot be enforced. We do not want to introduce a measure that does not work. We must take a practical approach. For this reason, I support the stance taken by the Minister.

Comment on this

I echo the views expressed by previous speakers on the purpose of the proposed measures, namely, the protection of children. Unfortunately, over the years, we have introduced laws which were subsequently shown to be unenforceable or not legal and fell as a result. Let us not allow the perfect to get in the way of the good. The good being done in the Bill is considerable and the Minister will be remembered for a long time for bringing the legislation through the House. I do not want it to fall or fail because of a well intentioned but unworkable amendment.

Comment on this

Senator Reilly's brief contribution got to the nub of the issue and does not merit repetition. As a parent and educationalist - I was a teacher for many years - it is important that young people are protected. We will have to address the potential of the Internet, Facebook and so forth to damage children. This is a whole new area which will need to be addressed properly.

All I want to do is acknowledge the quality of thought behind the amendments and the sentiments therein. The other arguments are well made and I will not repeat them.

Comment on this

I thank Senator Black and her colleagues for tabling the amendment. I will begin by agreeing that they strengthened the Bill by adding the words "children and child protection" specifically into the Title, which is what this Bill is about. Obviously, we want to change behaviour and culture in Ireland in terms of alcohol. In particular, we want to try to target and change behaviour and culture among the next generation of Irish citizens. I very much understand what the Senators have tried to do here. I feel a bit conflicted because I want to do the same thing as them. I want to arrive at a situation where we can put restrictions on advertising on the Internet in terms of this space.

I share the concern of others about not wanting to put anything into this Bill that is not then effective. I will provide some of my views, having taken some soundings on it. The amendments put forward propose provide for the creation of an offence in a case where a person advertises, or causes to be advertised, an alcohol product on an information society service unless all reasonable steps are taken to ensure that the advertisement cannot be viewed by children. These steps include whether age verification controls have been used to prevent access by children to an advertisement.

This amendment uses the framework of the audiovisual media service directive which is within the remit of my colleague, the Minister for Communications, Climate Action and Environment. My officials have consulted with that Department and the Department of Justice and Equality on this matter. The audiovisual media services directive is a sector-specific directive for television, and services that are like television. I am informed that the extension of its scope to include audiovisual content on any platform would cut across several directives and other regulations.

I would have some genuine concerns about the effectiveness of this proposed provision. If it was introduced for websites hosted in Ireland, for example, advertisers could simply move to websites that are not hosted in Ireland, but can be accessed by children in Ireland, in order to avoid the necessity to comply with this proposed amendment.

In terms of how effective age verification controls could be implemented, there is not enough clarity under the current proposal. A reliance on self-disclosure is obviously not a robust method of enforcement as children can simply claim to be over the age of 18 and, therefore, access the alcohol advertising.

I want to see this area fixed and Ireland should show leadership in this area. My ministerial colleagues and I should work at a European level on the audiovisual media services directive, which addresses all issues regarding intermediary or online platforms. That is what I will undertake to do, namely, to work with my colleague, the Minister for Communications, Climate Action and Environment. I hope this Bill will pass this House today. We will have an opportunity to further engage on this legislation before it is introduced into the Dáil. I do not think there is any Member in this House who does not want to achieve what the Senators concerned want to achieve. I respectfully suggest that we examine ways we can do this at a European level. This country has a very good record of working at a European level to advance the public health agenda and I will certainly undertake to do that. I hope that the Senators consider not pressing the amendments. I will commit to further engagement.

Comment on this
Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Senator Black has the final word.

Comment on this

I am disappointed that the Minister does not support the amendment. I am glad to hear that Fianna Fáil supports it. I hear what the Senators are saying. Everybody agrees with the sentiment behind the amendment and acceptance of it would be fantastic. We can see what happened with Facebook. Young children use Snapchat and it displays advertisements for alcohol all the time. I hope that the amendment gets enough support from Senators to be accepted. I thank Fianna Fáil, Sinn Féin and all the other Senators for supporting the amendment.

Comment on this
Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We are dealing with amendment No. 2.

Comment on this

Can I respond?

Comment on this
Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Yes, Minister.

Comment on this

Maybe we can try this another way. I genuinely do not want the Seanad to divide on this matter. My own party and the Government share the desire to protect children when they go online. I am concerned that the amendment may not be workable. I am concerned about the integrity of the Bill if we include an amendment we then find is not workable.

I reiterate my commitment to work with the concerned Senators on this issue. I will also engage with my colleague, the Minister for Communications, Climate Action and Environment, along with the Senators, on how we could reflect this when we go into the Dáil. I will give that very strong commitment here. I just do not want to leave this House with a sentiment in legislation that we all agree with but that may not be effective. I do not wish to divide the House on the matter but that, genuinely, is my very strong view.

Comment on this
Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment being pressed, Senator Black?

Comment on this

Which amendment is it?

Comment on this
Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We are dealing with amendment No. 2 at the moment, but these amendments are related.

Comment on this
Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

That is the Senator's prerogative.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 14
·
Níl 26
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 7, between lines 34 and 35, to insert the following:

“ “information society service” has the same meaning as it has in Article 1 of Directive (EU) 2015/1535 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 9 September 2015 laying down a procedure for the provision of information in the field of technical regulations and of rules on Information Society services;”.

Comment on this

I second the amendment.

Comment on this

I will not press the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

In page 8, between lines 5 and 6, to insert the following:

“ “media service provider” has the same meaning as it has in Article 1 of the Audiovisual Media Services Directive;”.

Comment on this

I second the amendment.

Comment on this

I will not press the amendment.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:

In page 10, line 21, after “20(1),” to insert “21(4),”.

Comment on this

I second the amendment.

Comment on this

I will not press the amendment.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 7 to 9, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 7 and 8 are to amend section 12 on the labelling provisions of this Bill. On Committee Stage, Senator McDowell rightly raised the possibility that section 12(1) would not allow for the import of alcohol products and the subsequent addition of the health information to the product before the sale. As I undertook to, I sought legal advice on the issue and, as rightly could be expected from such an eminent legal mind as Senator McDowell, this proved to be correct, so I am now amending the section. The objective of the labelling provision is to ensure that when the alcohol product is sold in the State, it has health and content information on it. Amendments Nos. 7 and 8 delete the offences of importing an alcohol product without the necessary information, either on the label as in section 12(1) or without a document setting out the information in the case of reusable containers as in section 12(3). To ensure that manufacturers, whether within or outside the jurisdiction are treated the same, amendment No. 7 also removes the offence of manufacturing a product with the intention to sell in the State without the necessary information. The result of these amendments does not change the substance of what we are doing with labelling but provides clarity that products will be able to be imported or manufactured without the necessary information but these cannot be sold without that information being added. This new formulation will achieve the same objective but by more proportionate means.

Amendment No. 9 from Senator Black and colleagues proposes to specify the amount of printed material which should be given over to health related warnings on labels. The form of the warnings and information to be included on labels and related documents can be prescribed by regulations made under section 12(10). As the Bill provides for the Minister for Health to be able to determine the form of the warnings and information, including to prescribe the size and font type of those warnings, I do not propose to accept this amendment, purely because the Minister has the power to do that through regulations. I think that is the better place to do it, rather than having to come back to primary legislation every time we want to amend a regulation.

Comment on this

Will the Minister clarify, on the labelling, the situation I raised at an earlier stage about airports? Products manufactured in Ireland will carry the labelling but there are a certain amount of international products that are only on sale at airports and not in the domestic market. What is the situation with them? It would seem that it is not really relevant to the prohibition of alcohol or whatever. Will the Minister clarify that?

Comment on this

I have raised this matter privately and publicly and I am obviously very supportive of the Bill. I am a strong advocate of this type of preventative health measure. I have raised this issue and want to support my colleague on the matter of airports. It is only a small exception. We are talking about rare whiskeys and rare wines. We know alcohol is still bad for a person but it is not drunk in volume, unless one is a very well-off person who wants to drink a particular expensive alcohol and buys it in bulk when going through the airport, which is logistically difficult. It is fair for an exception to be made here. Airports compete with other airports internationally. They do not compete with people in Ireland for the most part. They are competing with Amsterdam Airport Schiphol, Heathrow and so on. It is an international market where people who fly a lot and sometimes buy a rare whiskey will buy it in certain airports. There is probably recognition that Dublin is a reasonable place to get this type of rare alcohol. There could be a Taiwanese whiskey, which is very rare. Airports would not necessarily want to provide labelling on those bottles. I am not going to bash the Minister over the head with it, but at the end of the day, I am supportive of the Bill and think it is reasonable. We are not going to try to stop anything from going through today but if it could be addressed in the Dáil, I would appreciate it.

Comment on this
Ged Nash Senator Gerald Nash Labour Party

The Minister might reassure me that, given the changes he is proposing, it would still be an offence for an alcoholic product to be manufactured without the appropriate labelling being included on the container. There was confusion from some people I spoke to yesterday evening based on the changes the Minister is proposing. Some were assuming that a literal meaning of that might mean there would no longer be any obligation on the manufacturer to provide the labelling on the container but that that labelling obligation might fall on the shopkeeper. I am sure it is not the Minister's intention for that to be the case. Will he reassure me and the House that it is still the obligation of the manufacturer to include, on the container, the appropriate labelling as would be provided for under this legislation? In general, pertaining to labelling, I ask that the Minister and his officials engage in some detail with the Irish Cancer Society which is particularly anxious to ensure that we retain the measures, including the link between alcohol consumption and fatal cancers. I ask the Minister to engage with the society over the next short period between this Bill being passed, we hope, through Report and Final Stages today and when it enters the Dáil early in the new year. We want to ensure we can deploy best practice and get the best advice possible to ensure that this particular measure about linking excessive alcohol use and alcohol misuse to fatal cancers is done in the best possible way.

Comment on this

I will echo the last speaker. The health warnings are critically important. There was a real lack of awareness in this country until recently about the carcinogenic effect of alcohol and people need to be advised about it. The other issue I know was on the original Bill and which I presume is still there addresses the calorific content of alcohol. Many people do not realise how much of a contributor to obesity alcohol is. On the first point raised by Senator Nash, there is a need to be absolutely clear that all alcohol sold in this country, regardless of how it comes to be here, has to carry the warnings on the labels in their original context.

Comment on this

I will speak in favour of amendment No. 9 which seeks to ensure the evidence-based health warnings will take up a minimum of one third of the printed material on the label. As it stands, the Public Health (Alcohol) Bill makes it mandatory for labels to include health warnings but leaves details such as font, size, visibility and so on up to the Minister. We had a brief discussion on this point on Committee Stage and I understand the Minister feels that we should not put too much granular detail into the legislation. I appreciate this but without this amendment, we are essentially saying that we will leave it up to the Minister of the day to ensure the health warnings are noticeable and impactful. I know the Minister is very good and strong on this but a Minister might come in at another time who would not be as strong on it and that is my concern. I have no doubt that the Minister, Deputy Harris, would be very committed but we do not know if this would be the case for whoever may take up the role in the future. I am seeking reassurances on this point since I do not want to see a health warning introduced that amounts to a small run of text that simply will not make any difference. I am glad that the Bill will introduce these warnings but they must be substantial in size and clarity. They would not be effective if they were small and unnoticeable. I hope we will see support across the House, but if not, I urge the Minister to put strong assurances on the record today that when the labels are drawn up, expert advice will be sought on their size and shape and that they will be substantial.

Comment on this

An excellent thing that has arisen from the debate on the Public Health (Alcohol) Bill is the raising of awareness among people about the health consequences for abuse of alcohol in their lives and the consequences of binge-drinking. There has been much debate about it and we need more information and education. Alcohol, its abuse and the health consequences have been described. There are other foodstuffs that can have serious health consequences if abused or taken the wrong way.

I want to take up what Senator Noone had to say about the drinks industry at the moment. It is on the amendment and it is about the labelling. We are promoting the sale of premium drink products abroad. We are encouraging start-ups here at home. If we have a massive cancer sign on a label on a bottle of alcohol that we sell in this country but which is not on it when we are selling it abroad, there is a contradiction. We are saying that if one takes a drink here, potentially one is going to get cancer. We are selling it abroad but it is not subject to the same labelling. We also have the Internet to contend with and digital media. The idea that we have a product that we are selling abroad, saying it is premium, and yet we have a health warning label on it here, is something of a contradiction in policies.

In the development of the regulations around this, perhaps there could be engagement with the affected small start-up businesses and industry to get a reasonable solution. That would take on board what the Minister, Deputy Harris, is trying to do. It would also take on board the realities of business and the reality that the Government is encouraging them to produce this product and grow their businesses as provided for in Foodwise 2025. The Minister has engaged with the small shop owners in a most welcome fashion. Would he have a similar conversation with small start-up businesses and industry and not just shut it down? There is a fair point about a certain contradiction.

Comment on this

I am following the same line of thought as Senator Mulherin. It is an issue I have raised previously. We have a whiskey industry that we are trying to promote nationally and internationally. It is one of the key drivers in some parts of the economy, particularly in the southern half of the country. We have to look where we are going with our microbrewing industry and how we are tying it into place. These are high-end expensive products. These are products that are really like a collector's item rather than an item for consumption. Is it practical to be putting labels on something that will probably never be consumed? When we look at where the industry and market is going worldwide, there is a niche in that market itself.

When the Bill goes to the Dáil, we might look at some flexibility around these issues regarding this high-end product. Senator Noone said that there are very few people going to be consuming these products. They are such a high-end product that it is very unusual to see them consumed in a manner which will cause huge issues. It is an issue that we could look at, in particular the high-end issue. I have no problem, and I mean this, with the low-end stuff because that is where we need the legislation to take effect. Looking at what we are trying to do, we have a food policy in place, we are putting money into our distilling industry and there is also going to be a tourism trail for the whiskey industry itself. This is going to be very high-end stuff. When we put a label on such a high-end product, it does not do it justice in many ways. We should look at some flexibility around that issue.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I have heard a fair amount of nonsense in my time but there is a good quantity of it around here this morning.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Please be brief.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I will be very brief and absolutely to the point, as I always am. I am strongly in favour of alerting people to the dangers of cancer.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is an extraordinary attitude to say let us protect our own citizens but we will poison all the bloody old foreigners. We do not give a damn about them. They can get cancer in Germany or Italy or France or wherever it is. It does not bother us. We will not have to pay for it through our health service. I think that is a lot of rubbish. I also think it is a complete load of rubbish to say that these are collectors' items and that people are going to buy them, stick them up and admire them. Fine, if they are not going to drink them the label is not going to affect them. Forget that argument for a start.

Then there is this stuff about airports competing against each other. With the greatest respect, and I paid tribute to Senator Noone yesterday for her wonderful conduct of the Joint Committee on the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution, on the idea that airports are competing with each other, does the Senator seriously think-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

-----that someone going from Dublin Airport will say he or she cannot get his or her rare Vietnamese whiskey? I have never heard of Vietnamese whiskey-----

Comment on this

Taiwanese. The Senator needs to educate himself.

Comment on this

Very high quality.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Taiwanese. High-class Taiwanese. I will spite Dublin Airport, take myself off, get a flight from Schiphol Airport and I will buy my Taiwanese whiskey there. I never heard such utter rubbish in my entire life and I have heard a fair quantity of rubbish both here and in Trinity.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Order, please.

Comment on this

Senator Norris is as entertaining as ever. I am speaking as a co-signatory to amendment No. 9 on health consequences. I know we will deal later with an amendment to this tabled by the Labour Party. One third of the space to be given is an appropriate amount to protect our health. It is not just physical health consequences and every single part of our bodies, but also our minds. We had the association of general practitioners in yesterday presenting to Committee on the Future of Mental Health Care. When we asked the representatives about alcohol and co-morbidity, they just threw their eyes up and threw their hands in the air. I cannot emphasise enough the impact of alcohol. A third of the space on a bottle, can or whatever it may be is appropriate to warn against alcohol abuse.

Comment on this

I thank Senator McDowell for highlighting the issues relating to sections 7 and 8. I thank the Minister, Deputy Harris, for looking at it very carefully, taking on board comments in the previous debate and bringing forward the amendments. They are very welcome. On amendment No. 9, this is not an unreasonable amendment. We are talking about one third of the total printed material being set aside for health warnings. It is a matter that we should give serious consideration to in accepting this amendment. I certainly think it has been well researched by the Senators who have brought it forward. It is something that we should support.

Comment on this

I want to raise again a matter I raised on Committee Stage, namely, the language of any warning. Is it going to be in both Irish and English or will one suffice? I have not had any clarity on this thus far. If it is going to be in both languages, I am just making the point that these are going to get very lengthy. I remember getting my bus tickets when I was a kid going to school in the 1950s and wondering what the small print in the corner of the bus ticket actually meant, whenever there was ink in the conductor's machine to read it.

We have got to the point now where if we are going to have bilingual notices, that might also colour what Senator Norris has said about sending our produce off to Vietnam in Irish as well. There are issues which we have to be practical about here-----

Senator Michael McDowell: There was a matter that I raised on the Committee Stage and I want to raise it again now. That is the lanuage of any warning. Is it going to be in both Irish and English? Or will one suffice? I have not had any clarity on this thus far. If it is going to be in both languages these are going to get very lenghty. I remember getting my bus tickets when I was a kid going to school in the 1950s and wondering what the small print in the corner of the bus ticket actualyy meant when there was actually ink in the conductor's machine to read it. We have got toit the point now that if we are going to have bilingual notices that might also colour what Senator Norris has said about sending our produce off to Vietnam in Irish as well. There are issues which we have to be practical about here.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

There are Vietnamese Irish speakers. Did we not have one winning a case about-----

Comment on this

Exactly. The point I want to raise is that before we get carried away about the physical extent of the written words we had better be clear about what is going to be written and in how many languages it is going to be written.

Comment on this

I agree with Senator McDowell that we should be very clear what we are going to put on the labels. In relation to what my colleague from Mayo, Senator Mulherin, said about the labels, we should take a look at it before it goes to the Dáil. The organisation known as Drinkaware is funded by the industry; it does great work and works closely with the Department of Health on problems that people have-----

Comment on this

Redefine "close".

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

One at a time. Order, please. Senator Paddy Burke has the floor. Please be respectful.

Comment on this

I am led to believe that the health service works closely with it when people have problems. They go to it for advice on various issues regarding measurements and so forth.

It has brought forward many good proposals. It is funded by the organisation. It is independent and has an independent board.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

One is never independent if one is funded by a sectional interest.

Comment on this

The board is fully independent. It does great work. I ask the Minister to look at this in regard to the labels that he will draft. There will be no need for Drinkaware when the Minister drafts the label that is proposed in this legislation. I am asking the Minister to look at this before the Bill goes to the Dáil or before he concludes in the Dáil.

Comment on this

It is important the Minister clarify that this only applies to products sold in the State. I think there is merit in Senator Reilly's comment about calorific value, however one manages to quantify it, so that people know the calories. Perhaps we need to consider identifying it by symbols, for example the symbols on food packages - the red, the green, the orange or whatever. I am not an expert in this area but if we are to have writing in Irish and English - Senator McDowell might want it written in Latin-----

Comment on this

That would be too laborious.

Comment on this

Deputy Harris made a point about the ministerial order, and I presume the ministerial order could specify greater than one third, such as 40% or 50%. The amendment is looking for a guarantee of one third. Will the Minister indicate his thoughts as to where his initial base position is on this?

Comment on this

I want to put factual information in the public domain on Drinkaware. Drinkaware is funded by the alcohol industry.

Comment on this

I said that.

Comment on this

That means it is not an independent organisation and it does not work with the Department of Health. At present Drinkaware in South Africa is running a domestic violence campaign while also advertising whiskey. Drinkaware is trying to get into the health system, to also make profits on drink. It should be on the record that Drinkaware does not work with the Department of Health. I do not believe the Department of Health wants to work with it. It is not independent and has a vested interest in alcohol and alcohol sales.

Comment on this

Let me reiterate, as colleagues have, that my Department has no relationship whatsoever with Drinkaware.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

My Department has also written to other Departments and agencies to make that very clear, including the Road Safety Authority and the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade. I know that Senator Paddy Burke is supporting the legislation. What we are doing today is quite significant. We are moving beyond the need for industry baddies taking responsibility or voluntary codes, to state that we as legislators are taking charge of this-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

-----and that we have a public health duty. It is for the industry to do whatever it wants but that we will have our own labelling system as a result of the legislation. I accept the points Senator Paddy Burke makes about the need to engage, consult and inform people about any change to any labels and to engage with a wide range of stakeholders. I will certainly undertake to do so. If one is making a change to any product it is important to notify people and inform them of the impact it will have in advance of that happening.

Senator Nash put an important question about the practicalities of who has to put the label on the product after this change. That is an important point. In the original Bill and now, the offence is "to sell" and it arises when the product is being sold. For example, industry will have to sell to a wholesaler before it gets to the shops. I am quite satisfied that the practical obligation will still rest with whoever wants to sell the products because nobody will be able to sell the product without the appropriate label.

On the question of the size of the labels, I have listened very carefully to what Senators Black and Horkan have said as well as to what my Fine Gael colleagues have said. I am willing to accept that amendment because it is in line with what we were going to do anyway.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is the Minister going to accept amendment No. 9?

Comment on this

Yes. As the Senator was good enough to outline, it is in line with what I intend to do anyway. Putting it in legislation just provides that absolute clarity.

Comment on this

Congratulations.

Comment on this

I always planned on introducing labels. We are not here just to pretend we are going to do things. We are putting labels on to make people very much aware of the health consequences. I thank Senators Black and Devine for bringing forward the amendment. I am happy to accept it.

The legislation already states in section 12(11) that when the Minister or any future Minister for Health is making regulations, he or she should consider any expert research available on the effectiveness of labels. We have tried to capture that already in the legislation.

I take the point that Senator Mulherin makes about other products and the importance of making our citizens aware right across the range of products in terms of their own health and the health content or lack thereof in various products. Through the Healthy Ireland agenda and the national obesity strategy we will pursue that.

On the issue of labelling products for sale at airports, I hear what people are saying. There is a leadership role. If one were to stand in this Chamber and introduce the smoking ban years ago, one could have had people stand up and say, "We are doing it and other countries are not doing it." Sometimes somebody has to move. I certainly hope that Ireland making this change regarding labelling will result in it coming in other countries and that we will be able to go to European health Ministers' meetings and ask them if they have heard what we are doing in Ireland and if they have an opinion on it.

I take the point that regulations will enable me to engage in terms of providing specific information as well. From a health perspective, my basic premise is that if we are going to decide that we need to provide people with information and health information, we need to provide that, irrespective of where the product is sold in the country and irrespective of the cost of the product.

I am happy to clarify for Senator Horkan that this absolutely relates to sales in Ireland, not exports, but I certainly hope other countries will follow what I hope will be Ireland's lead in this area.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Will the Minister clarify the question raised by Senator McDowell about whether the labelling would be in both English and Irish?

Comment on this

I should clarify that. I accidentally overlooked Senator McDowell's question. The labels, just as other labels, will have to be in both Irish and English.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the Minister for that clarification.

Comment on this
Ged Nash Senator Gerald Nash Labour Party

On a point of information.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I cannot allow Senator Nash in again.

Comment on this
Ged Nash Senator Gerald Nash Labour Party

In the interest of clarification I think it would be important that the Minister would clarify this point.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We cannot have another debate on it.

Comment on this
Ged Nash Senator Gerald Nash Labour Party

I am not requesting another debate. I am requesting clarification so that we are all clear on what we will have to support.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I should not be allowing any Senators to speak a second time on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Ged Nash Senator Gerald Nash Labour Party

Where does the onus for providing the label rest? In the original iteration of the Bill, the manufacturer had responsibility for providing the label on the container in which the alcohol was sold. It seems now that this responsibility is no longer with the manufacturer but ultimately rests with the person who will be selling it. At which point in the process is the label introduced? That is an important clarification.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Will the Minister clarify that point briefly?

Comment on this

That is a fair point. The offence in the Bill is "to sell". If one owns a shop and sells the alcohol without the label, one has committed an offence. The point I am making is that, in practice, the person producing the product will have to sell it to wholesalers. Who will buy the product?

Comment on this
Ged Nash Senator Gerald Nash Labour Party

If it leaves the manufacturers facility without the label, it is no longer an offence.

Comment on this

The offence is only committed when the product is on sale.

Comment on this
Ged Nash Senator Gerald Nash Labour Party

Is that at the point of sale?

Comment on this

Exactly. The distribution cycle will not work if people are producing products that cannot be sold.

Comment on this
Ged Nash Senator Gerald Nash Labour Party

I understand that in practice.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:

In page 15, line 39, to delete “concerned;” and substitute the following:

“concerned, where at least one third of the printed material will be given over to evidence- based health warnings;”.

Comment on this

I second the amendment.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendment No. 10 arises out of Committee Stage proceedings. Amendments Nos. 10 and 11 are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 10:

In page 17, between lines 28 and 29, to insert the following:

“(e) a premises which is defined as a visitor centre which may or may not attach to a manufacturing licensed premises, such a visitor centre being defined as a tourism attraction the purpose of which is to generate tourism based on the manufacturing process of an alcohol product.”

Comment on this

I second the amendment.

Comment on this

I second the amendment.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fail group tabled amendments Nos. 10, 18, 25 and 27, as well as amendments Nos. 16, 22 and 26, which are now Government amendments, as they have the same wording as Fianna Fáil amendments.

The Minister has come a long way from where he started and we have come a long way from where the Department started. We have moved from two bays to three bays and changed from one year to two years in terms of construction. We have gone from 1.8 m to 1.2 m in the physical barrier height.

Comment on this

Is this relevant to amendment No. 10?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Coffey, I am in the Chair and I will rule on these matters.

Comment on this

I am trying to be helpful but I will stop being helpful if Senator Coffey wants. With the Minister, our party has some significant achievements in the context of this Bill, so I will not press the amendment.

Comment on this
Ged Nash Senator Gerald Nash Labour Party

I move amendment No. 11:

In page 17, between lines 34 and 35, to insert the following:

“(c) a warning that is intended to inform the public of the direct link between alcohol and fatal cancers,”.

This is a fairly straightforward amendment. We have accepted the principle that there should be labelling around alcohol misuse and its link to fatal cancers. This amendment merely seeks to include the principle in the content of advertisements as well.

Comment on this

I second the amendment.

Comment on this

I agree in principle with the amendment but I am a bit worried about putting too much into legislation as it makes it difficult to bring forward regulations. Would the Senator be happy if this was brought forward by way of regulation? This would give more discretion to the Minister. It is important to emphasise that there is a direct link between alcohol and cancer but I think regulation would be the way to deal with it, rather than legislation.

Comment on this

I cannot support amendment No. 10 from Senators Swanick and Ardagh.

Comment on this

It has been withdrawn.

Comment on this

I will say a few words about amendment No. 11 from me and the Labour Party Senators. I would like to thank Senator Nash in particular for his co-operation on this point. We spoke at length on the previous Stage about the clear link between alcohol and cancer and the need to reflect this in the legislation. We know that every year in Ireland, 900 new cancers and 500 cancer deaths are attributable to alcohol, but public awareness on this point is very low and this amendment can help to change that.

I was delighted that the Minister and Senators from all sides of the House accepted our four amendments on this point on the previous Stage.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I disagree with my distinguished colleague, Senator Colm Burke. It is very important to put this amendment through. The link between alcohol and cancer has not, until recently, been generally known. I certainly did not know that one in eight cases of breast cancer was caused by alcohol. It is extremely important to insist that information about the link between cancer and alcohol consumption be put on these labels.

Comment on this

I support the amendment and commend the Senators who brought the amendment forward from Committee Stage. I repeat what I said on that Stage that this measure is vital. The death rate through cancer in the poorest parts of Dublin is twice the rate of affluent areas. The proportion of alcohol-related deaths from cancer in Ireland is higher than the European average. It is about education and having the information on the label in a very visible way. I commend our national broadcaster on its recent advertisements on the radio, which have featured women talking about breast cancer and its link to alcohol.

Comment on this

I will not repeat what everybody else has said but I endorse the amendment and thank Senator Nash for proposing it.

Comment on this

I agree with what the Minister said earlier. I commend him on accepting the earlier amendment because the more one puts into legislation the more difficult and unwieldy it is to deal with regulations at a later stage. On the same basis that we accepted the amendment of Senator Frances Black, we have to accept this amendment. This is a critical point of information that I raised earlier on. Awareness that excessive use of alcohol can cause fatal cancers is minimal in this country and it needs be put into law, so I hope the Minister will accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I wholeheartedly support this amendment and commend the Minister on accepting it. It shows how well the Seanad can work and that we are not overly political about things.

Comment on this

I support the amendment as it is important to be unequivocal about this. Along with many other people, I was unaware for a long time of the links with a number of cancers. Senator Devine is correct that the recent radio advertising campaign on the link between breast cancer and alcohol was effective and should be commended. There should be more of such advertising. Labelling is critical but advertising and other media have a strong impact.

Comment on this

I thank Senators for their contributions. I said on Committee Stage that there was no doubt that there was a link between alcohol and cancer. It is a scientific fact, even if some do not wish to acknowledge it in public debates. It is not the only condition linked to alcohol and we need to avoid creating a hierarchy of conditions. On Committee Stage, we accepted a reference to cancer in labelling so it is consistent to replicate that in advertising and I am happy to support amendment No. 11. I thank Senators Nash, Black and Devine and I also thank those from my own party and from Fianna Fáil for their work on this.

Comment on this
Ged Nash Senator Gerald Nash Labour Party

I welcome the Minister's commitment.

Amendment agreed to.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendment No. 12 arises out of Committee proceedings. Amendments Nos. 12 to 14, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 12:

In page 20, lines 3 and 4, to delete “or within 200 metres of the perimeter of the grounds,”.

This group of amendments deals with a proposal that it be an offence to have any form of advertisement, which is not attached to a pub, within 200 m of the perimeter of a school grounds, a crèche - which in colloquial terms is a preschool or an early schooling place - or a playground. I worked out the figures relating to the city of Dublin and there are 444 mainstream primary schools in the city, 177 post-primary schools and 1,260 child care facilities. If Senators were to open out a map and use a protractor to draw a 200 m exclusion zone around all of those premises they would see that many main roads would be off limits. The legislation requires one to look at the perimeter of a school so if there are extensive football grounds it would involve going off into the neighbouring roads for the 200 m limit within which advertising hoardings would be banned.

The second problem with this legislation is that, for example, if someone opened up a crèche in Hawkins Street or at one end of Temple Bar, the Heineken advertisement on O'Connell Bridge House would have to come down.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Good.

Comment on this

That is what this legislation is all about. I live in Ranelagh and on Ranelagh Road, for instance, one has the presence of a multidenominational school, Sandford Park School, Muckross Park School, and the Church of Ireland national school beside Sandford church. The provision means, effectively, that large swathes of streets become off-limits to advertising hoardings.

Comment on this

That is the point.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Order in the House.

Comment on this

If that is the point, then let us be clear that one can have advertisements for McDonalds, Smarties and fattening sweets in these places. However, one would be operating on the basis that children going into a crèche would be influenced by a Coors beer advertisement, in some sense, and softened up psychologically to alcohol when they reach the ages of 15, 16, 17 or 18.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Absolutely.

Comment on this

That is the point. Senator McDowell is being repetitive.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Order, please. Senator McDowell, please.

Comment on this

In my view this is pathetic, stupid legislation.

I wish to raise another point and I ask the Minister to deal with it as well. What if a lorry delivering beer has the word "Heineken" displayed on it? Is that an offence?

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

Is this a way of saying that all delivery lorries for drink must now not pass within 200 m of a school or a crèche on their delivery rounds? We have got to be practical in what we try to do by legislation.

Senators have spoken here about the necessity to stop normalising alcohol. There is a diametric difference between me and those people because I believe that alcohol is normal. I believe that alcohol has been normal in Irish society for millennia.

Comment on this

That is the problem.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Hold on.

Comment on this

Some Senators here may think that is a problem. It certainly is a problem for some but it is not a problem for the great majority of people in this country. Alcohol has been part of our social life.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Then we should not have the Bill at all.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Order, please.

Comment on this

Alcohol is part of our social life. Alcohol is not the same as cigarettes. We have not decided as a country to wipe out alcohol or introduce a series of prohibitions to prohibit its place in our society. That is not part of the social programme here. Alcohol has existed for millennia and alcohol has been normal for millennia. There was a time when water was so unsafe to drink that one had to drink beer. That is where beer came from in the first place.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Order, please. Senator McDowell, without interruption.

Comment on this

Let us be clear about what we are talking about.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the Senator.

Comment on this

If we are going to ban the advertisement of alcohol we are saying, effectively, that alcohol is to become a dying industry in Ireland.

Comment on this

I support a lot of it.

Comment on this

The production of alcohol is to become a sequestered industry, which dare not speak its name and that the advertisement on, for example, Guinness or Heineken lorries, is to be something that must be painted out because we cannot have them in public advertising near a school.

I am quite happy that schools should not have advertisements for alcohol on their premises. I agree with that proposition.

Comment on this

I am delighted to hear that.

Comment on this

I would even, if people were mad enough to suggest that it would happen, prohibit the presence of alcohol advertisements in crèches. I do not know who is going to do that but I am against it. If the proponents of this legislation think that is a good idea then I think that is a good idea.

Comment on this

We are getting to the truth of it now.

Comment on this

I have never seen anybody who was tempted to display an advertisement for alcohol near a children's playground. I do not think that the advertising industry is that stupid.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the Senator. We are discussing schools.

Comment on this

What this series of amendments is saying is that one can prohibit all of those things. To start working out no-go zones around three different categories of places is foolish legislation. It necessarily brings up the situation if there is an advertising hoarding, which has always advertised Coors or Heineken on the side of a road in Ranelagh or wherever else, that if somebody opens a crèche across the road then that advertising space can no longer be used for that particular purpose.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator has amply made the point, to be honest.

Comment on this

The Senator has mentioned Ranelagh and Heineken.

Comment on this

I think the Senator has a problem.

Comment on this

Just because some people may not want to hear it, a Leas-Chathaoirligh.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will hear it.

Comment on this

These are important points.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am not saying they are not.

Comment on this

I know, yes. I am grateful for your observations, a Leas-Chathaoirligh.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am trying to avoid repetition.

Comment on this

What we are faced with here is whether this law is practicable. I expect the Minister to deal with this matter now or give an undertaking that he will deal with it before he brings this legislation to the Dáil. Is advertising on lorries and advertising floats permissible? I mean the things that we all do at election time. We pretend that we are driving around the country with these things.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Going up lamp posts.

Comment on this

The media arrive and take a picture of a lorry that has an advertising thing on it, which can be brought to Lansdowne Road, Croke Park or wherever and parked in a prominent place. Is that caught by this legislation? If it is caught by this legislation, does it mean that because a crèche has opened beside Lansdowne Road or Croke Park that becomes illegal? Does it even matter if the crèche is open? These are the kinds of things that we have to actually think about before we bring in stupid laws.

Comment on this

There will be a big advertisement for McDonalds and all of the ill-effects that is supposed to have. I am sure that Senator Reilly, who is a doctor, can tell us all about the obesity aspects of Big Macs, chips and all of the rest of it.

Comment on this

The Senator-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Surely, many of the----

Comment on this

Such advertisements will be displayed and they will not have to be taken down because there is a crèche nearby but something for Heineken, Coors or similar will be made illegal. I think this is a stupid law. I want the Minister to point out and say to me-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will-----

Comment on this

-----whether it will be lawful or unlawful to have a lorry carrying a big sign on the road advertising a drink. If that is the case, I ask him to confirm whether it will become unlawful to drive that lorry within 200 m of a crèche.

Comment on this

One cannot-----

Comment on this

Is that the law that the Minister is proposing? It seems to be what is in this section.

Comment on this