We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

Cervical screening concerns

Summary

Senator Maria Byrne and Senator Murnane O'Connor joined the call for a debate on CervicalCheck and for the Minister to come to the House, stressing Vicky Phelan's bravery and the distress caused to women. The Chair noted the matter had already been proposed and taken.

I congratulate our two new Senators and look forward to working with them. This is an historic day for both and I wish them all the best for the rest of the term.

I join other Senators who raised the plight of Ms Vicky Phelan and discussed how brave she has been. As the House knows, Vicky comes from Limerick. I compliment her and her family on the strength and power shown in interviews. Were it not for her, many of us would not be calling on the Leader to arrange for a debate on the importance and future of CervicalCheck and to find out what went wrong. The Minister has been encouraging people, but particularly women, to proceed with the various checkups that are available. I support Senators' calls for the Minister to be invited to the House to debate the CervicalCheck situation.

I attended the inaugural apprenticeship awards ceremony last night with the Minister for Education and Skills, Deputy Bruton. The competition was sponsored by the Construction Industry Federation, CIF, and the ESB. I congratulate the hospitality section of the Limerick and Clare Education and Training Board and the Limerick College of Further Education, which jointly submitted a culinary skills entry. It was wonderful for them to reach the last seven.

Comment on this

I welcome the two new Senators. We often have a few battles here but overall, everyone gets on extremely well.

I echo what has been said regarding this disturbing information dripping from the HSE in the past few days. Thousands of women across Ireland have been on tenterhooks in case their telephone will ring to inform them that they are among those women who are walking around with something that could kill them. The HSE put them in this position when it was revealed that it had not been able to contact all those affected. The cervical screening programme is extremely important. Early intervention, this type of screening and initiatives like the HPV vaccine are vital in reducing cervical cancer rates in Ireland. Everyone now has devastating doubts. There has been a breach of trust yet again. Yet again, the women of Ireland are not being looked after and there are questions to be answered here. I heard the briefing from the HSE yesterday and was sickened to learn that women still are being contacted today. Those women and their families must be in hell right now. Some women still cannot be located because no one can tally their records. This is beyond belief and it appears as though we may not have the whole truth. Women have died.

The chairperson of the HSE serious incident management team stated that 162 out of 208 women affected by the screening were not told that a review had been conducted by CervicalCheck or of the outcome. As a matter of urgency, the HSE must be held accountable. As far as I have seen, the HSE is like the wild west: anything goes and there are no laws, which is unacceptable. The Minister, Deputy Harris, must rush in to provide independent scrutiny in this regard. It must be efficient and fast and an outcome is needed because women are suffering. There must be a reason for someone to make a mistake and there needs to be a better system for concerns to be raised and heard. First and foremost, women must be told as soon as anything like this happens. I believe the Minister needs to come in and address this issue.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That has already been proposed.

Comment on this

I appreciate that. This is a major issue for the women of Ireland.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The point is taken.

Comment on this