We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Higher Education Authority Bill 2022: Committee Stage (Resumed)

Contributions 1–124 of 241. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Higher Education Authority Bill 2022
Enacted

No. 1 of 2022 ›

John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

A number of Members have indicated their wish to speak and I call now on Senator Craughwell.

Comment on this

The Minister is dead right as anybody who was appointed to a board in this country is subject to scrutiny from either within this House, the Lower House or anywhere else one may wish to mention in society in general. I wish to put on the record, however, that chairpersons of boards are frequently brought in before Oireachtas committees and we have absolutely no say in whether their appointment is sanctioned or not. It is purely an "Hello, nice to meet you" meeting. I have stated at committees on a number of occasions that it is a waste of both the board chairperson's and the committee's time. We do not scrutinise the people who are appointed by Ministers.

I fully appreciate the role of the Minister in making appointments but this House and the Dáil has a role in overseeing the work of the Minister. Where we cannot do that, there is a flaw, and that flaw does not just exist in this Bill, but it is in the system right across the Oireachtas. A Minister makes an appointment and no matter how repugnant to the public that appointment may be, nobody other than the Minister of the day can change that.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister that where a Minister makes appointments, they are subject to retrospective scrutiny by the media and by Members of the Houses but the simple fact is once those appointments are made, they cannot be unmade unless some massive scandal has emerged and the person is removed under the statutory powers.

The context for all of this is that - I do not wish to leap ahead because I do not believe we will ever get there in any event - under section 143, the HEA is given power to: "adopt and issue guidelines, codes or policies to designated institutions of higher education for any purpose relating to this Act and concerning [among other things, the implementation of any policy or objective of the Minister or of the Government.]" The HEA can therefore give guidelines, codes or policies out in respect of Government policy.

When one looks back then to the power of the Chief Executive Officer, CEO, of the HEA under section 64, he or she is entitled:

... if he or she is of [the] opinion that there are significant concerns regarding the governance of a designated institution of higher education or the performance by such an institution of its functions or, [and this is the crucial one] compliance by it with its obligations including, but not limited to, compliance with any guidelines, codes or policies issued under section 143, [it can issue a demand, effectively, to the institution in question to comply with Government policy.]

What does that mean in terms of autonomy?

Under section 143, the Bill states that here is a code for the Government's policy, comply with it, and if you do not, the chief executive officer is going to ask you to comply with it and then, horror of horrors, he or she is entitled to threaten to cut off your funding if you do not comply with it.

The Minister may say that that is democratic because he, as Minister, can enunciate a policy and the institution is obliged to comply with the Minister's policy as enunciated. That, however, is a very significant power to be given to an institution which until now has had autonomy to say that it will not go with the Minister's policies in respect of A, B and C and is entitled, as a group, to think that the Minister is putting an overemphasis on whatever it is. I am not talking here about things like gender equality, or such issues, but I am talking about the broad frame of policy.

If a Minister of the day can lay down policy guidelines and the HEA, through its chief executive, can threaten to cut off funding for failing to comply with a ministerial policy statement, that is in fact deeply corrosive of the notion that, for example, Trinity College, with its 400 year old charter, or the National University of Ireland NUI, with its 100 plus years of independence, is obliged to so comply. It gives the Minister of the day the right to say that he or she is enunciating the policy, and is requesting the HEA's chief executive officer to call UCD, for example, to book because it is not complying with his or her policy. Then, under the Act, the Minister can have the CEO of the HEA threaten to cut off the institution's funding if it does not comply. That is what this Act is about in principle.

I have no doubt that the Minister may have very benign thoughts on this matter, but not every Minister in the future is perhaps going to take a benign view of an institution that just simply does not like his or her policies.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

And the Minister may have no experience whatever of higher education.

Comment on this
Simon Harris Minister for Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science Fine Gael

Or health or justice or-----

Comment on this

We will not get into that.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Well, we have had several doctors in Health.

Comment on this

Senator McDowell was not a policeman when he was Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform.

Comment on this

I make the point that we are talking about fully preserving autonomy but we are also giving the Minister for Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science the right to enunciate policy and are giving the HEA the right to cut off funding for people who do not comply with the Minister's policies. I find that that is not consistent with what I used to believe was university autonomy.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

We have a number of speakers remaining, namely, Senators Malcolm Byrne, Craughwell, Dolan and Mullen. I call Senator Byrne now to speak.

Comment on this

There is a misrepresentation around this piece of legislation that it safeguards academic autonomy. This is not a piece of legislation that has anything to do with academic autonomy and there are specific safeguards built into legislation around this. This is to do with questions around governance and financial accountability.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

The institutions are already financially accountable to the Comptroller and Auditor General.

Comment on this

Yes, we will come to the Comptroller and Auditor General because I want to speak directly to the point raised by Senator Higgins that this gives more power to the HEA. It does. Part of the reason this legislation had to come about was because of incidents at the University of Limerick, UL, where serious questions were being asked about where money was being spent. UL was using the autonomy line and that essentially there was nothing to see here even though-----

Comment on this

The university is not here to defend itself.

Comment on this

This issue came extensively before the Committee of Public Accounts, and so on, at the time. I fully respect the academic autonomy of institutions, but we also expect that in respect of the very considerable sums of moneys that are made available to them by the State, that those institutions are accountable for these sums. I am particularly glad, incidentally, that the Minister is also addressing now the core funding issue. When the issues in respect of UL arose - there were other institutions involved also, and this is not just to single UL out - we, as a State were not able to get the necessary level of accountability concerned. The only options that were available, quite frequently, to the HEA under the old legislation was to send in a visitor. This was, essentially, to disband the governing body, to move in, and to press the nuclear button.

This legislation is about ensuring that there is accountability for the taxpayers' money that goes into the universities. We can have debates around the necessary safeguards which have to be put in place because I know that we have talked about conferring too much power on the chief executive of the HEA.

We had some discussion of that principle on Second Stage. There has to be checks and balances in that regard. However, where there are checks and balances, because the Minister is democratically accountable to these Houses, the chief executive of the HEA is the Accounting Officer to the Minister. The HEA has to have a certain level of power with regard to the State investment that goes in to the institutions.

With respect to Senator McDowell, the Minister will not determine the academic policies of any institution. I would completely oppose this legislation if any such measure were in it. This is why it was considered in detail. Amendments were tabled in the Dáil to strengthen this. I am certain that no Minister or Government would allow for that in the Bill, especially when we are pointing the finger at countries such as Hungary. The safeguards are in the legislation.

Those of us who have been involved in the process for a long time know that this is about financial accountability and governance. We need to understand that it has nothing to do with the question of academic autonomy, which must be protected. It is important that we ensure there are people in the authority with academic experience and, equally, that people outside of academia are appointed. Ministers do not always get appointments right. Senator Hoey might remember that one of the appointments to the board of the HEA by the Minister's predecessor, Deputy Bruton, was Mr. Paddy Cosgrave, who famously made a number of comments about academic achievement. It would be fair to say that the Minister and Mr. Cosgrave would not be good friends.

Comment on this

We might as well talk about amendments, for the benefit of the House, because we do not all have good memories.

Comment on this

It is not appropriate to speak in the Chamber about people who are not here. It is not okay.

Comment on this

If we are to speak specifically with regard to the authority and this amendment, it should be about its members having sufficient experience to inform the decision-making processes and meet the strategic objectives of the authority, rather than them all being representative.

Comment on this

My colleague, Senator Malcolm Byrne, made reference to how many inputs I made to pre-legislative scrutiny. I sit on two extremely busy committees, the Joint Committee on Foreign Affairs and Defence and the Joint Committee on Transport and Communications. I was also sitting on the Joint Committee on Public Petitions at the time, as well as conducting normal day-to-day business. I did not have any input in pre-legislative scrutiny in this area, as I am sure Senator Byrne does not have an input in foreign affairs, transport or some of the other areas. That does not preclude me from taking on board advice given to me by academics, members of trade unions and those who appeared before the very committee the Senator spoke about to try to have included in the legislation issues such as that addressed by Senator McDowell some time ago, namely, the overarching power of the chief executive officer, without any reference to his or her board, with respect to sanctions.

I made the point, as a former president of a trade union, that there should be provision to have academic representation from IFUT or the TUI. It works very well on the Teaching Council and I do not see any reason it would not work on this authority. I have every faith in the Minister. I have supported him in public on many of the things he has done. He is far-sighted and has ambition for higher and further education in this country, the like of which I have not seen before. I compliment him on that. However, the Minister will leave office at some stage and another Minister will be appointed who may not be the same type of person or may not hold the same principles as he does. What we are trying to do here is to define for the next Minister precisely what should be in this legislation.

The only issue on which I differ slightly with Senator Norris is on the academic experts or members. They should be drawn from IFUT or TUI, which are the main trade unions represented in the higher and further education sector. From that point of view, that is the argument I am making. We will not reach an amendment about having local authority members represented on the various boards included in this Bill. I will not take away from the considerable work done on this Bill but, at the end of day, there is a reasonable argument for this and it is not much to ask that it be taken on board.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

I gave speakers some latitude. I ask Senators to keep to the subject of amendments in order that we can get through them as quickly as possible.

Comment on this

I will address some of the comments on this amendment. The purpose of the Bill is to fund a greater number of students to access third level through traditional universities but also our brand new technological universities. As a democratic state, we need to ensure funding is equally disbursed and managed throughout all of our institutions. The chief executive of the HEA will be responsible to the board of the HEA and is the person responsible for the funding. He or she is making the funding allocations, on behalf of the HEA, to each of these institutions and is responsible for those funding announcements and decisions. As such, if the chief executive then identifies that there are issues with funding, it is within his or her remit to follow up on that.

The HEA puts policies together but there is engagement at a very early stage with the other departments and higher education institutions throughout the country. There is engagement with and on these policies prior to their final development. This ensures there is engagement with all stakeholders. It is crucial that we hear those voices at every stage. These policies are to benefit all in society, to ensure we have more people accessing third level and coming through further and higher education and to achieve the excellence we want to see at third level. That is what this Bill will achieve.

Comment on this

I will speak to amendment No. 317, for which I am responsible, and make a few points with regard to what has already been said. I remember when I was in student politics in Galway. I was elected president of the students' union there in 1991. It was for the Minister of the day to officially approve my appointment to the governing body of UCG, as it was. I remember these things took time. As sabbatical officers came and went, year in, year out, it was not always the case that the minute people were elected, their membership of the board of governors of the governing body would be ratified. The problem with that was dealt with by the governing body admitting me as a non-voting member until such time as the Minister of the day would ratify me. I cannot remember whether it was Noel Davern or Mary O'Rourke who was the Minister at the time. It was just as well that I was allowed to attend meetings because the Minister never got around to ratifying me during the course of the year. I remember, on one occasion, having completely forgotten about the matter and when I went to vote on an amendment or a point on which a vote was called by the governing body, I put up my hand. The then runaí um ghnóthaí acadúla, the secretary for academic affairs, brought me down with a bang and said that the vote was 24, instead of 25, agus nach raibh an tUasal Ó Maoláin ceadaithe go fóill.

I understand and respect the importance of student representation on important bodies and, therefore, I understand why the legislation makes specific reference to the appointment of student representation to an t-údarás. However, it highlights the distinct oddness of the absence of a specific reference to academic representation on an t-údarás. It is fine for the Minister to say this is because this is a competency-based body rather than a representative body. I believe that is the gist of his rationale for this exclusion. Does one infer from that, therefore, that it would not be enough protection for student representation to leave it to the Minister to judge that in appointing a competency-based body, it would be necessary to have student representation?

It seems to me that there is an element of sauce for the goose and sauce for the gander to this. Students are stakeholders with competency to participate in a board of governors of an t-údarás, the HEA or a university or designated institution, as are academics. We can all see how any test of competency, to have all the necessary skills and perspectives under the heading of "competence" for such a board, would require student and academic representation. The fact is that the Minister has chosen to specifically refer to student representation but not academic representation. He cannot explain away that anomaly by referring to the fact that it is the responsibility of the Minister to make competency-based appointments and imply that academics will, of course, be a part of that. It is not sufficient to imply it when the Minister specified another category, as he did with students, in another part of the Bill.

On that very subject, I am reminded of Ronald Reagan's phrase to Mikhail Gorbachev; "Let me tell you why we don't trust you". The Minister talks about competency-based bodies but I refer to the very point that Senator McDowell raised, which is the non-amenability of the CEO to the board of an t-údarás regarding certain very serious decisions the CEO may have to make. The CEO is amenable and requires the approval of the board of an t-údarás in certain decisions on compliance and measures, "remedial and other measures" is the phrase used in the Bill, that may have to be taken but not in others.

The problem that many universities have with this is that if one is serious about competence being the hallmark and criterion for the appointment of people to the boards of universities, as well as the board of an t-údarás, one must recognise that if people are being put into a position of competence, their competence to govern has to be respected. If they choose to depart from a prescribed guideline, code or policy, if one is to get the balance right in the context of universities as State-funded and State-recognised institutions, but nonetheless independent of the State, one must respect what it means to appoint a competency-based board. It means the presumption is that if they have a reason to depart from a particular code, guideline or policy and explain it, that that is a desirable approach. It is not as though there is no further measure open to the HEA if the explanation is unsatisfactory or the problem persists.

The other problem is that universities believe the actual competence of the board of governors is not being respected. They believe respect for their competence would mean that in the decision of a university to sanction or perform remedial or other such measures arising out of actions or failures to act, as seen by the CEO, they should be accountable to decisions that are themselves subject to the approval of a board. In other words, they believe that if a competent board, to whom a president of a university is ultimately responsible, backs the president and the administration of the university in making particular decisions, respect for their competence in getting the structures of all of this right would mean that any decisions, which seek to remedy the situation or intervene, involving serious decisions about the freezing or withholding of funding, because the Minister is insisting in putting competence-based boards in place at university level, any decisions to intervene on the recommendation of the CEO of an t-údarás, should by definition be precisely that. They should be decisions on the recommendations of the CEO but approved by the board. The board should be somehow held accountable, ultimately, not by an individual but by another board.

To the argument that the CEO is somehow the Accounting Officer to the Comptroller and Auditor General, or that the CEO is the man or woman in the spot, the fact that the CEO would have to get board approval for a decision in no way takes from the CEO's accountability or legal position of accountability. People come before Oireachtas committees all the time and have to account for their role, decisions and stewardship. It does not mean that the decisions they take are somehow decisions that they are empowered to take completely independently. They are decisions they take because they have boards to which they are accountable.

The Minister has presented the argument - a slippery argument which I ultimately do not believe is valid - that the reason he is not requiring that CEOs be accountable to the board of an t-údarás for certain key and serious actions they want to take in universities, is that somehow it is because they are the person in the accountable spot that justifies him or her not being required to have the approval of the board of an t-údarás. That argument makes no sense. People who are accountable in law for whatever function they hold, in most cases that I can think of, are still accountable to the boards that are behind them. That does not speak to the specific amendment but it does relate to the issue of a competency-based board. There is a problem in that aspects of the Bill do not seem to respect the competence and appropriate zone of action of individual universities and governors that hold them to account.

On the subject of amendment No. 317-----

Comment on this

We are only on amendment No. 2.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

There was a mix-up.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I thought they were coupled.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

We are still on section 2, amendment No. 2, in the names of Senators Norris, Clonan, Boyhan, and McDowell. There was a mistake with the TV-----

Comment on this

With the grouping. It caused me to do much hurried scribbling a few minutes ago.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

There were no mistakes with the grouping. The mistake was with the TV screen.

Comment on this

Amendment No. 317 is not being discussed yet?

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

No, not yet, which means the Senator has plenty of time.

Comment on this

Which brings me to my last point-----

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

The Senator may like to make his final point brief.

Comment on this

For the time being.

Comment on this

How can we believe the Minister when, last week, no one was left in any doubt that he fully supported thorough scrutiny of the many amendments that have been carefully prepared on foot of consultation and contact between Members and legitimate stakeholders? According to his explanation today, he is allowing a process to go ahead without protest that will see the Bill guillotined after a few, very short hours of scrutiny.

Comment on this

I do not think it is without protest, in fairness.

Comment on this

It is without protest from the Minister.

Comment on this

I protested much of it.

Comment on this

The Minister has the power to ask and insist that the Bill is not guillotined today. Has he used that power?

Comment on this

I have no such power.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

We will not have a back and forth with the Minister.

Comment on this

The Minister has the power to ask it.

Comment on this

We could call the Leader into the Chamber.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Hold on a second and relax. Everyone needs to tone it down a bit. Can we speak to the amendments, if that is alright? We do not need a back and forth.

Comment on this

The Senator is right. We could call in the Leader.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Let us speak to the amendments.

Comment on this

We are in a completely artificial process where we have to slide in important, substantive points relating to other amendments because we know we will not get to them today-----

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

That is a fair point but if we are also going to-----

Comment on this

-----and the Minister is asking us to trust the Government. He is the Minister but he is presiding here on behalf of the Government.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

I am all for letting Senators speak as much as possible, but let us get through some of the amendments and afford as much time to as many Senator to participate in the debate and go through as many amendments as possible.

Comment on this

How many amendments does the Acting Chair think that will be by the time he-----

Comment on this

It depends on votes.

Comment on this

-----as a percentage?

Comment on this

In fairness, if the Minister wants to, he could call the Leader in.

Comment on this

No, I cannot. How can I call in the Leader?

Comment on this

The Minister could ask to lift the guillotine.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

I am keen to let as many Senators from both sides of the House in as is possible. The next Senator to speak is Senator Higgins.

Comment on this

I commend the Acting Chair's spirit of fair play but this is a farce in which the Minister and Government are complicit.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

The point is well made.

Comment on this

I will be very brief because I am keen to move to the next grouping in which I have a number of amendments relating to equality. In response to the debate, I wish to correct two points that were made. First, it was suggested that the measures being put forward relate to governance and finance solely.

The other suggestion is that any policies that might be relevant will be developed with the Higher Education Authority, or an t-údarás.

In this Bill, in sections 76, 119 and, I think, in another section, there are extremely strong powers on policies that are not confined to the issues of finance or governance. In fact, there is a requirement by governing authorities to put in place measures to implement and report on compliance with the policies that may be set out in codes, guidelines or other documents, such as memos, circulars etc., of the Government or of a Minister of Government to the extent that those policies affect or relate to the functions of universities. Just to be very clear, there are measures in this Bill requiring governing authorities of universities to implement and be compliant with polices set out in codes, guidelines and other documents of the Government or a Minister. In that regard, it is quite a wide reach. It is not clear.

There will be opportunities when we come to debate sections 76, 119 and others where we have amendments where we seek to limit it so that it would be compliant with statutory requirements. I know there are amendments we may table, given the subject matter of this, which is the academic issue, and I am expecting there would be support from Government Senators for this, specifically to preclude that there would be any such requirement for compliance with any policies that relate to academic matters. Perhaps we can address those when we come to them in sections 76, 119 and others, but we need to be very clear these are not solely matters of governance and finance. There is quite wide language for policy in this Bill in the expectations on governing authorities of universities.

I am happy to leave it there because I do not want to talk longer. I want to get to the next grouping, which are important amendments around the issue of equality.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

I agree with that sentiment.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I apologise to the House. I thought we had been discussing amendment No. 317 when I heard an extensive discussion going on behind me. However, it has been ruled out of order and I accept that.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Would the Minister like to come back in?

Comment on this

I want to come back on the issue of academic autonomy and on the comments I have heard from Senators here. Autonomy is protected, but autonomy cannot be used as a fig leaf or a catch-all word to cover other issues that are of legitimate importance, such as governance, accountability and an education system that advances the delivery of public policy.

I attended a very good debate in this House, led by Senator Ruane, on the issue of non-disclosure agreements, NDAs. During that debate, I specifically referred to this legislation and the ability of the HEA to set guidelines, codes and practices on a number of areas, including, in the context of that debate, the issue of NDAs.

We have had reports from the Committee on Public Accounts, such as the report from 2017, which calls for legislation just like this. There some Senators, including my good friend Senator Craughwell, would rightly be jumping up and down about many issues if he felt there were concerns about the expenditure of public money and he did not feel the response was robust enough. He would probably be trying to hold people like me to account for this. You can only hold people like me to account, and the HEA and others, if there are enough levers, clarity and structures in place for accountability.

My job is not just to write the cheque on behalf of the taxpayer. That would be a very simple job. My job is not just to say, “Here is the cheque; here is the money; go off and spend it how you wish”. This is €2 billion of taxpayers’ money. When we are consulting all these stakeholders, whom I know very well, respect them and consult them regularly, there is another very important stakeholder here and that is the citizen, the person, the taxpayer. Their voice is not being heard enough in this debate. This debate is hearing the voices of representative groups, which is perfectly fine and legitimate. I meet them too and I have no issue with that, but there is also the citizen. I believe it is right and proper we put a HEA in place that has a competency-based board and that can set codes, guidelines and policies. I do think there is a link between public funding and public policy. That is not a revolutionary concept.

Senator Norris can keep on making that point about experience in higher education and the Minister. The man who is sitting beside Senator Norris was the Minister for Justice. He never wore a Garda uniform and he was a perfectly fine Minister for Justice. This idea-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

He was a very distinguished senior counsel, so he knew the law from the other side.

Comment on this

Be that as it may, did he know what it was to police-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

It is a very salient point.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

The Minister must be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

He invited it.

Comment on this

Does the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, have to be a farmer? I am just responding to it, with great affection and respect.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

I thank the Minister.

Comment on this

However, I do think it is an important point. The other point I want to make relates to the issue of the CEO of the HEA. I believe sometimes there is an issue with picking pieces of the legislation and reading them in isolation. I do not think that is a useful thing to do. The CEO of the HEA, as Senator Mullen pointed out, is always accountable to the board. There are certain things which the CEO will need the explicit approval of the board to do, but even in the areas where explicit approval is not needed, every CEO of every organisation is always accountable to the board. The CEO, though, cannot just be the convenor of the board meeting. It cannot just be the CEO’s job to convene a board meeting. The CEO has executive powers in relation to arrangements. I am sure we will debate where there is an appropriate division-----

Comment on this

We probably will not, because we will not get there.

Comment on this

This is not the Final Stage of this legislation.

Comment on this

We have Report Stage to go.

Comment on this

The Minister is taking the mick now.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Many other speakers want to come in after the Minister, so please let the Minister speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I have come into this House and I have had slurs and names being called at me. I am not taking it anymore.

Comment on this

The Minister is not being called a name. We are just not letting our entire-----

Comment on this

Senator Mullen is just heckling me. If he could just, for one moment-----

Comment on this

Feel free to heckle me back.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Hold on a second. When I chair the Seanad I try to be fair to everybody. Let us take the tone down a little bit. There are two other speakers, Senators Ruane and Craughwell, who would like to come in after the Minister. Let us not interrupt the Minister. Let him finish his point and then we can get on to the two other Senators, if that is fair enough.

Comment on this

We are engaging in good faith. I made myself available as the Seanad ordered its business. On Senator Craughwell’s point on the TUI and the issue of full representation, and I accept his bona fides as well as his long, distinguished relationship with the TUI, we have made progress on representation on governing authority boards. That was warmly welcomed at the TUI congress in Wexford. It was something it had sought for a long time.

We are making a different and distinct point about the HEA board, because if there is a seat here and a seat there, it very quickly becomes a representational board rather than a competency-based board. However, I accept, and there is no point in being disingenuous on my part, that it could be presented as an anomaly. I have made a conscious decision to put a seat in place for students on the board of an t-údarás. Beyond that, we have not done so for any other representative group, and a compelling case could be made for many. Beyond that, we have decided to go through the normal public appointment process, which is competency-based. I think and hope that is the correct balance.

Comment on this

As it was brought up in reference to the Employment Equality (Amendment) (Non-Disclosure Agreements) Bill, which has been very well-supported by the Minister and by the Government and will be so again this evening, I wish to point out one slight difference in that the NDA Bill is legislation that will apply to all citizens, and I know that is an intersection with policy, whereas the reference Senator Higgins made was to policies, which can change from Government to Government and Minister to Minister. Even though law and policy intersect, they are very different. The NDA Bill would be law, and what we are referring to is the overreach in potential policy areas different Governments may take on. That is to clarify and put on the record the difference between the two.

Comment on this

The Minister is dead right. If I saw something going wrong, I would hold the Department in question to account. I have been trying to do that for the past two years with another Department and getting nowhere. In fact, the worst thing that ever happened to this country was the Ministers and Secretaries Act 1924, where the Minister takes the fall but somebody else does the deed. That is the way I feel about it.

With respect to the Minister’s comment on us representing pressure groups or groups with specific interests, I have not been contacted by either IFUT or the TUI. It is in my DNA to question that. I have had two amendments provided to me by the Irish Universities Association, which thought it had a deal with the Minister on those two amendments, one of which relates to the CEO’s powers. The other amendments and contacts I have had have been from citizens, some of whom are sitting in the Gallery.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

We are all citizens.

Comment on this

I am talking about Joe Citizen here, the people the Minister is talking about-----

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Some are more than not.

Comment on this

-----who expect he will not write that cheque without having proper governance in place.

At the end of the day, even pressure groups that contact us are citizens with a specific interest; I will accept that. I will put on the record today that I attended the TUI conference where the Minister was hailed as a hero by many; he really impressed them all. I hope they will still be as impressed when this Bill passes.

My final point is that it is within the Minister's gift today to say he does not like the pace at which this Bill is going through and to ask whether the Leader could come to the House, amend the Order of Business and lift the guillotine.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

We must stick to the amendments.

Comment on this

We do not have to.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

We do, which the Senator knows well. I call Senator Malcom Byrne.

Comment on this

Again, I speak in support. As the Minister knows, Senator Craughwell was at the TUI conference. On what the Minister has done with governing bodies, it is about ensuring that the academic and non-academic staff are represented on governing authorities.

I find what Senator Higgins said about public policy and giving the Minister more powers kind of unusual. Yet, most of the amendments she tabled are on specific areas of public policy. It is around expecting an t-údarás and the universities to adhere to requirements around the sustainable development goals, SDG, and climate. Indeed, one of the areas in which the Minister has been to the fore has been addressing questions of gender equity within higher education.

These are public policy decisions; they are not to do with academic freedom. It has no impact on what a lecturer in medicine can teach or on a business studies lecturer's approach or philosophy. Indeed, as we know, where we saw the problems with some prominent academics who, for instance, preached an anti-vaccination message in institutions, their academic freedom had to be respected. The State criticised but did not seek to interfere with institutions in that regard. On matters of public policy where we as citizens are contributing in a particular way, however, we expect a response. That is why the legislation is correct. I find it somehow odd that Senator Higgins is almost arguing against giving the Minister and the authority-----

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

I will let Senator Higgins come back in.

Comment on this

I do not want to come back in. I want to move on, but I want to note that this is an inaccurate representation of what I said.

Comment on this

All I am saying is that the next number of amendments are all going to be dealing with specific areas and, as the Senator knows, I agree with many of them.

Comment on this

It is about putting them into legislation-----

Comment on this

Put them into legislation with names.

Comment on this

-----and naming them.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Senator Byrne might stick to the amendment at hand.

Comment on this

I am. Here is the point around this. That is all fine; it is around the principle that if we put them into legislation and they form part of public policy, then there is an expectation that the Minister and an t-údarás will ensure that action is taken on them. If there is not action taken on them by the universities and an t-údarás, what should the Minister do? Should the Minister just say this institution is doing nothing to further SDG goals or gender equality and that he must respect the autonomy of the institution and not do anything?

In fairness to the Minister, there have been a number of key areas. I will instance the question of gender equity, which he and his predecessor, Ms Mary Mitchell O'Connor, have pushed quite strongly. They are positive examples of where public policy must be followed. It is key with this legislation. That is why we should stick to what we are talking about. Confusion is being deliberately perpetrated that this impacts on academic freedom; it does not.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

I picked a good hour to chair the Seanad this week, that is for sure. Let us move on to the next amendment. Is Senator Norris pressing amendment No. 2?

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

Yes.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 3, 4, 156, 212, 214 and 317 are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 13, line 18, after “disadvantaged,” to insert “persons to whom the Equal Status Acts 2000 to 2018 apply to,”.

These amendments all relate to issues of equality. It gives me a useful opportunity, therefore, to clarify the points that were made previously. I am not against public policy existing but to be very clear, and I was clear in my intervention that my concerns are that there are requirements in the Bill for governing bodies of universities and individual institutions to implement and report on their compliance with policies of the Government or a Minister of the Government. Again, those are not policies that have become full public policy by means of either statute, regulation or law or, indeed, that have been agreed by the Oireachtas or the HEA. We all have policies we might put in our manifestos. Ministers may have policies and Government may have policy but the muddying of the line between public policy and Government policy is an issue on which we need to be clear.

I was specifically clear that I will have amendments that say they may have mechanisms on compliance with matters of statute, that is, regulations that are in place on a statutory basis, laws that are put into place, laws on non-disclosure agreements, NDA, which I hope will be law soon or, indeed, such measures as I propose putting into law here. I am clear on the policies I think should become law and be given a statutory basis and should, therefore, then be matters that are appropriately enforceable. I am not okay with a blank cheque whereby any future Government's or future Minister's policy should automatically become something on which an HEI must implement a report. That is what provisions in sections 76 and 119 say at the moment. I will propose amendments to them saying that there are many areas in which we should have more laws and clearer laws, including areas such as equality. They should be done in a proper way by law, however, and that is what should be indicated.

I will discuss the amendments in the grouping, all of which relate to the question of equality. Amendment No. 3 seeks to amend the definition of "priority groups" in the interpretations section and proposes to insert “persons to whom the Equal Status Acts 2000 to 2018 apply to”. Currently, the definition of "priority groups" mentions "persons who are economically or socially disadvantaged, persons who have a disability or persons from sections of society that are under-represented in the student body in higher education". It is important to be clear and to include those to whom the discrimination grounds in our Equal Status Acts apply, many of whom, in fact, are under-represented or even if they are represented, face particular obstacles in their access to higher education. Those include, for example, the grounds in the equality Act relating to things such as gender, marital status, family status, religious beliefs, age, disability, race and membership of the Traveller community. The current wording is quite narrow and does not specifically name many of the grounds that have historically been sources of exclusion such as, for example, race, family status, sexual orientation and members of the Traveller community who have experienced particular exclusion and, indeed, lone parents who face particular obstacles. Again, it is an attempt to widen who might be captured in the definition of "priority groups" and ensure that those groups which have been acknowledged by the Equal Status Acts to have experienced discrimination across society are not forgotten in the definition.

Amendment No. 156 would amend section 34(3) by providing that in the ongoing review of the demand for higher education in the State, an t-údarás would have regard to "the needs of society to address issues of poverty, social and economic inequality, racial inequalities and inequities and gender inequalities and inequities” in assessing the demand for higher education at a regional and national level in each discipline.

Amendments Nos. 212 and 214 relate to the equality statement provision under section 62 of the Equal Status Acts and suggest that in preparing the equality statement, the designated higher education institutions should consult with representative organisations of those to whom the Equal Status Acts apply. Examples of such groups are the Irish Traveller Movement, Pavee Point, the Disability Federation of Ireland or, indeed, many of the disabled persons organisations in the State, Social Justice Ireland, Movement of Asylum Seekers in Ireland, MASI, and others.

Amendment No. 214 seeks to insert the word "equity" in section 62(5)(b), which currently provides that an equality statement of a designated institution of higher education to which the section applies shall specify the policy of the institution on equality in all activities of the institution.

This amendment simply refers to equity. There is another point in the Bill where there is a reference to equality of opportunity, which is not the same as equality of outcomes or equality in its wider sense, so this is an attempt to add "equity" and thereby strengthen what we mean by equality. We are not going for a minimalist version. I know that is not the intention in the equality statement but elsewhere in the Bill equality of opportunity is referred to, which I believe is needlessly narrow and which I will seek to amend. These amendments all seek to give strength to the legislative provisions in respect of equality and equality statements in the Bill.

Comment on this

Senator Higgins covered many of the amendments but I will pick up on the last point. The difference between equity and equality is a crucial conversation. Equality of opportunity means, for example, everybody has the right to apply to Trinity College Dublin. The equality of opportunity exists for everyone, but obviously that is not true. Equity is a much more targeted, aggressive approach to addressing the inequalities that exist in society by taking account of the inequality in a person's environment, background, class or race, whatever that may be. Equity has much more of an agenda in really addressing many of the issues that will arise. Even with regard to the first amendment relating to the Equal Status Acts, when we look at the different groups who are under-represented, the last word change in adding "equity" under amendment No. 214 in section 62(5)(b) would go a long way in strengthening the language in the Bill.

Comment on this

I wish to speak to amendment No. 317.

Comment on this
David P.B. Norris Senator David Norris Independent

You cannot.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

There is a vote in the Dáil and the Minister, Deputy Harris, has to attend it.

Comment on this

I propose that we suspend for ten minutes to allow the Minister to attend.

Comment on this

It should be 15 minutes.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Is everybody happy with 15 minutes?

Comment on this

Once 15 minutes are added at the end.

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

As much as you like, Senator Mullen.

Comment on this

Can we amend the Order of Business to add the time at the end?

Comment on this
John McGahon Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

The Minister is happy with that.

Comment on this
Fiona O'Loughlin Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

We will continue our Committee Stage examination of the Higher Education Authority Bill 2022. I understand Senator Mullen is in control of the Chair. I mean he is in possession.

Comment on this

It does not feel like possession.

Comment on this
Fiona O'Loughlin Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

The Senator does not feel like he is in control but feels like he is in possession. Is that it?

Comment on this

While I am in possession, I must start with a confession. The amendment I have tabled is to the wrong section of the Bill. However, I can still speak to the principle of it. Amendment No. 317-----

Comment on this
Fiona O'Loughlin Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

Which amendment is the Senator speaking to now?

Comment on this