We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Judicial Appointments Commission Bill 2017: Report Stage (Resumed)

Contributions 190–384 of 384. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Judicial Appointments Commission Bill 2017
Lapsed

No. 71 of 2017 ›

Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Conway will resume his seat.

Comment on this

I will not until I have finished making my point.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

You will.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

You will. The Senator will respect the Chair.

Comment on this

I am making a point.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator will respect the Chair. I want to clarify the proposal. Resume your seat.

Comment on this

No, my point-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

You will be heard.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

You are out of order.

Comment on this

There is filibustering going on and that is out of order.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Kick him out.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Out of order.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Kick him out.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Norris is also out of order.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Kick him out.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

With respect, I want to get this clarified. What, specifically, is the proposal?

Comment on this

I propose that we recommit the Bill to Committee Stage in respect of amendment No. 7 in order that it can be fully discussed on that Stage.

Comment on this

That is not acceptable to this side of the House.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator will be heard but he is out of order now.

Comment on this

I am not out of order.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

You are out of order if I say you are. I am in the Chair.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is proposed that the Bill be recommitted in respect of amendment No. 7 only. Senator Conway opposes the proposal.

Comment on this

Yes, I oppose the proposal because discussion on Committee Stage of this Bill went on for longer than 100 hours. This is a House of the Oireachtas. It is not a Chamber for filibustering. I seriously object to the Bill being recommitted. I seek the protection of the Leas-Chathaoirleach for the integrity of this House in ensuring it does not happen. It is totally inappropriate.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is the Senator's view.

Comment on this

I am not finished.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator is entitled to his view, for what it is worth. The House will decide.

Comment on this

The Chairman needs to rule on this.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I ruled in accordance with Standing Orders.

Comment on this

The Chairman is quoting Standing Orders.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We do not want this to go on.

Comment on this

It is totally unacceptable -----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is to the Senator, I accept that.

Comment on this

------ to recommit something on Committee Stage.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator is entitled to his view, for what it is worth. I thank the Senator. We will now hear from Senator Bacik.

Comment on this

The issue of recommital is one for the Chair's discretion.

Comment on this

That is missing my point entirely.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt Senator Conway.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is a matter for decision by the House.

Comment on this

No it is not.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am advised that it is a matter for decision by the House and I accept that.

Comment on this

I stand corrected. It is certainly not a matter for Senator Conway, nor is it a matter related to the amount of time.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is not a matter for any individual Senator. The Senator should be respectful.

Comment on this

Nor, if I may say so, does it relate to the amount of time spent discussing other amendments on Committee Stage. This is a new and substantive amendment.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I have a proposal.

Comment on this

I do not believe that I have broken any rule or gone against Standing Orders in any way.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I did not say that the Senator had.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Leas-Chathaoirleach's indulgence on this. I wish to move that the Bill be recommitted to Committee Stage in respect of the amendment.

Comment on this

I object to that.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senator Conway is opposing.

Comment on this

Will the Leas-Chathaoirleach clarify if it is at the discretion of the House or at the discretion of the Chair?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is a decision of the House.

Comment on this

I would like the specific Standing Order that covers that.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator has been given a ruling by me. It is a decision by the House.

Comment on this

Under what Standing Order was that made?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will give the Senator the number in a minute.

Senator Craughwell has proposed to recommit. Has it been seconded?

Comment on this

And it has been objected to.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

And it has been objected to strongly by Senator Conway. Senator McFadden has seconded the objection.

Comment on this

For the purpose of being orderly, Senator Craughwell has proposed that the Bill be recommitted for the purpose of discussing amendment No. 7. I have seconded that proposal. I understand there is opposition to it but it is a matter for a decision by the House.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is correct. I am going to put the proposal to the House.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the Bill be recommitted in respect of amendment No. 7."

Tá 8
·
Níl 11
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

On a point of order, does that mean we are returning to discussing all the amendments grouped together?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

No, the vote on the recommital of amendment No. 7 is defeated.

Comment on this

Yes, so the Leas-Chathaoirleach was proposing to group the debate.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will speak on that in a minute and then the Senator can decide.

I welcome the Minister back to the Chamber. We are back to Report Stage. I have already moved amendment No. 7. Will Senators please pay attention? We will have no repetition of what happened earlier. Amendment Nos 7 to 12, inclusive, are related; amendment Nos 8 and 9 are physical alternatives to amendment No. 7, which means that if amendment No. 7 is agreed, Senators will be unable to speak to amendments Nos. 8 and 9; amendment No. 11 is consequential on amendment No. 7; and amendments Nos 11 and 12 are physical alternatives to amendment No. 10. Amendments Nos. 7 to 12, inclusive, may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed?

Comment on this

Are amendments Nos. 11 and 12 alternatives?

Comment on this

I respectfully request that we do not group them together.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator wants to separate them. Is that what the Members wish?

Comment on this

The groupings are set independently of the Members. The Members cannot decide what amendments go with what.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We generally seek the assent of Members.

Comment on this

With respect, I have never seen the assent of Members being asked for any other Bill in the House. If we are going to allow a minority to dictate what happens, we would set a bad precedent.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We will not do that.

Comment on this

The groupings of amendments have always been determined independent of the Members of the House.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The House is always asked by the Chair are the groupings agreed.

Comment on this

Let us talk to Senator Higgins and see how she got on with her groupings.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Order, please. I had to ask if they were agreed.

Comment on this

May I suggest to have agreement and consensus ------

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That is what I am looking for.

Comment on this

----- that amendments Nos 7 to 10, inclusive, be taken together.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

But not amendment Nos. 11 and 12.

Comment on this

No, let us leave those separately.

Comment on this

Let us take amendments Nos. 7 to 12, inclusive.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is it agreed that amendments Nos 7 to 10, inclusive be taken together?

Comment on this

No, the Leas-Chathaoirleach proposed amendments Nos. 7 to 12, inclusive.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am advised that we can take amendments Nos. 7 to 10, inclusive, together.

Comment on this

May I ask on what basis? Why has the Chair changed his mind on the first grouping?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am not changing my mind. The Members know that if amendment No. 7 was agreed, amendments Nos. 8 and 9 cannot be moved. The Members who are disadvantaged accept that.

Comment on this

What is the point of the list?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Members cannot all speak together, please.

Comment on this

I am sorry for incurring the displeasure of the Chair.

Comment on this

The spokesperson on behalf of the Government is Senator Joe O'Reilly. He has indicated that he wishes to speak.

Comment on this

What is the purpose of drawing up a list independent of Members?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will take Members, one at a time.

Comment on this

Presumably these amendments are grouped here for a reason. It is presented as the order of the day.

Does it count for anything? Has it any standing?

Comment on this

It is only a suggestion.

Comment on this

Can it constantly be subject to amendment?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Unfortunately, it is up to the House. The tradition is to ask for agreement.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments are taken together by agreement.

Comment on this

There has never been a case in which it has been opposed.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

No, because there is always agreement.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Senators are all trying to speak together. Order, please. What does Senator Craughwell wish to say?

Comment on this

On a point of order, there is a great deal of spurious information being thrown out about things not having been accepted or done in the past. As the Leas-Chathaoirleach, who is doing an excellent job-----

Comment on this

The Senator is right.

Comment on this

-----rightly pointed out, the groupings are a suggestion. It is up to the House to agree them. We have accepted that amendments Nos. 7 to 10, inclusive, will be grouped.

Comment on this

With respect, the Senator is suggesting anarchy in the House.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Ciúnas, please. I must-----

Comment on this

Might I just add-----

Comment on this

This is a democracy.

Comment on this

No, it is anarchy.

Comment on this

With respect to Senator Craughwell-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am going to clarify the procedural position. I will read the House a note.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Order. Will Senators please resume their seats?

Comment on this

Is the order not what is on this paper?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senator is out of order. I am not hearing anything.

Comment on this

I was just pointing something out.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Save it. Will Senators please listen to me? I am going to make a ruling.

Comment on this

There is no point in the groupings if we are going to go on like this.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Hold on. I want you all to pay attention to this. The Chair is always anxious to accommodate, as far as is reasonable, the views of Senators as to the grouping of amendments, and for this purpose generally seeks the assent of the House before proceeding. However, it is ultimately the prerogative of the Chair as the judge of order in the Seanad to rule on methods by which amendments are to be discussed with reference to one another so that duplication of discussion can be avoided.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The grouping of amendments is also sometimes necessary to protect the interests of a Senator whose later amendment might not be open to debate by reason of a decision on an earlier amendment, for example, in the case of physical alternatives. Groupings are never a matter for formal decision by the House. Amendments are grouped for a variety of reasons, for example, where an amendment is consequential on another; where amendments are physical alternatives to one another, that is, they seek to amend the same text within the Bill such that the agreement of one amendment would necessarily preclude the moving of another; where amendments are logical alternatives to one another; where amendments are cognate, that is, they embody the same principle where they are offered to different parts of the Bill; and where amendments are similar, that is, they effect the same or similar purposes. Ultimately, amendments are grouped in the interests of an efficient and productive debate and the Chair exercises such latitudes as are available to him or her with those principles in mind.

Comment on this

I might try to bring this together. If groupings of amendments are suggested and printed, I presume that they should be up for discussion and, if challenged, voted on.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Again, that is the prerogative of the Chair.

Comment on this

Is this a filibuster of business?

Comment on this

Talk about the pot calling the kettle black. Jesus Christ.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Order, please.

Comment on this

We are learning from the masters.

Comment on this

That is an own goal, Senator McDowell.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Hold on. I am going to make a ruling in light of all that Senators have said. Amendments Nos. 7 to 10, inclusive, will be taken together by agreement.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am ruling on that now.

Comment on this

On what basis?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I have just explained it. I read it out.

Comment on this

I heard the-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Let us not hold up the show further.

Comment on this

Why are we changing the order that was presented to the House?

Comment on this

Who presented an order?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is not an order.

Comment on this

Why are we changing the groupings that were presented to the House?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I am now ruling. Let us proceed.

Comment on this

Let us get on with this.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 7 to 10, inclusive, are being taken together.

Comment on this

Since we have discussed those already, can we vote on them?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The House has not discussed them.

Comment on this

The Government still has to move it.

Comment on this

We have discussed amendment No. 7.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Hold on. These are Government amendments. I will call on the Minister after amendment No. 7 has been moved.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It will be. I will then call on the Minister.

Comment on this

On a point of order, if I can make one. The Leas-Chathaoirleach will probably tell me that I cannot.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Minister probably cannot.

Comment on this

It seems clear to me from what the Chair has said that he has introduced an element of confusion. To my mind, amendment No. 12 must be read in conjunction with amendment No. 10. The Chair has now split them. I advise against the type of decoupling that we had on an earlier Stage that resulted in contradictions in the Bill, but I am in the hands of the House. I just-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

If amendment No. 10 is agreed, amendments Nos. 11 and 12 cannot be moved.

Comment on this

The House has a disposition to do more than just throw up every procedural angle available in order to ensure that this debate is slowed down. As Chair of the proceedings, I ask the Leas-Chathaoirleach for assistance to ensure the smooth running of the debate insofar as he can. It seems that, if he decouples amendments Nos. 11 and 12 from amendment No. 10, which is now his proposal, we will be in waters that could give rise to a contradiction.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

With respect, it will affect the debate, not the decision. Senator McDowell quite understands that amendments Nos. 11 and 12-----

Comment on this

On a point of order-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Hold on.

Comment on this

It is a relevant point of order. How did the groupings arise originally? Who made the decision to group the amendments in this fashion?

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

A recommendation was made by the Bills Office.

Comment on this

There was an independent recommendation that they be grouped together. We should be guided by that recommendation.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We normally are, but the Chair is not instructed by the Bills Office.

Comment on this

On a point of order, there is a lot of waffle going on here about-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are moving on.

Comment on this

I need to make the point. There is a lot of waffle going on here-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

It is not a point of order.

Comment on this

-----about filibusters and using procedural issues.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I will let the Senator in when we are discussing the amendments.

Comment on this

In a moment, a Leas-Chathaoirligh.

Comment on this

The Senator would recognise filibustering.

Comment on this

It is the duty of every Member of the House to scrutinise legislation-----

Comment on this

But not to go into the Bills Office to organise this.

Comment on this

-----and use whatever parliamentary tools are available to him or her to ensure that a Bill that is outrageous, like this one, never passes or a Bill is finely scrutinised.

Comment on this

It is outrageous that the Senator would interfere with the independence of the Bills Office.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I have ruled.

Comment on this

It is outrageous. I have never seen a Member of this House do that at any time. It is outrageous, Senator Craughwell.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Leader is out of order. All of the Senators are out of order.

Comment on this

On a point of order,-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Jesus.

Comment on this

On a point of order, to stop this filibuster by Fine Gael, I am quite happy to go back to the original grouping.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

The Senators are withdrawing their proposal.

Comment on this

The Leader should respect the Chair's ruling.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We have agreement on the original grouping. Amendments Nos. 7 to 12, inclusive, will be taken together.

Comment on this

I will be brief. This provides for a new definition of "lay person" to be inserted into section 3 to ensure that the term "lay person" is not confined to exclude only persons who held judicial office, had been the Director of Public Prosecutions, the Attorney General, the Chief State Solicitor or law officers in the State, or had been practising barristers or solicitors in the State. It now encompasses in its exclusions those persons who have held office outside of the State. A person who has held judicial office outside of the State or, subject to the time limit in subsection (2), has been the equivalent of a practising barrister or solicitor in another jurisdiction cannot be regarded as a lay person for the purposes of the Bill under the amendment.

Comment on this

I wish to address all of the amendments that we are discussing, if I may.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

We are dealing with amendments Nos. 7 to 12, inclusive, by agreement.

Comment on this

The Minister has very briefly and tersely proposed amendment No. 7. The effect of his amendment is to remove three existing paragraphs and substitute four. The fourth paragraph is the new point in this debate. It would appear that the Government, following Committee Stage in the House, suddenly got the bright idea that the definition of "lay person" was too loose and that what was needed in the definition that it had already proposed was an additional disqualification from being regarded as a lay person, namely, a person "does not hold or occupy, and has never held or occupied, an office or position in a place outside the State equivalent to an office or position referred to in paragraph (a) or (b)", which means judicial office or the attorney general, director of public prosecutions, chief state solicitor or a law officer of another state.

In other words, if a person is a civil servant in Britain whose position depends on having a qualification in law, he or she should never, ever be capable of being appointed to the Irish judicial appointments commission. Likewise, if one is a civil servant in Northern Ireland whose job involved having a legal qualification - and let us be clear about this because Senator Ó Donnghaile might have some interest in this - no matter what one does for the rest of one's life, and it could be 20, 30, 40 or 50 years later, one still stands disqualified under this provision from being eligible to be appointed to the judicial appointments commission. Does Sinn Féin really believe this is a good idea? If a person serves two years in a position in the civil service in Northern Ireland, for which a legal qualification is required, and should thereafter come south of the Border - or even remain north of the Border - this amendment would mean that he or she may never be capable of being a member of the Irish judicial appointments commission.

Comment on this

We should get rid of the Border.

Comment on this

It is a pretty shocking proposal in the Bill. This occurred when the light went on in somebody's brain in the Government - and I do not know who it was - to say the Bill contained a previous definition of "lay person" and that it should be amended to contain that prohibition. I believe this to be pretty shocking. I do not see how we can accept it. I want to be 100% clear about what we are doing.

The definition of "law officer" as I understand it is a person who holds office in the public service, and whose tenure of that office in service as a barrister or solicitor, or whose qualification as a barrister or solicitor-----

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Part 1, on page 8 of the administrative reprint has the definition. It is halfway down the page.

Comment on this

I am looking at the wrong document. Yes, I have it now. The Bill's definition is that " “law officer” means a person employed in the service of the State where a condition for the employment of the person was that he or she was a practising barrister or a practising solicitor". Paragraph (b) of amendment No. 7, however, means that if a person did two years' service - for example with the Director of Public Prosecutions Office for Northern Ireland - in a position for which he or she had to be a practising barrister or solicitor - then that person would thereafter never be capable of being a member of the Irish judicial appointments commission, no matter for how long. This is not a 15-year limit; it is forever and ever and the person could never carry out that function. One must ask why this is being done. Why would a young woman who did two years' service in the office of the Attorney General of Northern Ireland, for which the status of practising barrister was required at the time of appointment, be forever disqualified from being appointed to a position in the Republic of Ireland, no matter what she had done in the intervening period? I cannot understand why this is necessary. I do not understand why we are being asked to do that. That is paragraph (b).

Paragraphs (c) and (d) of amendment No. 7 state the person "is not, and in the relevant period specified in subsection (2) for the purposes of this paragraph, was not, a practising barrister or a practising solicitor [...] in a jurisdiction outside the State in accordance with the law of that jurisdiction;”. Again, it is a solicitor or barrister who is to be disqualified. Does this apply to notaries or advocates in France or Germany, or is it purely common law jurisdictions such as Canada, Australia and New Zealand? It may not apply to America as they have a unified profession of attorney. I do not understand this amendment.

Consider the first line of paragraph (d): " [...] has never held or occupied, an office or position in a place outside the State equivalent to an office or position referred to in paragraph (a) or (b)". There is an equivalence matter here, whereby the amendment would disqualify a person who is a magistrate in France, for example, which is an equivalence of judicial function. With the disqualification for persons acting as barristers or solicitors in a foreign jurisdiction it is only barristers and solicitors that the Bill is concerned with. I believe this to be completely irrational. An American attorney would not be excluded but a barrister in the Channel Islands would be. A Northern Ireland barrister is caught by this provision, whereas an American attorney is not. For the life of me I cannot see how this makes sense. I cannot see how such a provision could have been drafted. It is badly drafted.

If one was to try to knock out legal professionals across the world it should have said "has never been a barrister or solicitor or held or occupied an equivalent position anywhere else in the world", but the Minister has not done that. This is a simple flaw with the drafting. The Fine Gael Party came in here and prevented us from looking at this again on Committee Stage. They came in here and said "No" and objected. They said it was all wrong to recommit it. They voted down a motion to recommit this amendment. Now there is another dog's dinner being put into the law, whereby an American attorney can be appointed, a French notaire or advocate can be appointed, or an equivalent anywhere in Europe can be appointed to the judicial appointments commission but anybody whose name is barrister or solicitor cannot, because these are common law descriptions of divided professions. That is a major and embarrassing mistake to have put into legislation. It is inexplicable and indefensible. It should not be waived through this House. The Minister should withdraw the amendment because it simply does not make sense. Very little depends on this amendment and if the Minister withdraws this amendment the Bill will not be hugely changed. The disqualification of some people outside the State from being appointed to the commission is wholly unnecessary, wholly irrational and wholly indefensible because it distinguishes between a person who is described as a "solicitor" or a "barrister" in England, and a person who might be a professional anywhere in the EU, the United States of America, or anywhere else in large portions of the common law world where the profession of barristers and solicitors have been amalgamated into attorneys or equivalents.

It is a mystery to me as to why this proposal was made. I want to examine it again, if I may. Was there a danger that a foreign judge - or a retired judge from a foreign jurisdiction - would be appointed to this commission?

The Government, suddenly in its wisdom, when it framed these amendments decided we could not possibly have a retired judge from a foreign jurisdiction appointed to this commission. What is wrong with that? What is wrong, for instance, with having a retired judge from Northern Ireland function on this commission? Is that person supposed to be part of a cronyist cabal of practising lawyers who would tend to dominate the whole system to the detriment of the common good? It simply does not make sense. There is absolutely no reason a solicitor or barrister from all the professions practising law throughout the world should be selected for exclusion unless, and this is what I am wondering, this is aimed at Northern Ireland. I think it must be aimed at Northern Ireland. That is the most likely place from where somebody, if this amendment was not passed, would become a member of the judicial appointments commission.

If someone from Northern Ireland was or continued to reside north of the Border and had retired from practice 12 years ago, how could it possibly be inappropriate that such a person to be considered a lay person if he or she had never practised in a court in the Republic? How could that possibly offend Deputy Ross's view of the legal insider concept? It could not. Therefore, I am strongly of the view that this paragraph (d) which came from nowhere, was never discussed as far as I can recall on Second or Committee Stages in this House or the other House is the product of a hyperactive imagination. Someone saw some loophole whereby somebody with a legal qualification in Northern Ireland might be considered a lay person and quickly put together an amendment, used the term "barrister" or "solicitor", notwithstanding the fact that it does not apply to advocates, notaries and all the other descriptions, abogados and all the rest of it in Spain and the like, and simply said they did not want it to happen. It reeks of an anti-Northern Ireland prejudice. If the purpose of this lay-non-lay distinction is to exclude people who have practised in the Irish courts, this amendment goes far further than that and has no rational connection with it.

Comment on this
Paul Coghlan An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

When is it proposed to sit again?

Comment on this

Tomorrow morning at 10.30 a.m.

Comment on this