Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
Data Protection
Senator O’Reilly called for stronger safeguards against covert recording and misuse of AI smart glasses, while recognising their benefits. The Minister said existing GDPR and Irish data-protection law apply, and noted that the European Data Protection Board, with the DPC’s involvement, was considering guidance on the technology.
I welcome the Minister and thank him for underlining the seriousness of the matter that I am going to raise by coming here to address it himself.
I wish to raise a concern that will become increasingly important as technology continues to progress.
The latest development is the increasing use of smart glasses. These are not simply glasses or spectacles; they are cameras and AI assistants. Without a phone being taken out of a pocket, smart technology glasses can allow a person to make phone calls, listen to music, translate speech and written language, use facial recognition and take photographs and videos. This technology has its benefits. For example, blind and visually impaired adults can use smart glasses to identify objects and access information. Although it is important to recognise that the rise of new technology comes with advantages, it also comes with serious responsibilities. When someone, any of us, is recording with a smartphone, it can be clearly visible. You know you are being recorded. With smart glasses, it is much easier to record people without their knowledge, creating a big concern for all of us who in some way value our privacy.
The core issue is that I have seen many reports of young women in particular being secretly recorded by smart glasses users and the recordings subsequently being posted online for likes and so on. Recently, a young woman from Cork was filmed in her workplace by an influencer wearing Meta smart glasses. The recording was posted online without her knowledge or consent, creating a more than uncomfortable situation. Many other women have stated their discontent about smart glasses, creating calls for regulation of AI smart technology use to prevent any future threats to privacy and online safety. While I single out women, and young women specifically, it applies to all of us. Every one of us would like to think we can have a level of privacy at some time. It can affect people canvassing. I do not have to go through the list.
I am aware that the EU has a law insisting that there be a bright light on the smart glasses so that a person being recorded can identify that fact. However, I understand that those who are technologically advanced and have that kind of savvy can remove that light, which is sinister. I am delighted the Minister is here to address this and I acknowledge his proactivity in all these areas, so I am optimistic. I request that he consider taking up these concerns and updating and strengthening data protection legislation on the use of these glasses and other devices.
Other countries have already begun discussing potential regulations on AI smart glasses. Norwegian officials have announced that they intend to examine stricter regulation of smart glasses and similar devices. Norway’s digitalisation minister has raised the possibility of banning functions such as facial recognition of other people in public places and is establishing an expert group. I humbly submit that Ireland should recognise the immediate concerns with smart glasses, identify gaps in the legislation and in the laws on privacy protection and harassment, and put in place the necessary legislation and regulations to deal with it. There are the concerns I identified earlier. I ask the Minister to consider this unfortunate use of a technology that can potentially be good in some instances and to consider a legislative response.
Comment on this
I thank Senator O’Reilly for raising this important issue. It is important that I am here to respond to it. As the Senator has indicated, technology can provide huge advantages to us all in society but, when it comes to artificial intelligence and new technology, we also have to realise the challenges it can pose. We need to ensure we protect the privacy and autonomy of individuals who may, unknown to them, be subject to this technology. As the Senator has indicated, the use of smart glasses and other wearable technologies capable of capturing images creates new opportunities for communication, particularly for people who are blind or visually impaired.
I welcome that the Senator highlighted the advantages and benefits of these glasses. However, as he also indicated, they raise important considerations regarding the protection of personal data and the rights of individuals. Functionality varies between the types of smart glasses on the market. The most common offer the ability to listen to music, make or receive phone calls, take photos or videos and access real-time translation services and live streaming. There may also be Al-enabled features, as the Senator suggested.
The collection, use and disclosure of personal data through such technologies are generally subject to the requirements of the general data protection regulation, GDPR, and the Data Protection Act enacted by these Houses in 2018. These frameworks are intended to operate in a technology-neutral manner and apply to the processing of personal data regardless of the technology or device used. The Data Protection Commission, DPC, is Ireland's independent supervisory authority under the GDPR and is responsible for monitoring and enforcing compliance with data protection law. Therefore, in the first instance it is a matter for the DPC to consider the application of existing data protection legislation to particular technologies, products or processing operations.
Across Europe, concerns have been raised regarding the privacy implications of smart glasses and similar wearable technologies. Senator O’Reilly highlighted concerns, particularly in the context of the woman in Cork who, unknown to her, had been subjected to the use of these glasses. These concerns include issues relating to transparency, awareness of when recording is taking place and the collection and processing of personal data relating to third parties.
The European Data Protection Board, EDPB, is Europe’s independent body tasked with ensuring that the GDPR and the law enforcement directive are applied consistently and that there is co-operation, including on enforcement. The membership of the board comprises the heads of the national data protection authorities and the European Data Protection Supervisor. The issue of smart glasses is something that the EDPB is actively considering. I understand that it is discussing the matter at a meeting being held today with a view to adopting a statement to address the key privacy and data protection challenges. It is timely that Senator O’Reilly submitted this Commencement matter for discussion today in light of the fact that the European Data Protection Supervisor is considering it. I hope that the response will be to highlight best practice and provide recommendations. Obviously, Ireland's DPC has been involved in drafting the statement to address the key privacy and data protection challenges that is due for adoption.
There is a lot going on in this area. It is important that the Senator and the House highlight this issue, however, particularly as it is challenging for policymakers. We need to ensure that as well as permitting the opportunities that come with technology, we deal with the regulation.
Comment on this
Before the Senator responds, I welcome Catherine Kealy from Cratloe, County Clare, and her friends. They are in Leinster House to raise awareness of breast cancer. I attended a powerful, important and strong presentation in the audiovisual room in this regard. The advocacy they do around breast density and the need to communicate the importance of that to women is important. I wish them every best wish with their campaign.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for his positive response and his acknowledgment of the seriousness of the matter. Basically, my contention is simply that technology should be used to serve people by breaking down language barriers and making daily tasks easier. It should not be used to abuse others and their right to privacy. We have an opportunity to get ahead on this issue by beginning discussions around AI and smart technology regulations immediately. I look forward to discussing this matter more in the future.
I was truthfully unaware that the meeting was on today, but it is apt that we are discussing this matter on the same day. I am happy to be informed about that. I hope we can do something about this.
Comment on this
In many respects, technology companies – I have said this to them – are at a crossroads. They have an option as to which route they take. Obviously, huge benefits and opportunities come with technology.
Look at smartphones, for example. There must be huge advantages for people who are blind or visually impaired to be able to avail of this technology. Similarly, malign influences can misuse this technology negatively. In some instances, it can be used for purposes that completely violate the privacy or integrity of the individual. These pathways can be reconciled if we ensure that we allow the innovation for technology to advance while also putting in place regulation which recognises that there have to be rules in place to respond to this extraordinary new technology.
I again thank Senator O'Reilly for raising this pertinent issue. It is one to which we should return in this House.