Planning and Development Bill 2023: Committee Stage (Resumed)
Contributions 116–257 of 257. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 81 of 2023 ›
It is unfair. If Senator Flynn thinks this has something to do with her, she should realise it absolutely does not.
Comment on this
I am just going to clarify because I believe it is very important. I came in here because I heard Senator McDowell say we do not need the Bill, the national planning framework and these strategies. I am saying that while I might disagree with many of the points in the Bill and the national planning framework, it does not mean I do not engage in the democratic process. That is what we are all doing here. It was to Senator McDowell's comments and nothing else that I was referring. That we are all here having our opinions heard is very important and part of the democratic process. This is exactly why I went to the committee last week and why everybody should get involved in the consultation. However, I do not agree with the approach that we should not have any plans because we do not like the plans that exist. We all have to try as best we can to improve the system.
Comment on this
It is very important that I respond. Of course, I knew the Senator was not referring to me, but I believe, even with respect to her colleagues beside her, that it is a wee bit patronising to tell people how to do their job. That is my point. I am sure people know how to do their job. The Senator knows how to do hers.
Comment on this
That is okay. The Senator went off track earlier, too.
Comment on this
With due respect, Senator Flynn has been given considerable latitude. There is a parliamentary discourse going on. It is not personal to the Senator. There is a parliamentary discourse-----
Comment on this
It is personal to me. This is the second time today the Acting Chair has told me to stop being personal.
Comment on this
I take this extremely personally. We have to live in these conditions and the Senator does not know what it is like to live in dire conditions. Nobody gives a damn about members of the Traveller community. I am here as a member of the Traveller community and I have to stand up. My colleagues and I will keep standing up and doing the right thing. It is personal.
Comment on this
I appreciate that the Senator is speaking very passionately and advocating passionately-----
Comment on this
I will just keep saying it is personal, because it is. To me, it is very personal.
Comment on this
It was not personal to me because I was not making any personal comments, so I respectfully say we should leave it.
Comment on this
I was keeping an eye out. I was a guiding light for the Senator.
Comment on this
The Senator is a fantastic colleague, as always, and is very helpful.
I have a few follow-up comments. I listened closely to the Minister of State's response. I thank him for referring to the comments of everybody who contributed. My ears always prick up when I hear Ministers talk about rural planning and then about water quality and septic tanks.
Comment on this
I accept it is an issue. My starting point is that one-off rural housing should be maintained. I believe it is the right of rural people to build on family land without question. We have technology available to us to deal with water quality issues. If septic tanks are working properly, there is no issue. It is the language that concerns me as a person from rural Ireland, knowing the position of people within the Department. I understand the environmental concerns and I am not against addressing them. If a septic tank is not working properly, it is very problematic and needs to be addressed. We have to improve water quality. We know that, and we get the point on agriculture and rural housing.
The Minister of State mentioned transport. I do not believe any person building in a rural area, particularly a more remote one, expects a public bus to land at the front door. We are not looking for that. However, we do not want the inability to provide public transport to our front doors to be somehow used as a way to block people from getting planning permission. My point is on the mentality in this regard.
The Minister of State mentioned urban-generated rural housing. In Castlebar, where I live, very few properties are available to buy and the newer ones are quite expensive. If you and your partner are from the town, it is nearly impossible to get planning in a rural area. You have no option if you want to build your own house. That needs to be facilitated. Serviced sites would be very helpful. They comprise a way to bridge the gap. There are people who do not qualify for social housing who would like to build their own homes. If they are from the town, it is not an option for them. In the context of trying to encourage the development of housing of all types, that needs to be considered as well.
I have not picked up on the provision of age-appropriate housing. We need to provide housing in rural communities for older persons who would like to move out and downsize. That is not an option currently. It needs to be taken into consideration.
I will refer briefly to amendment No. 105. I disagree with the point that, by not supporting it, one somehow does not support people with disabilities. I absolutely reject such an inflammatory assertion from any Member of this House – an assertion made because there is a view that the amendment is not required, is catered for elsewhere or is not worded properly. It is very inflammatory to tell two thirds of the Chamber that they somehow have no concern for people with disabilities. I really reject that. It is really unnecessary language to be using.
Comment on this
I will come in on a few of the Minister of State's responses. Let us tease things out for a minute. Senator McDowell was speaking about the national planning framework and the national planning statement. To be clear, I am in favour of plans and a national planning framework, with all the caveats and suggestions for changes I have made, but the section we are now discussing is a new proposal for a new layer to the planning system that centres, remarkably, around ministerial and departmental discretion in setting policy. I am referring to the national planning statement. There are intense democratic issues. Let us be clear regarding the listing of consultations here and there. On the matter of the national planning statement, there is only a provision stating the public may be consulted. There is no guarantee of consultation with the public.
Let me refer to couple of the points made. I do not believe it is appropriate to use a word like "inflammatory" in respect of those who say a very important decision is being made on persons with a disability and that it will have effect. When we make laws, they have effect. On the making of a decision on a matter of law, I say to those opposite that it is not personal, in a sense, to say the decision on how you vote on something does have an impact on persons, on the public. Let us see who is getting caught out by much of the process. We talked yesterday about the public and how unexempted developments do not get the same look in. When we talk about the Minister's grand planning statement, we should note the public may be consulted, or they may not, but they will feel the impacts because the Office of the Planning Regulator will be required to implement and, indeed, give direction to local authorities on what is in the Minister's planning statement and penalise local authorities if they do not do what the Minister has determined to be the best things. That is why the detail matters. It matters, for example, in my amendment, which the Minister of State did not really address. It relates to the fact that the crosscutting constraints or requirements we can all point to, the factors listed in section 21(2) to which the national planning framework must have regard, do not apply to the Minister when coming up with a statement, bearing in mind all the impacts, rules, guidelines, requirements and constraints that will come with the ministerial statement.
The language does matter. If we have ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, and I do not think anybody would suggest we are in a situation where the rights of persons with disabilities are currently vindicated in the State, the idea we would not name the rights of persons with disabilities, which has huge spatial and planning implications, as one of the core things that needs to be reflected and developed in one of the largest pieces of legislation while business, industry and lots of other things are named, that does have consequences. It is not something that should have to get picked up after the fact by people who go around town by town having to campaign to make their own street accessible to them. It should be there from the beginning. It affects 18% of the population. Of course it should be there.
In terms of another accusation, we are talking about things that are important. They affect persons, the public, and we are their representatives and we are speaking about them. In that regard, they matter. During a moment when I stepped out of the Chamber it was suggested I was scaremongering about the climate. Let us be very clear. On climate change, we should be scared. We should be very concerned because, right now, Ireland is nowhere near on target to achieve the 51% reductions we need by 2030 and those reductions in themselves are grossly inadequate to what our actual fair share of climate emissions reduction would be when we look at the global picture, where hundreds of millions of people are in parts of the world that will very soon become unliveable. I make absolutely no apology for being very serious about climate and where it is put in and suggesting it needs to be put into some other places in the Bill. There is reference to the national climate objective and anthropogenic greenhouse gases but there are constraints in terms of where they are referenced and I do not think they are referenced in enough aspects.
The Minister of State suggested sustainable development underpins everything, so we do not need to talk about it separately, but why are we not adding the word "sustainable", which is one of my amendments, when we talk about commercial and industrial? When we mention sustainable development, if it is so crucial and what the Minister of the day will supposedly be doing in his or her planning statement, what do we mean by sustainable development? I would appreciate an answer on that because there is not a definition there. The sustainable development goals have been rejected as something to be named in the Bill as an anchor when we talk about sustainable development. Do we mean sustaining development, development that is environmentally sustainable or what do we mean by it? That is something that needs to be addressed on Report Stage. If we are not adding in these specific name-checked issues on climate in the various points suggested and we are relying on the vague language of sustainable development being referenced, let us be really clear. I would expect that it would be at a minimum equivalent to what we see in the sustainable development goals, though they may need to be revised further and upwards.
I have a couple of other areas and will be very brief because in many of them we have a substantial disagreement. Oversight from the Oireachtas is crucially important. This is the appropriate Stage where many of us are bringing amendments but we will not get to them. Right now on Committee Stage is the time for us to bring in points. I agree with Senator O'Reilly that people should bring in some of the work and we have brought in the work. I commend the Civil Engagement Group team who have been amazing and others across the Oireachtas who have all been working to bring in suggestions and changes. We have to be clear.
People are speaking about their terrible concerns with the Office of the Planning Regulator. I have concerns when the Leader of the House, who has chosen to guillotine this legislation, speaks at length about her concerns about the Office of the Planning Regulator when there is every chance we will not even get to the sections of the Bill that deal with it because there was a choice made to guillotine the legislation. If the Leader chooses to guillotine the legislation on the Office of the Planning Regulator but still wants to be able to give out about it, that is where the questions comes in. Make choices that allow good changes and laws to happen rather than giving a speech saying "I am very sorry". There are a number of areas of this Bill and that will come out of the national planning statement where a lot of people will be complaining after the fact. Maybe if they are lucky enough to be in the party the Minister happens to be in, they will have a little back road to try to get something into the national planning statement and express concerns. For many in the public who will be personally affected by the issues in the national planning statement, they cannot. Their local authorities will be overruled by the national planning statement. Their national parliamentary representatives will not have oversight of or an opportunity to reject the national planning statement. For many people in the public personally affected by the many issues in this Bill and the national planning statements, unless our amendments are accepted right now, they do not have an avenue for getting these issues addressed. It is important and very significant. There are some aspects of the Bill to be scared about. We will go through some of the rest of these other issues again in terms of local development plans when we come to that section. I support the comments made about nightlife by Senator Gavan.
Comment on this
With regard to the national planning statements, the Minister of State confirmed to the House, and that was new to me, so I thank him, that the Attorney General is now reviewing the draft rural housing guidelines. That is important and is progress. We had not heard about it before. What is the likely timeframe for this? Is it envisaged to be for the whole summer?
Comment on this
It is an important point to make and to follow up because the Minister of State said it and it is progress. At least we are another stage along the road. Clearly, the Attorney General will advise the Government. That is his call and his business. In line with the Minister of State's response, however, I reiterate my call that the message has to go out loud and clear and it would be important to have some sort of announcement about the commitment to put these guidelines out to public consultation. If we want consultation, it has to be all of the way, with everything. I am not selective, as I know the Minister of State is not, about the commitment to or need for to public consultation. I reiterate these are very important. There have been a lot of promises made by a lot of politicians on this, and no one seems to be delivering, stepping up to the plate and explaining to rural communities what is happening to them and their families with their family lands, their housing needs and their desire to build homes in their communities. Again, I thank the Minister of State for that clarification that the Attorney General is now reviewing these draft guidelines, and that is progress.
Comment on this
Like my colleague Senator Boyhan stated, that is a very welcome move but we need these rural planning guidelines to be published as soon as possible. These have been a long time in the pipeline. The Minister of State knows rural Kilkenny as well l as I do parts of rural Wexford, and he will appreciate the problems that are created. I speak in support of my colleague Senator Chambers's remarks on some of this. Let us be clear. Sustainability is built into this legislation, but sustainability in local communities will be driven, for the most part, by those families who have lived in those communities over a long number of years.
One of the difficulties is the sense that the Office of the Planning Regulator often tries to micromanage at a local level without the necessary local knowledge as to what is happening.
I have a particular concern because of where I am from. Over a long period, people from outside, mostly from Dublin, have come down, particularly to the Wexford coastal areas, looking to build homes or convert holiday homes. They often price locals out of the market, so it is right that there are restrictions in place to cater for local families and those with immediate connections to particular areas. Part of the problem is that there are variations in how this is being enforced from one local authority area to another. When it comes to some of the local area plans, there has also been a very high level of hands-on control on the part of the Office of the Planning Regulator. That said, I support the principle and agree that we need a central body to direct planning in general.
One of my concerns is that while in many ways we restrict a good deal of rural planning for very good reason, the next expectation then is to try to encourage people to live in villages. However, the difficulty with many villages is that they do not have the water or wastewater capacity to enable them to grow and become sustainable. In north Wexford, for example, the only village which has any water or sewerage capacity is Coolgreany. There is no other village in which people can live, despite the big demand. There is a lack of engagement between the Office of the Planning Regulator and Uisce Éireann. Ferns, which has some capacity, is currently in its third week of a boil water notice. Unusually, for those living in one-off rural houses with their own wells, the water is perfectly safe because people are maintaining it, but we have a problem with the maintenance in Ferns village. What this has done is forced more and more people to live in Gorey town. They are not being granted planning permission in rural areas and are continually being refused permission to build on the outskirts of villages because of water and sewerage capacity. At the same time, as part of the national planning framework, towns and villages in Wicklow and Wexford are being told that their populations have already exceeded the numbers that were anticipated. The question I put to the Minister of State is, which houses should we tear down? If we are going to apply the direct logic of the planning framework and the total numbers that are being set out, this is what we are facing.
I welcome the fact that the Minister of State, Deputy Dillon, committed yesterday to a review of the Office of the Planning Regulator. Like Senator Boyhan, I also welcome the fact we are going to see the planning guidelines. I would hope to see them published by the autumn, with a short consultation period. Clarity is needed around these issues. It is also needed with regard to short-term letting as part of the rural planning guidelines. I appreciate this is a separate issue but we still have not heard what exemptions will be put in place.
I disagree that the legislation does not address questions of sustainability and climate change. They are built into it entirely but it is important to understand in the context of rural housing and where it needs to be built that if the necessary infrastructure and support services are not in place, we have a major problem. I support the idea that if a family has lived within a rural community for several generations, it is not unreasonable for them to expect to be able to continue to live there.
Comment on this
On a point of information, I did not want to interrupt a colleague but I am seeking clarity. Are we supposed to be dealing with a group of amendments here?
Comment on this
Can Members keep to the group?
Comment on this
Since yesterday morning, I have heard people talking about the debate being cut short. However, hours have been wasted on repetitive points and points that have zero relevance to the actual amendments we are discussing.
Comment on this
I ask colleagues to be mindful of the groupings. There are plenty of opportunities to make points, but Members are not speaking to the actual grouping.
Comment on this
Where in the group is there a reference to rural planning guidelines?
Comment on this
We are in the hands of the Leas-Chathaoirleach.
Comment on this
It is not, in fairness. We are not going to make any progress.
Comment on this
It is open to any Member to ask a speaker to give way if he or she feels that the speaker drifting off. Under standing orders-----
Comment on this
Which is what I have done and I did not interrupt anyone.
Comment on this
You can point out that the Member is drifting off the amendments but it is such a broad topic that we are allowing for leeway. I am not sure we will get to all of the amendments that are ahead of us.
Comment on this
Notwithstanding what Senator Cummins said, and he is right, it has been a very interesting debate. I acknowledge in particular the contributions of Senator Higgins in respect of the national planning statement and her assertion that it represents another layer within the system. For half a day last week and over a number of months, the Leas-Chathaoirleach and I, as rapporteur, have been discussing the impact on the local authority and planning systems and the delivery of same. In an ever urbanised Ireland, it is only right that the infrastructural and housing development policies of Government would align with the very essence of where people are going to live. There should be an alignment between all layers of Government and, if anything, it has a been criticism of Governments over decades in this country that there has not been such. Communities have been left deficient in what they require because there have not been the types of statements, policies and alignments that create consistency across all arms of Government. In many ways we have failed our population by not having them. Through national planning statements and through alignments between the national development plan and our national planning statements vis-à-vis where people will live, we can get to a scenario where the best services are provided for people where they need them.
Last week, during the debate on the future of local government, we discussed the impact of the OPR and so forth. I was a councillor for 17 years prior to any of these procedures coming into place and I saw the stagnation of growth in certain areas because of over-zoning in some instances. As I said, some people would have zoned a lake if they could have got away with it. Not having that hierarchy and that system meant that large urban centres were not growing to the capacity needed to justify the development of infrastructure on a large-scale capital basis. I refer, for example, to the restoration of the Navan rail line, a €1 billion project that is now being advanced by the Government because the centralisation, urbanisation and level of development that we need is being achieved through the new rules that have been brought in. When we discuss these things, one would think they were going to have only negative consequences for this country and its population, but I would offer a different opinion. In fact, they will offer a chance for the population to realise what they are entitled to, which is good services, proper planning and the proper creation of communities in a manner that actually aligns with where things should be built.
In the context of that debate, we should acknowledge that. I would say that, respectfully, through the Chair, to Senator Higgins. I accept the contentions the Senator is making but the modus operandi here is that you deliver for people, not thwart them.
Comment on this
I will make a closing contribution. I will not make any further contributions because I want to try to progress this before the 6 p.m. break.
On the critical points about the OPR, I must question the consistent running down of or misunderstanding about the role of the OPR. I have outlined it here this afternoon. There is, as Senator Boyhan mentioned, a scheduled periodic critical review of the OPR that happens after five years of existence. That has just commenced. The OPR has no role in rural housing.
In relation to the national planning statements, NPS, in the Bill and the issue of public engagement, this replaces section 28 guidelines, which are ministerial but do not have a mandatory consultation or any consultation provision. The national planning statements will have Government approval. We have outlined in section 26 considerations for issuance of national planning statements and that the Minister shall have regard to this. The two issues mentioned by Senator Higgins, in relation to climate action and separately in relation to biodiversity, are addressed in section 26(1)(p) and (q). The consultation provisions are there.
Senator Higgins asked the question as to what is sustainable development. My understanding of it was always from the Brundtland Commission, the 1972 definition, that is, development which meets the needs of present generations and does not compromise the needs of future generations to meet their own needs. That was the classic definition of sustainable development. That has been refined and altered over the years. It was of its time. In planning terms, it is defined. Proper planning and sustainable development of an area is a clear definition in planning terms.
Previously, we discussed the sustainable development goals and cross-Government reporting on all 17 of the SDGs as well.
To conclude on the points on rural housing, the Attorney General's office is deliberating on that.
In response to Senator Chambers about water quality, there is a need for well-water testing. Many septic tanks in the country are not working properly and they are a threat to groundwater and water quality generally.
I agree with the point that local needs are critically important but infrastructure is hugely important. The point raised by Senator Malcolm Byrne around water and wastewater infrastructure in the rural towns and village to allow them to expand is significant because there are thousands of good houses and properties in towns and villages across the country that could be reused for families.
Senator Flynn raised the issue of temporary bays through the Traveller accommodation programme. Again, that is a local issue. As I stated earlier, the LTACCs need to engage in a meaningful way with the Traveller community. Generally, my understanding is that if there is a local need for temporary bays when families like to go travelling during the summer months, they should be provided for. That is not always the case. It is something that is part of Traveller heritage and Traveller culture. The right to be able to travel and to be able to go out travelling during the summer months, as many families like to do, should exist.
I think that has addressed all of the points that have been raised in this round by Senators.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 87:
In page 70, line 36, to delete "the Government" and substitute "both Houses of the Oireachtas".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 88:
In page 71, to delete lines 10 to 12 and substitute the following:
“(5) The Minister shall not publish a National Planning Statement, amendment or revocation under subsection (3) unless a resolution approving a draft of the proposed National Planning Statement, amendment or revocation has been approved by resolution of each House of the Oireachtas.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 89:
In page 71, to delete lines 10 to 12, and substitute the following:
"(5) The Minister shall, within 10 days of publication under subsection (3), lay a copy of a National Planning Statement, amendment or revocation so published before each House of the Oireachtas and, if a resolution annulling the National Planning Statement, amendment or revocation is passed by either such House within the next 21 days on which that House has sat after the National Planning Statement, amendment or revocation is laid before it, the National Planning Statement, amendment or revocation, as the case may be, shall be annulled accordingly but without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done thereunder.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 90:
In page 71, between lines 12 and 13, to insert the following:
"(6) The proposed National Planning Statement shall be the subject of a vote in both Houses of the Oireachtas and must be approved by the Oireachtas before coming into effect.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 91:
In page 71, to delete lines 21 and 22.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 92:
In page 71, between lines 22 and 23, to insert the following:
"(8) A National Planning Statement shall be consistent with the matters specified in section 21(2).".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 93:
In page 71, to delete lines 23 to 25, and substitute the following:
"(8) Any guidelines under section 52 of the Act of 2000 in force before the repeal of that section by section 6, shall continue in force until the full application of Part 10 or where a National Planning Statement is issued which provides an equal or greater level of protection.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 94:
In page 71, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following:
"(9) SSPRs as defined by the Act of 2000 shall be abolished.".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 95:
In page 71, lines 28 to 30, to delete all words from and including "the”" where it secondly occurs in line 28 down to and including "development" in line 30 and substitute the following:
"the desirability of setting out policy and providing guidance in relation to the performance of functions under this Part relating to planning matters to support proper planning and sustainable development".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 96:
In page 71, to delete lines 31 and 32.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 97:
In page 71, line 31, to delete "development plans".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 98:
In page 71, between lines 35 and 36, to insert the following:
"(d) the promotion of sustainable development—
(i) to reduce anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions;
(ii) to support adaptation to and mitigation of climate change;
(iii) to achieve the national climate objective, and
(iv) to support the circular economy strategy (within the meaning of section 6 of the Circular Economy and Miscellaneous Provisions Act 2022);".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 99:
In page 72, between lines 10 and 11, to insert the following:
"(i) provision of suitable Traveller accommodation;".
I withdraw it for re-submission on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 100:
In page 72, between lines 12 and 13, to insert the following:
“(j) protection of the linguistic and cultural heritage of Irish language and Gaeltacht communities including the promotion of Irish as the community language, specifically by supporting the implementation of language plans in Gaeltacht Language Planning Areas, Gaeltacht Service Towns, and Irish Language Networks, pursuant to the Gaeltacht Act 2012;”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 101:
In page 72, line 17, after "conducive to" to insert "sustainable".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 102:
In page 72, line 19, to delete "and transportation strategies" and substitute ", development and transportation strategies".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 103:
In page 72, to delete lines 26 to 29.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 104:
In page 72, lines 28 and 29, to delete “and the assessment of any application for development consent under Part 4”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 105:
In page 72, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following:
“(o)integration of accessible urban design and the provision of accessible and inclusive facilities as required under the United Nations on the Convention on the Rights of Disabled Persons;”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 106:
In page 72, after line 40, to insert the following:
“(r)recognition, protection and regulation of night venues.”.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 107:
In page 72, after line 40 to insert the following:
“(2) The Minister shall consult with stakeholders in all local planning authorities.”.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 108:
In page 73, line 1, to delete “may” and substitute “shall”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 109:
In page 73, to delete lines 8 to 21, and substitute the following:
“(4) The Minister shall,”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 113:
In page 74, line 38, after “Chapter” to insert “where such a National Planning Statement addresses the matters contained in such guidelines”.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 114 to 133, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I will speak to amendments Nos. 118, 119 and 122 to 124, inclusive, which are in my name. The purpose of these amendments is to amend sections 29, 30 and 35.
I will start with amendments Nos. 122 to 124, inclusive, which relate to the monitoring of the regional spatial and economic strategy, RSES. I understand that some amendments we made to the Bill in the Dáil in respect of this matter. The amendments are designed to reduce the time for the making of the regional economic and spatial strategy from four years to three, which was a welcome move. However, there is an inconsistency in or a sequencing issue with section 35(4). I understand what the Bill seeks to achieve in that the document would be drawn up and that there would be a report on it the following year. If it is made within three years of the passing of this Bill and there is then monitoring and reporting in respect of it within four years of the passage of the Bill, that would be fine for the first sequence. If we take it from 2024, that would mean the first RSES would be published in 2027 and that the monitoring report would come out in 2028. However, if you fast forward to the next one, three years on from that is 2030. There is actually a gap of two years when it comes to the monitoring report, which will go to three years, and then, in the next cycle, it will be in the same year. Amendments Nos. 122 to 124, inclusive, seek to put them in the same year. The most important one is probably amendment No. 124, where I suggest that in the event that the commencement of the review of the RSES is due to occur in the same year as the preparation and monitoring report of the economic strategy, the progress report under subsection (3) and the monitoring report under subsection (5) would be prepared and published one year earlier than the timeline set out in order to ensure that the sequencing is correct.
It achieves what we want, which is the correct sequencing, but perhaps the officials have a different way of addressing it. It is a really important point that I have identified in section 35.
Amendment No. 119 relates to the new metropolitan area strategic plans, MASPs. I propose that there must be new metropolitan area strategic plans as part of the process. I have highlighted this issue at committee and I have raised it previously. I believe there is a serious issue regarding the MASP boundary lines for Waterford.
I will give the Minister of State, who knows Waterford very well, the example of Tramore, which is 7 km or 8 km out the road from Waterford city. Basically, the population of Tramore works in Waterford city, as do many people in south Kilkenny, but yet they are not contained within the boundary of the MASP for Waterford that was set down by the Department. It artificially lowers the population of Waterford, which feeds into the national planning framework that we are discussing at the moment and means that the population targets are not accurate because it excludes a town of 11,500 people that is a suburb of Waterford city.
To re-emphasise and reinforce that point, Shannon is included in the Limerick MASP. Salthill is included in the Galway MASP. Carrigaline is included in the Cork MASP. All are much farther away from their respective cities than Tramore is from Waterford city. I believe the regional assemblies should have a role in creating the boundaries for the MASP and there is reference to commuting zones. I probably should have brought forward an amendment to the definitions set out in section 17 where there should be a definition of what a commuting zone is. I suggest it should refer to the geographic area of the city and surrounding areas characterised by the regular and frequent movement of residents between their homes and primary places of education and employment, typically with a travel time that is considered reasonable and practical for daily commuting. That covers what we are trying to achieve but there is no definition for it.
If you took Dublin, and you just said "commuting zone", you would probably be down in Wexford, which is not what you want to achieve in terms of the MASP. However, it would cover Tramore because it absolutely should be included. Perhaps that was my omission in not bringing such an amendment in the definitions, but it is relevant to these sections in the context of the MASP.
The other amendment I have, amendment No. 118, follows engagement with the regional assemblies themselves where they are looking for an implementation and delivery board within each of the assemblies for each of the metropolitan area strategic plan areas. There is merit in that and the implementation and delivery boards would implement monitoring and delivery objectives. That is exactly what the amendment is proposing. I think it has merit and it should be considered.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 117 seeks to strengthen the language around social development in a similar manner to amendment No. 65. It includes the word "social", which performs slightly different work than does "cultural" by itself, even though I am a big fan of cultural and I know others have amendments in this section looking at the very important issue of cultural matters, cultural spaces and cultural planning at a regional level. I insert the word "social" because something slightly different is captured by that, which pertains to ensuring there is planning, spaces and strategy to ensure opportunities for social engagement that may or may not be cultural but are crucial in terms of social cohesion and lives fully lived, as I have discussed earlier in respect of amendment No. 65. I hope the Minister of State will consider the inclusion of the world "social" in that context.
Amendment No. 120 is technical and relates to amendment No. 121. Amendment No. 121 seeks to insert protections for cultural infrastructure into regional, spatial and economic strategies. As we have seen in cities and towns across the country, cultural spaces are facing an existential crisis and are disappearing at an extraordinary rate. It went from 5,000 to about 85 or something - the figures are shocking. I will not quote those exactly but I know that it is a scale similar to that when we talk about the disappearance of some of the social and cultural spaces such as nightclubs and other nightlife spaces, for example. There are provisions within the subsection that all seem to protect the cultural heritage of the Gaeltacht. We know that cultural infrastructure and facilities are spaces where living culture exists today, where our heritage develops and evolves, where artists and musicians perform, develop their artistry and their expressive reflection of the society in which we live. In the future, our cultural heritage is not going to exist in a box. It is going to exist in a lived capacity and that means we need to plan for it and make spaces which accommodate it.
Amendment No. 125 is a technical amendment. Amendment No. 126 seeks the deletion of the line - there is a pattern the Minister of State will see here - that provides that "the Minister or a regional assembly may, at any time, notify the Office of the Planning Regulator of any provision in a regional, spatial or economic strategy" that is "materially inconsistent with ... National Planning Policies and Measures". There is a weird thing that happens here, where national planning policies and measures sound weighty, serious and thought through. That literally is just shorthand for the national planning statement we were just talking about. That is just the national planning statement. The definition, when you go back to national planning policies and measures, is the national planning statement.
It would probably look a little crass if it said the Minister can tell the Office of the Planning Regulator to go after a regional assembly that is not doing the things he or she said in its national planning statement but that is what that section actually provides. That is what that provision really is. I do not have a problem with the direction where there is an inconsistency with the national planning framework or indeed the national marine planning framework. I do not seek to remove those pieces. I propose to remove the provision that states the Minister, who effectively decided these sets of policies in the national planning statement, can then tell the OPR to go after and potentially sanction a regional plan that does not do exactly what he or she wanted in its framework. It is not the same. I do not believe the planning statement should carry the same weight in that regard as the framework or the marine framework. I also think we should not have a situation where the Minister effectively has excessive power here in both setting out the framework and demanding its enforcement. Again, this is another example of overreach and an almost authoritarian approach, especially given that the statement does not have those same checks and balances that maybe do apply to the planning framework.
Amendment No. 127 is of a similar principle. It is the same issue in relation to carrying out assessments that the Office of the Planning Regulator should not, for the purpose of forming an opinion, be giving the same weighting to the national planning policy frameworks as it may to the national planning framework. Amendment No. 128 is about the same issue again. It proposes to delete the provision that allows the Office of the Planning Regulator to form a view that a regional spatial and economic strategy should be suspended because it is inconsistent with national planning policy and measures, which is the national planning statement. This is a really heavy-handed power that has been given whereby the Office of the Planning Regulator is able to call for the suspension of a strategy. The Minister is able to request that the Office of the Planning Regulator look at and potentially call for a suspension of a regional strategy that does not do exactly what the Minister might want it to do in his or her national planning statement.
We can see how an individual Minister's individual statement could end up railroading over a large amount of extraordinarily nuanced planning.
Amendment No. 129 is with regard to the power of the Office of the Planning Regulator to recommend to the Minister a draft direction where a regional statement is inconsistent with the national planning statement.
Amendment No. 131 is a very simple amendment. It is a protective measure. If a measure made by the regional assembly is impugned by the Office of the Planning Regulator, it writes to the Minister, who has eight weeks to reply. We do not want a situation where protective measures do not apply for these eight weeks. If they were environmental or heritage protective measures, we would create a potential limbo during which irreversible damage may be done. Protective measures should apply during this period so that if the Minister declines to suspend the measure it does not come too late.
Amendment No. 133 seeks to delete another quite alarming paragraph from the Bill. This is the subsection that allows a ministerial directive to remain in force notwithstanding a successful judicial review finding the Minister came to some of the conclusions necessary to ground the directive in an unlawful manner. This provision is really something and this amendment is very important. This is not me paraphrasing what I think the Bill does; this is what it actually states:
Where, in any application for judicial review of a direction made pursuant to this section [etc.] the Court concludes that the Minister was not entitled to form the opinion that one or more of the criteria in ... subsection (8) of section 38 is met, this shall not warrant the quashing of the direction where—
(a) the Minister was also of the opinion that one or more of the other criteria... is met.
Under this provision, a Minister can state an intention to quash or overturn something in a regional plan on particular grounds. If the courts find the Minister was wrong in this, the directive will go ahead anyway if the Minister can give another reason it should happen. It is a short circuit. It is very strange. It seems like it is almost sanctioning a fishing expedition for Ministers if they wish. It is the type of thing that creates a very unhealthy power dynamic, if we think of discussions with regional and local assemblies. We could almost have a situation where a Minister who does not like what is being done can tie this up forever and block it forever. If the Minister likes some bits of the regional strategy but not other bits, they will need to be got rid of to get it through. There is a real danger. This is all a power imbalance in how it is approached.
Comment on this
I will speak briefly on amendment No. 121, which seeks to insert protection for cultural infrastructure and facilities. These are the spaces where living culture exists. As a member of the Traveller community, I have seen my culture regularly dismissed and even criminalised by wider society. Earlier I touched on the damaging impact of the report of the commission on itinerants in 1963, which is still felt by the Traveller community after more than 60 years. The report framed Traveller culture and the Traveller way of life as a problem rather than a culture to be embraced and celebrated in Irish society. We can still see the impact of the report through policies, legislation and people's attitude towards the Traveller community. The difference of cultures in all of our communities should be enhanced. We should celebrate differences in Irish society instead of stating we are all the same and that everybody should be treated the same as everybody else. We are not all the same. As individuals we all have different needs and we are all different. We should be able to celebrate this on a wider level. In the Planning and Development Bill, no culture or people with cultures should be left behind.
Comment on this
I will speak on amendment No. 116 on regional spatial and economic strategies. They should include a specific strategy for cultural matters, including space, infrastructure and facilities for creation, performance and culture engagement. Access to space is a big issue in the cultural and creative sector. Culture begins in the local community. It begins at home and in school with friends and family. Consequently, cultural activity is built on community. Local authorities have a big role to play in cultural engagement and in funding arts and culture. They do this to the tune of €70 million or €80 million throughout the State. Until very recently this was in line with the Arts Council spend until that jumped. It is significant for the culture and the arts.
To be selfish and mention my city of Dublin, there are 2,500 working artists and only 529 artists' workspaces in the city. Many of these are poorly structured. They have heating and light issues and do not have the necessary resources for various art forms. Many of them are under threat because there is a market failure issue. This is where the State can step in. This is why we propose the amendment, which I hope the Government will consider. All of the State agencies and the Arts Council state that workspace is the next issue to be tackled. The national campaign for the arts has highlighted workspace as a key issue for the sector. I have drafted a Bill, which I will launch over the summer, to give the Arts Council a function in the area of capital workspaces and affordable State-owned workspaces for artists. I hope this can contribute to the conversation we need to have.
I commend the Minister, Deputy Catherine Martin, on the funding increases but there will always be a market failure issue. We have seen nightclubs being lost. My colleague, Senator Gavan, mentioned earlier that we have gone from having more than 500 nightclubs in 2000 to 80 to 90 nightclubs now. There is pressure on space at a time when people need these environments. Robbie Kitt always says that if people were investing in something they would probably invest in the digital space or in something on their phone rather than in a meeting space where people can hang out, break down barriers and form connections. This is why nightlife is so important. It is where connections are made. This is a very important amendment and I hope the Minister of State will give it good consideration.
Comment on this
I wish to indicate our support for Senator Warfield's amendment. I apologise as I had mentioned 5,000 nightclubs being reduced to 85. This was an obvious exaggeration as the decrease was 500 to 85, which is still extraordinarily alarming.
We will support the amendment put by the Labour Party Senators regarding the linguistic and cultural heritage of the Irish language in Gaeltacht communities, which are crucial, not least at regional level, given that in many cases a Gaeltacht area will cross county boundaries, for example, as is the promotion of Irish as a community language where there is a community of speakers, specifically in the context of supporting the implementation of language plans, as set out in the Gaeltacht Act 2012. As I said, if we do not plan for it, it will not happen, which is why it needs to be reflected at regional level as well.
Comment on this
I will respond to some of the points raised by the Senators and then speak to the amendments. Senator Higgins spoke about the centralisation of power towards the Minister in the national planning statements. I again ask her to look at the guidance on the preparation of national planning statements, which state that the Minister shall have regard to what is quite an exhaustive list. That guidance ensures the Minister, whoever he or she is, will have to have regard to that clear set of guidelines and to the public consultation element. In regard to the protection of monuments, there is a significant volume of other legislation protecting built and archaeological heritage, such as the Historic and Archaeological Heritage Miscellaneous Provisions Act, elements of which are being enacted now. It is very significant legislation for the protection of monuments.
I agree with Senator Flynn about the recognition of Traveller culture, something I am keen to champion in my own work all the time. Where would we be without the John Dohertys, the Raineys or the Fureys in the context of Traveller music and the rich legacy of music that has been handed on to Ireland? Were it not for the Traveller community, we would lose so much language and music. The recognition of Travellers as an ethnic minority by the Dáil should not be tokenistic. It should be given effect and have meaning and I absolutely agree with that. I have funded the Heritage Council to employ an intercultural heritage officer, which includes working with the Traveller community, and some fantastic work has been done around tinsmithing and other aspects of Traveller culture.
I will address the wider issue of access to cultural space specifically in the context of how the amendments affect the Bill. Much of the general tone of today's debate has related to the removal of power from councils, but the provision of space for cultural facilities is a central role for local authorities and local authority members. The State provides funding through the urban regeneration and development fund, URDF, the rural regeneration and development fund, RRDF, and the THRIVE fund, which was for specific buildings that could be brought back into use. There is no shortage of initiatives of State funding for the readaptation or reuse of buildings in urban centres for cultural spaces, but it does involve the local authorities being very proactive about their arts strategies, their play policies and their cultural policies. Local authority members have a significant role to play there. Some local authorities are better than others, but I again point to the significant role and responsibility for the budgeting and resourcing of their arts strategies and play policies.
Government amendment No. 114 relates to section 29, which sets out the content of an RSES. The amendment clarifies that an RSES shall contain a strategy relating to onshore renewable energy. The word "onshore" has been added to clarify that an RSES shall deal with onshore renewable energy strategies only. Offshore renewable energy strategies will be a matter for the Maritime Area Regulatory Authority, under the maritime spatial plans provided for under the Maritime Area Planning Act 2021.
Government amendment No. 132 relates to section 39 and the issuance of a draft direction by the Office of the Planning Regulator in respect of an RSES. Section 39 currently provides that the Office of the Planning Regulator has four weeks from the final date on which submissions can be made in respect of a draft direction to consider the submissions and make a recommendation to the Minister as to whether to issue a direction. This amendment will alter this period to give the Office of the Planning Regulator a six-week period to consider such submissions prior to making a recommendation. Under the Act of 2000, a seven-week period was allowed. The proposed four-week period was not considered sufficient to allow the OPR to enough time to consider all submissions received and, therefore, a six-week period is now proposed.
Turning to Opposition amendments, amendment No. 115 was tabled by Senators Moynihan, Hoey, Sherlock and Wall; amendment No. 116 was tabled by Senators Warfield, Boylan and Gavan; amendments Nos. 117, 120, 121, 125 to 131, inclusive, and 133 were tabled by Senators Higgins, Ruane, Black and Flynn; and amendments Nos. 118, 119 and 122 to 124, inclusive, were tabled by Senator Cummins. Amendments Nos. 115 to 118, inclusive, relate to the content of an RSES. As discussed in respect of other parts of the Bill, amendment No. 115 seeks to insert provisions relating to Gaeltacht and Irish language matters. As I mentioned previously, sufficient Government amendments have been made regarding the Gaeltacht. Section 29(1) provides for the protection of the linguistic and cultural heritage of the Gaeltacht and, as with other related proposed amendments, this is considered sufficient because it is not appropriate, at the regional level of our planning system, to become excessively granular so as to end up replicating work that should be carried out at the local level of our planning system. For these reasons, I cannot accept the amendment.
Amendments Nos. 116 and 117 relate to the addition of cultural matters to the content of an RSES and the inclusion of “social facilities” in the measures relating to the implementation and monitoring of an RSES and a corresponding metropolitan area strategic plan. Cultural facilities are already referenced in section 29(1)(n) in the context of an RSES relating to economic matters, which, I believe, is appropriate content for a spatial and economic strategy. Strategies and policies relating to cultural matters are already provided for in the national cultural policy framework and the Culture Ireland Strategy 2022-2025. Section 29(13)(a) lists different categories of facilities in respect of priorities for infrastructure of scale that can be used for the implementation and monitoring of an RSES and a corresponding metropolitan area strategic plan. As things stand, I do not consider the addition of the words “social facilities” to have relevance here in the context of infrastructure of scale, but I will ask officials to consider the matter further to determine whether such facilities should be referenced here. I ask the Senators to withdraw amendment No. 117 in light of this in order that we can consider the matter further on Report Stage.
In regard to amendment No. 118, I do not see the need for the formation of an implementation and delivery board for each regional assembly or a metropolitan area strategic plan implementation and delivery board, as proposed under the amendment. Section 35 provides for the implementation and monitoring of an RSES, including reporting requirements, statutory timelines and consultation with the Office of the Planning Regulator. I believe this is sufficient and, therefore, I cannot accept the amendment.
I acknowledge the intent behind amendment No. 119 and the addition of a new paragraph under section 30(2) relating to the making of new metropolitan area strategic plans. However, a metropolitan area strategic plan does not sit separate to an RSES, under section 29(4). An RSES may include a metropolitan area strategic plan and, accordingly, any reference to an RSES under section 30(2) also includes a reference to a metropolitan area strategic plan. It is for this reason that I cannot accept the amendment, while noting the points Senator Cummins made about Waterford and Tramore.
I do not consider amendments Nos. 120 and 121 to be workable because it is not possible for an RSES to affect the provision or existence of cultural infrastructure or facilities in the manner suggested. In section 32(2)(b), however, in respect of the preparation or revision of an RSES, due account must be taken of any relevant policies or objectives of the Government or of any Minister of the Government, including any national plans, policies or strategies specified by the Minister to be of relevance to the determination of strategic economic policies.
I am not in a position to accept amendments Nos. 122 to 124, inclusive. Section 35(3) provides that a regional assembly shall prepare regular monitoring reports.
It is appropriate that these reports are every four years because the regional assembly will need to receive and review the reports from local authorities and other bodies, which will be done every three years. It would not be appropriate for regional assemblies to have to prepare their reports every three years because it would mean that they would not have time to review the reports from other bodies and reflect them in their own monitoring reports. I ask Senator Cummins to withdraw these amendments and we will give consideration to the matter on Report Stage.
Amendments Nos. 125 to 130, inclusive, relate to assessments by the Office of the Planning Regulator of a RSES to ensure that the regional tier of the planning system remains aligned with the national tier of the planning system. This is to ensure consistency and coherence across the planning system. The proposed amendments would delete all references to national planning policies and measures in relation to this assessment.
Considering that national planning policies and measures form an integral part of national planning statements, which are being introduced to provide national policy and guidance on planning matters in support of proper planning and sustainable development, I believe all references to national planning policies and measures in section 38 need to be retained for the purposes of the assessments carried out under that section. In order to ensure that a proper method of control exists to retain and readjust the alignment between national and regional planning tiers, I am not in a position to accept these amendments.
Amendment No. 131 makes reference to a "protective measure" in a RSES but, without a corresponding definition of this term or further provision to elaborate or explain the meaning of such a measure, I am unable to understand the purpose of the amendment. Again, I ask the Senators to elaborate further if possible but, as things stand, I cannot accept the amendment.
Amendment No. 133 would delete a reasonable and precautionary provision ensuring that, in the context of a judicial review, where a direction relates to the criteria specified in paragraphs (a) to (d), inclusive, of subsection (8) of section 38, and where only certain criteria are considered to have been met, once one or more of the other criteria listed in paragraphs (a) to (d), inclusive, have been met, and once the court finds that the Minister was entitled to form the opinion the subject of the direction, then the direction will not be quashed by the court. I believe this provision is sound and should be retained, and for that reason I cannot accept this amendment.
Comment on this
I note the request to withdraw amendments Nos. 122 to 124, inclusive. I want some clarity. The Minister of State understands the point I am making about the sequencing. Notwithstanding that one report is every three years and another report is every four years, if we start from 2024, today, and fast forward three years, as is in the Bill, that gets us to 2027, and if we fast forward four years from now, we get to 2028. That is perfect; the reports are one year apart. If, however, we fast forward three years on from 2027, it gets us to 2030, and if we fast forward four years on from 2028, it gets us to 2032, in which case there are two years between the reports. If we keep fast forwarding by three and four years, respectively, there will be three years in the gap, and the next time there will be four years in it, in which case the reports will be produced in the same year, which is not the purpose of this. We want to maintain a year between the reports. To withdraw the amendments is fine, but there has to be a commitment that we will align the reports to ensure that they are one year apart. That is what I have sought to try to amend here, and I think it is reasonable.
I accept that the MASP amendment does not fit exactly in section 30. I have made these points and will continue to make them. This is probably about the definition of what a commuting zone is, but the regional assembly should have a role in defining the boundary of the MASP. The existing MASPs were handed down by the Department, with no role for the regional assemblies or the local authorities. In the case of Waterford - I was on the council - Waterford City and County Council made submissions on the basis that Tramore had been excluded. This is not a parochial issue because only five areas can be defined under the legislation as metropolitan area strategic plans, but nobody has yet justified to me how Shannon is included in the Limerick MASP, Salthill is included in the Galway MASP and Carrigaline is included in the Cork MASP but Tramore, which is a shorter distance from the city than all of them, is not in the Waterford MASP. That results in a lower defined population of Waterford city and, as a result, the population targets for everything we are talking about here are wrong because they do not take that into account.
Whatever way it is achieved, we have to define the commuting zone. I would like the Minister of State to commit on Report Stage to defining the commuting zone, as I have suggested, which would typically be the travel time that is considered reasonable and practical for daily commuting. I think that would resolve the matter and I ask the Minister of State to commit to that.
Comment on this
I find this very disheartening as the only member of the Traveller community who comes in here and speaks very openly about culture and way of life, working on amendments with my colleagues. I am talking about infrastructure, spaces where Travellers can celebrate our way of life, be that during Traveller Pride Week or at equine centres for Traveller men to be able to create jobs. It would create so many opportunities for members of our community if the Minister of State were to accept amendment No. 121. Again, it is so regrettable to stand up here as a member of the Traveller community and beg for our rights to celebrate culture and to have spaces in local communities that celebrate culture. I do not want to come across as aggressive or as somebody who is fighting, but the sad reality is that it is a challenge when we have one of the largest documents in the history of the State in front of us and again we are excluding the Traveller community. I know there are many Travellers viewing this debate who will be very disappointed that the Minister of State is not accepting our amendment No. 121. I get that he said that through museums, tinsmiths and so on we can celebrate Traveller culture, yet we do not have the spaces to be able to celebrate. He can come back on this but he has clearly said he will not accept the amendment. I just feel like going home. What is the point in me coming here and bringing the voice of the Traveller community when not one of the amendments of our CEG - not one - has been accepted all day? Not one of Sinn Féin's amendments or Labour's amendments has been accepted. I think the Government has already made up its mind.
Comment on this
There is an issue here, which is that we have been told this is plan-led development. The framework is plan-led development; the Minister's statement I regard as not really as credible as the planning framework. The language, "national planning policies and measures", sounds really weighty and authoritative and so on, but if we track it back to section 25, it is literally just a way of saying the things the Minister put in the planning statement.
That is what that is. There is an assumption that the NPF and the national planning statement will in themselves be consistent with each other but there is no requirement for the Minister's national planning statement to be consistent with the NPF, and I have amendments on that. A situation could arise with some of these measures where we are asking the OPR to take action where there could be tension. This is why it would be better to have the OPR functioning directly with the NPF.
The Minister of State asked for clarification about amendment No. 131. It was very simple. That section mentions a provision of a regional strategy where the OPR has issued a direction relating to it and that the Minister is considering what the OPR's opinion on that is. In the circumstances, that provision of that regional strategy will stand suspended. My point is that if one of those provisions was a protective measure such as a measure protecting woodlands, there would be a concern that in that period of suspension, ground could be lost, so I am saying that, where it is a protective measure, there is an eight-week period during which the Minister decides what action to take and whether the provision should remain suspended. The very fact of suspending a protective measure could lead to a situation of jeopardy, which could be very significant from an environmental or heritage perspective.
We had a statement here that the NPF has a public consultation. This is not necessarily the case. The Bill does not require a public consultation. It simply says there may be consultation with the public regarding the national planning statement. Again, this is a really quick fix but we need to stop acting as if there is definitely going to be public consultation when the Bill does not require that. Bear in mind that there are revisions of it. The Minister can revoke parts of it and change it. There is no guarantee of public consultation on any of that in this Bill.
Going back to what Senators Flynn and Warfield said, there is a suggestion that, on one level, we are getting this very plan-led joined-up thing, but whenever something tricky emerges and the kind of things people tell you matter to them emerge, that is thrown back to the local level. It is being thrown back to local authority with the proviso that it may be overruled by national level, national frameworks, national statements and regional strategies but, effectively, it is passing the buck. Even the suggestion that the aspect of culture has to sit solely within local authorities and their budgets, they do not have budgets. They do not have the resources. There needs to be a vision that leads in terms of the provision of cultural and social spaces. The NPF has to plan for all of the people all of the time. It has to plan for what happens at night-time and for what happens if you are part of a group recognised in the State as an ethnic minority. That needs to be reflected in the national plan if it involves a national ethnic minority. It has to come through at the national plan level and not simply be dependent on local level.
Regarding the night-time economy activation strategy, the Department organised a specific event looking at best practice guidance for local authorities in provisions for planning effectively. Action 16 of the night-time economy report said the Department should develop best practice guidance to assist local authorities in planning for the night-time economy. These statements, the regional strategies and the framework are where those guidelines sit, yet the amendments relating to those issues have been rejected. If it is one of the clear actions that there needs to be guidance at national level upon which the local authorities can draw, it needs to sit somewhere within the national planning infrastructure and it needs to be more robust than it is currently in the legislation.
Comment on this
Regarding Senator Cummins's point on amendment No. 119, he mentioned Limerick-Shannon. That is a metropolitan area strategic plan. It is not for primary legislation to define a city commuting zone but I am more than happy for anyone in the regional assembly to have a role in that.
To go back to Senator Flynn's comments, it is not the case that there is any discrimination against the Traveller community in what we are doing here in this Bill. Far from it. It is quite the opposite. Regarding some of the measures that have been brought on access to cultural space, access to cultural space in terms of criteria attached to funding for development of cultural spaces usually incorporates everybody and is fully inclusive. That should be the case with all funding for cultural spaces. I again go back to the point raised by Senator Higgins about the local role in the development of arts strategies, cultural policy and play policy within local authorities. There is a very strong function there. Best practice guidance is what the State will provide to give guidance to local authorities but it is up to local authorities to provide those facilities. The State has put in significant funding in terms of the URDF, RRDF and town centre first heritage revival scheme, THRIVE, funds to support local authorities to develop. There is no shortage of vacant buildings, including former banks and post offices, in the country that can be used and adapted to become cultural spaces. Local authorities need to be creative. Even public open spaces can be used as active spaces for cultural activities. This is hugely important. Regarding amendment No. 131, it was unclear to me, so if the Senator wishes to resubmit it on Report Stage, that might be useful.
Comment on this
I am sorry if the Minister of State heard the word "discrimination". I am sure I did not say it was discriminatory that the Minister of State is not accepting amendment No. 121. I did not say anything about discrimination because I would not-----
Comment on this
There is no need to apologise. The Senator understands the rationale behind my inability to accept the amendment. I point to the initiatives that are in place. Again, that access to cultural space should be fully inclusive and, again, that responsibility falls at local level. I hope we get to discuss it later regarding development plans, but that is hugely important. I agree with the sentiment and what the Senator is trying to achieve.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 115:
In page 76, to delete lines 37 and 38 and substitute the following:
“(l) the protection of the linguistic and cultural heritage of Irish language and Gaeltacht communities, including the promotion of Irish as the community language, specifically by supporting the implementation of language plans pursuant to the Gaeltacht Act 2012;”.
I will withdraw the amendment and possibly resubmit it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 116:
In page 78, between lines 4 and 5, to insert the following:
“(s) a strategy relating to cultural matters, including consideration of requirements for cultural spaces.”.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?
I move amendment No. 117:
In page 80, line 6, after “cultural” to insert “, social”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 118:
In page 80, to delete lines 14 to 16 and substitute the following:
“(f) the formation of a metropolitan area strategic plan implementation and delivery board within each regional assembly for each metropolitan area strategic plan area, and the formation of an implementation and delivery board for each regional assembly, to include constituent local authorities, relevant public bodies, and their relevant agencies and other relevant bodies. These implementation and delivery boards shall implement and monitor the delivery of the objectives of the regional spatial and economic strategy.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 119:
In page 80, between lines 29 and 30, to insert the following:
“(d) make new metropolitan area strategic plans in accordance with section 29(5).”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 120:
In page 84, line 15, to delete “and”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 121:
In page 84, between lines 15 and 16, to insert the following:
“(v) where a regional spatial and economic strategy affects the provision or existence of cultural infrastructure and facilities, the need to protect such infrastructure and facilities, and”.
Comment on this
I moved amendment No. 122:
In page 89, line 32, to delete “4 years” and substitute “3 years”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 123:
In page 89, line 33, to delete “4 years” and substitute “3 years”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 124:
In page 89, between lines 35 and 36, to insert the following
“(5) In the event that the commencement of a review of a regional spatial and economic strategy is due to occur in the same year as the preparation of a monitoring report of the regional spatial and economic strategy in the same regional assembly area, the progress report under subsection (3) and the monitoring report under subsection (5) shall be prepared and published one year earlier than the timelines set out in those subsections; or as otherwise determined by the Minister.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 125:
In page 94, line 23, to delete “, or” and substitute “.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 126:
In page 94, to delete line 24.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 127:
In page 94, to delete line 37.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 128:
In page 95, to delete line 13.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 129:
In page 96, to delete line 11.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 130:
In page 97, between lines 23 and 34 to insert the following:
“(15) Where a regional assembly demonstrates that the regional spatial and economic strategy is consistent with the National Planning Framework and the National Maritime Planning Framework and to be brought into alignment with a National Planning Statement would lead to inconsistency with either the National Planning Framework or the National Maritime Planning Framework, a draft direction shall not be issued on any provisions of the regional spatial and economic strategy concerned.”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 131:
In page 98, between lines 4 and 5, to insert the following:
“(4) Where a provision is subject to a draft direction in accordance with subsection (2) but that provision is considered a protective measure such provision shall continue to have effect pending the decision of the Minister under section 40(4).”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 133:
In page 103, to delete lines 15 to 22.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 134 to 154, inclusive, are related. Amendments Nos. 135 to 137, inclusive, are physical alternatives to amendment No. 134; amendment No. 137 is a physical and logistical alternative to amendment No. 136; and amendment No. 142 is a physical alternative to amendment No. 141. Amendments Nos. 134 to 154, inclusive, may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 134:
In page 104, to delete lines 17 to 22 and substitute the following:
“(1) Subject to paragraph (b) of subsection (5), a planning authority shall make a development plan for its functional area every 7 years.
(2) Not later than 3 years after the making of each development plan for the functional area of a planning authority, the planning authority shall commence a review of the development plan in accordance with section 53 and 54, with a view to making a new development plan in accordance with section 55.”.
Amendment No. 134 relates to the development plans. The latter are one of the most important aspects of planning about which we have spoken in great length during this process. This is where our city and county councillors are active on the ground. They want to have their say when it comes to their county or city development plans. I will talk about this in some detail.
Section 42 relates to the obligations to make and review a development plan. The rationale behind the amendment is simple. Ten years is too long for a planning authority to draw up a development plan for its functional area. We had elections recently in which city and county councillors were elected to serve for a five-year period. We are already a month or two into that term. In effect, this means that the councillors elected in June may be involved in a review or the beginning of a review after four years, but they will not be in a position see a new county development plan right the way through within the life cycle of their local authorities. For many, it may be their only chance to do so because they may never serve on a local authority again.
Three county development plans at different stages passed through my hands when I was a councillor. I know the significant and hard work involved, but it is important. This is about public representatives, sitting county councillors, representing the communities they are elected to represent. They are best placed to know of the demands and the infrastructure deficits relating to healthcare, education, roads, energy, technology and innovation. On the whole, they, along with planning departments, make a valuable contribution.
I draw attention to the AILG, which sent an email to every Senator setting out the case in respect of this amendment and a number of others. In the context of the proposed extension of the lifetime of a development plan from six years to ten, the email states that in light of the rapid changes in social and economic life and in the interests of local democracy, the current six-year lifetime should be retained. That is the request. I have spoken to a number of the members of the executive of the AILG who understand that this request was to be given favourable consideration by Senators. That is for them to speak about if they wish. It is their prerogative or their call.
It is important that we have a plan. The AILG also made submissions to the Joint Committee on Housing, Local Government and Heritage on this proposal. The association runs conferences. Many Senators and TDs are in regular contact with it. LAMA has made a similar request. I have the AILG request in front of me . I want to be exact in quoting this organisation's view. I am in a position to be because I have, as I said, the document in front of me.
I am not suggesting five or six years. I have gone for the median in suggesting a seven-year plan. The AILG suggested five or six years. There is some merit in extending the time. The officials made that quite clear, but it is important that we have a reasonable period. Ten years is suggested in the Bill, with the proviso that it can only go to 12 years in exceptional circumstances. That is a long time. We are electing people, and the making of a city or council development plan is a reserved function of the elected members. Let us not fool ourselves.
Senator Daly chairs a Seanad consultation committee on local government. One of the recurring themes from councillors of all parties and none is the need to protect the powers and reserved functions of elected members. They have repeated that in their deliberations before us. They have talked about the need to continue to have their financial powers. I spoke about this earlier with respect to the chief planner. Councillors are not planners, accountants, economists, architects or engineers. As a result, they need independent professional advice. This is one of the most important functions. The Planning Regulator will say it is his plan, and rightly so. He supports the local councillors in that process and runs education and training on advanced issues around new and evolving planning policy which is of great assistance to the members.
My proposal is that these plans should be drawn up every seven years and that we must have a robust review, particularly as the reviews of city and county development plans have been weak. I have been there. I know what I am talking about. It is just a box-ticking exercise. There is no real measure. There will be an increase of the possibilities for variation, but we know the difficulties councillors have experienced in recent years in varying their plans. Ultimately, this is a reserved function and we are taking it away. Let us be honest. Let us not cod ourselves or have bits of paper telling us it is something else. This Bill will change the status quo for councillors. Currently, they can draw up plans every five or six years within the cycle of a council. They are now being told that it will be pushed out to ten years and, possibly, 12 in special circumstances. The majority of councillors I have spoken to do not want that. The AILG has made a strong case. I have gone for a number between the one suggested by the AILG and the one the Government is suggesting in the Bill. It is a pragmatic, reasonable and fair approach and it is responsive to requests from our city and county councillors. I would like the Minister of State to consider it.
Amendment No. 144 relates to section 42 and is about the obligations to make and review a development plan. It proposes:
In page 105, to deletes line 1 to 5 and substitute the following:
“(6) Any assessment carried out in relation to a development plan for the purposes of complying with the requires of Article 6 (3) of Habitats Directive or the Strategic Environmental Assessment Directive shall take account of the fact that the development plan may, by virtue [of] paragraph (b) of subsection (5), have effect for a period of 10 years.”.
The Government has something similar in there. I will not go on at great length. I am conscious that we need to push on with this legislation. This is a reasonable and fair request from a well-respected association that represents the members of local government. I gave a commitment that I would pursue it on the association's behalf. I do not give commitments lightly and when I do, I see them through. I have brought this to the table as that is what I was asked to do. I appeal to Members across the Chamber to give this proposal their full support.
Comment on this
I am concerned that we are seeing a deeper erosion of local democracy and further centralisation. The move from a six-year local development plan to a ten-year one means that elected councillors who already do not have the powers may never get an opportunity to work on the development plan for their local area. This is a key reserved power. By diluting it, the Bill will further undermine local democracy at a time when it is widely accepted that local government needs more power, not less, to allow it to deliver for communities. As my colleague Senator Boyhan said, the AILG and LAMA have been extremely outspoken in their opposition to this proposed change. I am concerned that the Government is not taking on board the experience and expertise of councillors, who understand their communities and the needs of those communities. They have a democratic mandate to represent the people. The requirement to align development plans with the national planning statement goes completely against the principles of subsidiarity and the idea that decisions should be made as close to the citizen as possible.
I urge the Minister of State to listen to the councillors - I know he was a councillor at one point - including councillors from his own party and to reconsider this change.
Amendments Nos. 135 and 140 seek to keep the duration of development plans at six years rather than the proposed ten years. Amendment No. 137 seeks for the review to be conducted four years into the plan rather than eight. I ask the Minister of State to very much consider accepting these amendments.
Amendments Nos. 138 and 139 seek to explore the pressing need for the creation of a statutory basis for the provision of independent political and technical advice to local councillors. This is very important. The need for this advice has been raised by the councillors' representative bodies, such as the AILG and LAMA, and has been a regular part of the contributions made by councillors appearing before the Seanad Public Consultation Committee, which was chaired by the Leas-Chathaoirleach, during its examination of the future of local democracy. We learned so much in that committee. The role of councillors is incredibly demanding, particularly given that many of them have additional work or caring responsibilities. That issue came up a great deal. The work of local authority strategic policy committees is very detailed and councillors need high-quality advice to be able to represent the interests of constituents.
We all know as Members of the Oireachtas that we would be lost without the help of our staff and the independent advice we get from the Office of Parliamentary Legal Advisers, OPLA, the Library and Research Service, the Civil Service and the secretariat in the case of the Government. The work we do is complex. It requires people with a democratic mandate to consult those with special expertise to make an informed decision in line with our values. The extraordinary size and intricacy of this Bill confirms that such assistance is needed. There is no doubt about it. Councillors lack all of that help. This is a problem particularly for newly elected councillors, Independent councillors and councillors from small parties who may not have experienced party veterans to rely on for guidance. Again, I ask the Minister of State to accept at least one of these amendments to take this issue forward. I ask him to listen to the councillors who are engaging in good faith to lay out the support they need to serve their communities. They do phenomenal work and this support is vital for their work. Let us make the changes we need to ensure they get what they need.
Amendment No. 141 seeks to delete section 42(5)(b). We have already outlined in some detail our opposition to the extension of the time between local development plans. This is why we are also perturbed by the prospect of an already unacceptably and undemocratically long ten-year window being extended by ministerial order. Even if this is a provision which is designed to be used sparingly, a potential 12-year period for local development plans freezes out newly elected councillors with a new vision for the area. This undermines their democratic mandate and makes the development less responsive and legitimate. This subsection is misconceived and should absolutely be deleted.
If the Minister of State will not accept our previous amendments seeking to delete section 42(5)(b), perhaps he will consider adopting one of these two amendments. Amendment No. 142 would allow the Minister to extend the plan at the behest of the elected council itself rather than an unelected manager. We continue to be sceptical about the wisdom of the 12-year plan in the Bill. At least, however, this extension would have come at the request of the elected councillors themselves, which seems more legitimate than the existing proposal in the subsection. Alternatively, amendment No. 143 would empower local councillors to overturn an extension requested by the chief executive. This would provide a democratic control on this power and would make the request for an extension more legitimate. We have tried to be constructive and to come up with multiple alternatives to make this section fairer. I hope the Minister of State will engage with this issue and give these proposals real consideration. I would very much ask him to do so.
Amendment No. 150 seeks to include considerations as to the location of cultural, social and recreational facilities in the city in a settlement strategy. Due to the extreme lack of access to space that cultural communities face in Ireland, cultural infrastructure must often be set up in ad hoc locations randomly dotted around cities. This can lead to tension, especially in areas where music, performance or dance venues exist close to residents. If cultural development is to happen in a way that works for both cultural spaces and residents, there needs to be a co-ordinated approach to this. These resources could also be incredibly useful to the public as there is very little data available to event producers and organisations on what spaces are even available to them. The Arts Council recently conducted a survey of venues in the night-time economy. It would be far more appropriate for our planning systems to be providing this data. Having an idea of the location and extent of these types of spaces could serve a dual purpose: from a planning perspective and also in creating a valuable resource for cultural organisers.
Comment on this
It seems that the Planning Regulator has a huge role in these plans. When one takes the regional assemblies into account and the plans they bring forward in the making of their own regional and economic strategies, it seems to me from my reading of this Bill, which is quite complex and complicated, that the Planning Regulator feeds into the regional assembly and that is what then feeds down into county development plans, and shapes them and what one can do at local authority level.
It is proposed to allow a county development plan to be extended to anything from seven to ten years, which is a huge length of time. If one goes back over ten years, one will see that we have had very significant changes, for example with regard to electric cars, batteries and charging points. One could make a plan today for the next ten years and before that period elapses, the issue may not be cars but might be small aeroplanes that people may be flying, or whatever. Technology is changing fast, which means that ten years for a county development plan is a very significant length of time. I agree with the previous speakers that it certainly should not be any more than ten years.
I agree with the proposal that local authority members might have the power to bring forward variations. They do not have that power at present, however. It is at the behest of the manager that a variation is brought forward, or not if the manager does not see fit. He or she is basically controlled in many cases by the Planning Regulator. If he or she does not bring forward a variation of a plan, then it will not be brought forward. The local authority members, therefore, have no power at all. The only power they have is to agree or adopt a variation of the plan and that is my interpretation of it. The Minister of State might clarify that point.
When one reads the entirety of the Bill and one takes a number of the sections into account, one sees that the Planning Regulator has all of the power. On a rolling basis, he or she is feeding into the regional assemblies and authorities in the making of regional plans. That is what shapes the county development plans and the councillors have to take that into account. The Planning Regulator, as I said yesterday, has told us that nearly anything can be put into a county development plan but he or she, at the same time, has all of the power where he or she feeds into the regional assemblies and regional plans. That is where the power really is. I would agree with the speakers here that ten years is too long for a county development plan. There are too many changes that can happen. Technology is changing. The local authority members should have the power to bring forward variations. If land is not zoned, they should have the power to bring forward that zoning by a variation to say that houses can be built here, or that we need an extra piece of land here for industrial development, or whatever. They should have that power to do that. Otherwise, it is at the behest of the manager and that is the way it is.
The Minister of State should have a good look at this before coming back on Report Stage.
Comment on this
Senator Burke has made some really important points. It relates to the hierarchy of plans in the planning system. We have the national planning framework, the national planning statement and the regional economic strategies which then feed down to development plans. They are all meant to interact with one other. I agree they should be extended to ten years. I have been through two development plan processes, along with Senator Fitzpatrick. I think we made some of our worst mistakes in coming up to a deadline of, say, 12 o’clock, that we were set by statutory processes and by which time we had to make decisions on really important things. We had been in for five days on the trot and were absolutely exhausted What Senator Burke said about the power to vary is really important - it is essential - and the power for local authority members to bring forward variations. In my time on a local authority, we were often superseded by things like ministerial guidelines, particularly when it came to things such as height in Dublin city. That comes back to the debate we had earlier on the national planning framework, the ministerial guidelines and the power of the OPR in the interpretation of those things. There are other elements of this planning Bill in the plan-led approach that need to be tightened up in respect of public consultation at that early stage of plan-led approaches in order that we do not have things like development plans being superseded. While I think ten years of a development plan is reasonable, the power to vary is absolutely key. When it comes to Dublin city, which is the one I have experience of, we varied the development plan quite often and we varied local area plans quite often too, but we had to convince the manager to be able to do it. That is one of the key points.
I wish to speak on another amendment I have in this grouping, namely, amendment No. 154. It relates to affordable housing zoning. There are many ways to try to achieve affordability in the context of land. How to get good supply of affordable development land in the places we need it has defeated so many people. It can be done through the taxation system. You can try to do it through the development plan system or things like having zoned land taxes. This amendment would allow local authorities to have affordable housing zoning. I am not saying it is a panacea or that it would automatically guarantee affordability but it would allow local authorities and their members to decide certain designations where only affordable housing can be built. It can be an essential part of the toolkit, particularly in urban areas, to try to engineer affordability into what is built in the area. I will give an example. In Dublin 8 a couple of years ago, there was a lot of derelict land in the Newmarket area. It would have been really good for residential housing zoning, and it was zoned residential. However, what we got was student accommodation almost exclusively. We got student accommodation development after student accommodation development. When An Bord Pleanála was before the housing committee a couple of years ago, it agreed that certain areas of Dublin have an over-concentration of student housing. Dublin 7 was one such area, Dublin 8 was another, and I think Dublin 1 was the other. However, because the sites were zoned for residential, An Bord Pleanála could not turn down permissions even though it knew there was an over-concentration of student accommodation there and no other standards of accommodation were being provided. This amendment seeks to at least allow the mix of affordable housing zoning to be in a development plan. That is what the local authority tried to do in Dublin city but it was told that there was no legislative basis for so doing. I will not say this is a panacea. I get that a lot of things go in behind affordability. I understand that zoning something affordable does not make it affordable and zoning something a green space does not make it a nice green space and so on. However, it would give local authority members a suite of measures through which they can try to engineer affordability and particularly into our urban settings. I ask the Minister of State to consider accepting the amendment.
Comment on this
The first amendment proposed by Senator Boyhan and me reflects his reasonable nature. I would be more radical than that. I do not believe in ten-year plans. I do not believe in ten-year plans that can be extended to 12 years. In particular, I do not believe in plans of this kind which are effectively pre-cooked by the Office of the Planning Regulator and, in effect, preordained in large measure as to their substance because of the obligation to consult with that office and then, in the end, subject to actual correction at the hands of the Planning Regulator and those of the Minister, who is obliged to obey the Planning Regulator or else come before the Houses to explain why he is not so doing.
This is a very sad piece of legislation. It marks the end of any real hope of local democracy in Ireland and of a functioning system of local government. It is a sad, sad piece of work and it is an immensely worrying development that the Department of housing is reconstructing local government in Ireland to remove as much as possible of the discretion and the independence of each local authority and to arrogate to itself and, as I said earlier, its daughter institution the Office of the Planning Regulator, virtually complete control over planning and development in Ireland. I really feel a sense of almost disgust at this legislation. I have to say that to the Minister of State, in all sincerity. I think this is one of the saddest and worst pieces of legislation that has ever come before this House. The fact that it is so enormous is almost bound to wear down the capacity of legislators to put their heads above the parapet and see what kind of Ireland we are creating. Who is this Planning Regulator? It is supposed to be an independent office. When you get to the end of the Bill, which we never will, it is an independent office with functions which are supposed to be independent. Independent of whom? This is probably the result of a slide that started with the various planning tribunals and planning corruption scandals. We are now cementing into place and building on the most secure foundations the most antidemocratic, centralised system of development law probably of any state in western Europe. I cannot imagine any other state accepting this. Britain would not accept it. No English local authority would accept this kind of behaviour. What is it about us? I know we are a small country and some people argue we have a population the size of greater Manchester and the like, but we did become independent as a small country. In this spurious attempt to pretend we have real local government and local democracy, which is reflected in the watered-down terms of Article 28A of the Constitution, we have at least the aspiration to create a genuine system of local democracy where local people really do choose what their community will do. What we are dealing with here is farcical. By constitutional requirement, there are local government elections every five years.
Local government members are then stuck with a development plan that may have come into existence before they were elected, will see them out well after and that they cannot vary except at the instance of and with the co-operation of the executives, who are all subject to the overriding and baleful control of the Planning Regulator. What is the function of a local authority member? Why do we have elections? I looked back at the recent local elections and one thing that struck me was that none of the candidates who sought my vote in writing said anything remotely intelligent about the development plan except for a few pious platitudes. I was not invited to make any decision by any of the aspirant local authority members where I live, which spoke to the kind of Dublin they were in a position to bring about. When we consider that in the future they will be stuck with a local authority development plan put in place by people who lost their seats and have been replaced, this reduces to a farce the whole local government process. How can it possibly be that local government elected members' mandates are five years and the life of a development plan, which is so difficult to vary, is ten? It is a sick joke. It is suggested that we need a planning regulator because, for instance, Dublin City Council might do something that contravenes a national planning framework or national planning statement. What can Dublin City Council do except carry out the functions conferred on it by statute and develop plans to try to improve the city? I got a message since my contribution earlier today: unless CPO powers are changed dramatically, Dublin City Council is emasculated in carrying out its functions. It must be able to, with ease, purchase compulsorily land, use it, change the nature of the areas over which it has control, redevelop areas that are derelict, underdeveloped or underused, take entire blocks of the city and say it has a different plan for that precinct of the city and will, like the wide street commissioners in the 18th century, redevelop that part of the city to make it a real living city and not await individual landowners putting together handkerchief sites and then come up with schemes for high-rise developments that bear no relation to the place in which they are. Unless we put in place such powers, give them to local authorities and give local authority elected members some considerable authority over the chief executive and planning executives in their authority and carry out that revolution, everything we do is fundamentally futile.
This House is now more or less inured to the notion that local government cannot be radically changed and that we have to have the same relationship that exists in the future as exists now between local authority elected members and their managers. We do not encourage, for example, the Dublin city manager, Richard Shakespeare, who is a good man, to have a vision that he implements for the city centre. Let us consider upper O'Connell Street and what has happened there. The Carlton Cinema site has been vacant for 20 years and nobody seems to be in a position to change that. What kind of crummy system of local government do we have that this has happened? Why is it O'Connell Street and the north inner city is so deprived and increasingly deprived of any concept of a living city? I do not know why it is permitted to happen but we in our smug laziness in this House consider that is enough for this city. It is the only city I am intimately aware of. What happens is absolutely pathetic. What does not happen is twice as sad. We live in a totally dysfunctional, non-functional society as regards genuine local government. This Bill is the dregs when it comes to that. It proposes to change the existing life of development plans by extending them to ten years and providing that they can, in circumstances in which the local executive requests it, be extended to 12 years. What function do local authority members have any more except to bicker about bicycle lanes in their areas? If the development plan is effectively precooked by a process involving the Planning Regulator being consulted before it even starts and then having the power to strike out anything the Planning Regulator so-called independently feels is inconsistent with its interpretation of these framework documents and planning statements, how sad and pathetic is that?
This Bill should never have been brought before this House. Things need to be done to increase housing supply and prevent fraudulent and abusive objections to planning permissions. This Bill does a bit of that but grabs more and more power for the Custom House and its daughter institution, the Office of the Planning Regulator, sucking the blood out of local democracy, such as is still left. It embeds in Ireland a system that has failed for so long. I support Senator Boyhan's amendment with some degree of reluctance since he makes a concession for seven years. The Bill is a sad reflection of a decadent democracy. The more I read about it and the relationship between this so-called independent regulator, the manner in which they are appointed, the Minister and Government of the day, draft directions and obligations of Ministers, I see a Bill that is the death knell of Irish local democracy. This is not the charter for a developing Ireland; this is a charter for a sclerotic stagnation over the next ten or 15 years. It should not be enacted. The particular provision with which we are dealing in the amendment proposed by Senator Boyhan is that the development plan should take place every ten years and possibly as much as every 12 years when things go slightly wrong, and that people would be elected to local authorities, never be involved in the development of a plan for their area and be bound by the decisions of the people elected five or ten years before them is grotesque. I will not put it any further than that.
Comment on this
I do not know where to start after listening to that tirade from Senator McDowell. Perhaps when I am making my contribution, the Senator might go beyond page 108 of the Bill, go to page 137, and actually read section 58, which refers to variations of the development plan. He will see some of the recommendations that we as members of the joint committee, including a number of us present, fed in as part of the pre-legislative scrutiny process, where we made similar points to those made by Senator Burke about local authority members having a role in the variation of a development plan. If the Senator reads section 58, he will see that has been inserted in the Bill, therefore much of his commentary for the past ten minutes is irrelevant based on the section, which I and members of the joint committee will welcome because it was one of our recommendations as part of pre-legislative scrutiny.
It is true that during that pre-legislative scrutiny on the matter of the length of time for making a development plan, there were various discussions where different opinions were given from different sections on the merits and demerits of extending the plan from five to seven years to five to ten years. Much of that debate surrounded the local authority members and their ability to have ownership over the Bill. I agree with the premise of that. Part of the pre-legislative scrutiny process was that a significant and robust interim review of that development plan would be built into the process. When we look at strategic infrastructure within our cities, towns and villages, those of us who have been members of local authorities all know that many of the recommendations that are written into a development plan in a five-year cycle are not achieved. We know that probably in reality, they will be achieved in the cycle of the next development plan, but they are included in the five-year development plan because it is aspirational and we do not want to impede what could happen. There is merit to extending to ten years. Where I may disagree with some officials in the Minister of State's Department is about what that will necessitate. I believe that will necessitate further zoned land for residential development, which is an important point to make, because if we are looking at a ten-year rather than a five-year horizon, additional land will require to be zoned.
It is important to note that this Bill is inserting the ability of local authority members to have that variation process. As Senator Moynihan correctly said, that is an integral part if we lengthen the time in which a development plan would be in force. Far from the perception that has been painted here that local authority members elected in 2024 would have no ability to be able to vary the plan that has been put in place, it is actually not the case when taken in the context of the overall Bill.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 138 and 139 seek to address the need for local councillors to access independent political and technical advice. When we vote for our local councillors, we vote for a person who will represent our communities. We must make sure they have all the supports they need to make these decisions in our best interests. These amendments would empower local councillors by giving them important tools to use when considering and acting on issues that come before them. Amendment No. 142 would allow the Minister to extend the plan at the request of the elected councillors themselves rather than an unelected manager. From speaking with local councillors up and down the country, I have heard too often that our councillors do not have the authority to bring about local changes they believe are needed. Councillors will tell you themselves that they have little to no powers.
Decisions like these should be made by elected councillors who are answerable to the people rather than unelected officials. I would like to see us addressing how to give more power to councillors, the elected representatives of the people. This is an example of an area where we can. A lot of the time when we look at Traveller accommodation, we tend to blame local councillors. However, if I have learned anything in the past four or five years, although there are many councillors who are - this is my first time to use the word - discriminatory and racist towards members of the Traveller community and believe that land, in some cases, is too valuable for Travellers, and we have seen Ministers get to be Ministers because they are anti-Traveller and racist, I know of 76 councillors who voted for a member of the Traveller community to come in here and be a voice for local councillors. That says an awful lot for our local authorities and not every single councillor on the local authorities is racist and does not want land or the best outcomes for Traveller accommodation, because that is not the case for every single councillor. While we see even Ministers get in here on the back of being racist and discriminatory, I think that the more power councillors have, the more changes they can bring about in local communities.
While we blame councillors, and many people do not know what little power county councillors have at a local level, the issue is with the system. I remember the corporation in the 1990s. Now there is Dublin City Council and the different local authorities. It is the same system underneath a different name and I genuinely believe that amendments Nos. 138, 139, 142 and 143 will give more powers to councillors, whom people in the area elected to be a voice for them.
Comment on this
Having had the privilege of serving on the country's largest local authority from when I was first elected in 2004, I take a particular interest in this section. As Senator Moynihan said, the pains and frustrations of the planning system are ones I am all too familiar with. When we apply ourselves to the exercise we are engaged in, in scrutinising this legislation, we would be well served by restricting our considerations to the legislation in front of us, and not to stuff that has gone on in the past or stuff that may or may not happen in the future, and applying ourselves to trying to put in place the best legislation to achieve the best mechanism to deliver the best planning outcomes. When I look at this section and the section on development plans, we currently have six years and Senator Boyhan is suggesting seven years.
I am not sure what magically is going to happen in those 12 months given it takes most local authorities at least 24 months to complete their development plan review, composition and the making of it. I welcome the ten-year process. As somebody who has had the privilege of being part of making the development plan I know the effort that goes into it not just by the elected members, but also the executive and most importantly the public. Residents' associations, community groups, sports groups, businesses and all types of organisations engage in that process. Let us not forget what it is. It is a strategic plan. It is not an operational plan or an individual planning permission, but a strategic plan to give strategic guidance. With that strategic guidance in place, a certain strategic certainty is created for a meaningful period of time. I welcome that.
I am absolutely determined to not just protect but enhance the role of elected members of our local authorities. I commend the improvements that have been made in the conditions of local authority members by this Government. They have been welcomed. Do they go far enough? No, of course they do not. The Minister of State knows this as he hears it from us often enough. We need to keep pushing in that direction. However, I am not going to bring amendments to a planning Bill to improve the powers or the capacities of local authority members because that would not be good practice. What this Bill does in section 58, as a really important amendment to the making of a development plan, is give the power to the local authority members at any point during the lifetime of the plan to trigger a variation to the plan. That is a really important power local authority members will have. It is important to read the full section 58. It states:
The members of a planning authority may at any time, by resolution request the chief executive of the planning authority to prepare a report on a proposal by them [not by anybody else, but by them] to initiate a process to consider the variation of the development plan for the time being in force.
It goes on to compel the chief executive to submit a report to the members within a specified period, namely, four weeks. The chief executive is going to have to come back to the elected members and respond to their request with a written report within four weeks. I am very conscious of the clock and I am not going to stand here talking all night and reading a document we can all read ourselves and that the public can read because it will be there for them to read. However, it very clearly sets out a process that puts the power into the hands of the local authority members at any point in the lifetime of the development plan to trigger a variation. It compels the chief executive to act on it and to do it all within specified periods of time. On that basis, I am very happy to support this section and hope we can move on.
Comment on this
I have been asked whether I read section 58. I read it, but I read on to what happens when a variation is proposed. First, it has to be sent to the OPR for examination. If the OPR decides it contravenes, in the OPR’s so-called independent view, any of the national planning criteria we spoke about earlier the Bill provides that a draft direction can be cooked up by the OPR to tell the local authority not to make the amendment. That is the end of it unless a Minister comes to this House and says he disagrees with the OPR, states the reasons for same and that the OPR’s view is technically incorrect. The Planning Regulator and his office have been put into this position of correcting the homework of every council and every initiative to vary any draft plan, and to veto it unless a Minister comes before this House and the other House and says he wants, for stated reasons, to disagree with-----
Comment on this
When does it happen is the question I have to ask. It is very easy to mutter about this and say it can happen, but it does not happen. The same machine that is in the Department of housing and local government is the parent of the daughter institution, the OPR. They select each other for all these positions as managers, or now chief executives, of county councils. There is a prefecture installed in Ireland that obeys a code of its own. That is the reality of the situation. Senator Fitzpatrick says a local authority can initiate a process to vary its development plan. It can, but when this is initiated, the chief executive is bound to come back with a report to the elected members and if he or she tells them he or she thinks it contradicts the national planning framework, ministerial guidelines or whatever, then at that stage it is dead in the water unless the members insist on it. By the time that happens, the OPR has been consulted on it, has consulted the chief executive of the local authority and its planning section and the die is cast.
Let us not cod ourselves here. We are putting together an antidemocratic centralised control system. I do not particularly worry about what Wexford County Council members are planning for Wexford. I wish them well in planning their area as they wish. I do not want somebody sitting in Dublin saying "Hold it" because the Government, at the insistence of the Minister, issued a national planning framework and the council does not seem to be paying it sufficient attention. I do not want to hear about national planning statements and the deference that has to be given to them by local authority members. All of that is a symptom of our unwillingness to trust elected local authority members to the same extent as those on United Kingdom local authorities are permitted to exercise their judgment. If these provisions were put before Westminster they would be laughed out of it, but we are prepared to subjugate local government to centralised control, centralised revision and centralised reversal. I know of no other country in the world that does that. I know of no common law country or civil law country which says a man or woman called the planning regulator shall be independent in their functions and shall effectively veto what is, subject to not being overridden by a Minister, the democratic wishes of a local authority. It does not have to be like this. We have grown accustomed to it. We have become house-trained by the gradual changes that took place in our planning system because we were so afraid of corruption by local authority members we thought they should be supervised to the extent they are. The great majority of local authority members are decent, straightforward, honourable people who are not corrupt and never have been corrupt, for that matter.
Only a tiny minority at one stage engaged in dubious and corrupt activity in respect of rezoning. However, this is not the remedy.
I will return to the point about which I was contacted today. Unless local authorities can acquire land easily, without going to the High Court or going through the ridiculous obstacle course of compulsory purchase orders, CPOs, unless they have an effective system of mobilising the land resources in their local authority functional areas, unless they can drive development rather than wait for random proposals from the private sector, and unless we have a system that radically changes, we will not have beautiful cities but ugly cities. We will not have adequate social housing or a mix of social, affordable and private housing to an adequate extent. We will have areas which are blighted and we will have the mess of Upper O'Connell Street.
I travel down the southern quays every day and I will be doing so until some day in mid-August when it will become illegal to do so. I notice across the river the site of the Ormond Hotel, which features in Ulysses. It has now been demolished and left empty for eight to ten years in a strategic and scenic part of our city. In any other world, the local authority would have taken that land from the developers, handed it to somebody and asked them to develop it quickly, within a year or two. The authority would have given that person a building lease and taken a use-it-or-lose-it approach. We do not have use-it-or-lose-it laws. We have derelict site laws that are grossly ineffective. As I said, the Carlton Cinema saga shows precisely how weak and ineffectual Irish local government is on its premier thoroughfare, which has been blighted for 20 or 30 years now. No other capital city anywhere in the civilised world would permit that situation to continue but that is what we have done.
You can have permissive. There are two things here. A Scandinavian academic went to Galway City Council and asked to see its plan for the city. He was shown the development plan and said it was not a plan but a series of restrictions. He asked what the council was going to do to build, rebuild and redevelop the city. The representatives of the council looked at him as if he was from another planet. We do not have positive planning in this country. We allow developers to put together sites randomly and to come up with random plans to develop their sites when there is sufficient profit to be made. We do not have the approach that made Dublin beautiful. Pembroke estate lies to the south of this House. It did not happen as a result of random planning. Gardiner Street, Mountjoy Square and all of those areas on the north side of the city did not arise from permissive planning but from positive planning. The sad fact is we are cementing into place negative and permissive so-called planning, which, in fact, does not plan and does not have any positive aspect to it but merely tells people what they cannot do and what certain people would love other people to do, but not what local authorities will do, to bring about positive development in their areas.
Comment on this
I will go back to consideration of amendment No. 134, with which we are dealing in this set of amendments, and to recap something Senator Fitzpatrick talked about. What is an additional year on six or seven years? To be clear, I am not asking for an additional year. I reiterate that the AILG is composed of members of the Minister of State's party, of every other party and of no party at all. The president is a Fianna Fáil councillor in Wicklow, Mr. Gail Dunne, who wrote to Senators. I do not know at what aspect of what I have said Senator Fitzpatrick is laughing at. I am not sure which was the funny part of that sentence.
Comment on this
The Senator is reminding me of members of my own party.
Comment on this
The AILG comprises practitioners and councillors, and this is the request it has made. Let us be clear that this is an opportunity to put where we stand on the record. We do not speak out of both sides of our mouths. We must make a commitment, honour it and make the best case for it. I am here to make the best case for Mr. Dunne, the president of the AILG, and all its members, of all parties and none. They were against ten years. They suggested in their submission to Members of this House that if they could not get ten years for their development plans, they could come down to eight years. It is clear they do not want a development plan that lasts for ten years. They want to know where people stand and I am going to tell them where I stand because that is all I am about. I would like to convince other people but it is a matter for them to decide. We will, I hope, be voting on this amendment in a few moments. To be crystal clear, I suggested a seven-year period as a sort of compromise. They suggested ten years, or possibly eight years. I think the seven-year period is reasonable. There has been much litigation in respect of development plans over the years. A famous case mentioned legitimate expectations. The citizens have a legitimate expectation of their city and county development plans and how they will map out and set out proper planning and sustainable development for their areas. I restate that I am here on behalf of the AILG to articulate its views on this particular aspect of the Bill. Its request is reasonable and we should support it. If we do not want to do so, that is fair enough and it will be a matter for other people to explain that on another day. I believe it is the right and appropriate thing to do. I hope we have support for the AILG in this House.
Comment on this
I will try to be brief so we can get through some of these amendments. I will make a general point in reply to the comments made by Senator McDowell. I have tremendous respect for him but I fundamentally disagree. He is consistently putting down the OPR. He has talked about draft directions that are precooked by the OPR. That is disingenuous. He suggested we are being house-trained. He also put down local government consistently in his contributions. I ask him to look at the force for good that local government is in Ireland. We have had this debate in the Chamber. I sat in on one of the sessions relating to the future of local government. I ask him to look at the good and positive work that is going on.
The Senator mentioned Mountjoy Square and many of the plans in that area have been led by the local community and by councillors. Budgets have been voted through and supported by councillors. There is a considerable amount of good and positive work going on within local government and it was disappointing to hear the Senator's contribution. He is not the only one who has been putting down the OPR during the debate, but it is disappointing. The office is there for a valid reason. I will remind Senators of the three functions of the OPR, which are to independently assess all statutory forward planning of all local authorities, including development plans and local area plans; to carry out organisational reviews of the systems and procedures used by any planning authority, including An Bord Pleanála, in the performance of its functions; and to drive national research, training, education and public information programmes. The issues around the role of the OPR are being misrepresented by the Senator. He has his view of the Bill, and it is clear he is not a supporter of it, as is his democratic right. However, the OPR does not precook plans and the Minister is not required to obey the regulator. In fact, he has, on quite a number of occasions, disagreed with the OPR. In a way, the Senator appears to be deflecting all the woes of our planning system onto the OPR to account for past failures. I ask the Senator to reflect on that. I have tremendous respect for him but some of what he has said this evening has been out of order.
Terms such as "dysfunctional" have been mentioned. It is not dysfunctional. There certainly have been issues and challenges in our planning system which it is hoped the Bill will address. I ask Senator McDowell to reflect on this. The bigger challenge regarding the democratic role of elected representatives, particularly the making of development plans and the reserved function, is very important. There are wider issues which the Government has addressed regarding the role of local government and local authority members. The mechanism for directly elected mayors in every urban area or county is important.
To make a general point, moving to ten-year plans will release local authority members from the repetition of the six-year development plan cycle, two years of which is spent in process, as Senator Fitzpatrick has said, to engage in real local plans for local development. Specific land area plans will be done by people who would otherwise be engaged in the six-year cycle. They have a very important role in climate plans, biodiversity plans, arts policies, housing strategies, and local economic and community plans. There is so much planning work in which local authority members are involved outside of the actual development plan and we cannot discount this.
I will now speak specifically to the amendments. I do not think there is anything else I need to address. I have to say the constant putting down of the Office of the Planning Regulator and the important role it has is disappointing.
I will now address amendments Nos. 134, 144 and 145, tabled by Senators Boyhan and McDowell; Nos. 135, 137 to 143, inclusive, and 150, tabled by Senators Higgins, Ruane, Black and Flynn; amendments Nos. 136 and 154, tabled by Senators Moynihan, Hoey, Sherlock and Wall; and amendments Nos. 146 to 149, inclusive, and 151 to 153, inclusive, tabled by Senators Warfield, Boylan and Gavan.
Amendments Nos. 134, 135 and 140 relate to the lifespan of a development plan and amendments Nos. 136 and 137 refer to the period of time after which a planning authority must review an existing development plan. The key purpose behind the change in development plan duration is to align the cycle of development plans with the cycle of census data availability. This will provide for more informed plans with greater certainty regarding the availability of adequate zoned land to align with the needs of housing development strategies and economic development strategies. In short, this change will provide greater certainty over a longer period for all stakeholders. The point has been made on the ability of elected members to vary development plans at any point in the lifetime of that plan.
As set out under section 56(4), elected members of local authorities will review the performance of their development plans after five years and may propose amendments to plans to take account of wider changes that may have occurred since the plan's inception. A point was raised with regard to changes in the lifespan of a plan. The timelines set out in subsections (1) and (2) of section 42 have been carefully considered and are intended to ensure adequate time is provided to prepare and finalise development plans and, most importantly, that sufficient time is now available to planning authorities for the implementation of their development plans. I thank the Senators for their proposals but I am not in a position to accept them.
Amendment No. 138 relates to discretionary consultation by elected members of local authorities with independent legal or technical advisers. I have not been able to determine why legislation may be required on this. If there are other provisions in law that for some reason prohibit elected members from carrying out non-compulsory consultation, then I can consider the matter in greater detail but, on the face of it, I am unable to see the need for this provision and for this reason I am not in a position to accept it.
I cannot accept amendment No. 139 as I am unable to determine the purpose, scope or process for producing a report as proposed. It is unclear what "viability" is supposed to refer to in the amendment. For example, does it mean the ability of elected members of a local authority to obtain independent services, or perhaps the cost-effectiveness of such a process, or even the availability of services that elected members can avail of? Not only am I unclear as to the purpose and the scope of this amendment, I am also unable to determine how the Department could be in a position to produce a report as proposed. For these reasons, I cannot accept this amendment.
Amendment No. 141 proposes to delete section 42(5)(b). This paragraph enables the Minster, only at the request of a chief executive of a planning authority, to extend the period of a development plan, but only in situations where exceptional circumstances exist and only for a period of not more than two years. I would consider that recent events alone provide more than enough justification as to why such a power may be required. As a precaution, given the safeguards relating to exceptional circumstances and the limited time periods involved, it is entirely worthwhile retaining this provision and, therefore, I cannot accept the amendment.
In relation to the Minister’s ability to extend a development plan in exceptional circumstances, amendments Nos. 142 and 143 seek to substitute the "elected council of a local authority" in place of the "chief executive of a planning authority" and to give elected members of a local authority the power to overturn the extension request. I see no reason to further amend section 42(5) in the manner proposed as I do not believe there is a necessity to provide for the additional powers as set out under this amendment. As I have mentioned, there are adequate safeguards built into the provision as currently drafted to ensure its proper operation. For these reasons, I cannot accept this amendment.
Amendment No. 144 cannot be accepted as the period of 12 years as currently set out under section 42(6) is correct and to reduce this period to ten years would be inappropriate based on the extension to a development plan's duration that is permitted by way of paragraph (b) of subsection (5) of that section.
In relation to amendment No. 145, which links back to amendment No. 3 and the proposed definition of a chief planning officer, for the same reasons I already outlined in respect of amendment No. 3 concerning the purposes, scope and functions of planning roles and the recruitment of staff being a matter for local authorities themselves, I am not in a position to accept this amendment.
Amendments Nos. 146 to 153, inclusive, propose additions to the content of development plans relating to a range of matters such as cultural spaces, night venues and artistic creativity. As drafted, section 48 makes adequate provision for the improvement, extension and preservation of amenities, facilities and services to meet, among other things, the cultural requirements of the functional area to which a development plan relates. This is a requirement of the process to make the development plan. I point Members to section 48(2)(a) and 48(2)(b), which are very strong in this regard.
Section 45 makes provision for an economic strategy to identify the attributes of particular places that are essential to enhancing economic performance and the social, community and cultural facilities in a given functional area. I am of the view that the matters to which the Senators refer are already sufficiently and effectively catered for in the Bill. Again, I point Senators to the sections I have just mentioned. Furthermore, their provision is balanced with other necessary and appropriate objectives, which are necessary to develop a rounded framework for the development of an administrative area.
With respect to night venues, the Department did participate actively in the night-time economy task force set up by my colleague, the Minister, Deputy Catherine Martin. I participated on it myself. The support for, and future development of, the night-time economy is a matter for planning policy rather than being specifically referred to in legislation. This is due to the varying considerations that apply to the night-time economy depending on the location of a given functional area within the State. For these reasons, unfortunately, I am not in a position to accept these amendments.
Amendment No. 154, proposed by Senator Moynihan, proposes that a development plan's written statement, as required under section 43(2), contains provision for the zoning of land for affordable housing within the meaning of the Affordable Housing Act 2021. While the sections of the Bill relating to the content of a development plan set out a series of strategies, they do not stand alone and, instead, form part of an interconnected series that consist of the core of a development plan, the essential function of which is to set out an integrated overall strategy for the proper planning and sustainable development of an area. Section 46 provides for the obligation to prepare a housing development strategy, which must be materially consistent with the housing strategy prepared under Part 7 and which, in turn, must include an estimate of the amount of social, affordable and cost-rental housing and Traveller accommodation required during the lifetime of the development plan. Section 46(5) provides that any land zoned for residential use, or a mix of residential use, can be developed exclusively for social or affordable housing. The provisions relating to the housing strategy and the housing development strategy under the Bill are carefully balanced and take account of the various inputs that are factored into consideration when dealing with housing policy and its spatial implications within a functional area. I cannot accept this amendment.
Senator McDowell mentioned UK local authorities several times. UK ministers have powers with regard to local planning decisions and they can intervene in a similar way.
Comment on this
They have some powers but they do not have an opposite planning regulation which vetoes everybody's activities.
Comment on this
Not to labour the point, but I ask the Senator to look at section 58(12)(e). Where, in proposing a variation the members of an authority are not in compliance with the Office of the Planning Regulator or the Minister, they have to give notice of the reasons for the decision not to comply with the recommendations concerned.
Comment on this
No, that is it. There is no recommendation. Let us be very clear. Senator McDowell is suggesting that there is some sort of other veto, but that is not in the Bill before us. We need to be honest about that. It is clear in section 58(12)(e).
Comment on this
There is also section 62 whereby the Office of the Planning Regulator can require them to make a variation, so there are major issues.
Comment on this
The point is that there were powers to make variation.
Comment on this
Can we let Senator Higgins make her contribution, please? I will allow any Member who wants to come in to do so. We are here until 9.30 p.m. so there are 20 minutes to go.
Comment on this
I am keen to move towards votes as well but it is important to mention the powers to vary were in the 2000 Act. In the powers to vary in this Act, there are differences and the Office of the Planning Regulator is an issue in relation to that. That is completely legitimate. It is not about any individual but about concerns we have about the powers in section 62. I was not going to raise it but it is important to mention because it is another point of intersection between the power of variation and the Office of the Planning Regulator.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?
It gives me great pleasure to welcome to the Public Gallery Mary Tully, the esteemed wife of our colleague and friend Senator Joe O’Reilly. I also welcome Barry Sweeny and his brother Conan, who are here from Donegal. Hard luck last weekend and it is great to see them. I welcome Johnny McGuinness and his partner Tracy to Leinster House and thank them for being here. I thank them for their public service as well. Go raibh míle maith agaibh go léir.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 135:
In page 104, line 18, to delete “10 years” and substitute “6 years”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 136:
In page 104, line 19, to delete “8 years” and substitute “7 years”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 137:
In page 104, line 19, to delete “8 years” and substitute “4 years”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 138:
In page 104, between line 22 and 23, to insert the following:
“(3) Elected members of the planning authority shall be able to consult independent legal and technical experts to assist them in their work on the creation of or review of the development plan.”.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?