Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
Tax Code
Senator Ahearn challenged the continued higher carbon-tax rate for heating LPG compared with kerosene and natural gas, warning it could penalise households and businesses that switched to LPG. Minister Troy said LPG’s carbon tax is paused at €63.50 per tonne, it has a 9% VAT rate and no non-carbon excise; Finance Bill amendments are possible but require Government agreement.
I thank the Minister of State for being here. My question relates to the treatment of liquefied petroleum gas under the budget 2027 carbon tax measures. The announced reduction in the carbon tax rate for kerosene and natural gas to €48.50 per tonne of CO2 until 2030 raises questions about the continued application of the existing carbon tax trajectory to heating LPG. My understanding of the current arrangements is that heating LPG remains subject to a rate of €63.50 per tonne at present, increasing to €71 in May 2027 and €78.50 in October 2027. I would welcome clarification of the rationale for the different treatment of these heating fuels and whether the position of LPG has been considered as part of the development of budget 2027 measures.
Liquid Gas Ireland estimates that LPG supports approximately 50,000 households and tens of thousands of businesses right across the country, particularly in rural Ireland, providing 2.5 to 3 TWh of energy annually. Many LPG users have already moved from a higher carbon fuel to a lower carbon and cleaner alternative. LPG combustion emits 36% less carbon dioxide than peat, 33% less than coal and 11% less than kerosene heating oil, according to Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, SEAI, carbon emission factors, yet under the proposed budget, its users will be penalised when compared with those reliant on more harmful kerosene and natural gas solutions.
I have four questions.
Can the Minister of State provide clarification on the rationale for maintaining the existing carbon tax trajectory for heating LPG while reducing the rate on kerosene and natural gas? Will he give an opportunity for the Department to meet Liquid Gas Ireland ahead of any publication of the Finance Bill, to discuss the implications of the current approach and explore scope for a review? Will the Department outline the potential impact on affected households and businesses? Would the Minister of State consider options through the Finance Bill process to align the treatment of heating LPG with the reduced rate applying to kerosene and natural gas? Liquid Gas Ireland and its member companies are committed to net zero by 2050 and to a fair and practical transition for off-gas grid households and businesses.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for raising this matter. I am taking it on behalf of the Senator's party leader and my senior colleague in the Department of Finance, the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance, Deputy Simon Harris. Let me begin by assuring the Senator that the Government is acutely aware of the impact increased prices have on the very basic need to heat one’s home. The disruption to shipping through the Strait of Hormuz has profound consequences in the cost of energy not just in Ireland but across Europe and beyond. However, what makes Ireland different is our continued ability to support those who need it most, through the responsible management of the economy. Consequently, the Government has been able to implement an array of supports easing the pressure of increased energy prices caused by the conflict in the Middle East. It must be said that this response is one of the largest support packages in the EU per capita, now totalling over €1.7 billion, targeted at households and businesses across the country.
Previously, this Government paused the 1 May carbon tax increase on heating fuels, including non-propellant LPG, at 2025 levels, reduced the NORA levy and extended the winter heating period by four weeks to ensure that those in receipt of fuel allowance were protected. This built on measures introduced last year to shield households from rising energy costs, which included an extension until 2030 of the 9% VAT rate for natural gas and electricity bills, as well as non-propellant LPG, supporting both businesses and households; enhanced social protection payments including an increase to the fuel allowance rate; an expansion in the fuel allowance eligibility rules benefiting approximately 50,000 households; and a €400 income tax disregard for households involved in microgeneration, which was extended for a further three years to the end of 2028.
The Government built on these supports through the measures taken in budget 2027. This included pausing the 14 October 2026 carbon tax increases on most fuel products, including LPG, and reducing kerosene and natural gas carbon tax rates for the lifetime of the Government.
Every budgetary measure we make has an impact on our ability to respond to a future crisis. It is the responsibility of the Government to take the needs of today into account with the challenges we may face tomorrow. The natural gas carbon tax and the carbon component of mineral oil tax on kerosene used other than as a propellant has been reduced to €48.50 per tonne of CO2 emitted. While reductions are not extended across all fuels, it is true to say that by pausing carbon tax increases, households have been relieved of some of the cost-of-living pressures with respect to the purchase of all fuel products.
LPG used other than as a propellant, that is, as a home heating fuel, does not attract the non-carbon component of mineral oil tax. Only the carbon component of mineral oil tax, that is, carbon tax, applies. The carbon tax on LPG used other than as a propellant is currently paused at €63.50 per tonne of CO2 emitted. This is the same rate that has applied since 1 May 2025 and will provide some relief to families. As previously mentioned, LPG used other than as a propellant also attracts a 9% VAT rate. This is a lower VAT rate than applied to kerosene heating oil, which attracts a rate of 13.5%. The kerosene home heating oil rate cannot be reduced to 9% due to restrictions in EU VAT law.
In summary, there is no non-carbon excise levied on LPG; the carbon tax for LPG remains at the May 2025 rate; and LPG attracts the 9% VAT rate unlike some other heating fuels.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for the response. I understand that it has been paused since 2025 but there have been reductions in the budget. As the Minister of State said, there is a different VAT rate on both but that does not massively narrow the distance with regard to the costs. In fairness, many businesses have made the switch from fuel oil and kerosene for high-peak purposes and also for carbon mitigation. They are now essentially being penalised for switching so there is a very good chance they will switch back. We are talking about rural hotels and restaurants, farms, tourism operators and food businesses. They could all face higher operational costs than some of their competitors because of the changes made.
I acknowledge that pauses have been made in pay and the taxes, with the VAT now at 9% rather than 13.5%, but the ordinary business owner is still paying more than someone else who has not switched. That seems a little unfair and it is something that could be changed in the Finance Bill going through the Houses.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator again for raising the point. To reiterate, we are not comparing like with like because some fuels benefit from the 9% VAT reduction, while others do not. There is no non-carbon excise levied on LPG. There is on other fuels and there was a balancing decision taken in relation to what could be done in any particular budget. We wanted to make interventions at this stage but we also recognised that we could only spend so much. For every intervention we make, there is a cost associated with it and we wanted to intervene in a balanced way that would not fundamentally undermine our ability to make further interventions as the situation evolves. No one can predict with any certainty how the situation will evolve over the coming months.
The budget was balanced, fair and proportionate. The Senator made a valid point. I will be introducing the Finance Bill in the Dáil later today and as with all Finance Bills, there will be an opportunity to make amendments. However, amendments would need the express agreement of all parties in Government.