We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó (Atógáil) - Order of Business (Resumed)

Trans rights and healthcare debate

Summary

Senator Hoey raised concerns about trans healthcare and media discourse on trans rights, warning against importing culture-war narratives. The Cathaoirleach asked if she wanted a debate, and she confirmed she did.

I will take a moment to reflect on what I will call a conversation, but I am not sure that is what it was. The conversation took place on a show on TV last night around the trans community. It is a replica of a conversation we keep seeing again and again. When these conversations are happening, it is very important we remember Ireland has been ranked as one of the worst at having trans healthcare in Europe. We need to listen to the trans community and avoid any attempts to import this divisive, cultural war narrative from the UK or elsewhere, which seems to be floating around the place. We need only look over to the US where there are dozens, nay, hundreds of anti-trans and anti-LGBT Bills in progress throughout the States. Hard-won rights are being rolled back, not only in the US, but in the UK. I do not know what the word is and conversation is not the right one. It was disheartening to see that last night-----

Comment on this
Jerry Buttimer An Cathaoirleach Fine Gael

Is the Senator seeking a debate?

Comment on this

Yes, I am seeking a debate. I do not even know if we wish to have a debate on the issue, because I do not know why we are debating it. I implore us to consider how we are discussing trans rights. Maybe we need to have statements on the fact our trans and LGBT community has been living the fullness of their lives, since gender recognition was introduced here in Ireland and even before gender recognition was introduced, and that we have a trans community living side by side with us. The terrifying prospect of this future these people seem to worry about simply has not happened here in Ireland. I do not know if we wish to have a debate or statements on it, but we have to resist, as hard as we can, the importation of this. We have to remember the concept that self-determination is based in human rights practice. Medicalising and pathologising trans people, when they know what is best for their lives and self-determination, is not helpful.

I will speak briefly about Traveller community suicide awareness. I always say it is not just Senator Flynn who speaks about the Traveller community. We have seen groups call out racism towards other minority groups in the past while, but I have seen members of the Traveller community say they do not feel that same level of call-out has been happening for them. We know Traveller men are seven times more likely and Traveller women six times more likely to die by suicide than people in the settled community. Culture and ethnicity should be celebrated rather than be a factor that destroys our mental health or even leads to our death. I know the hate crime legislation is in process, which cannot be overlooked. However, I take Senator Flynn's calls for how we include Traveller representation in all of the legislation we are looking at and especially to have a conversation around Traveller mental health and what it is we, as legislators, can do to ensure that is embedded into all of our mental health strategies.

Comment on this