We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Cass review and gender clinics

Summary

The Cathaoirleach repeatedly cautioned Senator Keogan about standing orders and naming an overseas clinic, while she defended her remarks and expanded her criticism of data collection, quality controls and gender identity treatment. She also described a case of a teenage boy rejected by friends after refusing a transgender label.

Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach

We are all about open debate here but the Senator must be careful of the Standing Orders relating to the Kerins case that we have adopted in the context of naming people who are not in the Chamber to defend themselves. I would just make that point. The Senator is aware of the Standing Order.

Comment on this

Have I mentioned somebody who is not here?

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach

No. If the Senator is making allegations, however, she has to be very careful.

Comment on this

I have not made any allegations.

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach

The Senator is saying this clinic been subject to numerous reports about its level of care and that therefore-----

Comment on this

This is documented.

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach

I am just saying-----

Comment on this

I understand the Cathaoirleach's concern. I would not be coming in here to voice any untruths that have not been stated in a report elsewhere. I assure him of that.

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach

I am just urging caution.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach.

Second, there has not been routine or consistent data collection, which has made it impossible to accurately track the outcomes of clinical intervention in solving gender dysphoria. Third, due to the explosion in demand, the clinic has not been subjected to best practice quality controls, which are usually required before a new treatment is approved.

This interim report has prompted a call for an urgent inquiry into the service from the British Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, Mr. Sajid Javid, amid fears that the system is failing children and that vulnerable children are wrongly being given gender hormone treatment. Mr. Javid was particularly alarmed by the pressures on staff to adopt an unquestioning affirmative approach to physically transitioning children over any form of psychological care or assistance. A concern among UK clinicians is that this recourse to the clinical approach is becoming a form of gay conversion therapy as a result of frequent cases of people who started identifying as trans after months of experiencing-----

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach

The Senator's time is up.

Comment on this

Do I not get extra time?

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach

I gave the Senator extra time.

Comment on this

May I finish briefly?

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach

Please.

Comment on this

I was made aware of an incident in this country a few weeks ago where a teenage boy came out as gay in confidence to a group of his female friends. They responded by saying that, if he liked boys, he must be a girl and, therefore, must be transgender. He rejected this, saying that he had never felt like a female and that he was simply attracted to men. As a result of his not accepting his friends foisting a gender identity on him, his female friends in whom he had confided broke contact and refused to speak to him. This scenario was never envisaged by those who fought for equality - a gay man being pressured to change his gender in order to have his sexual orientation become straight. A debate is in order so that we can find out the Minister's view on the Cass review and discuss the level of care that we in this Chamber want Irish children to receive.

Comment on this