Employment Equality and Institutional Burials (Amendment) Bill 2026: Committee and Remaining Stages
Senator Higgins proposed a six-month review of the 2022 Act, including whether “manifestly inappropriate” should cover sites where burials are suspected but not located, arguing the current definition could constrain action at Bessborough and elsewhere. Minister Foley opposed the amendment, while confirming Government approval to seek High Court access to technical records on Bessborough; Higgins pressed the amendment, and the excerpt does not record the vote outcome. Report and Fifth Stages were agreed to proceed immediately.
No. 95 of 2026 ›
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 7, between lines 4 and 5, to insert the following:
"Review of operation of section 7 and section 8 of Institutional Burials Act 2022
5.The Minister shall, within 6 months of the passing of this Act, conduct a review of the operation of section 7 and section 8 of the Institutional Burials Act 2022, with particular regard to—
(a) the limitations of the current definition of "manifestly appropriate" in section 7(3)(a)(ii), and,
(b) the potential for amendment or expansion of section 7(3) and section 8(1), including amendment to encompass sites where there is reasonable evidence to suggest that burials have taken place, though the precise location of burials has not yet been identified.".
This amendment would insert a requirement for a review of the operation of sections 7 and 8 of the Institutional Burials Act 2022. It would require the Minister, within six months of commencement, to conduct a review of the operation of sections 7 and 8, with particular regard to the limitations of the current definition of "manifestly inappropriate" in section 7(3)(a)(ii) and "the potential for amendment or expansion of section 7(3) and section 8(1), including amendment to encompass sites where there is reasonable evidence to suggest that burials have taken place", even if the precise location of burials has not yet been identified.
As I said, while this legislation is a positive step forward in terms of broadening the Institutional Burials Act to include more categories of relatives and widen the number of relatives who can take part in a potential identification programme, there is still a huge distance to go in ensuring that many of those whose relatives are currently buried in unmarked or mass graves are able to achieve peace, justice, recognition or commemoration in an appropriate way.
This amendment widens what is meant by "manifestly inappropriate" in the principal Act in the context of a burial site. The terms in the principal Act were very narrowly constrained. The amendment would simply allow the possibility that other grounds could be considered when determining what was "manifestly inappropriate". This would strengthen the legislation and the capacity of the Government to act in other circumstances, including, for example, the instances we highlighted in our previous legislation. We proposed legislation that would have expanded the definition of "manifestly inappropriate" to include situations where records indicate extraordinarily high death rates and a lack of proper death or burial records. It would not require intervention but allow its possibility.
In the case of Tuam, the horrendously inappropriate burial site had already been fully identified, but our Bill would have allowed action in circumstances where the precise burial ground was not yet known but was known to be located within a specific area.
When we introduced our legislation, we raised during the course of the debate the issue of the narrow scope of relatives, as the Minister might recall. It is good to see movement on that now, even if it did not happen under our Bill. However, I am worried about how long we might need to wait for the Government to introduce further legislation. I would like the Minister to explain why the opportunity was not taken at this time, when the expansion was happening in terms of the categories of relatives, to allow for a widening of the scope of the definition of "manifestly inappropriate".
The circumstances at Sean Ross Abbey have been described in detail, so I will focus on Bessborough primarily, although the review will be relevant to both institutions. In Bessborough, an estimated 923 children died, with an infant mortality rate hitting nearly 75% in one year, in 1943. Of the 923 deaths, 107 were not properly reported to the authorities at the time, and the commission was able to identify only 64 burial sites for those children. That is 923 dead children and only 64 burial sites recorded. Although the Government acknowledged during the debate on our legislation that the situation seemed inappropriate – it even seemed inappropriate at the time – it argued that high mortality rates could sometimes, sadly, be a feature of historical congregated settings. It emphasised that there was no legal obligation on private burial grounds to keep a register of burials. In fact, the Births and Deaths Registration Act 1874 stated any person who conducted a funeral or religious service in connection with the burial of any dead body for which no certificate had been delivered was required to give notice to the registrar. The alarm bells were rung at the time and were not listened to. It was not appropriate then to have such high mortality rates and a lack of burial records. It was regarded as inappropriate by many, and it remained inappropriate the whole way along. The idea of saying there is a level at which it could be considered appropriate to have a mortality rate of 75% and have records for only 64 out of 923 dead children is simply indefensible.
I am glad that the Government seems to have shifted position. It has probably done so in response to the absolutely powerful and impassioned campaigning of those who refuse to let their history and the history of their loved ones be disappeared. On the same day that the Government voted down our amendment Bill to address the issue of Bessborough, planning permission was granted. I have no doubt that those who have refused to accept the idea that this is merely a chapter of history that has come and gone, or that what happened was simply an unfortunate feature of the time, have driven this change. They have said they will not allow what happened to be made normal or acceptable, or even marked as some historically unfortunate footnote, but that they demand justice in the present moment from the present Government regarding their rights to justice, peace and reconciliation and to have the records show what happened. I am sure that is what has driven the decision. The Minister flagged it, and I welcome the fact that the Government is now not going to treat it solely as a feature of the time or simply wash its hands of the matter by saying private bodies did not have to keep records, but is actually going to look for records.
This should have been done from the beginning in the legislation, and it should have been done immediately when our legislation was put on the agenda previously. It would have been great if, at the moment Senators Ruane, Flynn and Black and I had tabled our legislation, the Minister had come in and said the Department was going to go looking for the records and it was going to address this. It is happening now but we are on the brink of potential obliteration of the evidence under an apartment development. The Minister is obviously also responding to a unanimous motion on the technical archaeological report passed by Cork City Council. I commend the Labour Party Councillor, Peter Horgan, who proposed the motion and all those who supported it.
We are in the last minute of action for something that should have been foreseen and this is why I urge the Minister to accept the amendment. It is not as prescriptive as our Bill, which wanted to directly change the definition. I am simply asking the Minister to commit to a review of the legislation and to a review of the definition of "manifestly inappropriate" so we do not see what is happening now in Bessborough playing out in Sean Ross Abbey or anywhere else, and that the Government ensures legislation is in place for the Minister or any future government to act swiftly and effectively, and that we have a definition of "manifestly inappropriate", which does not require intervention but allows for appropriate intervention in a quick way without requiring brand new primary legislation to do so.
I genuinely appeal to the Minister in saying we flagged that there were issues and we were right. One of these issues is being addressed but the other issue is still hanging. People want to know that the Government is serious about recognising their pain and recognising the need to deal with the past if we are to chart a new chapter forward. They want to know that the Government is going to shift the definition of "manifestly inappropriate" and allow for the possibility of appropriate interventions, be that investigation, record marking or commemoration, and appropriate action to be taken in respect of sites such as Bessborough and Sean Ross Abbey.
I see a small step forward in the Government's decision today but a big opportunity is being missed. This legislation could have done the work. If the technical archaeological records are unsealed, and if they show either the evidence of mass burials or a lack of evidence as to where the rest of the 923 children who are not in the 64 marked graves are, and if they fail to give satisfaction or raise concerns in further ways, will the Government act and take appropriate action or will the current definition of inappropriate burial still act as a constraint on Government intervention in respect of Bessborough? I would like this specific question to be answered.
Comment on this
I thank the Senators for tabling this amendment. While I say sincerely that I appreciate the intent behind it, I am not in a position to accept it. The legacy of Ireland's institutional past is a deeply sad one that has a real and lasting impact. One of the most tragic aspects is the continuing uncertainty regarding the burial places of many children who died while they were resident in institutions.
The Commission of Investigation into Mother and Baby Homes was established in 2015 to investigate and report on a range of issues associated with mother and baby institutions, including burial practices. The commission carried out detailed inquiries, extensive archival research and, where appropriate, test excavations and other investigative measures to identify burial locations. Through this work, the commission confirmed the presence of children's remains at the site of the former institution in Tuam that were interred in a repugnant manner. Despite its efforts, the commission was unable to identify a burial location at Bessborough nor at the other institutions it investigated.
While I understand amendment No. 1 has been brought forward in good faith, I have a number of concerns regarding its provisions as they are drafted, with a view to making further amendments that would fundamentally change the purpose and scope of the 2022 Act. Therefore, I cannot accept the amendment. Senator Higgins has referenced that I have confirmed to the House that this morning the Government did provide approval to seek a direction from the High Court, and it is only the High Court that can intervene to search for and publish technical factual documents from the commission's archive which relate to the matter of burials at the site of the former mother and baby institution at Bessborough. This, I hope, will support transparency and may provide further clarity on the findings of the commission in relation to the former mother and baby institution at Bessborough.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Minister's response but it did not really address the key question I asked. If transparency in relation to the historical records and archaeology does point to the likelihood of inappropriate burials, and I am going to keep calling them "inappropriate" even if the legislation does not, in the Bessborough grounds, and even if it points to the possibility of there being burials and bodies buried there which are unaccounted for and not marked by documentation, this in itself is an issue. If issues and concerns emerge from these technical archaeological records the very fact of the gaps in the records in itself should be a ground.
The fact of the testimony of those who continue to be distressed and affected by this, who have lost children and family members in terms of the disappearance of their loved ones through death recorded but burial not recorded, should be enough grounds. The absence in the records should be enough grounds. If these are not enough grounds but we come to a situation whereby these technical archaeological records are released and further arrows point to concerns in relation to burials, will the legislation as currently drafted allow for the Government to take appropriate action? This was my question. Will the legislation as currently drafted and the very narrow definition of "manifestly inappropriate" still act as a constraint in terms of Government action? This is the question and, sadly, it has not been answered. To say we are going to allow for more information to potentially enter the public domain is one thing but the question is about what actions are permitted to happen as a result of this. This is where the narrow definition of "manifestly inappropriate" kicks in and acts as a constraint.
I do not think this is good enough. It is a small measure in terms of the unsealing of records, driven by the fact that it was supported and passed by Cork City Council. There is also public support on the ground and demand for transparency. A step towards transparency is one thing and then a step towards accountability and recognition is something more. Frankly, the answer falls short and I will press the amendment.
Comment on this
Before I put the question to the floor, I welcome Shane Byrne, brother of Senator Cathal Byrne, and his colleagues. I hope they enjoy their visit here today.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?