Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
Teaching Council of Ireland
Senator Martin Conway raised concerns about delays, repeated information requests and extra costs faced by a Clare teacher seeking registration. Minister of State Michael Moynihan said he would seek clarification from the independent Teaching Council, ask it to ensure any further requirements are requested upfront and assessed promptly, and report back.
The Minister of State is welcome to the House. I appreciate that it is a busy week. I commend the Minister of State for his work in the role and for what he has secured in the budget. I know it was an arduous and difficult process. There is never enough. Well done on what he has achieved.
I want to raise a concern about the Teaching Council. I am raising it on behalf of a qualified teacher in Clare who I have been engaging with in recent weeks. It is frustrating how he has been treated by the Teaching Council. He did his degree and he got his honours degree with no problem and did very well. Given the particular course that he took, in order to reach an advanced educational level, he had to go to London because very few colleges in Ireland provide the specific training to advance him to the necessary level. He got his qualification and was delighted to come back to Ireland, where he wanted to commence his career as a teacher.
We know how scarce teachers are. We know that a lot of young teachers are opting to go abroad. Therefore, it is always good news when a young person like this decides to come back and use his skillset in Ireland, in his community, and to contribute to the enhancement and development of education in his community. That is where the good news stops. He applied to the Teaching Council in 2024. In the first instance, it told him that he did not qualify. Then, when what was required was provided to prove that he was qualified, the council kept writing back to him looking for additional information. The Minister and I deal with Departments all the time, as does the Acting Chairman. We know that most Departments will come back and say that A, B, C, D and E are missing. In this case, the council came back and said that A was missing. When that was provided, it came back and said B was missing. It proceeded to then say that C was missing. This went on for a protracted period of time. At one stage, the Teaching Council lost his application. He was then in the situation where he had to reapply, all of this costing money.
Parallel to this, he applied to the General Teaching Council for Northern Ireland, where his application was accepted successfully within two weeks. He then re-engaged with the Teaching Council of Ireland, and it pointed out that if someone is registered in Northern Ireland, that does qualify. However, it is still going on. It is very frustrating. In a cost of living crisis, where young people are doing their best to get on the ladder of life, it is costing him three to four times what it should cost him. Now, the Teaching Council is telling him to reapply in a different guise, which is going to cost another €200 or €300 on top of what he has already paid.
It is scandalous that this bureaucracy is dictating the lives of young people and dictating the life of this particular young, talented chap in County Clare.
I want the Minister of State to intervene to resolve this with the Teaching Council. All of us in this House have had issues with the Teaching Council, and I have no doubt the Minister of State has had them too. It considers itself a quasi-independent body. I believe there is a lack of accountability there, but that is a discussion for another day. It is a discussion we should have in the context of reforming the Teaching Council and certainly its approach to dealing with people.
However, the purpose of my Commencement matter is to resolve a problem for an individual. I hope the Minister of State might have good news in that regard.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Conway. I appreciate the question. At the outset I note that the specific details of the case highlighted by the Senator are not to hand. This information must be obtained by the Department from the Teaching Council of Ireland. I will ask my officials to provide further context for the Senator when it becomes available. The Teaching Council is the independent regulator of the teaching profession in Ireland, established by the Teaching Council Act 2001, as amended. Its role is to protect the public by promoting and regulating professional standards in teaching. This is carried out through the regulatory registration of teachers, ensuring highly qualified teaching professionals who meet and uphold high standards of professional competency and conduct. One of the ways the Teaching Council ensures the regulatory standard is by ensuring that all teachers entering the profession in the Republic have met the required standards.
The Teaching Council receives approximately 680 eligible applications annually from teachers who have qualified outside of the State. There are currently two dedicated application pathways for teachers who have qualified outside of the Republic of Ireland. Recognised applications are assessed in line with EU Directive 2005/36. Teachers who have qualified outside of the State and who are eligible to teach in the country in which they obtained their qualification may apply for recognition as a teacher with the Teaching Council. These qualifications proceed in line with the EU directive and are assessed to ensure they are of comparable standards to those achieved by graduates of the accredited teacher education programme in the Republic of Ireland.
A person deemed to be a fully qualified teacher has completed a recognised teacher training qualification and a programme of induction. A person must provide an official letter confirming they are a fully qualified teacher from the relevant teaching registration body or competent authority in the country of qualification. Post-primary teachers must also meet the requirements for at least one approved curricular subject. Where substantial differences are identified between the applicant’s qualification and experience and those that apply in Ireland, the applicant will be given the option of compensating for substantial differences via an aptitude test or an adaption period. In many instances, applicants put forward multiple qualifications for assessment and accordingly compensatory measures will reflect that.
Recognising applications received under the time-bound provision, the council's recent revised registration regulations allow teachers who qualify in another country but who have not completed any necessary induction there to apply to register with the Teaching Council where they meet specific criteria and complete their induction in the Republic of Ireland. The provision opened for applications in October 2025 and will remain open until 30 December 2027. To be eligible for registration under this provision teachers must have completed a teacher education qualification outside the country that is of equivalent standard to the Irish teaching qualification. This means no qualification shortfall should be identified between their teaching education qualification and that of the Irish standard, save the Irish language requirement for primary schools, and history and structure of the Irish education system for post-primary schools.
I propose to refer to the specifics in my closing remarks.
Comment on this
Is it possible for the Department to furnish the Seanad with a hard copy of the statement? I know that is normal practice but for the week that is in it, maybe we have could have a copy before close of day.
Comment on this
I also acknowledge the week that is in it. However, my office separately supplied details to the Seanad Office under cover of email, which I have no doubt were passed on to the Minister of State's Department. It should have the details of this case. I was hoping in this Commencement matter to get some clarity on the specific details. The details were supplied similar to a parliamentary question. I am looking for leave to resubmit this Commencement next week because something has obviously been lost in translation somewhere along the line. That is unless the Minister of State has the details.
Comment on this
I cannot give that commitment to the Senator. It is a matter for the Cathaoirleach's office. He will need to contact it.
Comment on this
Does the Acting Chair see my point? The details were supplied and the Minister of State has said in his opening address that he does not have the details.
Comment on this
To be clear, the Teaching Council is an independent regulatory body. That is 100%. We will seek clarification on the specific case raised and respond with any details. What the Senator outlined at the start was that the information sought by the Teaching Council came in dribs and drabs, for want of a better term. I will ensure to ask the Teaching Council to look at this. Obviously, we cannot interfere, but we will ask it to make sure any further information required from the young person who wants to go on the teaching register is requested upfront and assessed in a timely manner. I will ask that and come back directly to the Senator and the Seanad to clarify. We will circulate some hard copies.