We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Disability Matters: Statements

Summary

The Minister of State outlined Budget 2027’s €4.1 billion for disability services, including funding for staff, children’s therapies, residential and respite places, school-leaver supports, home assistance and capital investment. Senators welcomed increased funding and the rights-based strategy but stressed that long waits, inadequate therapies, scarce respite and emergency housing placements leave many disabled people and families without needed support. They called for better long-term planning with disabled people and families, more accessible transport and public spaces, and stronger coordination across services. Several questioned the one-off €500 payment’s adequacy and exclusion of disabled people who work, families with disabled children and people over 66.

Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I welcome the Minister of State to the House. She will address us for ten minutes, group spokespersons for eight minutes and all other Senators for five minutes, with the Minister of State to conclude by about 4.50 p.m., but the debate might be a bit longer. We might conclude the statements at 5 o'clock.

Comment on this
Emer Higgins Minister of State at the Department of Children, Disability and Equality Fine Gael

I thank the Senators for being here. I thank the members of the disability matters committee for the invitation to the Seanad to discuss the progress the Minister, Norma Foley, and I, working alongside our Department colleagues, are making in improving disability services across Ireland.

I will begin with something that is really important to remember in all these discussions, and that is that the real measure of progress is the difference we are making in the everyday lives of disabled people and their families. It is important we all never lose sight of that. We have made significant progress in recent years and we are investing more than ever before in disability services, expanding supports, strengthening our workforce and creating more opportunities for disabled people to live full and independent lives. I know, however, that there is a lot more work to do. As Minister of State with special responsibility for disability, I regularly meet people and families who tell me about the difficulties they face accessing services, the pressures of caring for loved ones and the uncertainty that often comes with waiting for support.

It is important we acknowledge those challenges while also recognising the progress being made and continuing to build on it. Delivering on that means continuing to invest in services, expand capacity and ensure the recent gains translate into lasting improvements for those who rely on these supports.

That is exactly what budget 2027 is about. It provides an additional €264 million in disability funding, bringing total investment in specialist disability services to €4.1 billion. This represents an almost 7% increase on last year and a 28% increase over the past two years. This budget will continue to support recruitment, with the recruitment of 930 additional staff across disability services. It will expand residential and respite supports, strengthen children's services and provide more opportunities for young people leaving school.

Expanding services also means having the right facilities in place. That is why the budget provides €48 million for specialist disability services capital, an increase of €5 million, or 12%, on last year. This is part of a five-year capital investment programme to 2030 backed by €278 million secured under the national development plan. To make sure this investment delivers the greatest benefit, I have asked the HSE to work with the Department to develop a multi-annual disability capital strategy to ensure investment is directed to the areas of greatest need.

Alongside that longer term investment, we are continuing to strengthen services across the sector. A key part of that work is improving access to children's disability services. I regularly meet parents who speak about the importance of getting the right supports in place for their children at the right time. We have made progress, but far too many families are still waiting longer than they should. This budget provides €6.3 million to support 150 new children's disability network team posts, CDNTs, helping us to strengthen services and improve access for children and families. We expect this to help reduce our CDNT waiting lists by a further 50% next year while also ensuring that every child on a CDNT caseload has an individual family service plan in place or in train. Importantly, we are also continuing our work to reduce the assessment of need waiting times, which I know remains a huge concern for families. This budget provides €20 million to continue the assessment of need targeted wait list initiative, prioritising children waiting the longest, with approximately 6,000 clinical assessments to be delivered next year and ultimately helping more people progress through the assessment of need process.

As young people move from school into adult life, we also need to make sure the right supports are there for them. Leaving school is a milestone for any young person but for young persons with disabilities and their families, that transition can bring uncertainty about what comes next. This budget provides €23.6 million for 1,450 new school-leaver placements from September of next year, alongside €17.5 million to continue supporting the young people who took up placements last year. We are also providing €1.6 million to make day services available to approximately 53 more adults, including those who may have acquired a disability later in life. These services are about much more than providing a place to go to during the day. They are about building friendships, developing skills, being part of a community and having the opportunity to live a fulfilling life. Another important priority is to make sure people can access appropriate residential supports when they need them while recognising the wider pressures facing housing and residential provision nationally.

I regularly meet families, including ageing parents, who worry about what will happen to their son or daughter when they are no longer able to provide the same level of care. It is a real concern and worry for those people and one we need to respond to carefully and sustainably. In this year's budget, we will invest an additional €108.4 million to strengthen and expand residential services, including €62.4 million to develop new residential supports. With detailed plans to be finalised by the HSE, this investment is expected to support 489 new residential responses.

That will include 212 new residential places, comprising 100 planned and 112 new priority one placements to meet urgent need. It will also help us make better use of existing accommodation, provide more support to people with complex needs and help people move from larger congregated settings to homes in their communities where suitable options are available. While we know demand for residential services remains high, we have continued to expand capacity, with more than 1,000 new specialist disability residential places created since 2020, which includes 142 new places between January and August of this year. We are also continuing to support younger people with disabilities who are living in nursing homes, helping more people move into suitable homes in their communities and to access the sports they need to live independently. These are important developments for people and families who want greater certainty about the future and we will continue to plan this work in the context of the broader national need for suitable housing and care supports.

Of course, many families want to continue living in their own homes and communities with the right supports in place. For families providing care every day, access to respite can make an enormous difference. Budget 2027 provides an additional €15 million for respite services, helping us maintain existing services and provide more services for respite next year. We expect this to deliver approximately 14,700 additional respite sessions over a full year. The HSE is working to finalise those details. We are also providing €6.5 million for home support and personal assistance services, helping more disabled people to live independently in their homes and communities. We are providing €500,000 to increase the allowance paid to families who provide home sharing supports. Those rates have not increased in more than a decade and that will help us attract and retain families who provide this important support.

Delivering all these improvements depends on having the right people in place and, as I mentioned earlier, the budget provides for 930 additional posts across disability services. That will bring the HSE and section 38 workforce to almost 24,600 full-time equivalents by the end of next year, alongside the important contribution made by section 39 organisations and private providers. Behind these figures are nurses, therapists, psychologists, social care workers, personal assistants and many others whose work makes a huge difference to people's everyday lives. I take this opportunity to thank everyone working in our disability services for their dedication and commitment and, most important, for the difference they make in the lives of disabled people and their families every day.

We are also continuing to expand specialist supports, including community neuro-rehabilitation services across the country. For people living with from a neurological condition or recovering from a serious injury, having access to the right rehabilitation supports can be crucial in rebuilding independence and improving quality of life. Budget 2027 builds on the national roll-out of community neuro-rehabilitation teams and will fund two new teams. This will help more people access specialist supports closer to home.

The review of the Disability Act 2005 remains under way, informed by public consultation and engagement with disabled people, their families and important stakeholders. Disability has also remained a key priority during Ireland's Presidency of the Council of Europe. Later this week, the Minister and I will host a high-level conference on disability, focusing on assistive and accessible digital technology and bringing together expertise from across Europe.

Budget 2027 also increases funding for the Decision Support Service by 33% to more than €14.2 million. This is about helping people get the support they need to make decisions about their own lives. A review of the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015 will also begin this year, with the experiences of people directly affected being central to that work. Looking further ahead, my Department is developing Equal Lives, our new disability services reform strategy. Building on the national human rights strategy for disabled people and the programme for Government, it will set out a clearer direction for disability services, with proposals expected by the end of this year.

I will finish where I began. We have made progress this year when it comes to the budget and the work that is happening in the disability sector, but I recognise that for so many disabled people and families, accessing services remains more difficult than it should be.

We have a lot more work to do, which I do not underestimate, but what matters now is making sure the investment we secured in this year's budget translates into improvements people can see, feel and experience in their everyday lives. At the heart of all this work, and why all the Senators are here outlining their commitment to this area, is we have a shared vision. That shared vision is one that gives disabled people the same opportunities as everyone else. It is the opportunity to live independently, to participate in their community, to make their own choices about their own lives and being able to plan for their future with better confidence. That is what the Minister, Deputy Foley, and I are committed to delivering and that is how our progress should be measured, not in the figures and stats I have read out. It is about the tangible difference to people's lives.

I thank the Cathaoirleach for the opportunity to speak here today. I look forward to hearing Senators' contributions.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister of State to the Chamber once again and I thank her for the work she is doing in this area.

I begin by acknowledging the measures announced in budget 2027, which the Minister of State has gone through extensively and has spoken about the figures. I particularly welcome the €500 cost-of-disability payment. It is a very welcome recognition of the additional costs people living with disabilities encounter everyday, whether that is transport, heating, specialist equipment, accessing services or simply going about their everyday lives. There are costs that many of us never have to consider. I also welcome the wider investment in disability services, including the additional day services places the Minister of State mentioned, as well as home support, personal assistance hours and the measures aimed at helping people with disabilities access employment.

However, I wish to focus on something I believe could make a significant difference in people's lives as well as all those measures, which is better collaboration, better planning and, most importantly, listening to people with disabilities before the decisions are made. Too often, accessibility is an afterthought. This is not directly aimed at the Minister of State, but we design public spaces, develop town centres and introduce public services and only afterwards discover these do not adequately meet the needs of an awful lot of people. In many cases, those problems could have been avoided by simply asking the right people the right questions at the right time. I have always advocated for early engagement within communities, whether we are talking about wind turbines, public realm projects, traffic management or the availability of local services. The people who live in those communities understand the challenges better than anyone. When it comes to disabilities, that engagement is even more important.

I have had the pleasure of attending a number of local advocacy meetings. The Minister of State attended Corlann services in Boyle with me in recent months. Corlann, formerly the Brothers of Charity, is the organisation I raise here today. During the summer, I attended a meeting in Castlerea with the organisation, alongside my colleague, Councillor Ruth Conboy. I take this opportunity to compliment the councillor on the wonderful advocacy work she is doing within Roscommon County Council, especially in the area of disability. At the meeting, we heard directly from people about the everyday challenges they face. They were not asking for anything out of the ordinary. They wanted to know why there was not adequate wheelchair-accessible public toilets in Castlerea and the wider Roscommon area. This is something people support and ask for nationwide. There are not enough of the Changing Places toilets available, and this is something that should be looked at specifically. Local authorities should be supported and encouraged to roll out more of them.

They also spoke about footpaths being obstructed by parked cars and outdoor furniture, which leaves wheelchair users having to move onto the road. They raised concerns about pedestrian crossings, road safety and access to Local Link bus shelters. They wanted more opportunities to participate in local sport, community activities and employment. It would be wrong of me to mention this and not mention an organisation like the Lisnamult sports partnership, which has made a very accessible facility and recently hosted Roscommon Special Olympics, playing the local gardaí in a soccer match. It has always looked at doing things there, but we need to learn from the best-in-class examples around the country.

People also did not simply raise conversations about disability services.

The conversation was also about participating in community life. They wanted to have a voice on the local community councils and the opportunity to directly address the local authority. These are things we are actively trying to pursue with them.

Over the summer, I had further engagement with other units of Corlann and they brought a number of issues to my attention. In towns like Strokestown and Ballaghaderreen, there is an urgent need for investment in accessible disability services infrastructure. Demand for these services is expected to grow significantly over the next three to five years, but there is already a shortage of suitable accessible buildings available for them to lease at present. Corlann wants to expand services and provide person-centred supports to people within their own communities, but without suitable buildings this can be very difficult.

I ask the Minister of State to look at this because people living in Strokestown or Ballaghaderreen should not have to travel significant distances simply because there are no suitably accessible buildings available to them locally. We need to look at how the State, local authorities, the HSE and disability providers can work together to identify suitable buildings and plan for future demand. Perhaps there is an opportunity to make use of vacant buildings in our towns, provided they can be adapted appropriately. That would be good for disability services and our towns, and would probably represent good value for the taxpayer as well.

I also want us to be a little more ambitious in measuring accessibility for our local communities. We have performance indicators for so many public services nowadays, so why not develop an annual disability and accessibility scorecard for every local authority? This could also possibly be through NOAC. We could monitor accessibility audits, delivery improvements, community engagement, transport accessibility and accessible housing delivery to respond to complaints by people with disabilities. We could measure the availability of accessible public toilets, accessibility of footpaths and pedestrian crossings, public buildings, transport connections and community facilities.

Equally important, we should measure the level of engagement each local authority has with people with disabilities and the advocacy groups. I would go one step further. I would like to publish the annual reports on a leader board for the local authorities. This would not be about trying to criticise or point out where stuff is not going right, but to show and recognise progress, see the real progress being made and highlight good practices to encourage others to improve. I would like to see the disability communities involved in designing that scorecard because there is little point in us measuring what we think is right if it does not reflect the opinions of the people supported.

Transport is another area on which we can make significant progress through more collaboration. In rural Ireland, access to transport can determine whether someone can take up employment, attend an appointment, participate in education or simply socialise. I welcome the current review being done by the Minister, Deputy Naughton, who is engaging with the Department of Transport on the Local Link network and school transport. This brings in a much bigger picture of transporting all people to education and education opportunities. We should extend the Minister's exercise to include disability service providers nationwide. There are vehicles and transport services operating across the country through disability organisations, community services, Local Link and other publicly supported schemes. Surely we should examinee where these services can work more closely together and, where appropriate, improve availability and accessibility. That does not mean taking dedicated transport away from people who depend on it. Rather, it means identifying gaps, avoiding unnecessary duplication and making better use of the resources already available to us. We must also continue to improve accessibility on our rail network. I raised the importance of accessibility improvements in both Castlerea and Roscommon railway stations, which was based on feedback from people supported within our communities. I welcome the progress that has been made in Boyle railway station but I encourage a lot more of this.

We also visited Vision Ireland with members of the Oireachtas education committee recently, and it was a genuinely valuable experience. We heard directly from people with visual impairments about the barriers they face in education, particularly when moving from secondary school into further and higher education and employment. What struck me most was their desire for independence. They were not looking for any special treatment; they just wanted the same opportunities as everyone else to explore their potential. I will come back to that.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister of State. I thank the Cathaoirleach for facilitating this debate. It is something for which I have asked for quite some time. I feel - I do not feel, I know from lived experience - that the experiences of the disabled and carers in Ireland are abject. We are in crisis. We are outliers in European Union terms in the way we deal with the fundamental human rights of this category of citizen; disabled citizens. We are the only country in the European Union where disabled citizens do not have legal justiciable rights to care, supports, interventions, personal assistance, housing or to any of the supports and structures they need to live independent, autonomous lives and participate in the political, cultural, social, artistic and economic activities of this society. For example, the participation rates of disabled citizens in Ireland in the workforce are the lowest in the OECD.

Why is this the case? Let us look at recent legislative developments in these Houses. In the previous Government, one of the Minister of State's former colleagues, as Minister for Social Protection, attempted to introduce a Green Paper on disability reform which had only one prescription for action in it. That was to compulsorily medically examine every single disabled citizen in the State in receipt of disability allowance, which is just short of 250,000 people. These are citizens who cannot get speech therapy, physiotherapy, occupational therapy or any of the other therapies that are necessary to ameliorate their conditions within the therapeutic window. We have disabled children literally dying on waiting lists, yet the Government proposed in its Green Paper to compulsorily medically examine 250,000 disabled citizens in order to see if they could work. It was a cut-and-paste from a discredited austerity measure that was put in place in the United Kingdom, which led to a surge in deaths.

A study carried by Liverpool Hope University revealed there was a surge in suicide amongst disabled citizens, all across England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. The big idea from the Department of Social Protection was to repeat this and bring it into Ireland. Can you imagine using such a scarce medical resource to medically examine 250,000 disabled citizens within a five year period, as was set out? It would involve examining hundreds of disabled people every day, seven days a week, 365 days a year - at what cost? They would have been provided with no therapeutic supports. This is emblematic of a culture in our polity and a set of philosophical, political and cultural attitudes towards the disabled which is Victorian in essence. Imagine somebody compulsorily subjecting my son to a medical examination in order to see was he able to work. This is straight out of Dickens. It is Dickensian. It is ableist. It is deterministic.

That deterministic conflation of a disabled citizen with their socio-economic status was given expression in this year's budget. While I welcome €500 for disabled citizens to address the cost of disability, the Government's own research shows it is between €12,000 and €20,000 per annum before you pay for light, heat or food. It is €500. The Government could have got rid of means testing for the disability allowance and carer's allowance for an amount not far off what was invested in the relief given to people in fuel supports. They parked their tractors on O'Connell Street, despite what the Taoiseach said that you cannot just park your tractor on O'Connell Street and expect to get a meeting with the Taoiseach. I have been marching for 22 years on O'Connell Street and this year alone, we marched twice. There were children in wheelchairs with PEG tubes, nasal tubes, oxygen tanks and young adults. The humiliation of it. We went down O'Connell street and out to the front of the Department of housing on Custom House Quay begging for the bare minimum in supports.

What we got was a €500 once-off payment to be paid to people in receipt of disability allowance. There was nothing for disabled citizens who were working and nothing for families with disabled children. The costs of disability do not just assert themselves when you turn 16. If you look at the care referenda, it has been revealed on the public record that the Attorney General gave very specific advice that the wording must not in any way give disabled citizens or carers any justiciable rights. It was to give constitutional expression to the idea that the family is the exclusive or primary provider of care in the State and the State would have no obligation in law whatsoever to support the family. That is emblematic of a very deeply held cultural view of disabled citizens as not having fundamental rights.

Before I conclude, the context of all of this is that we have children dying on wait lists for spinal surgery. We have children on the urology wait list at CHI. There are hundreds of young adults and teenagers, young boys and girls, whose reproductive organs are not being developed, whose little penises and vaginas cannot develop properly for want of a routine urological intervention which is called a urology pathway that has been best practice throughout Europe for over 30 years. They are becoming incontinent. Imagine being a little teenager, going to school and trying to socialise and then you become unnecessarily incontinent.

According to Before We Die, there are 55,000 adults over the age of 25 who are forced to live with parents over 60. You can add a similar number of physically disabled adults like my son who will be over 25 next year and I am already over 60. What is the plan for that demographic profile? There is no ambition. There is no vision. The Government had one opportunity to amend or review the Disability Act 2005. From the extensive pre-legislative scrutiny we have carried out, the bottom line is the only difference this will make is that, heretofore, the only legal right we had was to an assessment of need. Now, all you will have is a legal right to ask for an assessment of need. That ask will be triaged by non-medical, non-professional grade 7 administrators in the HSE. It is a dilution of the rights. The Government had an opportunity to do something positive and constructive.

I will conclude by saying I have carried out extensive research. I have said it to the Minister of State and the Minister, Deputy Foley. I did it with the assistance of one of the top law firms and it is the first time in the history of the State it worked with the Office of Parliamentary Advisers, OPLA. We looked at the Australian model, which is not perfect but, my God, it is generations ahead of this. It costs the Australians $22 billion. It has a population of 28 million. If you were to transpose that system here, it would probably cost about €4.5 billion. We are probably spending about €3 billion on disability in this country and it is going to service providers. It is going to these high level conferences, the fancy brochures, the bottles of still and sparkling water, the travel allowance and subsistence of all these CEOs of NGOs and section 38 and section 39 organisations. It is not going to disabled people. My son has had no meaningful physiotherapy, occupational therapy or anything since 2007. His situation is deteriorating now and we were told as a family last year that he needed to voice bank, like Charlie Bird, because he will not be able to speak. We were told we would have to fundraise for that ourselves.

This is not personal to the Minister of State but I say to her it is about time this Government put its hands up and, in the same way as was done with the economic crash, be intellectually honest and say we need somebody to come in here and take over our affairs when it comes to disability because this is a shamefully ableist republic and the conditions for disabled citizens and carers are abject. There is no plan for my son, me or the thousands of other parents. Tinkering around the edges is not the radical change and fundamental human rights-based approach the Minister of State spoke about at the UN Assembly in New York. The Government is not walking in that direction. It is walking away from that.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I ask Members to try to stick to their time because I am trying to get everyone in and we are tight on time.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for coming in today to talk about this very important issue. I am very glad to contribute to statements on disability. It is impossible to talk about disability without talking about inclusion and what that actually means in somebody's everyday life.

Can you go shopping, enjoy an afternoon out or support your football team? Can you look to the future knowing that you will have a suitable home and the support you need?

As a Fianna Fáil Senator, I am encouraged by the priority the Taoiseach has given disability, including establishing a dedicated disability unit in his Department to drive delivery and accountability. The national human rights strategy for disabled people sets out commitments across education, employment, independent living, health and transport. Those commitments must translate into changes that people and their families can feel and benefit from. Budget 2027 provided €4 billion for disability services, a €10 increase in weekly social welfare payments and a new €500 disability support grant. That will help address some of the additional costs people face. There is also funding for the additional CDNT posts, residential care, day services and more home support and personal assistance hours. However, families waiting for therapies or desperately needing respite will judge progress by whether that support actually arrives. Recruitment and delivery must follow that funding.

I will talk briefly about my home town of Drogheda, highlighting the Changing Places facility, which was mentioned by Senator Scahill. For anybody who does not know what Changing Places facilities are, the fact is that an ordinary accessible toilet does not meet everybody's needs. Some people require a hoist, an adult-sized changing bench and space for assistance. Without those facilities, a family's day can be cut short or, indeed, never happen. I am delighted to say that Drogheda now has had a Changing Places facility at our Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital since April of this year, and work is due to begin in January of next year on another at Scotch Hall Shopping Centre, something for which I have long lobbied and in respect of which I have worked with those who have been pushing this for a long time. With that in mind, I acknowledge the fantastic work of Annette Monaghan, her husband, Philip, and others in trying to secure those facilities. She kept pushing for those practical changes that make a real difference. Her son Jamie Monaghan is a tremendous Drogheda United supporter - one of their best.

That brings me to the cost of attending the likes of sporting events. I was contacted by Paul Crilly, who pointed out that students and older people can avail of reduced admission prices and asked whether we could look for similar arrangements for people with disabilities. I would like to explore the possibility of a nationally recognised disability card allowing those who qualify to receive a reduction of up to 50% on admission to sporting events with provision for an essential companion where needed. We do know that the European disability card is expected in 2028, but it will not introduce a standard discount. There is an opportunity now to work with sporting organisations here on a consistent concession fee, making it more affordable for people to support their team.

Annette Monaghan has also raised a much bigger issue with me, one that reflects the concerns of the Before We Die campaign, namely, what happens to adults with disabilities when their parents can no longer care for them. She would like the HSE to work with advocacy groups to identify future care and accommodation needs and establish a database in order that we can plan with these adults and their families. We should not wait until a parent becomes seriously ill or dies before putting supports in place. This leaves families already in crisis and services scrambling for an emergency placement. For somebody like Jamie Monaghan, that could mean being placed miles away from his family, his community and indeed the football club he loves so much. Those connections could be central to planning his future. We need more supported homes and residential options for adults with disabilities built into our housing plans and rooted in their communities. Parents need to know that there is a plan for the person they love. It should not be landed in the lap of the State when it is almost too late. Now is the time to plan and to put together that database so we know what we have in future and what funding we will need for that. Adults with disabilities deserve a say in that plan and the security of knowing that they will have a suitable home and the supports they need.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

My apologies to Senator Murphy O'Mahony. There was a mistake in the print so she should have been first. I will go on to the next speakers, Senators Tully and Noonan, and then come back to Senator Murphy O'Mahony, if that is okay. Before I forget this young man down here on my right, I welcome Aaron Foley Doran, who is from Kildare and is on work experience in the Leader's office. He is accompanied by Councillor Mark Fitzgerald. They are very welcome here today and I hope they enjoy their visit.

Comment on this

I engage all of the time with parents of children with disabilities.

They are at the end of their tether. Just a few weeks ago, members of the Every Child Matters campaign were outside the gates of Leinster House. The campaign started in Meath and Cavan and has spread countrywide at this stage. Some of them came into the audiovisual room and told their stories, which they should not have to do. We all love talking about our children but people should not have to talk about their children when it involves trying to highlight their disability in order to get the supports they should be getting anyway. One mother, Serena, told us about her three beautiful sons, all of whom have additional needs. Her eight-and-a-half-year old son is pre-verbal and has been on a waiting list for speech and language therapy in the local CDNT for seven years. He did not speak until he was five. The family engaged a private speech and language therapist at considerable cost and he is progressing really well, but he still needs support. He still has not got any speech and language appointments. He has been waiting for a psychology appointment for six years. He was referred to CAMHS because it was suspected that he had ADHD but CAMHS kept refusing him, without having even met him. Eventually it did an assessment. He has ADHD and is now on a waiting list in CAMHS. We were told there was no waiting list in the Cavan CAMHS section. As a result, he has developed severe anxiety about issues, such as going places where he used to love to go.

Serena's six-year-old son was with primary care and was referred for an autism assessment. The family were then told he did not meet the threshold and, again, they had to source an assessment for him in the private sector at considerable cost. He has developmental co-ordination disorder and a sensory processing issue and he is autistic. The family's youngest son is non-verbal. He has been diagnosed as autistic and has global developmental delay. They have been waiting ages for a communication device and finally got one, but then there were no training providers. They had to try to work out themselves how best to support him. Eventually, months later, training was provided and it consisted of 30 minutes in the school - that was it. Serena says she wants to be a parent to her children but she is actually their advocate, therapist, researcher and administrator. She is also fund-raising. She is everything and she is obviously not alone. There are many other parents in the same situation. Early intervention is key and yet these children are not getting the early intervention they need.

Another very frustrated mother contacted me. Her son finally got a letter stating he had an appointment for speech and language therapy but before he can do that, she must undertake a two-hour training course. She was told in no uncertain terms that if she did not do this, her son would be discharged from the list. No account is taken of the fact that sometimes parents have several children with additional needs. They may have already undertaken this training, yet they have to do it again or their child will be discharged and no account is taken of when this training is put on as well. There is no consideration given to the fact that many parents are parenting alone and the training could be during school holidays or other times when parents do not have childcare.

We need to see CDNT teams, primary care and CAMHS working with families and working together to ensure they are supporting them and providing the therapies. Phone calls, emails and letters to parents are being counted as interventions. They are not interventions. Parent training is not an intervention. It is a support but it is not an intervention. We want to see the children getting the actual therapy that they deserve.

Regarding the Before We Die campaign, I believe that 212 new residential places were announced in the budget but over half of them are for emergencies. This means 112 are for emergencies while 100 are planned. We do not have a definite figure because there is no centralised data system to track people to find out how many people who have an intellectual disability are living with an elderly parent. We know there are at least 2,000 people with an intellectual disability living with parents over 70, and up to 500 of those parents are aged over 80. Of those persons, 98% are only housed as an emergency case when a parent has died. They are trying to deal with the grief of losing a parent and then they become a business cases. This is such dehumanising language. A business case is prepared and the place is basically offered out to providers. It is like bidding, with whoever offers the best value getting the place. The location could be anywhere in the country. It might not be where people have been living all their life, have been attending a day service, have all their family members or in their community.

As I said, they do not cope very well with that situation so they are medically restrained. They are doped up to make them easy to deal with. It is a disgrace that we have no planned system for people with intellectual disabilities in this country and we need to put one in place. This has gone on long enough.

I know responsibility for the cost-of-disability payment is in a different Department, but the Departments should all be working together and we would hope that they are. As Senator Clonan has said, the cost-of-disability payment is only for people on long-term disability payments. What about the disabled people who are working? They have considerable extra costs. We are trying to encourage people to go out and work. We have the worst record in Europe for disabled people in employment and this is a further disincentive to people going and getting work. What about the families with children? What about older people? Several older people have said to me, "When I get to age 66, I lose my disability. It's great." They are being sarcastic, of course. Suddenly, it is not recognised any more. They do not get any support or services. They are not entitled to disability payment even though they still have additional costs of disability to address. All these things need to be addressed.

We need a proper system where we have services. We are hearing about the increased numbers in the CDNTs, in primary care or wherever, but the waiting lists are not coming down and the children are not getting intervention they need. As I said, older people are not being considered. Adults with intellectual disabilities are left living with parents who are not able to look after them and then they are put into an emergency situation.

The Minister of State mentioned respite. Respite is such a vital support and yet many families are not able to avail of it because the places just are not available. If an emergency case arises and a child is put into respite but then cannot go home for some reason, there is nowhere else for that child to go. That becomes the emergency accommodation, meaning everybody else is denied respite for that length of time. Again, that needs to be addressed. It all comes down to a lack of planning. We need to see much more planning done for our disabled citizens. It goes without saying that they must be involved in decisions that affect their lives. Decisions cannot be made without the input from people with disabilities.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I welcome the guests of the Ceann Comhairle, Verona Murphy. I hope they enjoy their visit to Leinster House.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit. I acknowledge the progress that has been made in the two previous budgets and the change of direction in terms of the rights-based approach to disabilities more generally. I want to make a case for people living with Down's syndrome in Ireland. I have had engagement with Down Syndrome Ireland in Kilkenny on developing a clear pathway for people with Down's syndrome from birth to older age. We have heard from the Before We Die campaign about the challenges older people with family members who have Down's syndrome and other disabilities are facing. The anxiety that creates is really significant. Children with Down's syndrome need to get a diagnosis at an early age for arthritis, sleep apnoea and other medical issues which may go undiagnosed for some time. Extra years in preschool, in Montessori or primary school would make a significant difference. It is critical that such a process be led by Government.

I agree with the points made about the cost-of-disability payment. I welcome the €500 as a starting point and it is locked in. I agree with the points made by two previous speakers that it should be broadened out for those in receipt of carer's allowance.

I wish to speak about housing and universal design. At a time when we have a construction boom in the country, we are missing an opportunity not to have life-cycle design embedded in our housing system to prevent having to retrofit both public and private housing stock in the future. We will have an older population but the opportunity is being lost by not having that built in. That also applies in the public realm. As has been said here previously, our public realm spaces need to have disability designed into them.

This needs reskilling within local authorities and engagement with local access groups. We have the Kilkenny access group in our city. Those are important. I have previously raised it in relation to road safety around the Love 30 campaign. Default 30 km/h speed limits in our cities would make a huge difference, particularly for people with visual impairments and other disabilities.

The human rights-centred approach is vital, as mentioned in points raised across the House here this afternoon. That puts the person with a disability at the centre of decision-making. It is really important for people with disabilities. It is about their dignity and their access to employment, which is woefully low in this country. There is no doubt that employing somebody with a physical or intellectual disability can only enhance the workplace. We need to make significant gains in relation to that. This is about a right to thrive rather than just survive the system. I welcome the progress being made but we have a distance to go. I welcome the work the Minister of State is doing but we have significant challenges ahead.

Comment on this

Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit anseo. Táim an-bhuíoch di as a bheith anseo Dé Máirt, i mí Dheireadh Fómhair. Today we are discussing disability matters. It brings to mind the name of the Oireachtas committee of which the Minister of State is a former member. I do not often get the opportunity to praise my fellow Oireachtas Members on that committee and I take the opportunity now. We have a very good Chair in Deputy Quinlivan and I have the pleasure of being the Vice Chair. It is a fantastic committee in that politics is left completely at the door and we all work together. Mention of disability matters just put that into my head.

I welcome the opportunity to speak on this important debate on disability matters. Supporting disabled people remains a central priority for Fianna Fáil in government. We believe that every person regardless of ability should have the opportunity to live independently, to access the services they need, to participate fully in society and to enjoy the same rights and opportunities as everybody else. That commitment is reflected in the National Human Rights Strategy for Disabled People 2025-2030, which provides a clear roadmap for advancing disability rights and improving outcomes across all areas of life. It is a strategy built on inclusion, equality and dignity, with a strong focus on delivering real and measurable change.

To strengthen accountability and improve co-ordination across government, An Taoiseach, Micheál Martin, established a disability unit within the Department of the Taoiseach. This reflects the recognition that disability issues cannot be addressed by one Department alone. A whole-of-government approach is required if we are to remove barriers and ensure that disabled people can participate fully in Irish society. Importantly, these ambitions are being supported by significant investment.

Budget 2027 marks a milestone, with €4 billion being allocated to disability services and supports. This unprecedented investment demonstrates the Government's determination to improve the lives of disabled people and their families. The budget provides a €10 increase in weekly social welfare payments and introduces a €500 tax-free disability support grant for recipients of long-term disability payments. These measures will help address the additional costs that many disabled people face in everyday life.

The Government is also continuing to support family carers through further increases to the carer's allowance income disregard. Carers play a vital role in communities across the country and it is important that they receive the recognition and support they deserve.

For children with disabilities and additional needs, funding is being provided for additional special needs assistants, continued expansion of the access and inclusion model, and enhanced staffing in children's disability network teams. Early intervention and timely supports are critical in ensuring that children can achieve their full potential.

Additional funding is also being directed towards respite services, residential supports, day services, home supports and personal assistance hours. These services provide practical assistance that enables people to live more independently and helps families who rely on them every day.

I also welcome the introduction of a new vehicle adaptation scheme. Accessible transport is about much more than mobility. It provides access to employment, education, healthcare and community life. Greater independence in transport means greater independence in life in general. The national human rights strategy focuses on a number of key areas where progress is needed. Education remains one of the most important. Every child should be able to access an education that meets their needs and allows them to thrive. We must continue working towards a truly inclusive education system where all children are supported to succeed.

Employment is another area requiring continued attention. While progress has been made, many disabled people still encounter barriers when seeking work or progressing in their careers. Increasing opportunities, promoting workplace inclusion and ensuring appropriate supports are available will benefit individuals, employers and society as a whole. The strategy also emphasises independent living and participation in society. Disabled people should have the opportunity to live where and how they choose, participate in their communities and have their voices heard in decisions which affect their lives.

Access to healthcare is equally important. Healthcare services must be accessible, responsive and designed around the needs of the individual. Improving access to health services, mental health supports and specialist services remains a key priority. Transport and mobility continue to be major concerns for many disabled people, particularly in rural Ireland. Ensuring accessible and reliable transport services is essential if we are to be serious about removing barriers to participation and inclusion.

Alongside these practical improvements, we must also continue strengthening disability rights through legislation. The assisted decision-making capacity legislation represents an important step forward. It promotes an approach that respects the rights, dignity and autonomy of individuals, recognising that people should be supported to make their own decisions whenever possible. This reflects a modern, rights-based approach that is fully consistent with the principles of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities.

While significant progress has been made, we know there is more work to do. Disabled people and their families continue to face challenges in accessing services, supports and opportunities. Addressing these challenges requires ongoing commitment, sustained investment and a willingness to listen to those with lived experience. I believe the direction of travel is the right one. Through the national human rights strategy, significant budget investments and continued legislative reform, we are making meaningful progress towards a more inclusive Ireland. Our goal must be clear: an Ireland where disabled people can participate fully in society, barriers are removed, where independence is supported and every individual is treated with dignity, equality and respect.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

There are five speakers left and we have seven minutes because I have to bring the Minister of State in at 5.50 p.m. If I gave everybody two minutes and cut the Minister of State short by a minute or two, would that be okay with her? Yes. I call Senator Duffy.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for being here this afternoon and for all of her work in supporting those across Ireland with a variety of disabilities. I acknowledge the Mayo DPO, the disabled persons' organisation, that was officially launched this summer by Avril Greham and her team. I known the Minister of State has met with them, and I thank her for that. They are brilliant advocates on the ground in the community who identify practical changes which can improve the livelihoods of those with disabilities.

I am a member of the Oireachtas Committee on Transport. I saw yesterday that the Erris employability and workability group attended The WayFinding Centre in Dublin. This is a great example of a facility that gives an opportunity for those interacting with public transport networks to train and familiarise themselves with public transport, whether it is a trial pedestrian crossing, Luas or bus.

This is a great way of giving those with disabilities confidence before using public transport.

One of the things I have raised in the committee, and it has been mentioned in the debate already, is the lack of Changing Places facilities across the country. I have raised this many times because of parents who have approached me, who have young daughters or sons and who have to time their visit into their local town of Ballina, Castlebar or Westport around when their child will next need to go to the bathroom. Thankfully, Manulla FC is one organisation that has led in this area in County Mayo. I am leading a similar intervention in Ballina, but it is all community-led and there are no specific grants for businesses, sporting groups or organisations for Changing Places facilities. These facilities give incredible dignity to those who need it most. Perhaps the Minister of State might make a request across Government to consider a capital fund to support the creation of Changing Places facilities in different towns and communities across Ireland because it would make a marked difference to improving dignity for those who need it most.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for coming in for this important topic. My first point is the €500 payment that a lot of the organisations have reached out to us about. The Disability Federation of Ireland said that it is not going to cover even 5% of the additional costs people are facing. As Senator Clonan pointed out, the Minister of State’s Department’s own research said it costs between €12,000 and €20,000. Members of the Irish Wheelchair Association are constantly outside this House in their wheelchairs as they are having to decide between heating and eating.

Age Action highlighted that approximately 350,000 older people living with disabilities are being left out, and that leads me to the particular question that I am being asked. I have an aunt who lives with a disability and I was explaining the budget to her after it came out. She turned 66 in July, and because she is 66 she does not qualify for the €500 payment. She really did not understand it. It is not an oversight but I genuinely ask if this can be looked at because I have had many queries into my office since then from people, who are saying their disability did not disappear when they turned 66 and went on to the old age pension. They want to know why somebody else gets the payment and they do not. I hope the Minister of State can answer that question.

I second the call for capital funding for changing facilities. County Laois really needs changing facilities. Many parents have reached out to me on that.

We are in total disability crisis as regards CAMHS and services in Laois. There are 900 overdue assessments of need. The local disability teams have serious gaps. Network 11 in north Laois has no dedicated occupational therapist, OT, psychologist or improved social care. It is the same with network 12. There are big problems causing mayhem for families. I would love if the Minister of State could give me some information about what can be done.

Comment on this

Bhí mé thíos san oifig ag déanamh puinn oibre san iarnóin agus ag éisteacht leis na Seanadóirí go léir an t-am go léir ag leagan a gcás amach. Nuair a tháinig an Seanadóir Clonan ar a chosa, bhí iallach orm teacht suas agus tacú leis an bhfianaise ar thug sé. I had no intention of being here, but listening on the monitor to the evidence of Senator Clonan compelled me to come up here and show cause. It was one of the most compelling pieces of advocacy that has been done in this Chamber in a long time. That is lived experience from Senator Clonan and that is what makes it so poignant and chomh gonta sin.

I pick three things out of the course of the debate I heard. I heard him dispel the whole tendency to go along the failed model that was proposed based on the cut-and-paste English model.

I am pleased to hear that this has been eschewed by the Government.

I was also heartened when Senator Murphy O'Mahony mentioned that a Taoiseach's committee is looking at disability. That is encouraging because knowing the compassionate man that he is, I am not surprised. It is to be greatly welcomed that the leader of the Government is so given.

The figure given by Senator Clonan for the expenditure in Australia just shows us how pathetically off the pace we are in dealing with people with disabilities. What was done in the budget was a small step on the way, but my God, we have a long way to go, and I am speaking as someone who is blessed with three healthy children. I suppose it is because so many of us are so blessed that society has not given the attention to disability that it deserves. I applaud all the speakers.

Comment on this

I acknowledge the good work being done, but I do not want to use up my time giving compliments. I speak to a lot of people in my community who are carers or have children with disabilities. I had a Commencement matter today about people with intellectual or learning disabilities in acute hospital settings who are medically fit to be discharged. I have one particular case where a girl has been offered a placement but due to funding not being approved, she is staying in an acute hospital setting. I will speak to the Minister of State about it outside because it is an horrific failure for that girl. She has been in a hospital for 17 weeks and is taking up a bed. We need to prioritise supplementary budget funding before the end of the year to move such cases into suitable settings.

Stewarts hospital is a fantastic facility and I know they are moving a lot of the day care services out. We need to look at the land around Stewarts hospital and its facilities. It could maybe be repurposed for more respite services. The people who avail of the services speak so highly of it, but as time moves forward and the model changes, we need to retain Stewarts hospital for disability services.

I have also heard that some of the people who avail of Stewarts hospital's day services are not entitled to the respite places there, and that is something that I would like to know about.

Comment on this

What we can gather from all of this is that we are all getting the same problems across the board. There is a lot to cover in such a short space of time, but I want to focus on children and early intervention because the CDNT system is not working. There were problems with the old system but at least parents and teachers saw Enable Ireland coming into schools, assessing children and providing some level of support. That has now been replaced with what are called interventions, but what does that actually mean? It means a phone call, text message, video or brochure to parents. A parent and a teacher I spoke to recently said that the HSE is essentially trying to make parents into therapists. CDNTs were established under the progressing disability service model, but how progressive is it if a child goes from preschool to senior infants to second class without seeing a therapist? Senator Tully referred to two brilliant mothers in Cavan, and I have also met them. They are involved in the Every Child Matters campaign. One mother is spending €1,300 a month on private therapies. She travels from Cavan to Dublin for this. Another mother showed me a 13-page record of calls and emails over the last year for one child. These are recorded as interventions. This is the type of intervention provided for a child who cannot speak. That is unacceptable. In Cavan, early intervention classes with six places in each are available in just two primary schools. There are no afterschool services for children with autism and there is extremely limited respite.

I know the Minister of State is not the Minister responsible for it, but I also want to get clarity on the €500 disability grant. Once a person reaches pension age, they do not receive it. Does that mean that there is no cost of disability for somebody once they reach 65?

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

I thank the Minister of State for facilitating all the speakers.

Comment on this
Emer Higgins Minister of State at the Department of Children, Disability and Equality Fine Gael

Not at all; it is really important that we hear from everybody. The Members will have to bear with me. I have a kind of spider's web of responses based on what was raised. I want to make sure that we take the time to as much as possible address what was raised.

There were issues raised in relation to education, transport, the Department of Social Protection, health and housing. That serves as a reminder to all of us that disability cannot just be a priority for me or for the Minister, Deputy Foley, or the disability matters committee. It needs to be a priority for every Minister in every Department. That is what the national human rights strategy for disabled people is about. It is about making sure that Ministers are working cross-government to achieve progress. That is what the disability unit in the Department of the Taoiseach is about. It is about helping to co-ordinate that. The human rights strategy gave rise to our action plan which is monitored by a monitoring, implementation and delivery group chaired by the Taoiseach. It includes all of the relevant Ministers and Secretaries General from these Departments, but more importantly, there are also disabled people and representatives from disabled persons' organisations at the table, and they are holding the Government to account. That is truly the only way that we can make sure that we are all going in the right direction.

A number of Senators spoke about disabled people in the workplace, and it is disability work and skills week. I want to let Senators know about that, if they did not already, and to ask if they will help share details of events that are taking place in their constituencies. There are over 30 events happening this week.

Quite a number of people raised the cost-of-disability payment. While it is welcome that the summit and consultation happened this year and that we are now moving forward into a payment in the first quarter of next year, there are still a number of queries in relation to this. That is why the Minister for Social Protection has clearly committed to putting the payment in place in the first quarter of 2027 and to also co-design with disabled people a process to develop a permanent payment for 2028. At that point, that payment will be used going forward. Between now and then, there will be the opportunity for the kind of feedback that Senators have given in this room to be heard, and I will pass it on.

I want to pick up on some of the organisations mentioned and whose work I have seen first-hand such as Stewarts, Mayo DPO, Gleann Aoibhinn in Boyle and the Kilkenny branch of Down Syndrome Ireland, which actually inspired a collaboration between Down Syndrome Ireland and quite a number of Down's syndrome charities. I think five were involved. Glór - Voices for Life is a new speech and language therapy initiative for children and adults with Down's syndrome. I wanted to put this on the record because that is what happens when lived experience is listened to and taken on board. That is something I am committed to doing, and I know the Minister, Deputy Foley, is too.

Many Senators asked about what happens to ageing carers and, more importantly, their children. A number of Senators pointed out that we do not even have reliable data in this area. That is something that is changing and we have done a lot of work from a data commissioning perspective. We also need to put in place the resources and framework to be able to support those people. We are moving towards planned residential places. This is this first year that there was funding for it in the budget and we are building on that next year too. In terms of recruitment, we are putting in place housing officers and residential planning teams in the HSE to help support parents in this situation and their adult children. People may be aware that the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage is introducing targets for each local authority in terms of two different types of accessible and supported living arrangements.

We are also investing in capital because we know we need to invest in capacity in the sector as well.

The Equal Lives vision and strategy I spoke of earlier is about co-designing what our services need to look like going forward. There is huge scope for us to ensure that this is really front and centre for that.

I am out of time but I would ask for a little leeway to mention a couple of other things that Senators mentioned. One was the need to co-design accessible infrastructure. Changing Places facilities were mentioned by a number of Senators. I have seen really great examples of Changing Places facilities around the country but I have also seen the black holes that exist on the map. That is not fair for people. There were some very constructive suggestions about that.

Many Senators also spoke about the frustrations when someone goes into the HSE services. They might be on a CAMHS waiting list or it could be a waiting list for primary care or CDNT either. I know, and I hear from families too, that they get to the top of the waiting list and are told they are on the wrong waiting list. It should not happen and it will not happen going forward. That is what single point of access is set out to eradicate.

Several Senators raised the matter of long waiting lists in their areas for CDNT. Overall, waiting lists are reducing but we need to make sure we are reducing them further. There are 150 additional CDNT posts in this year’s budget and we have the same in next year’s budget. We need to make sure they are being prioritised for the teams with the highest vacancies or those which are struggling the most. We need to equip them and that will also help with retention.

A number of Senators shared really harrowing experiences here today, whether their own family experience or those of people who have come to them. That is why we are all here, because we all want to pull in the same direction and change things for those people. That is what the strategy is about and what the increased budget and workforce numbers are about: making sure we are taking funding and transforming it into something people can see, feel and touch and is actually delivering change on the ground. That is something the Minister, Deputy Foley, and I, working with the HSE and our colleagues in section 38 and 39 organisations, are really determined to achieve. I look forward to working with Senators on any ideas or constructive suggestions they have to see how we can do that more efficiently.

Comment on this