Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
Waste Management
Teresa Costello called for stronger traceability and accountability for skip-bag companies, arguing they should collect illegally dumped branded bags rather than leave costs to councils. Alan Dillon said bags already require permit-holder details and unique IDs, but users remain responsible until collection and local authorities handle enforcement; Costello was dissatisfied with this response.
I raise the issue of the lack of traceability of large skip bags and, in particular, the recent increase in these bags being illegally dumped in housing estates and along roadsides. I am receiving reports of this happening across my constituency in areas including Knocklyon, Firhouse, Bohernabreena, Springfield, Aylesbury, Belgard and Kilnamanagh.
These communities all have strong residents associations and volunteer groups. People give up their own time to pick litter, look after green spaces and work alongside South Dublin County Council to keep their communities clean and tidy, and it is extremely frustrating for residents to see a large skip bag full of waste dumped in their estate.
I cannot understand why these bags are not being traced. These large skip bags can be bought in shops. They are not expensive but when somebody purchases one, no information is required to be recorded. The skip company does not know who purchased that bag, the bags do not seem to have an individual identification or serial number, and if that bag is subsequently found illegally dumped in a housing estate, it cannot be traced back through a system.
I have difficulty with a skip company being able to sell a bag designed specifically for the disposal of a large amount of waste without responsibility being attached to that bag from the point of sale right through to its proper disposal. A skip bag should not be sold simply as a bag. A proper system should be attached to it. If I hire a skip, I am not just paying for the physical skip. I am paying for a service, including the delivery, collection and appropriate disposal of the waste. We need to look at applying the same principle to these large skip bags. Full traceability is needed in this regard. Either every bag should have a unique number and can be followed from point of purchase through to collection and disposal, or the full cost of collection should be included when the bag is purchased. People should be purchasing the bag and the collection service rather than simply the bag without any guarantee about what happens afterwards.
I acknowledge that there are legitimate small operators, including people operating so-called man with a van services, who collect waste and bring it to authorised facilities. They provide a genuine service. However, there are also people who take money to remove waste but, unfortunately, that waste is then being dumped in our communities. When it is dumped, it is not the skip company whose name is on the bag that picks it up. Rather, in the case of my area, it is South Dublin County Council. I seek clarification that something will change in this regard. Surely, a large skip bag containing a significant amount of waste should be able to be traced. Our residents and volunteers are doing their part, and South Dublin County Council is doing considerable work to tackle illegal dumping, a task I do not envy. We need the companies selling these bags to be a part of the solution. Will the Minister of State confirm whether a mandatory system of traceability for every large skip bag sold should be put in place or whether collection and proper disposal should be included as part of the purchase price? Once a company puts one of these bags into circulation, responsibility should not end at the shop counter.
I reached out to a skip company whose branded bag was illegally dumped in my community over one week ago. To date, that skip company did not extend me the courtesy of a response. That shows me where its attitude is. Its silence concerns me. Accountability is needed for where these bags and the waste contained within them end up. The skip companies should be billed instead of the local authority.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Costello for raising this important matter. It is disappointing to hear such illegal dumping activity in her community. I thank her for raising the issue in the House.
Waste management, planning and enforcement are a statutory function of local authorities. Under the Waste Management Act 1996, the Minister for Climate, Energy and the Environment, Deputy O’Brien, is precluded from any powers or control regarding the performance by a local authority in individual cases of its statutory responsibilities under the waste management legislation. The National Waste Collection Permit Office, operated by Offaly County Council, is the designated authority responsible for issuing waste collection permits on behalf of the local authorities. Any company that provides skips or skip bag services must hold a valid waste collection permit and comply with the associated conditions of the permit. These permit conditions include measures designed to support traceability and accountability. Skip bags are required to display either the name of the permit holder or the waste collection permit number alongside the unique identification number, which must be clearly visible.
Permit holders must also provide customers with information outlining the conditions of use, including the type of waste that may be disposed and the arrangements for collection. While a permit framework provides for the identification and tracking of skip bags, the commercial arrangements governing sale or hire of bags, including the collection and retention of consumer information, are matters for individual operators, subject to compliance with all relevant legislative requirements.
Local authorities, in the exercise of their enforcement powers, may seek information from authorised waste collectors where required to assist investigations into suspected breaches of waste legislation. It is important to emphasise that the responsibility for a skip bag, including any waste contained within, remains with the person who hired or used the skip bag until it is collected by the authorised waste collector in accordance with the arrangements.
The abandonment or unauthorised disposal of a skip bag constitutes illegal dumping and is an offence under the Waste Management Act. Where a skip bag is found to be illegally dumped, the relevant local authority has responsibility for investigating the incident and determining the appropriate enforcement response. In doing so, the local authority may utilise a range of evidential sources, including the unique identification markings on the bag, information provided by the authorised waste collectors, CCTV footage, witness evidence and other materials to assist in identifying the person responsible.
There are severe penalties under the Waste Management Act for illegal dumping. A person convicted on summary conviction may be liable to a fine of over €5,000 and imprisonment of up to 12 months. On serial offences, penalties can include fines of over €1.5 million or imprisonment. More broadly, our Department is looking at tackling illegal dumping and it continues to be a key priority. We have issued a number of campaigns, such as the Think Before You Skip It campaign, that have provided practical advice to householders and commercial contractors. Ultimately, while the permit system includes important traceability measures for skip bags, responsibility for investigating illegal dumping incidents and pursuing enforcement actions rests with the local authorities in exercising their statutory functions.
Comment on this
I am not happy with that response because I do not see a solution to the issue of these skip bags in it. If a skip bag is branded with a company’s name and it is left on the side of the road, the skip bag company in question should be tasked to pick it up. If these companies are selling and making money off their branded bags, they should be responsible for the pick-up, rather than, in the case of my area, South Dublin County Council. It is an easy issue to solve. Either we get rid of the skip bags because they are being abused and turn up all over my area, costing my local authority money and causing people in my area frustration, or the skip bag companies step up to the plate, follow through and ensure their skip bags end up in the proper facility.
Comment on this
The individual cases the Senator referenced are significant. There is no denying that there are challenges in respective local authorities around illegal dumping. It is important that local authorities continue to investigate and enforce individual cases that have been identified and highlighted. The Government and my Department have issued substantial funding to local authorities regarding illegal dumping and enforcement measures. Over €23 million has been provided in that regard. Last year, we provided an additional €3 million for illegal dumping. That programme is around targeted enforcement actions, the use of more modern technology, such as drones, CCTV, etc., and community-led initiatives. The investment demonstrates our commitment to try to alleviate a lot of the issues the Senator referenced.
In the first instance, it is the responsibility of the person who hires or rents the skip bag to ensure it is disposed of correctly. It is then the responsibility of the company that collects the waste to ensure it is properly segregated and goes to the correct disposal premise. I cannot outline any more than that. Enforcement and the issuing of permits is the responsibility of the local authorities.