Mica homeowners and defective concrete scheme
Keogan criticised accountability under the defective concrete scheme, saying 98 Donegal families face downgraded homes despite engineers’ calls for demolition.
I wish to bring a shocking failure of professional accountability to the floor of this House. I am speaking about the defective concrete blocks scheme and downgraded homeowners in Donegal. There are 98 families fighting for roofs over their children's heads under this scheme. While €70 million has been allocated to defective homes, I doubt it will be enough. Two years ago, I stood in this Chamber and raised the alarm about how these families' homes were systematically downgraded. While independent engineers stated that these crumbling, mica-damaged houses required full demolition, State-vouched chartered engineers conducted unprofessional desktop-only reviews and overrode those decisions, forcing families to live in crackling, mould-infested limbo.
Today, those families stand completely vindicated. Independent statutory appeals panels have annulled every single downgrade decision adjudicated upon to date, exposing multiple significant errors in both fact and law. These State-vouched engineers failed to inspect homes in person or consult geologists and signed off on retaining foundations that were actively falling apart. While the legal system has vindicated the homeowners, the professional regulator has completely failed them. In September 2024, these families submitted detailed, evidence-backed ethics complaints to Engineers Ireland. Two years later, those complaints remain completely unresolved, with zero scrutiny or accountability. This is a massive threat to public safety and trust.
The Government cannot disclaim responsibility for the actions of engineers acting as agents of the State. I call on the Government to immediately launch a review. We must ensure that any professional work that has been legally proven by a statutory appeal panel to contain serious and significant errors is held fully accountable, and even removed from making life-altering decisions over State-funded redress schemes.