Order of Business
The Leader answers at length on the housing dispute with Senator Leyden, repeatedly defending government spending and housing policy while the exchange descends into interruptions over biblical references and homelessness rhetoric. The chair repeatedly restores order as Senators interject and joke, but no new substantive item is properly taken up.
I thank the 12 Members of the House for their contributions to the Order of Business. Senator Leyden, in his usual dramatic presentation - Senator Mullen will enjoy this - fails to recognise that the Holy Family were not homeless in Bethlehem. They could not find accommodation. They were from Nazareth and they returned to their home in Nazareth. If the Senator wants to use the Holy Family in the context of the housing debate, he should get his facts right.
Comment on this
I was not there and I was not trained for the priesthood like the Senator. However, I can tell him-----
Comment on this
-----that there was no room at the inn. There was no accommodation in Bethlehem. The Senator's party is providing the same level of accommodation for young children in Dublin.
Comment on this
I know as much about the matter as Senator Buttimer.
Comment on this
Will the Leas-Chathaoirleach allow me to respond?
Comment on this
If Senator Leyden wants to invoke the name of the Holy Family, he should get his facts right. They were not homeless. They were going to Bethlehem to fulfil the census obligation. The difficulty they had in finding temporary accommodation is very different from what the Senator outlined.
Comment on this
Does the Leader think a stable is adequate?
Comment on this
I suppose they were migrants when they went to Egypt.
Comment on this
That is different. Senator Leyden did not refer to that.
Comment on this
I think Senator Bacik pointed that out.
Comment on this
Senator Leyden did not open up and cross-----
Comment on this
The word "bedlam" comes from Bethlehem. It is easy to understand that when one is in this House.
Comment on this
Are we going to Booking.com?
Comment on this
It is typical of Senator Leyden that he fails to recognise, as is normal, that €2.4 billion - the highest ever amount in the history of the Government of this country - is being spent on housing and homelessness.
Comment on this
Some €3 billion is being spent on broadband-----
Comment on this
We need broadband in Roscommon.
Comment on this
-----and €1.9 billion for the hospital.
Comment on this
The Senator's party leader is not in favour of the national broadband strategy.
Comment on this
That again shows the hypocrisy of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Some €2.4 billion is being spent on housing and homelessness.
Comment on this
Before Rebuilding Ireland, child homelessness was increasing at a rate of 5%. It is now at 1%. Some 15,000 first-time buyers are out of the rental trap through the help-to-buy scheme. Senator Leyden did not refer to that, nor did he comment on the fact that supply is up 25% and that 64,000 new social houses are being built. He did not refer to Rebuilding Ireland. An additional 30,000 planning permissions were granted last year, one in three of which was for social housing, to which, again, the Senator did not refer. Nor did he make reference to the fact that never before in the history of the State has more social housing been built than is being built under this Government.
Comment on this
The Senator forgot to tell the people that the Government he voted for regularly decimated the building sector, changed the provision of social housing and destroyed our construction sector. That would never interest him in giving his-----
Comment on this
A total of 12,000 people exited homelessness last year. We accept that there is a challenge ahead. That is why we are working on this matter. It is a priority for the Government. I will make the point one more time for Senator Leyden. Some €2.4 billion, the highest amount ever in the history of the State, will be spent on housing and homelessness.
I welcome a former Ceann Comhairle and friend, Dr. Rory O'Hanlon, to the Gallery. He is very welcome.
Comment on this
I heard there was a row at the Fine Gael Parliamentary Party meeting.
Comment on this
Senator Leyden is entitled to his selectivity when he is speaking. He must remain silent-----
Comment on this
Would I not love to be Leader of the House?
Comment on this
I could reply to Senator Buttimer.
Comment on this
He could be Leader yet; He is learning.