Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
Court Accommodation
Senator McCormack urged urgent replacement of Portlaoise’s unfit courthouse, citing safety, accessibility and disruption to Main Street. The Minister said the project has initial funding under the National Development Plan and a design team preparing a business case, but gave no construction timeline.
I thank the Minister for coming in to take this important Commencement matter on Portlaoise courthouse, which I have discussed in the Chamber previously. As he will be aware, there is an urgent need for the updated courthouse in Portlaoise. I have raised it several times, but we are still here talking about the same problem. There is no new courthouse and no clear timeline for the new courthouse. The Courts Service purchased a site behind Aldi for €750,000 in 2020, which was six years ago, and we are still waiting.
We are not talking about a small courthouse in a small area that is only used occasionally. Portlaoise courthouse deals with thousands of criminal, civil and family law cases every year. We are asking judges, court staff, gardaí and legal professionals, victims of crime and families to continue using a building that is simply no longer fit for purpose. Numerous judges have raised serious concerns about the condition and safety of the existing courthouse.
However, it is not only the people inside the building who are affected. That is the bit that bothers me and the locals who reach out to me all the time. Anyone who knows Portlaoise knows what Main Street in Portlaoise can be like on a busy court day and they are becoming more frequent. I urge the Minister to visit Portlaoise on one of those days to see the impact it has with prison vans and Garda vehicles, footpaths obstructed, crowds gathering outside and people trying to go about their everyday business. The businesses on Main Street are being wiped out because of the impact it has. Wheelchair users and women with buggies cannot get by. Having it on Main Street simply does not suit. There is no parking there. There is also the question of dignity for people attending the court, who include victims and vulnerable families. They deserve to have proper facilities and privacy.
It is frustrating when we have a site that has been sitting there since 2020. When the project was left out of the announced construction funding for 2026 to 2030, it set off alarm bells. We are all concerned because it was in the previous plan for implementation to 2027. I hope we can get to the bottom of this. Portlaoise is unique, in that it has two major prisons. It plays a significant role in our justice system and that puts more demand on our courthouse. There are pros and cons to having these major prisons in our town, but surely it is not unreasonable to expect that a town have a modern, safe and accessible courthouse.
Comment on this
I thank Senator McCormack for raising this matter. She has raised it previously. I had a meeting last year with some locals from Portlaoise about the issues arising from the courthouse, so I am aware of the issues she highlighted.
It is important that we have in place proper court facilities throughout the country. There has been upgrading of facilities in the past ten or 15 years and a lot of the older buildings are being renovated or replaced with new buildings. The size, geographical spread and age of the courts estate means renovation, maintenance and management is a multi-annual programme of work, which must be phased and progressed based on delivery capacity and affordability. As Minister, it is my priority to ensure that resources are in place to deliver efficient and timely access to justice.
Last week as part of budget 2027, I announced an overall allocation to the Courts Service of €228 million. Current courts funding for 2027 will reach €159 million, with additional funding of €69 million being provided for capital expenditure.
To be of assistance, my officials have made inquiries with the Courts Service regarding an update on Portlaoise courthouse, which is the matter raised by Senator McCormack. I am advised that, as the Senator has indicated, the Courts Service purchased a site for a new courthouse at Kylekiproe in 2020. The Courts Service has received an initial funding allocation under the revised national development plan to support the advancement of a courthouse project in several areas, including Portlaoise. This funding will facilitate the preparatory work required to develop a robust business case and evaluate the options necessary to inform future decisions regarding courthouse accommodation.
I am also advised that a design team has been appointed to prepare the strategic assessment and preliminary business case for the proposed project. This work is being undertaken in accordance with the infrastructure guidelines and will define the scope, scale and requirements of the project while assessing its feasibility, affordability and value for money.
I appreciate the Senator's concern in respect of the courthouse at Portlaoise. I am concerned about the impact it is having, not just in terms of the court users, including the solicitors and barristers working there, but also in terms of the wider Portlaoise town. I am aware of the impact it is having on local businesses and how they can be disrupted as a result of not having adequate, modern infrastructure in place to ensure that the administration of justice can take place effectively in Portlaoise.
The good news is that there has been progress, as I have indicated. It is the case that we have a site. The Senator will say that we have had the site for a number of years, but it is important that a design team has been appointed to prepare the strategic assessment and preliminary business case for the proposed project. I think that is a positive step and I certainly will keep a close eye on Portlaoise to ensure that we can progress this development.
It is the case, however, that the renovation or redevelopment of courthouses takes time. I know that we want to speed that up but there are competing interests as well. The Courts Service has a budget that it needs to spend in respect of the renovation or development work, but I am aware of Portlaoise. It is on the list and I hear clearly what Senator McCormack is saying.
Comment on this
That is welcome news. I am delighted to hear that a design team has been put in place. I understand that we are talking about a large-scale project and that it will take a bit of time. There is funding, but the frustrating part is that the site has sat idle for six years. If we can see blocks starting to come into place, then it will be a welcome relief to the residents of Portlaoise in terms of the courthouse.
I will follow up the matter with the Minister. I appreciate that he has provided some information, the project is now part of the national development plan, funding is available for Portlaoise, which is fantastic, and there is a design plan in place. I hope that, within the soon-coming future, we will have this courthouse in place and the Minister can visit. Perhaps he might pay a visit to Portlaoise Prison as well. I believe it is one of the prisons that he has not got around to visiting. We would really like him to visit and meet us.
Comment on this
I thank Senator McCormack for raising this important issue. I assure her that I have been to Portlaoise. I have been to the Midlands Prison and Portlaoise Prison. In fact, I have visited every prison in the country and there is a lot of great work being done in our prisons.
In terms of our courts, it is important that we understand the reason for trying to modernise and renovate the courts. It is so that the people who seek access to justice and who are involved in the administration of justice can ensure that it is done in a professional and welcoming environment. Going to court can be a very challenging event for individuals but it is important that we put in place the infrastructure that makes that a little bit easier because, as the Senator will know, people are there in many instances for family law disputes, which can be very traumatic. The real obligation on the State is to ensure that we have the infrastructure in place to facilitate that.