We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›

Pension Provisions

Summary

Senator Duffy urged equal pension treatment for retired pre-1984 An Post workers. The Minister said the law guarantees no less favourable terms than before the transfer, but pension increases remain discretionary; a legal review found the scheme compliant, with a 2% increase pending and cumulative increases of 22.4% since 2021.

I thank the Minister of State, Deputy McConalogue, for attending. I have raised this a number of times in recent weeks and have been engaging with An Post workers who have retired and feel very let down by their treatment and the lack of parity they have received regarding their pension entitlements. This has being going on since An Post became a semi-State body in 1984 when postal workers were promised that they would receive the same benefits and entitlements that anyone else in the Civil Service or the wider public sector would receive. They have served the State in every corner of all of our counties that we all represent and are from. They feel very much aggrieved with the lack of parity regarding their pension entitlements.

Increases, for example, announced this week are very positive in certain cases, but the contributory pension entitlements do not benefit these affected workers. Whether someone is from Brickens, Bohola or Ballina in Mayo, anywhere across the country or Ballybofey, they are worse off if they are a retired An Post worker. They do not have the pension entitlements that they should. Those were guaranteed. It was the State that moved these workers over. They did not move or change anything. It was the State that vested An Post as a semi-State body. They feel very aggrieved and let down. It affects hundreds of retired postal workers who served the State and where there on tough days and stormy days and dealt with rural isolation. The Minister of State knows well the positive impact that postal workers have made down through the years.

This is a simple request for equal treatment and parity. That is why I have raised this Commencement matter on the floor and am asking for the Minister of State's intervention. It would be very beneficial if the Government could meet the representative body to hear its case and address same. There is also a cap on the increase of 2%. There are a lot of limitations of these people and they feel very aggrieved. It is affecting every corner of the country. I ask the Minister of State for his support and intervention to look after these people who are retired and deserve parity in their pensions.

Comment on this
Charlie McConalogue Minister of State at the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport Fianna Fáil

I thank the Senator for raising this matter. I welcome the opportunity to discuss on the floor the An Post superannuation scheme and how it relates to An Post staff who would formerly have been civil servants, particularly those who would have been employed by the former Department of Posts and Telegraphs prior to January 1984 when they would have transferred from that Department to the newly established An Post.

Under section 46 of the Postal and Telecommunications Services Act 1983, the Minister for the Culture, Communications and Sport, with the concurrence of the Minister for public expenditure and reform, approves any superannuation schemes submitted by An Post. The operation of the schemes is a matter between the management of An Post, staff representatives and the trustees of the pension scheme. The Act provides that, for former civil servants who transferred to An Post on vesting day, which was 1 January 1984, An Post’s pension scheme must provide for not less favourable conditions than those to which the members of staff were entitled immediately before the vesting day. The pension entitlements of pre- and post-vesting day members of the An Post superannuation schemes are set out in the scheme rules, which were approved at the time by the relevant Ministers.

Paragraph 13 of the An Post main superannuation scheme rules — pension increases — provides that the company may grant such increases in pensions and preserved pensions under this scheme as may be authorised from time to time by the Minister, with the concurrence of the Minister for public expenditure and reform. Paragraph 13 accurately reflects the pre-1984 discretionary nature of the award of increases to pensions in payment. An Post has indicated that the trustees are not aware of any basis on which the superannuation entitlements of the pensioners are less favourable under the scheme in a manner that would amount to a breach of section 46 of the 1983 Act. The benefits for those members to whom section 46 of the 1983 Act applies did not include automatic increases. They included discretionary increases.

Section 46 sets a minimum level of parity between the An Post scheme and the scheme that applied to staff members of the Department of Posts and Telegraphs as it stood on the day before vesting day. It does not provide that the conditions in the An Post scheme must continue to match any subsequent improvement in pension conditions for the award of pension increases in the civil service. Section 46 does not give rise to an entitlement to pension increases other than those granted in accordance with the An Post superannuation scheme rules.

Prior to vesting day and continuing to the present day, the matter of pension increases for civil servants is a discretionary decision for the Minister for public expenditure under section 29(2) of the Pensions (Increase) Act 1964, which allows the Minister to make regulations providing for such increases. The 1964 Act does not prescribe what form the pension increases should take, how often pension increases should be applied or how they should be calculated.

The rules of the An Post scheme accurately reflect the pre-vesting day discretionary nature of pension increases in the public sector. The pension increase rule has remained unaltered since the commencement of the scheme. Pension increases are considered by An Post annually. An assessment is carried out, taking into consideration the relevant factors in deciding whether to seek ministerial approval for a pension increase, including the sustainability of the scheme's funding relative to its liabilities.

Matters have been raised in the past concerning the operation of the An Post superannuation schemes. Notwithstanding the fact that such operation is a matter for An Post, the then Minister sought legal advice in 2023 for clarity on the matter. The Minister was satisfied, having had the matter reviewed, that there were no issues of concern and the schemes were being operated in compliance with the relevant legislation, which remains the position.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for his reply. It will not be much welcomed by those who are affected by it. There are certain elements that are contradictory from the point of view of the Department. These people were guaranteed conditions that would not be less favourable than they had the day before the vesting of An Post as a semi-State body, but the Minister of State went on to say that it was a discretionary matter and was up to An Post to make a decision. It should be locked in and tied to the benefits enjoyed by any other civil servant.

I acknowledge the reply and thank the Minister of State for being here, but there are more questions than answers. We need to have delivery for these retired workers, who served the State and deserve parity in their pay and entitlements. I ask the Government and An Post to engage. An Post has raised the price of a stamp and continues to do so. It has gone from about 55 cent in 2010 up to €1.85 now.

It has almost €1 billion of turnover and revenue. A small bit of support and acknowledgement for its former workers would go a long way in terms of looking after those who deserve parity.

Comment on this

I know this is a concern for those who were with the Department of Posts and Telegraphs pre-1984. I have engaged with a number of my own constituents on the matter as well.

The response here is laying out clearly what the position is. Long before we were paying attention to any of this, it was that 1983 Act that set out how things would work in law. As we all know, it is the laws and regulations which set out the clarity in relation to matters. That Act provided that for civil servants who transferred to An Post on vesting day, 1 January 1984, the An Post pension scheme must provide not less favourable conditions than those to which the members of staff were entitled immediately before the vesting day. That is what the law stated and what has applied since then. It would, clearly, have been the law when it was introduced in terms of people assessing what it would mean as well. That is the legal position. Legal advice has been sought in recent times too.

The feedback I have from my Department officials is that the increases An Post pensioners would have received would have been very similar to, if not along exactly the same lines as, what civil servants would have received since 2011. If we look at the situation since 2021, there has been a 22.4% cumulative increase for An Post pensioners. That is taking into account the 2% that will be delivered this year, which is currently going through the approval process in my own Department and with the Department of public expenditure and reform. Once this 2% increase is included, the overall increase of 22.4% since 2021 will probably, depending on how the pay talks go this year in respect of any pension increases this year, be similar, if not a little bit more, than what pensioners who would have been civil servants would have received.

Comment on this