Local Democracy Taskforce Report and Implementation Plan: Statements
The Minister of State outlined a 2026–29 plan to implement the Local Democracy Taskforce’s 23 recommendations through 79 actions, including municipal councils with stronger powers, new council oversight and finance committees, and a formal forum between local and central government. Senators broadly welcomed the reforms as a way to bring decisions closer to communities and rebalance power between councillors and executives, while urging clear timelines and legislation ahead of the 2029 elections. They also called for adequate funding, administrative support and fairer councillor remuneration, and raised concerns about boundary reviews, representation and the privacy of councillors’ security allowances.
I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy John Cummins, for the debate on this report. I also welcome from the Association of Irish Local Government its president, Councillor Aengus O’Rourke, and Mr. Tommy Moylan, its chief executive.
The Minister of State will speak for ten minutes, Senators will have five minutes each and the Minister of State will then reply to the debate at no later than 5.50 p.m.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for the invitation to attend this afternoon to discuss local government. It is a topic I know very well, having served for 11 years on Waterford City Council and then Waterford City and County Council. I am acutely aware of the very strong interest in this House on matters that relate to local government reform. Senators have consistently demonstrated their commitment to strengthening local democracy and supporting local authorities in their vital role. As Minister of State for local government, I greatly appreciate and value the ongoing advocacy and engagement that they continue to espouse.
It was the Seanad Public Consultation Committee’s report on the future of local democracy, published in 2024, that recommended the establishment of a local democracy task force to provide a pathway of working together to ensure that we safeguard the local democratic institutions. I was delighted to carry this forward during the programme for Government negotiations. It is in that context that I am delighted to have the opportunity to address the House today and to provide an update on the progress since publication of the task force report and implementation plan in July this year. The establishment of the local democracy task force was a key priority in the programme for Government, with a commitment to strengthening local democracy and examining the principle of subsidiarity along with opportunities to increase the powers of elected councillors, devolve functions to local government and improve local decision-making. The task force was chaired by Jim Breslin, a former Secretary General, and undertook its work between June 2025 and September this year. Its membership reflected a broad range of expertise and perspectives, including representatives of elected members, local authority executives, the National Oversight and Audit Commission, the Local Government Audit Service and the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage, as well as a number of independent experts. I want to record my thanks to each and every one of those who participated in the local democracy task force. Its work built on the substantial body of research and analysis that had already been undertaken in this areas, including the Seanad report and, importantly, contributions from the Association of Irish Local Government, AILG - I also want to acknowledge Aengus O'Rourke and Tommy Moylan from the AILG - as well as the Council of Europe on the powers, functions and responsibilities of local government.
The considerable preparatory work that had been already completed across the sector provided a strong foundation that enabled the task force to deliver its report in the challenging timeframe that I set for it. Meaningful stakeholder engagement was at the heart of the process. Engagement took place with a wide range of organisations and representative bodies, including employer and employee representatives, community and voluntary organisations, academic experts and other key stakeholders. The task force also invited submissions from political parties and the wider sector, resulting in a very strong level of participation and engagement. This extensive consultation process provided a strong basis for confidence that the recommendations reflected not only the views and experience of the local government sector itself, but also those of the communities, organisations and citizens who depended on local authorities every day.
The local democracy task force implementation plan, published alongside the report, sets out an ambitious and transformative programme of reform for local government over the period 2026 to 2029. The plan identifies 23 high-level recommendations, with 79 actions underpinning them. Work is now well under way to implement the 79 actions contained therein. The recommendations contained in the report are ambitious but are practical and grounded in a deep understanding of how local government operates every day. The report recommends the creation of municipal councils in every local authority, with enhanced decision-making and budgetary powers. These municipal councils will have a specific focus on towns and will develop town priority programmes.
Unlike former town councils, municipal councils will represent all residents across the State, including rural areas, ensuring equality of representation.
Another important recommendation of the task force was a review of the local electoral boundaries in advance of the 2029 elections. I am currently considering draft terms of reference for a future boundary review in advance of the 2029 local elections, which would need to take account of the relevant recommendations arising from the local democracy task force report, such as municipal councils being established in all local authority areas, including cities where area committees are currently in place. I expect progress on these terms of reference in the not-too-distant future.
The reforms recommended also seek to rebalance the relationship between elected councillors and executive management through new council oversight and governance committees, which will replace existing corporate policy groups. These committees will be designed to support the plenary council in holding the executive to account and ensuring that council policies and priorities are delivered. The key functions of the council oversight and governance committees will include governance, strategic policy oversight, performance monitoring and accountability. To further strengthen the budgetary oversight roles of elected members, finance committees will also be established in every council. These committees will oversee the financial performance of the local authority throughout the year to ensure that the decisions of the councillors, as set out in the budget, are delivered in an efficient and effective manner. They will also inform the strategic financial policy of the council.
Additional measures contained in the task force recommendations include a formal engagement mechanism between central and local government through the establishment of a consultative forum, which will enable a strong representative voice for local government to meet with the Government to discuss policy and strategy development. There will also be expanded transparency and communications, through a wide range of measures, to provide better and more timely data and information to councillors and the public, supported by enhanced oversight by the National Oversight and Audit Commission, which I want to ensure provides timely data to allow councillors to scrutinise the performance of their local authorities with others.
It is important that the proposed reforms are implemented in a timely manner. Implementation will involve a period of detailed policy development, which has commenced, followed by significant legislative change and structured delivery arrangements, with the overarching objective of having key legislation in place a year before the June 2029 local elections. The implementation plan will be overseen by a steering group chaired by an assistant secretary in my Department and involving key stakeholders of local government, including elected members, who have been involved throughout the process. It will be driven by a number of implementation groups that will lead the development of that detailed policy in respect of each of the actions.
The programme for Government sets out a clear commitment to strengthening local democracy. The local democracy task force has delivered a comprehensive report and the Government has agreed an ambitious implementation plan to deliver on that commitment. This is an ongoing process and one which, with the support and advocacy of Members of this House, I am sure will be implemented in full. I thank each of the Members here for their constant commitment and advocacy for local government. I was recently at the AILG conference and previously at Local Authority Members Association, LAMA, conferences as well. It is not a prerequisite for the job that I am honoured to hold to have served in local government, but it is certainly useful to have the experience. I look forward to working with Members and with our councillor representative bodies and all the key stakeholders involved with local government as we ensure the roll-out of the implementation plan to implement the recommendations that have been drafted with great expertise by the task force.
Comment on this
The Minister of State is very welcome to the Seanad. I thank him very much for joining us to discuss what is in my view the very important matter of the reform of local democracy and local governance.
Having served on Galway County Council for six years as a councillor, I am acutely aware of the great rewarding role that being a councillor is and how it can sometimes be a very frustrating one. A lot of the frustrations felt by our local authority elected representatives around the country are addressed in this task force report we are discussing. There are frustrations; the balance of power between the elected representative and the executive of the council is something that comes up again and again. This is something that is favourably dealt with within this report.
The report seeks to rectify some of the imbalances that have to date existed in our local authorities and the feeling of lack of power elected representatives feel. They feel that, in many cases, the tail is wagging the dog in the local authorities. The executives are putting forward what they see, in many cases, as being a done deal simply to be signed off on by the elected representatives. That fait accompli that is felt by many local authority representatives has to be rectified and I hope this document will be a step in rectifying that.
Another issue the report touches on is the municipal authorities. Senator Rabbitte and I both served on Galway County Council. The council has for many years successfully hosted the municipal district, MD, meetings. Each municipal district meets on a monthly basis, bringing forward what until now have been only recommendations that have to be further decided on at plenary. However, I welcome any increased powers for MDs. Galway can be seen as a county where this works very well. Both Senator Rabbitte and I sat on the Loughrea municipal district in the south of the county and a lot of the heavy lifting of the work in Galway County Council has for many years been done at MD level and then brought forward. I very much welcome this change as well.
Expanding the reserved functions of the elected representatives is also a real positive step in the right direction and seeks to redress what many elected representatives feel has been that same imbalance power. Many have the feeling that the executive functions simply outweigh the role of the reserved function of the elected representatives in too many cases.
While we are on the subject of local governance, of which I have no doubt the Minister of State is acutely aware, I want to raise the issue of the personal security allowance for local representative and how, in recent times, many people who have been recipients of that for the protection of their own safety have had their private business published in local and national media. That has been a very difficult issue for local elected representatives to deal with. In this case, I call for the same protocols to be put in place around the publishing of details of personal security allowances for local elected representatives that are currently in place for Oireachtas representatives. We are talking about money being spent on the protection of the personal safety of elected representatives. It should not matter if someone is an elected representative in the Oireachtas or on a local authority. The same privacy should be offered in terms of how money is spent to ensure the safety of that elected representative. I really urge that protocols in local authorities be changed nationally to match the protocols around this particular topic we see in place here in the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
I join the Cathaoirleach in welcoming my Déise colleague to the Seanad. It is lovely to see him again.
I join the Minister of State in regard to the huge body of work that has been done on this. Nobody could accuse the Government or any of the Ministers of coming forward with paltry preparation in regard to the preamble to the legislation that is going to come along in the fullness of time between now and 2029. It is very considerable and I hope much of it sees its way through to fruition.
In the few minutes allowed to me, I want to advert a little bit to the subtle differences between the value of local government and its worth. There is a very subtle difference but, when you think about it, it is critical. It is critical for all of those involved in local government anyway. I will move along to that in a moment or two.
If you look back to prehistoric times, we see from anthropological reports regarding tribes and peoples who congregated together that all the way back in the history of humanity some people were deferred to as being leaders or the promoters of the common good. This has come down through all the various civilisations right down to our own time, where we have central government and local government. The accepted wisdom about local government in Europe is that the more it has by way of subsidiarity, the better it will be and the more likely it will be successful. That is probably one of the great strengths of the document we are speaking of today on the work of the task force. In saying that, I join with the Minister of State in praising and validating the huge work that went into this. I was aware of it going on over the past couple of years but this is no half-baked or idiotic document. This is a serious document that deserved serious consideration by us all in this House, the other House and local government in general.
Getting on to the worth of local government, the value of it is not in dispute. It is fundamental to the way we organise our societies. If we have effective local government and effective people in local government, it is for the betterment of the citizen. The value of it is distinct from the worth of it. The worth of it, I think, is often measured in the way that we remunerate the practitioners. To me, it is the single weakness in the document that nowhere in it do I see any solid commitment to examining the remuneration of councillors. I was speaking to a councillor in my local authority last week about the complexity of the work involved. I probably have a better perception of this than most because, when I came in here, a member of my family was co-opted to my seat. I cannot believe how much the work involved has grown in the past two years. That is echoed by all the councillors I speak to. I was down in the west over the summer and a lot of the councillors there said it is multiplying day by day in its complexity.
We need to look at remuneration and how it maybe does not reflect the amount of work that is done, or the ability of the local authority to attract people. I notice that the document refers to a significant, co-ordinated communications campaign to highlight the work of local authorities. I hope that is very successful because it is going to achieve one or other of these objectives. It will either set out local government as being immensely complex and frighten everybody off, or it will portray it as being a wonderful career and it will suck a lot of people in. I hope the latter is going to be the outcome.
A subject and document of this nature cannot be adequately discussed by Senators here in five minutes. It does not do the subject justice. I also compliment Councillor O'Rourke and Mr. Moylan from the AILG for the amazing work they do on behalf of local authority members and for their input into this pre-legislative document.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for coming to the House. It is my pleasure to welcome him. His credentials in terms of local government and commitment to local democracy are right up there with the best. I am delighted he is here to discuss this important document.
As spokesperson for local government and as a former city councillor, I was very proud to be elected to Dublin City Council, the country's largest local authority. I understand first hand the value of our local democracy and the role and value of our local elected representatives in and to their community and wider area. I understand the dedication of those elected councillors. They are on the front line of our democracy and we are living in a world where democracy is under threat.
Councillors are, in many instances, that very first line in the fight for our democracy. They are often the first people citizens will come to if there is a flood, a crisis or if they have a vision and an ambition for their community. It will be their local councillor they will go to and that local councillor will champion them. I appreciate the fact that this Government and the Minister of State are committed to local democracy. The threats are very real and the message from this report is very clear. It is one that none of us in this House, the other House or anywhere should ignore.
I pay tribute to Mr. Jim Breslin and all members of the task force. It is a very serious report with 23 high-level recommendations and 79 implementation actions. Specifically, we are delighted Councillor O'Rourke join us here today. I thank him and Mr. Tommy Moylan for the work they have done at the AILG, as well as Councillors Damien Ryan and Brian Lawlor from LAMA, and everybody else who contributed to the report.
The report must be the beginning. It really cannot be the end of a piece of work. This has to be the start of serious radical reform of our local government. The reality is we have one of the most centralised government systems in all of Europe. We need to trust local communities and councillors and empower and resource our elected representatives to do the job that their communities elect them to do. It is imperative that the Minister of State owns that and takes it forward for them.
The task force report talks about and correctly concludes that councillors need enhanced powers. This report goes a long way to doing that. It talks about making officials more accountable. It talks about councillors not simply being consulted or even advised but being made central to decision-making power and that is exactly where they need to be. I welcome the proposal to establish municipal councils. That is really welcome as long as they have enhanced powers when it comes to budgets and decision-making. I would appreciate if the Minister of State could explain in his reply how municipal councils are going to work for towns that have two local authorities. I am thinking of Drogheda and Athlone.
I also welcome the new council oversight and governance committees. They will strengthen the accountability of executives to the elected representatives. I welcome the greater devolution of powers from central government to local government. The proposal for a national local government forum is really welcome. I would like to better understand how it is going to work.
This is welcome news but it will also mean an awful lot of extra work for our councillors, who we all know are already overwhelmed, to be fair to them. Many of them are inundated because they are that first line of contact between citizens and government. There is a very uncomfortable truth that we must address and that I have to ask the Minister of State to address. Many councillors today are doing beyond full-time work, working weekends and evenings, and they are not even getting part-time pay.
They are not resourced to do it, and we are talking about giving them more powers. We have to resource them. Talk about making them accountable and transparent and the public having more access to what is going on at local government level is welcome but we cannot set councillors up to fail. We have to resource them so they will be able to act in a transparent way and respond promptly. The AILG has commissioned an independent report by Indecon to examine the workload of councillors. Will the report be reviewed by the Department when it is completed and will it be taken to Government? The Government needs to respond if we are going to protect our democracy.
The second issue is the local boundary reviews that have to be completed before 2029. The reality of it is, though, that the Electoral Commission, which is charged to do it, will base the reviews on the 2022 census. We all know the population is growing by almost 100,000 per year. Is the Minister of State comfortable with the fact that there will be a review of local boundaries based on the 2022 census for a 2029 election? I am not sure that does justice to democracy. I am also not sure that will guarantee fair and adequate representation at local government level. I would appreciate if he could respond to that.
I note the call for a single voice for councillors. I can understand where that is coming from. I welcome the local and national government forum. Will LAMA or AILG make the decision? How will it be achieved? Is the Minister of State appointing somebody to work with AILG and LAMA? Is the vision for a merger, or how will that work? There are a lot of questions. I wish him well with his work. He has my support, but this is imperative. This is not just about our councillors today. This is about our democracy for the future, and serving each and every one of our communities adequately.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to speak on this and I also welcome the Minister of State. Sinn Féin has long called for the establishment of town councils. This task force must be the first step in that process. I will echo what others have said. It cannot happen on its own. The report and the implementation plan have to be accompanied by real action to give local authorities and their elected members back their voice and powers in their communities. It cannot just be about the implementation plan, ticking boxes, and committing to legislation to create town councils. Local representatives need to be empowered and the new town councils, as well as county councils, need to be properly resourced. We were really disappointed by the funding recommendations and the implementation processes. All the fancy documents and worthy plans in the world will do nothing if local councils do not have the budget to maintain and transform our communities.
Laois County Council has one of the lowest capital revenue budgets. I think it is the second lowest in the country. Qualifying funding plans with "where possible", is nothing short of a cop-out. This should be an ambitious plan to provide multi-annual funding, not a qualified half measure. Decisions made about local communities should happen within these communities. Local elected members are on the ground listening to their communities every day. Many of them have exciting ideas and can bring real innovation that benefits communities and ultimately, the State. We had sought a broadening of the terms of reference of the task force to allow for discussion on how balance can be better found within local authorities, as well as between elected members and officials. We are disappointed that there does not appear to be any real expansion of the powers local authorities will have. There seems to be no proposal for decentralisation of democracy.
Ireland has some of the least democratic local government structures in Europe. This plan must be a step in fixing that. Action 30 states: "Provide a structure to support the ongoing consideration of further devolution of functions, through the proposed National and Local Government Forum timeline" The timeline for this is quarter 4 2027.
It is giving a year to provide a structure and then this structure will start to support discussion to consider further devolution of functions. It does not sound very productive or promising. I note action 33 regarding rural transport, but we have to see if this review is actually going to happen in the first quarter of 2027, as promised. It is really important that all of the timelines set out in the implementation plan are not consistently missed and that there is a clear road map for proper implementation. There are key issues, like waste, that could be within the remit of local authorities right now. Municipal councils cannot just be talking shops. They must be places of real action and delivery for communities. Our elected representatives want that. Sinn Féin engaged with the local democracy task force because we want to see local democracy working for our communities. It has been destroyed in previous budgets by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael. This task force and implementation plan must be the first step to righting that wrong and giving local authorities back the budget and the power to make decisions for our communities. It cannot be a task force that is more ticking boxes. We need a proper road map for when we will see the implementation of this.
Comment on this
I welcome the Chair of the enterprise committee, Deputy James O'Connor, and his guests, Mr. Michael Lonergan and Mr. Gerard McCoy, from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade.
Comment on this
I express my condolences to the Minister of State and to all concerned regarding the tragedy in his community in Waterford.
Having engaged in the process in the last number of months, it would be an understatement to say we are disappointed. We are in the depths of multiple crises, from climate to biodiversity, housing, energy and the cost of living. At this time, we need radical reshaping of the local government system. Other Members have spoken about Ireland having the most centralised form of local government in Europe. It is simply not good enough, and it does not serve Dublin well as a European capital city, that it does not have a directly elected mayor and instead the chain is passed on year to year on a ceremonial and rotating basis. This has to be central to the reform being brought forward.
The points have been made about the boundaries. The boundary review should be triggered and informed by the 2027 census. That should be the mechanism used because the figures would be right up to date. I think back to the local government reforms of the Minister of State's predecessor, Phil Hogan, a former constituency colleague of mine. In 2014, Kilkenny city was split in two, which was disastrous from a governance perspective. Is that going to happen again?
Another issue which has to be addressed is the number of councillors per head of population. While the size of the Dáil increases after every census review and boundary review, the number of councillors in the local government system has decreased. They are representing more and more people in their communities, which, as others have said, means much more work for them. I proudly served as a member of Kilkenny County Council for 16 years, and I still witness the fantastic work that goes on in our local government system. We stand in solidarity with them tomorrow and all the other public sector workers and commend them on the continuing innovation they show despite significant funding challenges. It is not a broken system; it is a good system. The reforms being brought forward through this national and local government task force have to be much more meaningful.
A number of other points are important. The PPN structures have worked well. We need to develop a much more participatory model of public engagement in the planning system. We need to move away from the box-ticking exercises of Part 8 proposals. There needs to be greater public engagement at the early stages of the planning system. Many local authorities are moving in the right direction in that regard.
Local government works well when it shares its knowledge and best practice with its European partners. While there are EU units in some of the larger local authorities, it is also important that there is a universal approach to engagement on EU projects. Regarding smaller local authorities, Carlow has been a fantastic example. Off its own bat, it set up an EU unit and has now engaged in many projects such as URBACT, Erasmus and twinning projects. The ability for local authorities to engage on a European level through knowledge sharing but also through projects that deliver an economic return is hugely important as well.
The other point about the mandate around the increased function for local authorities and transport has to be a critically important one. Removing powers from TFI and giving local authorities a direct responsibility in shaping and designing routes and putting in public transport provision services is really important, particularly from a rural perspective. I say that from designing and delivering rural public transport services. I know the Minister of State is committed to reform but it is critically important. I come from a city that was one of the five boroughs that had a directly elected tier of urban governance since the early 13th century, which was whittled away in one stroke of the pen by a predecessor of the Minister of State. We should look at that urban agenda along with putting a direct elected tier of urban governance back into our local government system. I wish the Minister of State well in his endeavours. He has the support of this House in his work. We need something that is significantly more radical than what is on the table at the moment.
Comment on this
I too send my condolences to the Minister of State's community on this very sad and tragic day. I welcome Tommy Moylan and the president of the AILG, Councillor Aengus O'Rourke, and thank them for all the work they have done on this along with a lot of people in the LAMA. I welcome these statements and the opportunity to speak on the importance of this report. I think every single one of us here in this Chamber knows that the doors of councillors are the first that people knock on. When a road floods, when a family is waiting on a housing list or when a town centre is really struggling, it is the local councillor who picks up the phone, often late at night or at weekends. I am sure a lot of Members would have experienced all of that. Councillors make a real difference in their communities every single day. If we are serious about protecting our democracy, we have to cherish, protect and strengthen local democracy and councillors are at the heart of all of that.
I have been a very proud member of the Seanad Public Consultation Committee with the Cathaoirleach and with others such as Senator Boyhan. In 2024, we held hearings on the future of local democracy during which we heard powerful testimonies from all over Ireland. We heard from local government representative bodies North and South, former Ministers, party leaders, experts and, most importantly, we heard from councillors themselves - the familiar faces in every parish and town. I am very glad that the task force has acknowledged our committee's 2024 report as an invaluable source for its work. That really shows what this House can do when it listens.
What councillors told us back then was very clear. The role has grown hugely in complexity, workload and public expectation but the supports have not kept pace. The task force agrees. The report says plainly that the councillor's role has become increasingly difficult and that supports are needed. The numbers tell the story. Councillor numbers have not changed since 2014 but our population has grown. Each councillor now represents more people than ever before. Only about one quarter of our councillors are women. If we want our councils to reflect the communities they serve, we have to make the role possible for working parents, carers, people with disabilities and people from every background. That is why I introduced a local government support for elected members Bill in 2024. That Bill would give councillors proper administrative support to do their jobs. The task force now makes the same call, which is great, recommending consistent administrative, secretarial and meeting supports for every councillor in the country. These supports are long overdue. My Bill is ready and I ask the Government and every member of the Oireachtas to support it. Let us not just start from scratch when the work has already been done.
There is much in this report to welcome: municipal councils with real budgetary and decision-making powers; new oversight committees so councillors can hold the executive to account; statutory timeframes for responses to councillors' representations; access to information from Departments and State agencies, which Members of the Oireachtas Members already take for granted; and a library and research service for councillors. Above all, the report is built on subsidiarity. Decisions should be made as close as possible to the people they affect. For too long, power has drifted away from council chambers towards Departments, agencies and executives, and we must reverse that drift. Local decisions on planning, towns and local services belong with local representatives, who are accountable to local people. A report is a commitment and a promise. Implementation is what keeps it on the table.
The task force itself warned that a broad range of legislative and administrative changes will be needed if these reforms are to take effect before the 2029 local elections. This is not far away. It is very close actually and legislation has to be drafted, debated and passed. A total of 31 local authorities have to change how they work, and people considering whether to put their names forward in 2029 deserve to know what role they will be stepping into. I have some questions for the Minister of State today and I want to put them to him directly on behalf of councillors across this country. When will the first measures start on the ground? When will the legislation be published? Which recommendations come first and by what date? Will the Minister of State publish a timeline with clear dates and report progress to both Houses regularly so we can hold this process to account? Councillors have waited a long time for this moment. They have worked very hard, given their evidence, made their case and kept serving their communities in the meantime. They do not need more consultation. They need a start date so I ask the Minister of State to give them a date today and let us make this happen.
Comment on this
Before I call the next speaker, I welcome guests of Deputies Barry Heneghan and Michael Healy-Rae to the Gallery. They are most welcome to Seanad Éireann.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to contribute to this important debate. I also welcome Councillor O'Rourke and Tommy Moylan from the AILG. I acknowledge the work undertaken through the Seanad Public Consultation Committee in 2024 and the local democracy task force chaired by Jim Breslin, whose report and implementation proposals were brought forward in 2026. Ireland has a long and proud tradition of democracy and it is something we should value, protect and never take for granted.
At the very heart of that tradition in local democracy is the relationship between people, their communities and those elected to represent them. While local democracy is not a panacea for division or authoritarianism, it does something enormously important. It brings people together to address the everyday issues that they have in common such as the quality of the place where they live and the services and the infrastructure needed to make it better. Housing, roads, flooding, local amenities and the future of our towns and villages are the issues that unite communities and bring people into the democratic process. Respect for local democracy and participation in its activities is a vital guard rail against a disengaged electorate, so we need to transfer more powers to the council. For me, that must at the centre of this reform agenda.
I pay particular tribute to our wonderful councillors throughout the country and across all political parties and none. They are the people who answer the phone, attend community meetings, listen to concerns and advocate tirelessly for their communities. They know their areas, they understand the challenges and they are often the first people contacted when something goes wrong, yet too often they are expected to find solutions without having sufficient authority or resources to deliver them. If we value local democracy, we must value and empower the people elected to represent it.
The reforms provide an opportunity to build on the foundations of the Local Government Reform Act 2014 to ensure local government continues to evolve to meet the needs of modern Ireland. When I was listening to Senator P. J. Murphy speak, I thought that every constituency and every local authority had the municipal councils like we had in Galway. I realised that is not actually the case.
When I was elected in 2014, I was the first to walk into a municipal local authority. We actually make decisions at a local level and we feed them on to a municipal or a full plenary meeting. I took that as the norm as to how things were done, but it may not be the case everywhere.
I welcome the task force's emphasis on strengthening the role of councillors, bringing decision-making closer to communities, improving engagement between central and local government and ensuring greater financial autonomy and accountability. The principle of subsidiarity is particularly important. Decisions should be made as close as possible to the people affected by them, where they can be made effectively and where there are appropriate resources. Empowering communities must mean more than consultation. It must also mean giving local representatives a genuine influence over decisions and priorities and the resources needed to deliver.
Nowhere do we see the importance of effective local government more clearly than in a time of crisis. A time of crisis last year for us in Galway was Storm Éowyn. We saw the valuable work of the local councillors along with the first responders and the crews from the local authorities out on the ground. That was where decisions had to be made locally. Even though telephone lines were down and the internet was not working, they did it seamlessly. They did not have to look for permission or get some sign-off but they were able to do it. That is when the local people see the value and trust in local democracy.
Implementation has to be key to today's conversation. The 2024 Seanad report and the 2026 task force report have given us a substantial body of work on strengthening local democracy. The implementation plan provides a framework for progressing reforms. What matters now is ensuring that these commitments translate into real, measurable improvements on the ground. We need clear timelines, defined responsibilities, appropriate funding and accountability for delivery. We need to ensure that councillors, themselves, are central to the implementation process because they understand better than anyone the practical challenges facing the communities they represent. We must ensure that the public can see and understand what these reforms will mean for them. We also need to strengthen our communities. When we strengthen our communities, we strengthen our democracy.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister of State and acknowledge how proactive he is in all spheres of his Ministry. In this particular instance, I am very happy that he ran with and gave effect to the recommendation of the special Seanad committee, of which, as the Cathaoirleach knows, I was proud to be a very active member. I also welcome his commitment to implement the recommendations, which is really the ultimate objective.
I will just address a few matters in the time available to me. Regarding the review of boundaries and the terms of reference, anecdotally councillor colleagues have told me that the geographical areas have been very difficult in that they are spread out and large, making it very difficult to serve them. The Minister of State should consider that when he addresses the terms of reference. The disparate nature of rural communities can be an issue there.
While I will not be present for the Minister of State's reply because I have something else on, I will read it from the blacks. I ask him to address the differences between the municipal council areas and the new municipal bodies. In other words, what specific differences will there be between the two? The municipal districts were working well, but I understand the change and the need to focus on towns, etc. I would be interested to hear an elaboration on that matter.
In relation to the budgetary oversight, the finance committees are good. This goes back to the American Revolution. The link between taxation and councillors' powers is critical. If local authorities do not have the power to collect taxes, the responsibility to collect as many taxes as possible should, as in the American model, be taken out of central taxation and sent down for local administration.
That is a requirement. The power to collect taxes and the responsibility to answer for tax collection need to be part of the extension of powers. I know that is a big issue. In that context - we have informally discussed this - I welcome Mr. Moylan and Mr. O'Rourke from the representative bodies because I know that is an important issue for them.
I endorse and support what my colleague Senator Murphy said about privacy for members in relation to their security. That is a sensitive issue and in fact it is almost counterintuitive to publish what somebody spent on security and how. Surely that is an invitation to crime in itself or a challenge therein.
Councillors work unreal hours. In many instances, it makes it impossible to hold down proper jobs, and they lose professional opportunity. We need to keep constant focus on the question of remuneration and pensions. I would like the Minister of State to address that in his response. To use the well-hackneyed phrase, there is more to do in this sphere. I know of many people who lose businesses, lose farms and damage their whole situation by virtue of being councillors. They can damage promotional opportunities and create a strain within their jobs. All of that is important.
This is an exciting development. Like the Minister of State and many colleagues here I spent many happy years in local government. I loved it and what we did was always very relevant to people. While councillors are doing more of it than they used to with the decision-making on the local property tax, until they collect taxes, take responsibility for collecting them and spending that money, and answer to the electorate for that, they do not have real power. Therein lies the core issue.
Comment on this
The Minister of State is very welcome to talk about the task force. I welcome the opportunity to speak on this vital debate regarding the future of local democracy across this Republic. First and foremost, I acknowledge and thank the AILG and LAMA for their extraordinary and tireless work. They have been the absolute backbone of the local government sector. They have stepped up to represent the voice, the lived experience and the democratic mandate of our hard-working councillors on the local democracy task force. Without their leadership and technical expertise, the profound evidence-based recommendation that we see in this report simply would not exist.
As a matter of principle, I enthusiastically welcome the landmark recommendation to establish municipal councils across all 31 local authorities nationwide. Since the sweeping reforms of 2014, there has been a painful structure wound felt in the towns and villages of Ireland. The abolition of town councils ripped away an historic layer of civic identity. It created a perceived vacuum where communities felt distant from the choices that dictated their daily lives. When it comes to local services, decisions are always better made when they are made by the direct representatives of the communities that actually use them. This is the raw definition of the principle of subsidiarity. It is absolutely essential that our smaller local areas are legally empowered to govern much more directly.
Under these proposals, municipal councils will be handed critical new statutory powers to drive local life. We are talking about enhanced decision-making and budgetary controls, the power to construct stand-alone municipal council budgets, the implementation of mid-year financial adjustments and the executive power to enact town priority programmes to directly revitalise our urban centres and rural hinterlands. These are serious levers of public governance.
However, we must be brutally honest about the reality of what we are proposing to load onto our local representatives. With more power comes a massive, unprecedented wave of governance, meetings and more administrative work. Let us consider what this report demands. Councillors are expected to participate in the new municipal council budget cycles, sit on newly established council oversight and governance committees to hold executives to account, run restructured strategic policy committees and manage brand new stand-alone finance committees.
They are being asked to oversee central funding applications, vet State agency intersections and manage complex performance data dashboards. To put the question plainly to this House, is it possible for the role of local councillors to continue being part time? The days of the local councillor treating public service as a part-time evening obligation are structurally over under this programme. The sheer volume of statutory oversight required by these 23 high-level recommendations transforms the role into a punishing full-time position. A total of €85 a day before any taxes is what a councillor will get because it is a seven-day role. Therefore, any meaningful devolution of powers must carry with it a matching devolution of resources directly to the councillor themselves. I have a deep underlying fear that the current proposals land an avalanche of tasks into the laps of councillors, without providing the institutional resource they ultimately need, which in all likelihood is a full-time salary. If the Government wants to devolve these serious powers, it has to resource them properly. If it is not prepared to provide for a full-time fully salaried council structure, it should not throw these massive, complex, corporate tasks at underfunded and overstretched local representatives.
I wish to address the organisational structure of representation. The report notes the logical step of merging the AILG and LAMA to establish a single national representative voice to act as a unified consultee for central government. On paper, streamlining this relationship makes complete sense, but the implementation plan leaves a massive cloud of operational uncertainty. How exactly would this merger be handled? Who will sit at the table to negotiate and make the ultimate decisions on behalf of the councillors? Crucially, who will be chosen to head up the new unified body, and what democratic mechanisms will be used to choose them? We cannot allow a logical merger to become a top-down bureaucratic centralisation that dilutes the independent spirit of either organisation. We need absolute clarity from the Ministers on these transitional governance questions.
While I am here, I echo Senator Murphy's concern regarding the privacy of councillors when it comes to their security allowance. When I raised this issue on the floor of the House as a Commencement matter last Thursday, the Minister of State responded with administrative waffle and bureaucratic buck-passing. She hid behind individual local interpretations. She fully admitted that the Oireachtas uses section 32 exemptions to protect our own homes, while councillors' safety is paraded on a public ledger. This is a very important matter. If the Government wants to devolve real power to our local democracy, it must stop its passive reviews. We must stand up for the people on the front line and immediately issue an explicit mandatory directive protecting these names before an entirely preventable tragedy occurs. If we are building a framework for stronger local democracy, the very body representing our democracy must be transparent, fully resourced and robustly structured.
Comment on this
Before I call the next speaker, I welcome the guests of Senator McCarthy in the Gallery. They are very welcome. I hope they enjoy their visit to Leinster House.
Comment on this
I add my voice of welcome to Senator McCarthy's guests. It is a privilege to be in this House to participate in this debate and to address the Minister of State on the work of the task force and the 79 recommendations that have been made. It is very significant. For far too long, we have spoken in this House and in the other House about the need to strengthen local democracy, particularly through our locally elected councillors. We have acknowledged the imbalance between executive authority and the role of elected members. Therefore, it is time to take action. We have also spoken about and recognised the frustration of communities who feel very distant from decision making. We all have a role to play in that. We have seen year after year independent reviews from the Council of Europe, from the AILG and from our own Oireachtas committees all pointing to the same conclusion, which is that local government and, particularly, the democratically elected councillors in Ireland, must be empowered if they are going to serve our people effectively. Finally, we have the task force recommendations and they give a structured evidence-based pathway to achieve that.
I acknowledge everybody who contributed and all the officials who worked on it. The AILG had a very big role, as did LAMA. At the heart of the task force's work is a very simple but powerful principle: local democracy must be strengthened by enhancing the role of elected councillors in directing priorities. This is not just an administrative reform; it is a democratic correction that is needed. Councillors are the closest representatives to the public. They are the ones who hear directly from families, businesses, community groups and volunteers. For years, their ability to influence and shape policy and budgets and to oversee implementation has been constrained. It is really good to see the task force recognising this and proposing reforms that give councillors clearer authority, stronger oversight tools and a more meaningful role in setting the direction of their local authority.
The task force rightly places subsidiarity at the centre of its vision that decisions should be made as close as possible to the communities they affect. When councillors have real authority at district level, communities benefit from faster responses, better alignment with local priorities and more accountable governance. I hope we will see that through the strengthening of municipal districts, the establishment of municipal councils and the clarification of the functions of area committees. They all need to serve one purpose, which is ensuring local decisions are made locally.
Regarding financial autonomy and transparency, the task force confronts the critical issue that local government cannot be effective without financial autonomy. That is hugely important. I had a Commencement matter here last week in relation to my own council in County Kildare, which is getting an LPT allocation that is far below the national average. I totally appreciate that the Minister of State could not be here to take it, but I have sent in follow-up correspondence. At the moment, we are getting just €715 per person living in County Kildare, whereas the average is over €1,000. I look forward to talking to the Minister of State about that again. Greater budgetary influence for councillors is not about expanding spending; it is about ensuring public money is used in ways that reflect local priorities and community needs.
Strengthening community engagement is hugely important and councillors are absolutely central to that. The establishment of a national and local government forum is one of the most important innovations of the work of the task force, and I look forward to seeing that. There is a long-term reform agenda. The recommendations are not cosmetic; they are hugely important. They have given us a roadmap to a stronger, more democratic and more responsive system of local government. It is our responsibility as legislators and as public representatives to ensure these recommendations are implemented with ambition and urgency. We will work with the president of the AILG, Councillor Aengus O'Rourke, who was here. We will work with Tommy Moylan, who is the director of the AILG, with LAMA and with the Department.
The remuneration for councillors needs to be looked at. Very significantly, PRSI needs to be looked at because councillors are paying it and they do not get any benefit. The pension needs to be looked at. For some people, getting a pension at the end of their career in local government is important but some people who have another full-time job may want the continuation of a payment. The flexibility needs to be there both in terms of that payment and in terms of pensions.
My final point is on security. Is it really good that councillors have an allowance. I was really disturbed-----
Comment on this
-----when I saw some media reporting on who took the allowance and who did not, and on a councillor virtue signalling that they did not take it while others did. We need to support one another in terms of security and all the excellent work that needs to be done.
Comment on this
Chomh maith leis na Seanadóirí eile, cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit, an Teachta Cummins. Gabhaim buíochas leis as teacht chun labhairt linn agus éisteacht linn mar gheall ar an tascfhórsa um dhaonlathas áitiúil.
Chomh maith leis na Seanadóirí eile, déanaim comhbhrón leis an Aire Stáit agus le muintir Phort Láirge as ucht an tragóid a tharla. Guímid gach rath ar an mbeirt páiste a mhaireann.
Cuirim fáilte chomh maith roimh stiúrthóir feidhmiúcháin an AILG, Tommy Moylan, agus uachtarán an AILG, an Comhairleoir Aengus O’Rourke. Gabhaim buíochas leo as teacht isteach. Bíonn an t-uachtarán ag obair go crua le mo chara féin, atá ina iar-uachtarán anois, an Comhairleoir Mary Hanna Hourigan. Bíonn sí ag rá liom go mbíonn siad ag obair go maith le chéile agus is maith an rud é sin a chloisteáil.
I welcome the local democracy task force report which I believe will, if fully implemented, succeed in making local government more responsive, engaged, democratic and transparent, and will deliver better for our local communities. I welcome the central involvement of the councillors, who made up five out of the 14 representatives of the task force. It is very important to have councillor input. From what I can gather, they very much feel that their voices were heard. As has been said by other contributors to this evening's debate, the task now is to ensure the recommendations made and key objectives highlighted are implemented to make sure we can strengthen local government. I also compliment the task force chair, Jim Breslin, on his excellent stewardship of the task force and in the delivery of the report.
The task force itself obviously came about as a result of a number of reports which highlighted deficiencies in our local democracy, something which was rightly taken on board by Government and included as a commitment in the programme for Government. Those reports included the Council for Local and Regional Authorities of Europe, which forms part of the Council of Europe, which was quite damning in what it had to say about local democracy in Ireland, the AILG's collaboration with Maynooth University in its report on the 21st century councillor, the AILG policy document, Building Stronger Local Government, and, prior to my election to the Seanad, the public consultation report on the future of local democracy, and I compliment the Senators from the previous Seanad on their excellent work on that.
For too long, our 31 city and county councils have been virtually relegated to the roles of local administrators of decisions made at a national level, and I see this report as a very important step in redressing that imbalance that has come about in government throughout the country. I welcome the provision under action point 22 of the report, which provides for greater consultation with councillors and meaningful councillor input into delivering services and devising and implementing policy at a local level.
One item which did not fall under the remit of the report but which is an ongoing concern for me is the lack of democracy that exists at a regional level. We have three excellent regional assemblies, and while I am not arriving to today's debate with solutions, but the manner in which representatives are appointed to regional assemblies lacks the democracy that would give our regional assemblies greater clout. That is something that might be looked upon at some point in the future. We often speak of the importance of balanced regional development, and for those words to carry greater weight and more meaning, more commitment from us to try to set about doing at regional government level what this task force report sets out to do at local government level would be an important step in the not too distant future.
As other contributors have mentioned, the two final points I make are listening to people - there is a lot of goodwill and many people put a lot of time and effort into the drawing up of the report - and if the Minister of State would give us some indication in his concluding remarks of the timeline for the delivery and implementation. There is no reference, and it is beyond the remit of the report to talk about the funding that will be involved in making sure this is a success, so perhaps the Minister of State would make a brief reference to that in his concluding remarks.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for coming in and extend my condolences to him regarding his constituents who were killed in the arson attack.
I acknowledge the work that councillors do. It is an incredibly difficult job and it does not get a lot of sunshine when people talk about local councils. They do an incredible job. It is 24-7. I do not think any councillor can say they are off on any one particular day because there is always going to be a call they have to deal with or something to respond to. There is no acknowledgement among the public of the difficult job. Obviously, we in this House know the difficulty of the job and the challenges and it is an important job. Councillors make up a really important pillar of the community and that has to be recognised. The proposals that have come from the task force are really important. It is one thing to put together a task force and issue a report, but we need to ensure those proposals are delivered on for local communities and councillors who are the front line in our local democracy.
It is a well-established fact that Ireland has one of the most centralised government systems in Europe and some of the weakest local authorities. The powers of local authorities have been whittled away by State bodies and corporations to a point where they simply cannot deliver fully for communities. One notable example of that is bin collection. Dublin City Council privatised its bin collection services in 2012, and that has resulted in increasing prices and a worsening service. People know the challenges it has created for communities and, without getting into the details, the system, with 13 different companies operating in parallel, is wildly inefficient. These companies are not capable of providing the quality of services that Dubliners need. The competition between them is not resulting in lower prices as was predicted. To my knowledge, there is no other European city that handles waste collection like we do in Dublin, and all this system has resulted in is our streets being clogged with unnecessary bin trucks operating inefficient routes for high profits. Waste collection powers should be restored to Dublin City Council in order that it can implement a comprehensive and effective waste management collection system in line with other similarly sized cities across Europe. Dublin City Council still has to pick up the rubbish after the private companies have gone, and it gets no thanks for doing that job. Councillors get no thanks for doing their job. The reality is that without increased powers and funding, Dublin City Council will continue to fail to provide the necessary level of services we need in the city.
Another example of that, with the lack of funding and resources, is housing maintenance and allocations in Dublin City Council. There are simply not enough resources on the ground. When we look at the condition of flat complexes around Dublin and the country, but I know Dublin best, the conditions and maintenance levels are just deplorable. The funding is not there. Residents in inner-city communities have been forgotten about. The regeneration of flat complexes is being organised at a snail's pace, and it is not acceptable that families could be left. I heard a question to the Minister for Finance over the budget period last week. He was asked about deep retrofitting and retrofitting grants. No one in Dublin City Council flat complexes can avail of retrofitting.
Dublin City Council has to agree to put it in. They cannot put in new doors and new windows. They cannot avail of any of the grants for them in the flat complexes. Private owners who have plenty of money can go ahead and the grant is there for them, but there is no grant for those living in a flat complex. For them, there is no insulation from the cold. That is just another example of the neglect of Dublin City Council tenants by local government and the Government. Local government gets the blame, but it is the Government that is ultimately responsible.
Comment on this
As a vote has been called in the Dáil, we need to suspend to allow the Minister of State to attend it.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister of State to the Chamber, and like many of my colleagues in the Seanad, I pass on my condolences to his constituents on the very difficult and tragic 24 hours that have taken place in Waterford.
I welcome the opportunity to make a contribution on this debate, particularly given my five and a half years on Wexford County Council. I have particularly fond memories of serving on a local authority. It is important that we reflect on the current situation at local authority level. Some of feedback I will give is based on my experience and that of many colleagues up, down and across the country, together with our friends in the AILG. I acknowledge Mr. Tommy Moylan and Councillor Aengus O'Rourke, who are here with us.
There is a feeling that too many powers that the public believe lie with councillors actually lie with the executive. Sometimes, one of the most frustrating things for a councillor is to be blamed for a decision where they had no input or responsibility. As a reforming Minister of State with the portfolio of local government, he has a unique opportunity to rebalance those powers. I am particularly thinking of some of the applications for large-scale regeneration funds. I am also thinking of cycleways and active travel measures where individual councillors might prefer that the funding be allocated to a particular project over another but their representations go unheard and, ultimately, the project that the councillors are not in favour of is the one that is submitted to the Department for funding.
If we are to place value on the local councillor's voice as a representative of the people on the ground, then those voices have to be capable of being heard right through our system up to the highest level. At the moment, there is quite a lot of work that could be done to strengthen the individual powers and responsibilities of councillors, particularly in the two keys areas of large regeneration funding applications to the rural and urban regeneration schemes and their successors, and the large active travel measures.
I want to speak for a few moments about the inability of an individual councillor to receive specific advice. If I have a query on a policy or I want to get a proposal costed or some research done about how a particular policy gets done in the EU, America, the UK or somewhere else, then there is the Library and Research Service here. I welcome the fact that the task force report says that there will be a designated availability, through the AILG and some of its work, to strengthen the research available to councillors. This is important.
My concern is not that it will not be good advice, but given that there are currently 949 councillors and the boundary review could see that number increase, the actual ability of a councillor to access that advice in a timely fashion will not be possible unless quite significant resources are put in there. I encourage the Minister of State to adequately staff it. It is no use saying that there will be a service available if it is taking weeks or perhaps months to receive that advice.
A second concern I have is around the question of independent legal advice. I am aware that a councillor can seek independent legal advice on any aspect of a policy decision that is put before them by the executive, but there has to be a better way of doing it than the current mechanism where they have to go to the county CEO, who then requests that the advice be provided. I suggest that the legal advice be provided through the AILG in the new format of the library and decision service there. Councillors are not seeking advice every week, but as people who are elected to represent their areas, it should be made available when an issue comes up that is consequential enough for a councillor or a group of councillors to feel that they need assistance and advice. I encourage the Minister of State to put those resources in place.
I want to speak about the point raised by my colleague, Senator P.J. Murphy, which I agree with, regarding the security allowance. It is important that all politicians have the same level of protection when it comes to the security allowance. There is some merit in taking up Senator Murphy's suggestion.
In relation to the new municipal councils, I am concerned that if they are not anchored around a town, particularly in a rural area like my county of Wexford, it has to have the hinterland of the town in the same area so that those people who grew up in a town but moved slightly out to its suburbs are all captured in the one area and the unique identity of a location is reflected in the council that represents it.
Comment on this
I welcome to the Gallery Mr. Usman Ajmal and a delegation from the mosque in Dublin 1, who are guests of our colleague Senator Fitzpatrick. They are very welcome to Leinster House and I hope they enjoy their visit.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to discuss the report of the local democracy task force. I am happy with some of the recommendations in the report but what I am interested to know is if and when they will be implemented. To understand local democracy, we must look to our councillors, who are the ones working locally. They are being asked to do more with less and to take the blame when things go wrong. Councillors in my area are contacted constantly by constituents, particularly regarding funding for the basic services of roads and housing. The councillors raise those issues on a regular basis with the council executive and with Ministers but they cannot get straight answers as to when anything will be done.
I am very interested to see how a formal mechanism to discuss these issues with the Government will actually work. I have been before Monaghan County Council twice and Cavan County Council once in the past six months. That is born out of frustration on the part of councillors who really believe they have not been listened to, particularly regarding roads and housing funding. Will the formal mechanism for discussion work for councillors or will it just be a mechanism by which the Government can say "No"? I reiterate how frustrated councillors feel at not being listened to on particular issues of concern in their areas. There is a tendency for the Government to take a one-size-fits-all approach to all counties, which is not realistic, given their different topographies and demographics.
This year, councillors in Cavan were pressured into increasing the local property tax just to obtain a tiny amount of extra money for the roads programme, which really did not go too far for that purpose. As Senator Cathal Byrne said, people believe a lot of decisions are made by councillors that are, in fact, made by the council executive. We need more clarity as to how those decisions are made.
The report recommends greater certainty by way of multi-annual funding, where appropriate. Roads projects certainly are in need of multi-annual funding to enable planning for the years to come. Councillors have told me that there is very little flexibility within roads funding to react to emergencies such as storm damage. We need more flexibility in that regard.
Feedback I have received from councillors points to a huge reliance by executives on reports, consultants and reviews. It seems that the executives are risk averse. They find it very hard to make a decisions without hundreds of thousands of euro being spent on reports and reviews. They have whole road design teams but they outsource a lot of the work to consultants and companies that seem to be cleaning up on those contracts.
The report's proposal for statutory response timeframes for councillors is welcome. I have raised that issue previously and I am really interested in hearing how the proposal will be implemented. It is a huge frustration for councillors that they do not feel that they are being listened to. Like everybody else here, I would like to know the timeline for legislation.
Pension provision for retired councillors is a huge issue, particularly in my area. I know of a couple of people who retired two years ago but still have not received their pensions.
Another issue relates to the security allowance. The media reporting of it recently as a kind of "gotcha" is totally uncalled for and unfair. Councillors' role is hard enough and they need to be protected.
Comment on this
Before calling the final speaker, I welcome to the Public Gallery Mr. Shane Byrne, brother of Senator Byrne, and his colleagues. They are all very welcome to Leinster House and I hope they enjoy their visit.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for giving two hours of his time to discuss the local democracy task force. I welcome the uachtarán of the Association of Irish Local Government, Councillor Aengus O'Rourke, and congratulate him on his election. I acknowledge the sterling work of his predecessor, Councillor Mary Hanna Hourigan. Clearly, she was in the post for longer than Councillor O'Rourke has been, but I have no doubt he will continue in the same realm and with the same enthusiasm as she had for the job.
I thank Mr. Tommy Moylan and Ms Elaine Lynch, both of whom are fiercely committed to the AILG. I also acknowledge the work of the Local Authority Members Association. Senator Fitzpatrick mentioned that there was an issue regarding the respective roles of LAMA and the AILG. That needs to be resolved and doing so should not rest totally on the political establishment. It will require communication and guidance. We do not want to see one councillors' organisation pitted against the other. They may have distinct roles and there may be new functions and roles for different elements within the organisations. Whatever happens, I hope it is done in a professional and amicable way. We do not want rancour among democratically elected city and county councillors.
There is a recurring theme regarding boundaries, of which the Minister of State is aware. It is an important issue of concern on which I have had a number of emails, as I am sure all my colleagues have. Many councillors have come to the decision that they will not run again for a whole range of reasons. That is the reality. Some want to retire, having given up to 25 years' service to local government. Others within structures, families, associations and organisations, may decide to seek election for that role. Time is of the essence here. I ask that preparation begin as soon as possible for the drafting of the terms of reference. That is a prerogative of the Minister of State and he has indicated that he is favourable to acting sooner rather than later. There is a role for the Oireachtas in this as well because all terms of reference for the Electoral Commission must have the support, which I have no doubt they will, of both the Dáil and the Seanad. That is an important point.
We need to take a closer look at the focus on devolved powers. There are not enough devolved powers but the task force's remit was crafted in such a way that it could not go beyond a certain point. Let us keep an open mind about devolving powers and functions from central to local government. That is enough said.
Senator Cathal Byrne talked about councillors seeking advice. A recurring theme throughout the report, which I certainly would echo, is that sometimes - not always, but at some points - councillors need independent planning, financial and legal advice. Councillors are not all accountants, actuaries, lawyers, planners or whatever else. It is an important point. I understand that where legal advice is given to a council, it must be procured by the chief executive. Only by a special resolution of a council can councillors, backed by a certain number of votes, seek a second opinion. They cannot seek another advice but they can seek advice on the first opinion. I would like clarity on that point.
We need to be honest and frank in discussing these issues. We do not want to gild councillors with lots of lollipops. There are shortcomings in local government and I will outline three of which I am aware. The audit committees are weak. Some councils nod through an audit report in ten minutes, which is appalling. I single out Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council as an exemplar in terms of its audit committee. It is chaired by Ms Noreen Fahy, who is also chairperson of the Oireachtas audit committee, of which I am a member. She attends the meetings of the Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council audit committee, as she feels it is the right thing to do. She fields the questions because she is the chairperson. That is an example I would like to see followed elsewhere. It is not good enough that councillors should wave through a very detailed audit report in ten minutes. I suggest that there be a special annual meeting of the audit committee for those who want to participate.
Another issue relates to council finance committees.
I welcome what the Minister of State said about finance committees. That is positive. We should consider the possibility of audit and risk committee, ARC, and the practice of ARC, which is audit, risk and governance. That model works. We can get a lot of assistance and direction from the IPA. That is important. There will need to be a focus on training and upskilling. That is where the AILG will come in. Members are eager to learn with more training and upskilling.
Well done to them. Representatives of the Electoral Commission and the CCMA are here today. I met both of them at 2.45 p.m. They appeared before the Oireachtas Joint Committee on housing and local government. I want to salute them on voter.ie. I thank the Minister of State and his colleagues for the collaboration in relation to voter.ie which was launched today or yesterday. That is good. I thank the CCMA. We must collaborate on a better deal, better governance and more power to local people. That has to come through more power, devolved power, more functions and more financial support to our 949 city and county councils. Again, I genuinely thank the Minister of State and acknowledge his significant impact in local governance. I thank him for giving two hours of his time here this afternoon.
Comment on this
I propose, notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders or the Order of Business today, that No.2 will conclude at 6.05 p.m., if not previously concluded.
Comment on this
There was a break for the vote. It is not just for my own opportunity to speak-----
Comment on this
The Senator has good things to say.
Comment on this
-----as happy as I am to take this opportunity to speak.
I thank the Minister of State for being here. As he would expect after this report was launched, there were numerous requests from Senators to have him to come to the Chamber to outline his vision on the future of local government and local democracy. I thank him for facilitating that. There has been a keen interest in this in this House and a very good debate over the past two hours.
There is only one topic that I will focus on in the short time that I have to speak. I have spoken to the Minister of State numerous times on it. I know his concern and commitment to always support councillors in the work that they do. It is in relation to security. The Minister of State is aware that we had a situation over the summer months where two councillors who used the security allowance, which is available for them and rightly so, were named in a newspaper. The impression was given that they were almost essentially given free money to secure their homes for them and their family. That has caused huge concern among councillors right across the country. It is deterring some from applying to secure their homes, premises and where they work because of a fear of being named in a national newspaper. There are a couple of issues with it. I know the Minister of State is aware of it. One of them we are familiar with in this building. That there is-----
Comment on this
There is another vote in the Dáil. We are going to have to suspend to let the Minister of State to go to vote. I will allow the Senator to continue after that.
Comment on this
Does the Leas-Chathaoirleach wish to suspend now?
Comment on this
As the Minister of State knows, this a real concern for councillors where they are fearful that they are going to be named in a paper for using an allowance that they are allowed to use to protect them and their families and being portrayed in a sense that they are just getting taxpayers' money for no reason whatsoever, which is not right or fair. This is at a time we are trying to attract people into local government and politics, particularly women who suffer more from it than men do if we are being honest about it. We saw on Kieran Cuddihy's programme during the summer the challenges that many women have, particularly in rural areas, in executing their duties as councillors, that we need to protect those councillors. In fairness, no Minister has done more to protect councillors across the country than the Minister of State has. He was only in office for a month or two months when he increased that fund to support councillors in terms of putting up security, whether it is in their homes or where they work and making it 100% that they could recoup.
We have a situation even in this building if we are a Senator or TD and a freedom of information, FOI, comes into us, we get informed before it goes out to the public, so we have an opportunity to tell the person who is putting a FOI request back out, "Look, I don't think my name should be in that. I don't think my address should be there." We can inform the Houses of Oireachtas that it should not be done. They might not agree with Members, or they might, but at least we have the opportunity to do that. Councillors should have that opportunity with their local councils to say, "Look, don't send that out with my name on it. I don't think you should" and then the council makes an informed decision based on the FOI request that comes into it and on the councillor in question who questions what should be put out and what should not be put out.
However, the fundamental issue is that this is about the protection of public servants across the country. The work the Minister of State has done to enhance that protection is hugely welcome but we just need to make sure that we are not deterring people from using that opportunity because of journalists writing the names of people who do it. I have been inundated by requests from a number of councillors who want to apply for that security allowance, but do not want to do it now because of the fear of being named. I know it is a real concern of the Minister of State. I do not know if he has an update, but I would appreciate when he comes back that he might be able to.
Comment on this
As a vote has been called in the Dáil, we need to suspend to allow the Minister of State to attend.
Comment on this
I propose, notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders or the Order of Business today, that No.2 will conclude at 6.20 p.m., if not previously concluded.
Comment on this
I thank everyone for their forbearance in facilitating the votes in the Dáil. I thank the 16 Senators who contributed to the debate on this very important topic. Local government is the absolute heartbeat of our democracy. Local authorities right across the country provide up to 1,100 services to the public every day and provide an invaluable service. The councillors who serve in local government represent their communities with great distinction.
That is the reason we, as a Government, have brought forward the local democracy task force and the implementation plan I published alongside it. I did not want a gap around the task force report. I did not want everyone asking whether something would be implemented or not. Over a number of months after receiving the task force report, my officials and I worked extensively to put a comprehensive implementation plan in place alongside the task force report. It sets out the clear timelines for the implementation of the recommendations. A number of Members referenced the timeframe and asked when certain milestones will be hit. The implementation plan was done to set out those milestones. It outlines the items that can be implemented in short order. A number of other recommendations will require more work and extensive dialogue with the likes of the AILG, LAMA and other representative bodies. I do not accept the premise that one Senator mentioned earlier on, which was that we do not need more consultation. That was referenced. The reality is that a number of the recommendations in the task force report require additional work with stakeholders to ensure that the legislation that will subsequently underpin it is correct. I will not apologise for continuing to work with representative bodies in that respect.
The timeline is that the legislation to underpin this must be implemented 12 months in advance of the local elections of June 2029. That means the legislation will be in place by the summer recess in 2028. We can work backwards from that to find the milestones that have to be hit for the legislative underpinning.
I will speak to the broad points raised by Senators Murphy, Conway, Fitzpatrick, McCormack, Noonan, Black, Rabbitte, O'Reilly, Keogan, O'Loughlin, Kelleher, Andrews, Byrne, O'Reilly, Boyhan and Ahearn. The premise of what they have said is about the rebalancing of power within local government. As the Minister of State, that is what I want to see. I want to ensure that our duly elected councillors who are representing their communities are empowered and that they have the responsibility for policy-setting within local authorities. Councillors should not be policy takers but policymakers. That is what I am striving to ensure occurs as part of the implementation and the legislative underpinning that will come with it.
I am also thinking of the service provided to councillors and the timely reporting of data on how their local authority is performing against other local authorities, which will inform them in their work. I do not want that data to be provided at just a single point in time within the year but on a more regular basis. I also want councillors to have an expectation that they will get a response within a certain statutory timeline to their queries not on their own behalf but on behalf of the communities that they represent. That is key to what we are trying to do here.
The other broad area that Senators spoke to was the local electoral boundary review. As I said in my opening contribution, I am working on the terms of reference for that at the moment with the Minister, Deputy Browne, and I expect that we will see progress shortly. It is likely to see an increase in councillor representation as a result of the increased population. We used the 2011 census data for reviews in 2014 and 2019, and in the most recent local elections in 2024. It is appropriate that we use a more updated census. The question put to me was why not wait until the 2027 census data and reporting is available. The likelihood is that finalised reporting on that census will not be available to me until the end of 2027. If we then give the Electoral Commission nine months to carry out its work, we would be looking at the end of 2028, with local elections only six, seven or eight months away. That would not give people an adequate opportunity to make informed decisions on their futures and whether they wish to participate in elections. That is why we will be using the 2022 census as part of the local electoral boundary review. That will reflect 11 years of population increase, which will be factored in as part of that process. We will see progress.
Another item has been raised by a number of Senators, including the Leader who raised it in his contribution. His contribution captured what a number of the Senators raised with me about the security allowance and the issues that have arisen in that regard. It is my intention to bring forward amended regulations and an updated circular in this respect in order to state that, from a Department perspective, we will only require the number of councillors that have availed of that allowance and the quantum of money that has been drawn down in a calendar year. Each local authority deals with freedom of information requests itself but I would hope and expect that setting out the circular and the regulations to underpin it and to provide for what we require will inform decision-making within local authorities on any further requests that may come. I hear what has been said by Senators. It has also been communicated to me through the LAMA and the AILG, the representative bodies. I hope that will provide some comfort for local authority members around the country.
I thank each of the Senators for their continued advocacy for local government. I said in my opening contribution that I will continue to work with them on the reform programme that will be ongoing over the next number of years ahead of the local elections and that mid-2028 timeline. We have a steering group led by an assistant secretary within the Department to drive that. I look forward to continuing my engagement with Members of the House as we implement the next generation of local government reform in this country.
If the Leas-Chathaoirleach would indulge me, I did not get an opportunity to mention a matter at the outset. A number of Members referenced the tragic and appalling circumstances of the fire in my constituency of Waterford today. I put on the record my thoughts and prayers to the family. I know that the community in Waterford and the Sacred Heart parish, of which I am a member, will rally behind the family concerned. I also acknowledge our first responders who dealt with an absolutely horrific circumstance in the early hours of this morning. I know Senators will join me in thanking them for the continued work they do on our behalf.
Comment on this
Hear, hear. I thank the Minister of State for being here and for his comprehensive response. I also thank the Senators who contributed. I acknowledge Mr. Moylan and Councillor Aengus O'Rourke, the chairperson. When the task force was first set up, I and the then Leader, now Deputy, Sean Kyne, went to the Ashling Hotel. We contributed to the report when there was an opportunity for Senators to do so. I thank the Minister of State for all he does.