We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad
‹ An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business

Leader’s response to contributions

Summary

Rabbitte welcomed the students, acknowledged the English family’s bereavement and reflected on the session’s themes, including justice, the strike and the loss of life.

The students and teachers are very welcome to the House.

There were a number of strong themes across the contributions. I have to start by acknowledging the bereavement of the English family in Waterford. Strong themes here today have included justice, unions, the strike and pay, but the one that stands out the most to all of us is the loss of life and putting a price on life as though it is equal to a drug debt. It is really sobering for us all. This is not the first time we have had these issues in this House. I think of Clara in Offaly in the last 12 months, where a grand-aunt and a young ladeen lost their lives. It is not the first time a drug debt has cost lives in this country.

Senator Fitzpatrick raised the issue of the unions, as did the last contributor, Senator Duffy, and others. Some 300,000 public sector workers were out yesterday, and 150,000 appointments were lost. One million children did not get to go to school, and dysfunctionality was brought to the State. I agree with Senator Fitzpatrick and all the Members, including Senator Duffy, who stated that leadership is required on both sides. We need everybody around the table, and we need to prevent another strike happening next Wednesday. We cannot have two days of this. It is total dysfunctionality. We have good leaders at the top on both sides. It is time for them to sit down, put their shoulders to the wheel and avert a strike next Wednesday. It is no example for anybody to be setting. We are a modern society. We have money available. The Minister has made money available. He explicitly said so in his budgetary remarks. We now need to sit down and give leadership to all 300,000 public sector workers so that we can sort this out once and for all. For the next generation coming behind, let them see that this is how we do business. We do not need to end up on the streets. I completely agree with Senator Duffy. We do not need to end up on the streets.

Senator Fitzpatrick also raised the AI summit. It was a wonderful success. It was great to see different organisations on a world stage in the RDS yesterday. It was great to see wonderful speakers, from EU Commissioners to the heads of the likes of Google, Meta and Microsoft. However, the most important thing that I took away was that AI cannot replace human beings. We need to have an ethical, rules-based approach to how it is managed, legislated for and regulated, and that came across very strongly yesterday. One takeaway I got from it, when I met representatives of Vision Ireland, was hearing about Meta's donation of 15,000 pairs of glasses for people who are visually impaired. That is a gesture of kindness and it also creates awareness of how assistive technology can do good for people.

Senator Nelson Murray raised the issue of dual players. I saw her raising the issue last night on social media. She had been out in Trim and there had been two county finals within 17 hours of each other. That is not good enough by any manner of means. We certainly would not allow it for the lads, and I do not know why we would allow it for the ladies. It is obviously to do with access to the pitch, and any of us who are into GAA know exactly what that means. It is about time on the pitch, but it needs a little bit more consideration. If we are to take integration seriously, we need to think about player welfare, recovery time and how we organise ourselves. That shows leadership too from within those organisations. The Senator was referring to camogie and football, but at the end of the day we all know that maybe the camogie association and the LGFA do not have the pitches and are asking the GAA for them.

The Senator also raised the issue of pregnancy and infant loss and encouraged us to show our support tonight with a candle. It is really important. These advocates have struggled for so long to get their message out. I compliment the Senator on the work she is doing on it. We should show our support for it.

I was captivated by Senator McDowell's presentation, and I probably did not write down enough in acknowledgment of what he was saying. However, I was captivated by everything that he said. He raised very serious matters, which at the very minimum should start with a Commencement matter with the Minister for justice. I genuinely believe that. I am on the justice committee, as is the Senator, and at the very minimum we should start with a Commencement matter on it and see where we go from there depending on the answer from the Minister. I will not pre-empt anything, but we should start there. As the Senator said, he is not going to let this go. We will follow his lead and listen to him because he has raised very serious matters.

Senator Tully, who is not here, raised the strike issue, and I concur, as I have already said. She also raised the issue of graduate nurses. It is not the first time this year we have heard about graduate nurses being an issue. As the mother of a trainee nurse, a second-year pediatric general nurse in Trinity College, we want to encourage them to say, but we should not give false promises to them. If we say we will give them a contract, we should give the contract, pay them what they are supposed to be paid and not give them false hope because that is wrong. That will discourage them and once that starts, it will have an attritional effect on the future. We will write to the Minister for Health about this matter to seek clarity around whether there is standardisation among the six REOs. I have spent a long time campaigning for graduate nurses to be given contracts to deter them from travelling and get them into the system. We should hold onto that and capture their energy. It is great that we have 65 graduates in a class, but we then have only nine offers for them, comprising five permanent and four temporary. That is wrong when we need our nurses here.

Regarding the issue raised by Senator Murphy O'Mahony, I have this vision that the next time I see the Luas, there will be people on the roof of it. However, to be honest, it is not far off that because it is fairly cramped. She suggests that they run two additional trams both ways.

It might compensate a little for capacity, need and everything else, but I would not like to be a frail person, a person with additional needs or someone who is claustrophobic and travelling on the Luas in the evenings or the mornings. While Senator Murphy O’Mahony has engaged with TII, I ask her to submit a Commencement Matter on this issue. Any of us who use the service understand exactly what she is saying. This issue does need to be addressed.

Turning to the topic raised by Senator Scahill, I started by addressing the issue in Waterford and paying my respects, as has the Senator. I do not speak for myself but for the entire House when I pay those respects. Regarding intimidation and drug-related debt, I have to acknowledge the friends and family who have spoken openly. While the emotion is raw now, they have spoken openly about what this has meant to their family. A young man was speaking last night about the loss of his dad, his brothers and his mum. To be honest, it would go to one’s heart. Senator Keogan read a very powerful script into the record as well. We need to have an open conversation here. Time must be set aside for a debate on this matter. This is what we do here in the Upper House. We should all come together and set out our stall on this issue. This type of fear is in every corner of Ireland. Families are selling farms and land because of it. It is about the fear that mothers and fathers have when they are going to bed at night. Whoever might have the debt may not be in the house, but the fear is that a knock might come to the door or worse. We have seen the worst of the worst this week. I think we should have a debate on this issue and I believe the Minister would be open to coming into the House. We cannot stand back. Silence is condoning. We cannot do that. We owe it to the mums and dads who have fear. While there is good work going on in the drug-related intimidation and violence engagement, DRIVE, programme and everything else like that out there, we need to be focused on this issue. I support the call for a debate. It needs to be prioritised in this House and we need to take it seriously. It is not an issue for one group of people or for one sector of society, but for all sectors of society.

Senator Clonan raised a number of issues. I do not know how he got so much into two minutes, but he did manage it. He supported Senator McDowell in relation to protected disclosures. He spoke about the drug intimidation issue. He then went on to speak about the acceleration of attacks on Ukraine. I think this is something he should also raise as a Commencement Matter with the Minister for enterprise. He did say it was quite a detailed contribution. At the same time, however, I do not have the knowledge or expertise to give him the answer. A Commencement Matter would be the best approach on this issue.

Senator Crowe raised the issue of Galway Hospice. As a Galwegian, I have to acknowledge the wonderful work it does. Any of us who have hospices in our communities really see the work and the invaluable support provided by them. It is not until you have a loved one involved with a hospice that you realise the work they do. Regarding seeking a meeting with Galway City Council, of course I support that request for a meeting with the Minister for Housing, Local Government and Heritage in relation to Galway City Council funding. I will take this issue on myself.

Senator Ní Chuilinn raised a very good question in relation to the national governing bodies, NGBs, and the National Aquatic Centre and the National Gymnastics Training Centre. They are excluded from getting access to the equipment. These groups are providing services in their own areas but, at the same time, because they are NGBs, they cannot get access to the equipment. That is something that could be worked out between the Minister and the NGBs. The community sport facilities fund, CSFF, is now open for applications, and I think all of us would back a letter of support in this regard. I encourage the Minister to have an open mind in this regard, and I have no doubt that he will.

Senator Andrews brought up the culture card. I always think back to Planet Youth in counties Galway, Mayo and Roscommon. A pilot was undertaken, and one of the recommendations concerning Planet Youth was in relation to the culture card. People may sometimes misunderstand the definition of “culture”. It is access to what a child is interested in. This is to divert them from drugs and alcohol and the misappropriation of time and, instead, give them a choice of what they might like to be interested in. I genuinely believe that the barrier for some families is the cost. We are living in a cost-of-living crisis. We could start our budgetary request today for next year in relation to the culture card or the sports card. To be fair to the Minister, it is what Planet Youth has told us for years. This is what has been done in the Scandinavian countries and how those countries have supported young people by giving them a choice. I have no doubt that the Minister and the Minister of State will address this issue again next year. I understand exactly where this is coming from.

Senator Boyhan spoke about the lack of solar farm planning guidelines. Senator Kennelly and I, and lots of Senators, have raised this issue. We need proper planning guidelines for this area. It has gone beyond the point of expecting local authorities to make decisions. They need rules and guidelines. If there was even a nod from the Department that something was coming, that would be very welcome. A debate has been called for, though, and we should still request that the debate go ahead. This is the third Thursday in a row that we have raised solar farms, and it is time that we got an answer from the Department. There is a Minister and three Ministers of State in the Department and it is time one of them came into us.

Senator Cathal Byrne raised the issue of CCTV. The Minister or one of the Ministers of State coming in to address solar farm guidelines might address this issue as well. I completely get it. There is a lack of common sense. If it was not so serious, it would be laughable. We are telling people where we are putting the CCTV, so they might just go and dump elsewhere where we have no coverage. That is what we are saying. How local authorities address CCTV and procure the technology is very important. The idea is that it is meant to be done secretly. If this is outsourced to a third party, it holds the general data protection regulation, GDPR, data. The local authority does not have to take on the responsibility of being the data controller. Wexford is not the first county that has come up against these sorts of challenges. Public consultation is well exercised in this country when it comes to CCTV. The Senator should talk to his colleague, Deputy Peter Roche. He worked on this issue fairly well in Abbeyknockmoy. The reality is that we do not need public consultation. It is a direct intervention that is required.

I referred to Senator Keogan and her contribution already, where she supported Senator Duffy and all the Senators who spoke about drug debt. I refer to the silence of the dealers now.

Fair play to Senator Eileen Lynch for acknowledging that it is the International Day of Rural Women. It is unfortunate that we are not outside the gate with a rural women sign. There are enough of us here from outside the Pale who should be out there supporting it and asking our male colleagues from around the country to come out and support it as well. Maybe we will do that next year. A big event is taking place today in County Tipperary, which is the launch of the Teagasc report the Senator spoke about. It is also the International Year of the Woman Farmer 2026. We should be celebrating that and a lot of good work is going on in relation to it.

Senator Craughwell also spoke about the strike. I covered this issue already. I do think it is time for leadership and for everybody to get around the table and address the issue.

I think I have spoken comprehensively about all of the matters raised by the Senators. There are a few actions that I would like to see undertaken now by the various Ministers. I thank the House

Comment on this