We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ Order of Business

Michael D Higgins re-election

Summary

Senator Gavan congratulated President Higgins and used the opportunity to highlight racist abuse of footballer James McClean. Senator Burke also congratulated the President, thanked other candidates, and emphasised the democratic legitimacy of the result.

I also give full congratulations to President Michael D. Higgins on his success in the presidential election and I wish him well for the next seven years.

I welcome the statement this afternoon from Show Racism the Red Card in Ireland and England, both of which have joined with the Professional Footballers Association of Ireland to support James McClean and call on the English Football Association, FA, to investigate all incidents of anti-Irish discrimination. Members who have seen the videos from the weekend will be aware of the horrific treatment meted out to James last Saturday during a football game. In that context, it is probably time to call for a debate on commemoration in light of the 100th anniversary of the First World War. Hopefully, there is a great deal on which we can all agree. The first is that the 35,000 to 40,000 Irishmen and Irishwomen who died should be remembered. They have been written out of the history of this State for too long. I hope we would also be able to agree on the nature of that war, a pointless, futile exercise with needless deaths and a generation butchered and damned, as the song says. The conflict was a war of empires. We could at least agree on that. Indeed, we could perhaps reflect on the role of John Redmond in encouraging so many Irish men to pointless and horrendous deaths. Where we would disagree, I suspect, is on how to commemorate them. I would not wear a poppy. The reason is what the poppy symbolises. It is on the Royal British Legion website that it is to commemorate the dead of all wars including colonial wars, which the site lists as including Iraq, Afghanistan, the Falklands, Kenya, Cyprus and in our country. People will say they are wearing the poppy only to commemorate the Irish dead. That is fine, but it is not what the poppy symbolises. That is the reality, not an opinion. People can look up the Royal British Legion website. The other problem is that the Royal British Legion, unfortunately, has been and continues to be a cheerleader for British wars, both past and present. That is a fact.

We must find a way to commemorate the poor people who suffered horrendously in that war. We should be able to do that as an independent Irish nation. It is important we do so and have a mature debate on it. I recognise Senator Feighan's genuine attempt to do that. However, it is flawed for two reasons. First, it still represents the poppy and, second, the Royal British Legion is attached to it. I do not wish to commemorate the men in Afghanistan today or the British soldiers in Iraq, and I do not believe the Irish people wish to do so. Let us have a mature debate on this and, hopefully, reach a positive consensus.

Comment on this

I join colleagues in congratulating Michael D. Higgins on his re-election as President of Ireland. It is also appropriate to thank the other candidates, including our colleague, Senator Freeman, who took part. I do not necessarily agree with the views expressed by some of the candidates but this is about democracy and people who put their heads above the parapet should be given recognition for doing so and be thanked for allowing their names to go forward in the democratic process. It is the electorate - not this or the Lower House - that decides how it will vote. The electorate is extremely independent and it gives what it considers to be the appropriate decision. On this occasion it gave its decision in favour of Michael D. Higgins.

I wish to refer to the facility in Cork that was purchased by Cuan Mhuire for €2.1 million in 2007. It was refurbished but has been lying idle for the past eight years. It has the capacity to cater for 18 people at any time but there appears to be a disagreement between Cuan Mhuire, the HSE, Cork City Council and various Departments on how the facility should operate. We are facing into a difficult period in the run-up to Christmas, with people trying to access accommodation. However, this extremely good facility is lying idle because people cannot come to an agreement. Cuan Mhuire set out a careful plan for how it wished to use it, but it appears that some people in the HSE have not come to the same view. In fairness, Cork City Council is prepared to come on board and offer assistance provided agreement can be reached.

It is wrong that where money has been invested by an organisation and where it needs the support of the health service and the local authority, we find the facility lying idle. I ask that this matter be brought to the attention of the Minister. I also hope that we might have a debate about value for money within the HSE and about facilities like this being left idle when they could be put to good use.

Comment on this