We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›

Crime Prevention

Summary

Senator Comyn urged the Government to enact a standalone spiking offence, arguing existing poisoning laws are inadequate and incidents are underreported. The Minister of State cited current offences, Garda investigations and night-time safety training, and said she would pass the Senator’s concerns about the stalled Bill to the Minister.

I thank the Minister of State for coming to the Chamber to address this serious issue. I first became properly aware of the changing nature of spiking when a colleague in the south of the country spoke to me about what he is hearing on the ground. That prompted me to speak to Mary Crilly and Dola Twomey of the Sexual Violence Centre Cork who have done enormous work in this area. They run a project called safe gigs Ireland. They have the spikinginireland.ie website. What they told me has genuinely shocked me.

Incidents of spiking nationwide are being described as "off the charts" at the moment, and it is not just in nightclubs. It is in festivals and in other social settings, such as a lot of college balls, etc. Most of us think that we know what spiking means. We think of someone secretly slipping a drug into somebody's drink in a nightclub to perhaps incapacitate them before an assault. However, what is happening is far more complex and that is why we need to treat spiking as a separate crime to the way it is already treated.

Spiking can involve drugs being put into a drink, but it can also involve somebody being injected and can even mean deliberately giving someone far more alcohol than they agreed to consume, such as ordering a double or a treble when they believed they were drinking a single. One of the most sinister things that I have been told about in recent times is described as "take them down", as if it is almost a challenge.

Dola has spoken about cases where the apparent objective is not sexual assault or robbery; the act of spiking is itself the objective. Somebody is apparently deliberately incapacitated for the amusement of watching what happens to them, and it is often filmed and shared. We should think about what this means. Somebody is intentionally putting a substance into another person's body without their knowledge and consent specifically to make them lose control. That is an offence against the person's bodily autonomy in its own right, yet Irish criminal law does not contain a specific offence called "spiking". We currently deal with it under legislation on poisoning, but I do not believe poisoning adequately describes the criminal behaviour we are seeing.

We are not starting from scratch. In 2023, a spiking Bill which proposed a specific standalone defence and a maximum sentence of ten years on indictment was brought before this House. It passed every Stage in the Seanad, yet three years on we have not heard anything. It still has not become law. This matters because if we do not specifically define spiking in criminal law, we make it more difficult to understand the scale of the crime. We are not seeing the proper reports or research done into it.

There is no dedicated Garda category for spiking. We cannot easily track those cases through the criminal justice system. We are not seeing the true nature of the incidences. We only saw 52 reports, and I hear that there are hundreds of cases happening. Incidents are not widely reported and do not represent what is actually happening.

There is also the question of evidence. A person may wake up knowing something is terribly wrong but have little idea what actually happened. They may have been given a drug, injected with a substance, or deliberately served much more alcohol than they consented to. They will not know what it is, and some of these substances can leave the body very quickly.

We need a clear and consistent pathway for somebody reporting a suspected spiking, so that evidence can be gathered promptly, tests can be taken and gardaí can have the best possible chance of identifying what happened and pursuing a prosecution.

Of course, prevention and education matter too, particularly for young people in schools, colleges and universities, but there has to be a very clear deterrent. Anyone contemplating doing this should know that spiking is not a prank, a joke or a bit of fun and it should not be dismissed as something. The act itself is very serious.

The programme for Government commits us to stronger laws to combat spiking and much of the legislative groundwork has been done. I ask the Minister of State to examine the legislation, strengthen it where necessary and finally put a specific offence of spiking on our Statute Book. We need to name the crime, define it and record it properly, and give gardaí and our courts the legislation they need to deal with it.

We also need to send an unmistakable message that if someone deliberately puts a substance into another person's body without their knowledge or consent whether through a drink, additional alcohol or a needle for whatever purpose, we should call that crime what it is - spiking - and the full force of the law should follow.

I urge people to go to spikinginireland.ie for more information, myths and the reality of this.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator for raising this really important issue. Spiking is a crime that preys on vulnerability and sometimes it creates the vulnerability to prey on it. That undermines consent and it can have absolutely devastating consequences for victims. I am here today taking this Commencement matter on behalf of the Minister, Deputy Jim O'Callaghan, whom I know is committed to fostering a zero-tolerance approach to all forms of domestic, sexual and gender-based violence.

Spiking a person's drink or spiking someone by injecting them, as Senator Comyn said, is poisoning. A range of criminal offences may be relevant depending on the circumstances. This includes the specific offence of poisoning under section 12 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997. That can result in a three-year prison term. Section 12 applies to anyone who intentionally or recklessly administers a substance which is capable of interfering substantially with another person's bodily functions, explicitly including inducing unconsciousness or sleep. Depending on the nature of the substance that is administered, it may be possible to charge the perpetrator with endangerment under section 13 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997. This provides that it is an offence to intentionally or recklessly engage in conduct which creates a substantial risk of death or serious harm to another. The offence of endangerment carries a maximum penalty of seven years imprisonment.

In some circumstances, as the Senator alluded to, assault offences may happen afterwards and in such cases assault legislation will be relevant, including the offence of causing serious harm under section 4 of the 1997 Act, which applies in cases involving serious injury and is subject to a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. Where spiking is perpetrated in order to facilitate the commission of a further substantive offence, for example sexual assault, rape or theft, the perpetrator may also be charged with that offence or, where that offence was not completed, an attempt to commit that offence.

In the case of drug-facilitated sexual assault, in addition to the poisoning charge, a perpetrator may be charged with sexual assault under section 2 of the Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act 1990, which carries a maximum sentence of five years imprisonment or with aggravated sexual assault under section 4 of that same Act, which carries a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. Where spiking is used to commit a sexual offence, then that offence should be clearly charged and will carry the penalties I have mentioned. If an attempt to commit a further offence can be proven alongside the poisoning, then an attempt charge arises. If such intent cannot be proven, then the poisoning may still be charged.

Research by An Garda Síochána published in 2024 confirms that in practice, incidents involving spiking may give rise to charges for a principal offence in the incident, for example sexual assault or assault causing harm, rather than for the spiking or poisoning element of the incident. The Garda take all reports of spiking seriously and thoroughly investigate them to determine the exact nature of each incident, including the results of toxicology reports in each case. I would advise victims of any form of spiking to come forward and report it. I too commend the work of organisations that work on the ground to raise awareness of this issue and to support victims.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for her comprehensive response. I was afraid I was going to be read chapter and verse of what is already there and I was. It is disappointing to hear that because it is clearly not working. I was not able to find one incidence of a prosecution because of spiking. I am open to correction on that, but I was not able to find one specific prosecution. This is very different. This is not poisoning. It is being treated almost as a joke at this stage. There is no deterrent in place to put people off doing it. There was no mention of the spiking Bill that should be heading for Second Stage in the Dáil, although it passed through this House. I do not know whether I should take it that it has not been mentioned because it has been shelved. If that is the case, then we need to start again. We need to make sure that spiking goes on to the Statute Book because at the moment it is too vague.

The Minister of State mentioned all the other criminal offences that could come after spiking has been proven, but if it is coming under poisoning and poison is not used - alcohol is not seen as a poison - and we cannot determine what drug was used then we cannot say that it was a poison. Young people are being put off going to the Garda because of this. Sometimes the Garda are not given the appropriate legislation to prove something. I hope it will be taken more seriously and spiking will be seen as an individual crime.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator very much. The Minister, who cannot be here today, has provided me with the facts regarding what legislation exists in this regard, and that is what I have provided. He has also advised that there were 61 reported spiking incidents in 2024 and 58 in 2025. Each of these reported incidents was investigated by An Garda Síochána and the data on spiking incidents will continue to be made available through the annual proactive publication from the police service.

I also want to mention another initiative to combat the spiking of drinks. Last year the Department of Culture, Communications and Sport launched a new Safe & Sound safety training initiative, which includes new policy templates for a wide range of businesses in the night-time economy. There is also free online training in nine night-time economy pilot areas. They are Cork city, which the Senator referred to, Dublin city, Limerick city, Galway city, Kilkenny city, Drogheda, Sligo, Buncrana and Longford town. The training delves into the various aspects of vulnerability after dark. It is specifically tailored and developed for those working at night, providing workers with an increased awareness of their responsibilities and duty of care and training in actions that must be taken to reduce identified risks. This online training offers a number of express 30-minute modules which include drink spiking prevention and the response strategies. I will provide the Senator's feedback on the spiking Bill directly to the Minister.

Comment on this