We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

MetroLink value and consultation

Summary

Senator McDowell continued his criticism of the MetroLink proposal, arguing the Oireachtas had not been given enough opportunity to assess alternatives. The exchange broadened into a debate on consultation, with other Senators interjecting and the Leader insisting the process was open and transparent.

I cannot perform bilocation, as the Leader understands.

Comment on this
Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

We always try to accommodate senior Senators.

Comment on this

He is not a senior Senator but a new one.

Comment on this

I refer to the proposed MetroLink in the national transport infrastructure plan. I live close to the Luas green line and have strongly supported such public transport initiatives. I am not a NIMBY person in any shape or form. However, the House may or may not be aware that it is proposed to incorporate the Luas green line with a metrorail system. While that may seem innocuous and fine, we have just spent €368 million in extending the Luas green line to Cabra. We are now being told that a metro system will be built at a cost of between €3 billion and €4 billion, replicating, in large measure, in the city centre access to places such as St. Stephen's Green and O’Connell Street with new underground stations. Will the Leader ask the Minister for Transport, Tourism and Sport, Deputy Shane Ross, to explain to the House how this proposal is being described to all and sundry as a public consultation process, when, from an email I received yesterday, an €18 million tender for architecture and engineering has already been awarded for the project? If it is a genuine consultation process, I would like to have some clear views on where Dublin's transport infrastructure could be alternatively served in areas such as Rathfarnham, south-west Dublin and different areas of north Dublin, as well as keeping the Luas green line. I would like to have some indication as to who made the decision to do this, why and what the alternatives are. To describe it as a public consultation process and for Transport Infrastructure Ireland executives to say they are open to discussion about the alternatives rings very hollow when one sees the detailed planning and realises an €18 million tender has already been awarded for the particular module.

Comment on this

Is it Ceaucescu era consultation?

Comment on this

It reminds me of a certain bowl in north-west Dublin several years ago. It raises the question of whether we should be considering alternatives before we commit to this €3 billion to €4 billion project. If we have up to €4 billion to invest in public transport in the Dublin region, I do not believe the Houses of the Oireachtas have been given a fair opportunity to consider if this is the best idea. Even in the worst case scenario, if the project were go ahead, as I very much doubt that it will in the end, the existing Luas green line would be closed for between one and two years. People should be told the consequences of the decisions being made in their names.

Comment on this