Rental car price crisis
Senator Lombard warned that soaring rental car prices, especially for tourism, threaten Ireland’s affordability and credibility as a holiday destination. Senator Craughwell then used the opportunity to welcome PDFORRA’s move to ICTU, oppose RACO’s exclusion, and raise a separate report on children’s mental health.
This afternoon I raise the issue of the crisis in our rental car industry. We are all very much aware of the inflation in prices. This morning I got a quote to rent a car for ten days. The sum of that, if I were to take it up, would be €1,800. That is quite extraordinary to see the inflation in the rental car trade. Some 20% of visitors who come to Ireland use rental cars. This inflation imposed upon our tourism market will have a huge knock-on effect on our credibility as being an affordable place to go on holidays. We need to look over the next few weeks at how we can ensure that our rental car trade will be competitive. That would require engagement with the motor trade and with the Minister. I respectfully ask the Leader of the House to organise a debate with the Minister for Tourism, Culture, Arts, Gaeltacht, Sport and Media, Deputy Catherine Martin, on how she will move in the next few days and weeks to curb the inflation that is being seen at present in the rental car trade. More importantly, how will she make sure that our tourism industry will not be grossly affected by this inflation? This could undermine our entire tourism industry, as 20% of tourists use cars. They go to rural locations, such as Kerry or west Cork. They will not go to west Cork unless they have the opportunity to get an affordable rental car. We need to have a real, genuine debate in this House on how we will solve this issue as otherwise, the tourism industry unfortunately could be undermined.
Comment on this
First, I join with my colleague, Senator Wall, and I am sure with the Acting Leader, in welcoming the accession of PDFORRA to ICTU. However, it is outrageous that RACO has not been granted the same permission. I call today on the Minister for Defence to immediately address that. There are pay talks ongoing right now and they need to be there.
There has been much talk recently about mental health for children and mental health issues for children. One wonders about the way business is done in this country. I brought this report before this House last week. It is 415 pages in length and is the Air Corps's pitch to take part in the search and rescue, SAR. This would result in €378,661,302 in savings to the Exchequer. I guarantee the Leader that no Minister has read this or has been asked to read it. Furthermore, the critique of that report is three pages in length. There is not one technological, empirical or statistical piece of evidence to support this piece of nonsense.
The Secretary General was invited before the Oireachtas joint committee on a number of occasions to discuss this process and has refused to come. If the Departments are not answerable to the Oireachtas and the Ministers appear to not be in control of their Departments, where the hell do we go? It is outrageous there is no way to question this process. This process is banging ahead like a steam engine. There would be almost €400 million in savings over ten years and nobody will explain why it is not happening.
We talk all the time about the pride we have in the Defence Forces in this House. There is no pride in the Defence Forces. This weekend an RAF aircraft was called in to do top cover without the knowledge of the Air Corps. I am told it was RAF, but it was English and that is for sure. This fits neatly into the desire of the Irish Coast Guard to have top cover provided by somebody other than the Air Corps for the next three years.
Who is running this State? Is it the faceless civil servants who are so God-damned powerful at this stage that they are answerable to nobody, not even to the Houses of the Oireachtas? To compel a Secretary General to come before an Oireachtas committee, you need the Committee on Parliamentary Privileges and Oversight of both Houses to agree. That is way too cumbersome, as far as I am concerned. This is an outrage. I understand that the tender will be going out today. That tender will be going out in contempt of this House, of the Lower House and of the Oireachtas joint committee. That is simply not good enough.