We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›

Local Authorities

Summary

Sharon Keogan called for national rules to prevent disclosure of councillors’ identities and security-grant details, arguing they deserve the same protection as Oireachtas members. Emer Higgins agreed parity is needed and said the Department is reviewing guidance; no decision has been made, while FOI requests remain decisions for individual councils.

Malcolm Noonan Acting Chairperson Green Party

Cuirim fáilte ar ais roimh an Aire Stáit, an Teachta Higgins.

Comment on this

The Minister of State is very welcome into the Chamber. I am raising an issue that goes to the very heart of the safety of our democracy and the physical protection of the men and women who serve on the front line of local government. Following a series of deeply concerning credible threats and security incidents directed at local elected representatives, the Government took the welcome step of enacting SI 297 of 2025, which increased the lifetime cap of the councillor security allowance up to €10,000. This fund was designed to act as an essential shield, allowing local representatives to install basic security measures such as gates, CCTV and intruder alarms at their private family residence following a formal threat assessment by an independent Garda crime prevention officer.

However, a dangerous and entirely counterproductive paradox has emerged in how this scheme is being administered across our 31 local authorities. This allowance operates on a vouched reimbursement basis, and, therefore, the current administrative guidelines require these safety payments to be treated as a standard transparent public expense. Just some weeks ago, this structural flaw exploded into the public domain. Figures published openly on the website of Waterford City and County Council, and subsequently picked up via freedom of information, FOI, requests and national media broadsheets, disclosed the exact identities of the specific councillors who availed of this security fund, along with the precise thousands of euro they were paid. This is a profound breach of basic common sense. We are witnessing a scenario where a councillor faces a threat so severe that An Garda Síochána formally mandates the installation of security gates at their home, only for the local authority to immediately publish that councillor’s name and expenditure on a public dashboard. We are handing bad actors a virtual map of which public representatives feel unsafe, where families are under threat and where their security investments are concentrated.

There is also a fundamental issue of equality between elected representatives. Members of the Dáil and this very Chamber have access to a €25,000 personal security allowance. Yet under the Freedom of Information Act 2014 and Oireachtas guidelines, there are rigid, clear protections that ensure our itemised invoices and receipt details are heavily redacted or withheld to protect our personal safety and stop bad actors from mapping out our home security layouts. Why is a TD or a Senator granted absolute statutory confidentiality to protect their family home while a local county councillor is forced to have their safety paraded on a public ledger? Are the lives and homes of local representatives somehow worth less protection?

While transparency in public spending is an important democratic principle, it must never be weaponised to compromise human safety. The Freedom of Information Act 2014 contains clear exemptions under section 32 for law enforcement and public safety. Yet there is currently a total lack of harmonised national guidelines instructing council FOI officers to rigidly protect the identities of those utilising personal safety grants. I am, therefore, calling on the Minister to urgently intervene. Will the Department issue updated mandatory guidelines to all local authorities to ensure that while the macro spending of the scheme is accounted for, the individual names, specific properties and funding breakdowns of threatened local representatives are permanently restricted from public disclosure and freedom of information releases? We must protect the people who run our local democracies before an entirely preventable tragedy occurs.

Comment on this

As Senator Keogan rightly says, our councillors serve on the front line of public service and must be allowed to do their work and carry out their duties without fear. I am very disturbed to hear that some local authorities are publishing the level of information that the Senator went through. I thank her for taking this opportunity to draw attention to this issue. I am taking today’s Commencement matter on behalf of the Minister for public expenditure, Deputy Jack Chambers. He has asked me to clarify how the freedom of information framework is generally applied and the relevance of the guidelines the Senator referred to which were issued by the Department of public expenditure in that realm.

For the information of the House, the Department maintains a website, foi.gov.ie, which contains a range of helpful resources to assist public bodies and people requesting information in navigating what is quite complex legislation. This includes a code of practice published by the Minister for public expenditure and reform in accordance with section 48 of the Freedom of Information Act 2014. Among other things, the code of practice aims to support the implementation of FOI in line with best practice and to provide guidance to decision-makers in that regard.

To be clear, it is not the Department, or, indeed, the Minister for public expenditure, that decides what information is or is not disclosed in any case. The statutory framework has been in place for many years and it is applied on a case-by-case basis by designated FOI officers, within each relevant public body. The code itself states that the FOI officer, as the gatekeeper for the public body’s FOI requests and the conduit to the requester and decision-maker, is the linchpin of a public body’s capacity in relation to the FOI. In any given request under FOI, a public interest test is a relevant consideration when determining whether a record should be released.

The code states:

This requires the decision-maker [the FOI officer] in examining the records deemed relevant to the request, to take the public interest into account, inter alia, the need to achieve openness, transparency and accountability in decision-making, [but also] the right of the people to be aware of and participate in the decision-making process which affects them, and the public interest and safety generally.

When it comes to sensitive information, as the Senator has alluded to today, the decision-maker is advised to review the guidelines available on the exemptions in the Act and apply them as appropriate. A manual on exemptions and consultation procedures is provided. Part 6 of the manual notes that the exemption provided under section 32 of the 2014 Act is a "discretionary exemption" and is concerned with "upholding the interests and safety of the community through the administration and enforcement of law". Specifically, it serves "to prevent the prejudicing of law enforcement measures to uphold the security of certain institutions, and to protect the life and [critically] safety of individuals and the public". Section 32(1)(b) of the 2014 Act offers explicit protection for information which, if disclosed, would be likely to "endanger the life or safety of any person", whether members of the public or those discharging public functions.

It is emphasised that a decision to refuse access to information on these grounds is a sensitive matter and must be approached with caution. An assessment of the expected consequences of releasing particular records, in terms of endangering life or safety, is required to have been undergone. It is not necessary, or even possible, to establish that physical harm will occur, but the FOI body should be able to demonstrate that there is a reasonable expectation that it could, so that lowers the threshold for the FOI deciding officer to reasonable expectation of any impact on somebody's safety. To be clear, in this situation, freedom of information requests are processed by the individual local authorities. They are not processed by the Department of public expenditure and reform or by the Minister for public expenditure and reform.

Comment on this

What the Minister of State has given me is quite a lot of waffle in relation to the FOI process. We all know how the FOI process works, but unfortunately at this moment in time county councillors are not exempt from that process when it comes to this security allowance. It is a grey area. It sits with the Department of public expenditure. It does not sit with the Department of local government. The Association of Irish Local Government, AILG, has raised this issue, as has the Local Authority Members Association, LAMA.

There is absolutely no way it is acceptable that Members of this House have their information redacted while members of local government have their information made available to the public. It is unequal not to put them on a par with us. I do not know how many times over the years - the Minister of State comes from a local authority background as well - that we, as councillors and members of local and national government, have come under threat. It is important that we protect our county councillors around this country, particularly at this time. I would say that every member of a local authority has had a threat on their life at some stage.

It is a specific thing I am asking for. The Minister for justice must issue guidelines, whether it is to the local authorities or the County and City Management Association. He must issue a directive as soon as possible that the information will not be published by the local authorities.

Comment on this

I completely agree with the Senator. I see her passion and her frustration on this, and I understand it. As she said, I served as a local authority member for a decade. I know councillors and I know that over the past number of years the culture has changed. I appreciate that every councillor needs to be able to go about their business without any fear. However, just to be clear, under this scheme, FOI requests for Members of this House and councillors are all processed under the same legislation.

The issue here seems to be that certain local authorities interpret the legislation differently. For example, sections 32(1) and 32(3) of the Act have been used by the Oireachtas to this effect and that is the discrepancy that the Senator is talking about. She gave one example of a local authority that has looked at this legislation differently. If there are more, I am happy to pass them on, not just to the Minister for local government, but also to the Minister for public expenditure to ensure he is aware of this.

I agree that if the guidelines need to be updated, that will and should happen. I understand that the Department of housing is reviewing the regulations and the guidance to determine whether they require updating. No decision has been made on this yet, but I will pass on the Senator's feedback and the feedback of the AILG and LAMA. I know that LAMA has done a lot of work on this, in particular around making sure there is parity in terms of the allocation between councillors and Members of this House. This was the right thing to do, and we need to make sure there is parity in every element of this.

Comment on this