We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Ormeau Road disclosure failure

Summary

Senator Conway-Walsh and Senator Bacik raise serious concerns about PSNI material withheld from the ombudsman in the Ormeau Road bookmakers case, linking it to systemic failures and wider justice issues.

Denis O'Donovan An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I call Senator Conway-Walsh. The good wishes also extend to her.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach and wish him and everyone here a happy St. Valentine's Day.

I raise the appalling revelation that emerged overnight that evidential materials were withheld by the PSNI from the police ombudsman in the North in the case of the atrocity at a bookmakers on the Ormeau Road in which five people were killed and several others injured. Relatives for Justice and its lawyers were continuously assured that, in the course of the police ombudsman's investigation, all of the materials sought had been provided. We now find that is not the case. There was clearly a systemic problem with disclosure in cases involving state killings, in particular killings where collusion was a feature. People may ask why this matter is the business of this House. The first reason is that the Government is the co-guarantor of the Good Friday Agreement. Moreover, there are many legal minds in this House who will find this revelation appalling. The only reason this evidence has come to light is that it was uncovered as part of a civil case that has been taken. It is appalling to hear the issue being explained away. My colleague, Senator Ó Donnghaile, has called time and again for money to be made available to enable inquests to be carried out and the depth and breadth of state collusion to be examined properly in order that the families can get the truth about what happened to their loved ones.

It is not good enough to say computer systems were archaic or that there were things that were not keyed in. There were the Stevens investigation, the review by Mr. Justice Cory and the de Silva review of the investigation into the murder of Pat Finucane by the UDA and in each of the three processes more material was uncovered that it had been claimed did not exist. It is time for the files to be opened and the information laid bare in order that the families can get the truth. It is also important for us to have it as we have had a narrative spun for us and we have turned our backs on what happened over the decades in the North. The files and the information now coming to light on collusion will help us all to better understand what went on during the conflict. I commend the Pat Finucane Centre and Anne Cadwallader on her wonderful work. I recommend her books to Members, in particular Lethal Allies.

Comment on this

I commend Senator Ruane on her Bill dealing with the rehabilitation of offenders and to expand the framework for spent convictions which was passed last night on Second Stage without opposition from the Government. I hope it will progress to Committee Stage. In the coming weeks Seanad group leaders will speak about the subject of making progress on Bills that have been passed on Second Stage without opposition from the Government.

I wish colleagues a happy St. Valentine's Day. Women's Aid has today launched a campaign to warn people about the dark side of dating and ensure there are knowledge and awareness, among young women in particular, of dating abuse which has been criminalised under the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 2017 as coercive control. The campaign has been launched with the hashtag, #TooIntoYou and is a way of bringing home, to young women in particular, the need to be aware of the signs when a relationship is becoming abusive such as when somebody stalks someone through the use of social media such as Twitter and persistent texting, including trolling. The Deputy Leader has been taking the lead on the issue for quite some time and we are all concerned about it. I am glad that Women's Aid has launched the campaign. Last night I spoke in the HIST debate of the historical society in Trinity College Dublin on the #MeToo movement. It was quite chilling to hear about the levels of sexual harassment the young women speakers had experienced. They are continuing to experience harassment, even with the #MeToo movement and despite there being greater awareness. Therefore, the campaign is really important. It is perhaps not very romantic to highlight the darker side of dating on St. Valentine's Day, but it is really necessary to do so.

Comment on this