Children's hospital and defence housing
Senator Wilson backed criticism of the hospital overrun, argued the cost had escalated repeatedly, and blamed political handling of the Mater site decision. He then moved to the housing of Defence Forces members, calling it wasteful to leave a purpose-built barracks idle while soldiers are housed in warehouses.
I support Senator Clifford-Lee, my party's deputy leader in the Seanad, in her comments on the national children's hospital and the overrun. Statements on housing are listed on the Order of Business and it is appropriate that we should raise the housing of sick children and the building in which they will be housed. Senator Marie-Louise O'Donnell tabled a Private Members' motion in the previous Seanad, the aim of which was to try to prevent the Government from selling the national lottery licence. We were told at that stage that the cost of the hospital would be €450 million and that the sale of the national lottery licence would go more than half way towards providing funding for this much needed facility.
Comment on this
The amount involved became €930 million and has now risen to €1.7 billion. Following what was stated at a committee meeting last week, it appears that the final figure could be more than €2 billion. Senator Colm Burke pointed out the various stages of planning the hospital went through. The reality is that the decision of An Bord Pleanála regarding the Mater Hospital site could have been appealed but it was not and that was as a result of political reasons.
Comment on this
Where could the An Bord Pleanála decision be appealed to?
Comment on this
There is no appeal, except through the courts.
Comment on this
It was not for political reasons. Senator Wilson should get his facts right.
Comment on this
I refer to the decision to transfer the project to the St. James's Hospital site.
Comment on this
I am making a ruling. Senator Wilson should be allowed to speak, without interruption.
Comment on this
The development costs of that site were outrageous.
Comment on this
The An Bord Pleanála decision would have had to be appealed through the courts.
Comment on this
I agree with my party's deputy leader in the Seanad-----
Comment on this
-----that it is time for the Minister for Health to come before the House to explain exactly what is going on. We do not need to pay €500,000 extra to PwC to tell us what we already know.
Comment on this
A blunder has been made. People are running for cover and do not want to be blamed for the overrun.
Comment on this
PwC was one of the auditors of the Bank of Ireland and was discussed at the banking inquiry.
Comment on this
The Minister has overall responsibility for the Department and it is time he came to the House and took responsibility.
Comment on this
I thank the Leas-Chathaoirleach for indulging me. In the context of housing, I also want to discuss the housing of members of the Defence Forces. This is an issue I have raised in the House on many occasions, including last week. A purpose-built, state-of-the-art Army barracks is lying idle in Cavan town at a time when the Department of Defence is looking at warehouses to put soldiers into.
Comment on this
It is more waste of money. It is nonsense. It is time people stood up and took responsibility for the Departments they are being paid to run.