We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Public Health (Tobacco Products and Nicotine Inhaling Products) (Amendment) Bill 2026: Committee and Remaining Stages

Summary

The Minister of State urged swift passage of the Bill, saying it would prevent under-18s buying nicotine pouches and similar products and restrict their display and advertising. Senator McDowell’s proposed 12-month delay was opposed; he and Senator Byrne also called for tighter regulation of pouches and a level playing field for licensed retailers. Amendments to allow a wider list of vape flavours, including menthol and fruit, were rejected: the Government defended tobacco and unflavoured products as less appealing to young people, while Senators warned of harms to adult smokers trying to quit and possible black-market sales. The Minister said ingredient regulation was a separate issue being considered with EU counterparts.

Bill Public Health (Tobacco Products and Nicotine Inhaling Products) (Amendment) Bill 2026
Enacted

No. 36 of 2026 ›

Garret Kelleher Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 1 and 2 are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No.1:

In page 5, line 24, after “and 28(2),” to insert “and subject to subsection (4)”.

I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Murnane O'Connor, to the Chamber. I have a few general observations to make in relation to the context of these amendments. The consumption of nicotine products is the subject of a variety of measures from the Government, but there does not seem to be an overall strategy in relation to them. First, we have a proposal that cigarettes should be made progressively unavailable by age over the next number of years. That is the first thing. The second proposition is that some of the products should be regulated, such as inhaling products like vapes and so forth. The third issue is the whole question of tobacco pouches and other products, which are called nicotine consumption products, that are not being properly addressed by the Government.

We have a contradiction on top of this, namely, that a number of people participated in a committee of these Houses on the issue of drugs. They produced an elaborate report in this regard. One of the suggested consequences of the report being implemented is, for instance, that cannabis should be legalised in the sense that possession of it for a person's own use should not be a criminal offence in the future. Unfortunately, the same logic has been applied to other controlled drugs, including stronger drugs. We know from recent tragic and savage events just how serious the whole drug problem is for Ireland and innocent people, who are not merely losing their lives but having the lives of their communities destroyed as a consequence. I want to put everybody on the same basis as a tobacco retailer, at the very least. The regime for nicotine inhaling products should apply to tobacco pouches, lozenges and other items. I am surprised the Government has not done this.

Amendment No. 3, which is in my name, has been ruled out of order. It would have extended the existing licensing fees and controls to persons who are retailing nicotine products generally. That has been ruled out of order on the basis that it contravenes Standing Order 42, which prohibits amendments being accepted that could impose a charge on the people. The logic of all of this is that a huge area of retailing is being left outside control, whereas nicotine inhaling products are being more rigidly controlled than before. I do not see a logic in what is being proposed.

Amendment No. 2, also in my name, is designed to delay the introduction of the provisions that are laid to nicotine inhaling products for, effectively, one year in order to allow those people who are involved in the legitimate and authorised sale of these products by retail to make all the relevant changes to advertising, display, packaging and product presentation that will flow from the other provisions of the Bill.

That is what I want to say at this stage on my amendments that have survived scrutiny, namely, amendments Nos. 1 and 2. I strongly believe that those people who are complying with the law and paying substantial sums in respect of the retail sale of tobacco products should have an adequate window of time to comply with the new regime this Bill proposes. I say that in the context where I am very much of the view that the failure to deal with nicotine consumption products in this legislation is not merely regrettable but inexplicable. If we are going to have barber shops and nail bars selling nicotine products without control of any kind whatsoever, it makes a mockery of the pretensions of our public health policy to address the damage that is being done by nicotine inhaling products, which are so widespread in our communities.

They are not aimed at weaning people off smoking anymore. They are aimed at introducing youngsters to inhaling nicotine. The evidence is to be found in every gutter in every street in every town in Ireland. We have not adequately dealt with the whole vaping phenomenon. We are now going to create a new form of nicotine consumption, which is unregulated, through pouches, lozenges and the like. For want of a proper consultation before this legislation was put in place, and I am speaking on behalf of the convenience stores proprietors who are now effectively heavily regulated in relation to tobacco products and nicotine inhaling products, they are to be in competition with unregulated premises right across the country in respect of whom this legislation makes no difference to whatsoever.

Comment on this

I thank the Minster of State so much for coming in. I fully support the legislation, but I support Senator McDowell. I am former owner of a convenience store. I have been contacted by many convenience store owners about their concern that pouches are not being regulated. Maybe it could be tied to the licensing of vapes. At the moment, convenience stores have to apply for a licence for selling tobacco and vapes, but there is no licence to sell pouches. When a shop has a licence, the environmental health officer calls around and checks that everything is up to date. However, there are shops that are selling some of these products from the corner of the shop. They do not have a licence, and the environmental health officer has no control over it. We should put in place some sort of regulation of that whole area because convenience stores are up against so much competition, as Senator McDowell outlined. There are so many corner shops that are not even convenience stores, but they have pouches that are on sale and the young people know where to find them. I support Senator McDowell in relation to that.

Comment on this

I support the Bill. As a party, Fianna Fáil has had a huge focus on the consumption of nicotine products. The smoking ban has saved the State so much money. We cannot quantify it because we cannot even imagine how many people would have been affected by illness if that had not come into effect. Pricing younger people out of the market for nicotine products is a very effective way of dealing with it. We are in new territory. It is evolving. I am not a smoker. The pouches are relatively new. They are a new habit. They are even taking away from the physical element of the habit of having something in your hand. It is just the direct hit of nicotine. It is all about addiction. I know the hard work the Minister of State does. I know her understanding and feelings on addiction. We want to protect our children from addiction because, primarily, the packaging and flavours associated with these single-use vapes are really to capture younger people.

Comment on this

Absolutely.

Comment on this

The pouches are a worry. They should be increased in price as much as they can to squeeze them out because they are serving no real use, only just to get people immediately addicted to nicotine.

Comment on this

I will not hide the fact that I oppose the Bill. I wish to pick up on something Senator McDowell said about the drugs committee, the health approach and the talk among the committees about the possibility of decriminalising the likes of cannabis and stuff. It stood out to me when I heard it. I did not correlate the two at the time. On looking at the possibility of decriminalising something like cannabis but a banning a flavour on a vape that is nicotine, one point I have on the amendment is that we seem to be going very far when comes to vapes and we seem to be softening a little bit on the other side. I will leave it at that until our amendment.

Comment on this
Garret Kelleher Acting Chairperson Fine Gael

Gabhaim buíochas leis an Seanadóir. Sula nglaoimid ar an Aire Stáit chun freagra a thabhairt, cuirimid fáilte roimh ár gcuairteoirí. I welcome our visitors from Crana College in Donegal who are here as guests of the Minister of State, Deputy McConalogue. They are all very welcome.

Comment on this
Jennifer Murnane O'Connor Minister of State at the Department of Health Fianna Fáil

I thank Senator Byrne and Senator Costello for both having the speaking points. This is an important Bill. I thank Senator McDowell for his amendments Nos. 1 and 2. I wish to go back to the drugs strategy. We are the Department of Health, so we are health-led and we work with the Department of justice. It is very much a health-led approach, and this is part of what we do.

Regarding the Senator's amendments, this Bill will make it illegal to sell or give out free nicotine to our children. At the moment, a child in primary school who goes into a shop and looks for a pouch is not breaking any law. They can get a pouch. They can get other nicotine and other similar products as well. At the moment, a child can go into a shop and buy a pouch. The first thing we need to do, and urgently, is to stop that. We have to make sure anyone under 18 cannot go into a shop and buy a pouch or any other similar products. That is the first reason we have to move on this. If we delayed this today, it would mean that we would have to go back to Europe. As Senators know, if we have to go back to our counterparts in Europe, it could take months. This Bill will now stop any children from going into a shop and buying pouches or similar items. That is important.

I pay to tribute to the retailers here today. Most of them are compliant. I always feel it is important we recognise them. A lot of them implement the age policy. If they have the nicotine pouches, they are inclined ask a person's age, even though a young person can go in and buy it. It is important we recognise that. The age of sale for nicotine inhaling products was brought in shortly after the commencement in 2023. Again, it is important that this Bill gets approved today. Under section 21, it creates a 12-month transition period for restrictions on flavours. The Senators asked me about this. Regarding the packaging and appearance of nicotine inhaling products, the timeline for introducing the age of sale to retail, advertisements and display measures for all nicotine will be determined. That will go back to the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill. She will decide on that herself. Amendment Nos. 1 and 2 would mean that these measures could not be brought in sooner because of this.

Senators mentioned about pouches and what we are doing. With this Bill we are putting a ban on sale to minors to ensure no one under 18 can buy a pouch. The other part of this is that we have a ban on display in general stores. As part of this, when we go into a shop and see all the different pouches and products, that cannot happen anymore. We are also putting in a ban on advertisements in shops. We are doing a lot of work on this. I know what Senators are saying and that we should look at the long-term measures, such as licences, going forward. I understand the Senators' concerns. These are really good initiatives. This is about our children. I am delighted to see the school in the Visitors Gallery today because I am talking about pouches and nicotine and it is lovely to see a class here. It is important that we legislate on this. We want to keep our children healthy.

We are here as part of a health-led approach. That is why this Bill is very important.

On another matter that Senator McDowell brought up, the Government first announced these proposals in 2024. The Senator said that there was not enough time. The Government announced its intention to extend this to all nicotine products almost a year ago. Following enactment, the Minister will decide on this. I understand the Senator's concern but we have to get this Bill done so that no child under 18 will be able to purchase a pouch or similar product.

I do not propose to accept either of the two amendments.

Comment on this

I am disappointed by that reaction. What I am seeking to achieve is limited control. I seek to put people who are complying with the law and paying €1,000 to apply for a licence and another €1,000 every year to continue selling on roughly the same football pitch as people who are not prohibited by these laws from selling these products to adults. The Government has to ask itself whether it is looking around any corners at all. For instance, are we really aiming for it to be possible to sell nicotine pouches to adults without regulation? Is there some problem relating to our relationship with the European Union or in the bureaucracy of our own Government that means we cannot look at all of this in the round and come up with a rational set of rules that do not put law-abiding retailers at a disadvantage while allowing those who are not regulated free rein?

I have to accept the ruling of the Chair, so I am not going to argue about Standing Order 42. However, I have to make the point that this is a partial measure and that a more appropriate regulatory regime is needed. This kind of incremental approach is crab-like. It is nibbling at the edges of a problem.

While it is slightly outside the scope of this legislation, I want to say this; as a former Minister for justice and as a liberal, I have always wondered whether arguments made in magazines like The Economist that the personal consumption of drugs should be decriminalised and left a matter of personal behaviour have any merit whatsoever. If you say that a 19-year-old can legitimately have cannabis in the house, how can you ensure a 14-year-old does not have access to it? We need a debate in this House on that report. I believe that the great majority of Senators are against that report even though Senator Ruane and others are passionately in favour of it. I believe that the great majority of people who have looked around a few corners do not agree with the decriminalisation of cannabis. I am particularly conscious of the fact of something I read in a newspaper the other day, which is that 30% of acute psychotic episodes are directly related to cannabis consumption. This is personality-destroying material. It is wholly unacceptable for us to say that it is up to individuals to deal with this and that it should be available to 19-year-olds without consequence and that, if it ends up in the hands of a 14-year-old, it is parents who should be trying to stop it rather than the police.

I have said as much as I can say, even it if it was a bit outside the scope of the Bill. I accept that the Minister of State's Department looks at things from a health perspective, but if we are not clearly willing to stop drug pushers from facilitating personal consumption of drugs - I fully accept that is a matter of criminal law and a question for the Department of justice - it will result in deep-seated confusion. In my view, that report from the drugs committee is going in the wrong direction and needs to be debated in this House. The public needs to be very clear that it is not going to be public policy or Government policy that the possession of controlled drugs for personal use will be decriminalised in the manner suggested.

Comment on this

I sat on that drugs committee and I would welcome a debate in the Seanad. There was not unanimous agreement. People did voice concerns. I have similar concerns to Senator McDowell's. It was not the case that everybody said we should make it legal; it certainly was not like that. There were differing opinions. I came into the group late because I was elected later. I would 100% welcome a debate on the report.

Comment on this

It is important to state today that it is illegal to take drugs. I will certainly speak to my colleague, the Minister, Deputy Jim O'Callaghan. It is important to have the conversation Senator McDowell suggested with the Minister in here.

On amendment No. 3, which has been ruled out of order, I will just say that the licensing system was introduced in 2023. It only came into full operation in August of this year. To accept this amendment would mean starting a whole new EU notification process. It is important that we get the Bill through so that children are not able to go into shops and legally buy pouches or similar products. That is what this is about.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State and fully support what she has just said. I understand the significance and importance of getting this through today but perhaps, in the future, the Government could look separately at linking the licence for pouches to the existing licence.

Comment on this

Yes, we certainly will.

Comment on this

Pouches are being sold in the corners of shops - I will not say "back rooms" - and people are getting access to them. It is not only adults who are buying them. It is about trying to regularise what is happening out there.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 5, between lines 27 and 28, to insert the following:

“(4) Notwithstanding subsection (3), any provision of this Act that introduces new obligations or restrictions relating to—

(a) the retail sale,

(b) advertising,

(c) display,

(d) packaging or appearance, or

(e) product presentation,

of nicotine inhaling products or nicotine consumption products shall not come into operation earlier than 12 months after the date of the passing of this Act.”.

Comment on this

On section 5, I just want to indicate to the Chair that the Standing Orders of this House and of Dáil Éireann require reviews at the end of every year after any legislation is passed irrespective of any requirement for a three-year review, as provided for here.

I am not letting that slip.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

That will be taken into account and the Minister of State is in agreement.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendment No. 3 in the name of Senator McDowell has already been ruled out of order.

Comment on this
Maria Byrne An Leas-Chathaoirleach Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 4 to 6, inclusive, are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

In page 28, to delete lines 8 to 39 and substitute the following:

“Flavour names and descriptions of nicotine inhaling products and nicotine consumption products

32F.(1) A person shall not sell by retail a nicotine inhaling product or nicotine consumption product with a flavour name or variant name unless that name consists exclusively of one or two words specified in the Schedule.

(2) Subject to subsection (3), the Minister may, by regulation, add flavour words to the Schedule or remove flavour words specified in the Schedule.

(3) When making regulations under subsection (2), the Minister shall, having regard to public health and to the objectives of reducing harm from tobacco products and nicotine inhaling products and prioritising the protection of health of children, take the following matters into account:

(a) the need to limit flavour names that may disproportionately appeal to children;

(b) evidence relating to flavours for nicotine inhaling products and smoking cessation, initiation and continuation of nicotine inhaling product use, or harm to health relating to nicotine inhaling products;

(c) the prevalence of smoking of tobacco and use of nicotine inhaling products in both children and adults, and the demographics of children and adults who smoke tobacco or use nicotine inhaling products;

(d) evidence of the effectiveness, and other impacts, of the restrictions concerning flavour names for nicotine inhaling products contained in this Act.

(4) A person who contravenes subsection (1) commits an offence.”.

I wish to speak to amendments Nos. 4 and 5. Before I go into the specific mechanics of these changes, I feel compelled to express a deep, fundamental scepticism about the entire architecture of section 21 as it is currently presented to us. When you read through the text of this Bill as initiated, it becomes increasingly clear that there are some glaring structural holes here that risk making the entire exercise completely ineffectual. It seems to me, looking at the wording of the proposed section 32F, that the entire scope of this regulation concerns product labelling alone, not the physical product itself. We are spending hours meticulously policing the commercial vocabulary, the text assets and the marketing names printed on the piece of cardboard. What does the Bill do to regulate the chemical liquid inside the tank?

If a manufacturer conforms to every single packaging rule, wraps its product in a plain, Government-prescribed drab box and legally labels the text as flavour name "unflavoured" or flavour name "tobacco", but fills that physical liquid with high-intensity synthetic sweeteners or strawberry or banana flavours, has the manufacturer committed an offence under the text? I do not see how it has. We are passing a law that polices the dictionary by leaving the chemical formulations completely untouched. You could argue that restricting the flavour names is basically restricting the flavours, as arguably you cannot sell a menthol-flavoured vape under a tobacco-flavoured label. However, companies could readily work around this by putting the actual flavour name in the description or the variant name.

If we look closely at the wording of subsection (5) on page 28, the Bill states that a variant name cannot imply a sensory characteristic or an unpermitted flavour. What happens if a retailer or manufacturer completely abandons abstract wordplay and hints? What if, instead of implying a taste, it prints a literal, overt statement of manufacturing fact? What if the box explicitly reads, "This product contains a 2% synthetic berry additive"? In Irish statutory interpretation, explicitly stating a fact is the exact opposite of implying it. Maybe I am missing something here. Perhaps the Government can point to something, a cross-cutting section, some other law or general precedent, that completely plugs this gap. If it can, I will happily stand corrected and withdraw my scepticism. As the text reads on the page today, it looks like a wide-open invitation for the industry to bypass the spirit of the law using neutral, literal declarations.

To be clear, I support the retention of flavours, as others have rightly stated in the Chamber today. These variations play a vital role in helping adult smokers permanently quit cigarettes. We must draw a line when it comes to predatory marketing. The combination of garish, bright packaging and a complete free-for-all in names such as candy twist or bubblegum bliss goes entirely too far. As other Members have accurately mentioned, these tactics make vapes uniquely alluring to children. My support for flavour availability does not mean we should tolerate a marketing landscape designed to attract minors.

That brings me directly to why I believe my amendments are so important if this labelling regime is to have any functional teeth at all. If we are legally bound to a framework that can only police commercial naming conventions, we must ensure that those naming rules are comprehensive enough to incentivise compliance. We cannot pass a flawed, toothless ledger. Amendment No. 4 completely rewrites section 32F by adopting the successful operational model recently enacted in New Zealand. Instead of embroiling our health officers in endless subjective courtroom debates over whether a vague marketing word implies a fruit or an oral sensation, amendment No. 4 creates a flat, absolute rule: a flavour name or a variant name can only consist of words drawn directly from a standardised, permitted list in the Schedule. If a word is not sitting inside the specific statutory table, it is automatically illegal to print it on the box. It encourages the industry to avoid semantic workarounds and instead to work within a frame that will limit the more absurd excesses of our flavour free-for-all. This is paired directly with amendment No. 5, which expands the Schedule table from the Minister's current, highly restrictive two-word cap into a comprehensive, plain-text list of basic botanical and standard fruit terms such as mint, menthol, apple, berry and citrus.

Capping the list at only "tobacco" and "unflavoured" is a dangerous policy that will instantly trigger a massive, uncontrollable black market in illicit sweet vapes smuggled from abroad, completely blind to age verification. By expanding the list to basic, plain descriptors, we allow adult smokers a versatile path to cessation. Because the rest of the Bill's plain packaging rules apply, these products will be sold in ugly, uniform boxes, completely stripped of silly titles like bubblegum bliss or cloud 9.

Amendment No. 4 explicitly retains the mechanism for ministerial adjustments by regulation, empowering the Minister for Health to add or remove words from the Schedule as the public health evidence base evolves. This is a pragmatic compromise. It protects our children from predatory marketing language while protecting our regulatory framework from embarrassing industrial loopholes. I urge the Minister to accept these amendments. This one is a practical amendment, which the Minister of State may not even have thought of.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State for coming in as we progress through this Bill. I support 99.9% of this Bill. It takes a fantastic, health-led approach. I support banning disposable vapes. I support 100% banning products, packaging and advertising designed to appeal to children. I have two children and I would not want to see them vaping. No one wants to see children vaping. I support getting rid of all the vape shops from our town centres and main streets. They have taken over, which is not fair on other businesses around them, and it is making vapes readily accessible to children.

However, I have concerns about banning every flavour. I will speak particularly to our amendment, to research I have done and to studies of what has been done in other countries. The Healthy Ireland survey in 2025 found that, among people who vape, 59% use fruit flavours, 25% use mint or menthol and 17% use tobacco flavours.

Why are we banning every flavour except tobacco? This is a Healthy Ireland survey that was done here. I will move on to the research I have done with other countries. That is why I am urging the Minister of State to look at accepting the amendment so it is not punishing adults for trying to protect our children.

A 2026 British survey found that fruit flavours were preferred by 60% of former smokers who are now vaping. Many adults are using vapes as an alternative to stop smoking. We know that vaping is not risk free but evidence indicates it is substantially less harmful than smoking so we need to understand whether removing the preferred flavours can lead to former smokers returning to flavours or having to purchase them on the black market. I compare it to an off-licence. It is like telling an off-licence that it can only sell Guinness because it is black and it cannot sell WKD because it is brightly coloured and it may appeal to children. We do not tackle underage drinking by telling adults what they can drink or what they are allowed to have. We can regulate who buys it, how it is advertised and how it is sold, but if we are looking more seriously at how we approach it here, we have to look at evidence from other countries. There are certain parts of this that are going too far.

Menthol and fruit flavours are very common, even if there was only one of each and they were in black plain packaging, behind closed doors or whatever it is that needs to happen. In Estonia, they introduced vape flavour restrictions in 2019. In 2020, they went back and then they subsequently allowed menthol flavour. In Denmark, they allow tobacco and menthol flavours. This demonstrates that tobacco-only is not the sole regulatory approach. The Netherlands introduced a tobacco-only flavour restriction in January 2024. A 2026 survey found that 47.2% of the surveyed people who continued vaping were using prohibited products so they went to source them on the black market. It raises the question about enforcement, cross-border purchase and informal supply. Has the Minister of State looked at what other countries are doing? Estonia subsequently permitted menthol. Is this something that we can look at?

I do not want to delay this legislation coming in. I understand there are massive health benefits, but for the likes of a 50-year-old man or woman who managed to give up smoking successfully and is using this as a nicotine replacement therapy, we are now going to tell them that they must only smoke tobacco flavour or else they will not get any other flavours ever again.

Have we looked at plain packaging for vape products, locked cabinets, behind doors, as I said, and no colourful displays? None of those things are needed and they appeal to children. An adult does not care about what colour packages they are coming in. A lot of people are vaping for cost reasons and then other people are doing it for health reasons.

The important points I need answered are as follows. The Irish proposal permits tobacco flavoured and unflavoured vape. The strongest argument is that if we are banning all the flavours of vapes, where are we going to end up with this legislation? Are we going to have to revisit it in a year's time because we see the detrimental impact it has? If we want to continue with a health-led approach, we do not want to see ex-smokers having to return to smoking. We also want to see that we are not punishing adults. If adults choose to drink, they choose to smoke or they choose to vape, we have to be able to provide that they have an option to do it. I would like to see an approach where vape products in menthol flavour and fruit flavour would be put behind closed doors, but let us not punish adults who are choosing to do this for health reasons.

Comment on this

The Minister of State will know my stance on this. I do not agree with it. I would be of the exact same view as Senator McCormack. This Bill is overreaching. It is turning towards the nanny-state policy.

The Minister of State keeps mentioning children. Nobody wants kids to vape or to smoke, to do drugs or to drink alcohol, but you are going to punish every single person that uses a vape, whether to give up cigarettes or because they are over the age of 18 and they figure they have the legal right, they are over 18, they can use a vape if they want, and they can use it with a flavour in it. It took nearly 20 years from vapes coming out to bring in a Bill to say that under-18s should not have them, which I thought was complete madness. I assumed, because there was nicotine, under-18s should not have them, but they were being sold. It is as if the next Bill that comes along is going to have to be for a one-flavour alcohol, because it is not fair to say to somebody who is vaping that there is one flavour and that is it, that if they do not like it, they do not get it. I do not see why you could not do it with alcohol as well. I do not see why you could not do it with cigarettes.

Cigarettes have been around for so many years, well before my time. The Minister of State will know exactly, and can probably pinpoint, when we realised that cigarettes were not good for health. Never once did this State say that it would ban cigarettes or it would ban every single brand of cigarettes except for Silk Cut Ultra because it has the least amount of damage in it, apparently. There was never anything like that. The most the Government did was introduce the smoking ban in public areas, in pubs and restaurants, which I completely agree with. There is nothing worse than being a non-smoker and being stuck inside in that smell, with it on your clothes or the health effects of passive smoking. The Government also changed the packaging. However, none of that is being done for vapes. There is so much money being made on cigarettes. In 2025, there was €841.7 million in tax on cigarettes, and the Government is estimating €17 million a year on vapes. It is as if the State does not care if people go back on cigarettes, and that is what is going to happen. I have heard from so many people. With the Dutch model that Senator McCormack mentioned, two years in they found that youth vaping more than doubled after the ban.

The Minister of State will push this through. We do not have a hope in hell of stopping it but I want it on the record when I stood up and told her so, and she can look back and see exactly when I told her so because that is what is going to happen. Nobody is listening. The Minister of State is not listening to any of the vaping companies. She is not listening to any of the retailers. The Minister of State is not listening to the people who use vaping. I do not mean that the Minister of State is not listening to the children because they should not be getting them in the first place. Shame on any retailer who sells to under-18s, the same way they should not sell alcohol to under-18s. This is a collective punishment and it is not right. I see it sometimes in schools where one student is misbehaving and the whole class gets punished. That is exactly what is happening with this Bill because the Minister of State is taking the option away from people who gave up cigarettes. They will not be able to vape. They will go back on cigarettes.

I will be adding to that tax of €841.7 million because, when the flavours go, I will not be vaping tobacco flavour because I tried that at the start. I will go back on cigarettes because I enjoyed smoking when I smoked and I am not going to lie about it. I only gave them up because of the cost, but if I cannot get something that is cheaper, I will have to go back to something. It sounds awful, but it never affected my health. I enjoyed smoking and I am not going to pretend, stand up here and say I did not, or pretend to be holier than thou and I am not going to do something I am not supposed to do, but I was never told I was not allowed to smoke because it was not illegal. It was not banned, it was never restricted and so I do not understand why the flavours are the big bugbear.

There is still never going to be a mention of an outright ban on cigarettes. Eventually, the Government will look at phasing it out, but it is 100 years, or probably more, since cigarettes were around and before that there was something else that was bad for your health. If it will take that long to bring a phasing out of cigarettes, how is it only taking this length to get rid of the flavoured vapes? I will put it down to money. I think it is that the Government is not getting enough tax on it. It is very unfair to do something because of tax revenue.

Comment on this

I listened to what Senator Collins said. I respect her decisions and that she wants to smoke, but I understand why the flavours are being restricted. You only have to drive past kids going to school and they are vaping.

The health implications are huge. Senator Collins spoke about tax and getting the tax income but what are we paying in our health service for the damage done because of cigarettes and vapes? What is that costing the State? It is costing a huge amount of money. The misery and the pain people go through with a lung cancer diagnosis is horrific. I would love it if nobody smoked. It is a horrible thing to see. I understand that people have the habit and that it is their decision. I respect that but if there is any way we can stop younger people from developing an addiction to it, and if that means removing the flavours, then I am all for it. I actually do not like the smell of vapes. I can get the smell of a vape a mile away and I do not like that kind of smell. I empathise with the Senator because I would probably be the same if somebody told me to give up my gin and tonic. I get what Senator Collins is saying but I do not think she appreciates the impact the smoking ban had. The Senator kind of brushed over that when she was talking. I think the smoking ban was one of the best things ever brought in to our country, without a shadow of a doubt. When I worked in a pub around that time, people were so resistant to it. There was a huge amount of resistance to it but it was one of the best decisions ever made for Ireland. I keep going back to costs. That ban saved us an awful lot of money. A lot of people gave up cigarettes at that point and cigarettes became quite unfashionable. Vapes, however, are fashionable and they are everywhere. They have all got them. It is just unnecessary for kids to be doing it. I understand that Senator Collins is trying to stop smoking and move on to them, but do we really know the full health implications of vapes, even now? I support the removal of the flavours but then I look at the Senator in the knowledge that I do not vape, so I respect her for standing up and voicing her opinion.

Comment on this

I thank Senator Keogan and our Sinn Féin Senators for amendments Nos. 4 to 6, inclusive. I will take them together. The first piece, which we have spoken about, is the flavours. Research from other countries has shown that existing users respond to flavour restrictions in different ways. We have been monitoring this. These ways include switching to permitted flavours; sourcing flavoured e-liquids elsewhere; quitting vaping; quitting all nicotine products, including tobacco; or switching to other nicotine products, including tobacco. The most relevant evidence for Ireland comes from the Netherlands, which found that the ban on all flavours except tobacco led to overall decreases in both vaping and smoking. This is working with other countries.

There are two amendments that seek to increase the range of flavours in the Schedule. Amendment No. 6 refers to menthol. We had this amendment in the Dáil. I did not accept it there and I will not accept it here. The amendment was brought in there as well. I appreciate that the intention behind the proposal is to ensure that we do not discourage smokers who wish to switch from cigarettes or tobacco to these products. Tobacco flavour and unflavoured are the flavours we have chosen because they are the least likely to appeal to our younger people. We are going by the data and working from all the different surveys. The data from Healthy Ireland shows that tobacco is the least popular flavour among 15- to 24-year-olds but the most popular for those over the age of 45. This data makes it clear that tobacco flavour is more important for our adults, some of whom smoke or used to smoke, but it is not likely to attract our younger people. The position is different with menthol. Our Healthy Ireland survey data shows us that it is the second most popular flavour category from ages 15 to 24 years, with one in four purchasing them. Again, apologies to the Senator but I cannot accept that.

We are looking at a tobacco-free generation. Tobacco is a product that causes lots of illnesses. It causes almost 100 deaths and 1,000 hospitalisations every week in Ireland so there is no age at which it becomes safe to consume tobacco. I really believe that this is what we are trying to get out here today. This is what we are saying. It does not matter how old you are; it is not good for your health. We are health led. Our national tobacco control policy for a tobacco-free Ireland is currently being reviewed. We are reviewing that as it is. One of the central goals would be to set out a pathway to end tobacco-related harm in Ireland. My officials and I are considering all measures to fulfil this objective, including a generational ban. That is the other one too.

Senator Keogan brought up a lot of the flavours. Our Bill restricts flavours by controlling the flavour names that are used. This is the most efficient approach to enforcement. Other countries have regulated the ingredients of vaping liquids or other flavours. Again, it is all down to experience.

We are very mindful of people who smoke. We are not forgetting people who smoke. This law is taking place. We are looking at the free stop-smoking medicine, which we have spoken about, and the nicotine replacement therapy for anyone who wants to use it. There is also the free We Can Quit programme to help people to stop. Flavours are banned in cigarettes. We do not have flavoured cigarettes.

I can see the commitment from all the Senators here today. They understand it is so important now with the pouches, the colours, the flavours and the packaging that we get this Bill enacted as soon as possible. I will not be accepting amendments Nos. 4 to 6, inclusive. I thank all the Senators for their work on this. It is very important that we try to move this Bill as soon as possible.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State. Before we move on, I welcome the guests of Senator Eileen Lynch from the Macroom Active Retirement Association. You are all very welcome to the Seanad.

Comment on this

I wish to comment on the Minister of State's remarks. If they fill the product - the physical liquid - with synthetic sweeteners such as strawberry or banana flavours, will they have committed an offence under the text of this legislation? If companies can readily work around this by putting an actual flavour name in the description or in the variant rule, will they have broken the legislation?

Comment on this

My understanding is that they will have broken the law. There is no EU law or regulations yet, but it is something we are looking at. I need to check. Again, this is about enforcement and how we do this. It is something I will definitely come back to the Senator on. There is no EU law or regulation on ingredients-----

Comment on this

Very simply, this legislation is basically policing the labelling of the product, not the actual product itself. Therefore, what is in the tank can be whatever - it can be flavoured - but the labelling could say something different.

Comment on this

That is just other jurisdictions. Remember, we are separate here. At the end of the day it is like online-----

Comment on this

We are not separate. This is our legislation.

Comment on this

Yes, but with what we are doing here it is important that we do not break any rules or regulations, again through enforcement. This Bill is just about selling pouches or other products to under 18s. That is it. What the Senator is asking me-----

Comment on this

I get that but I honestly believe-----

Comment on this

-----is something that will have to be addressed through other-----

Comment on this

I believe we will be revisiting this because the manufacturers out there will look at every trick in the book to keep people addicted to these products.

Comment on this

It is a worry to think that we are saying that these are bad for you and that they are looking at this. This would be the worry from our point of view as legislators. I compliment the retailers. Senator McDowell spoke about them in his amendments. The bulk of the retailers are very good, in fairness. What I am saying is-----

Comment on this

I am not worried about the retailers; I am worried about the manufacturers.

Comment on this

I know but that is what we are regulating.

Comment on this

It is the manufacturers.

Comment on this
Shane Curley Acting Chairperson Fianna Fáil

I will let Senator Keogan back in but can we allow the Minister of State to finish first?

Comment on this

I am sorry. I appreciate what the Minister of State has said, but I am not worried about the retailers. I am worried about the manufacturers. This is really what I am worried about. What it says on the label is one thing, but what is actually in the product itself is another. The Minister of State is legislating for the boxes and the packaging, but not for what is actually in the product. Is this correct?

Comment on this

That is something totally different. I know what Senator Keogan is saying but why would a manufacturer want to put something different on the box? Why would they do that?

Comment on this

The EU is looking at addressing flavours and ingredients. We are working with our EU counterparts. As I said, our legislation is about health and well-being and making sure that young people are not able to go into a shop and buy pouches or other similar products. Unfortunately, we will have to work with our EU counterparts on this. We are very well ahead of other EU counterparts on pouches and vaping. I see what Senator Keogan is saying but this is an EU law matter and not part of the remit of the Bill. However, I will absolutely look into it for her. I would not like to think that there is inaccurate labelling.

Comment on this

I understand Senator Keogan's point. The packaging aspect is very important because it is the packaging that attracts younger people to the product. I would not be dismissive of the strong focus on packaging and flavouring because these are what attract younger people. The nicotine is in the product itself and, having been taken in by the flavour and the packaging, people become addicted. It is imperative that this proposal is passed today. Handing out nicotine products for free at festivals is deplorable and is aimed at young people. I have had it up to here with products that are damaging to young people being aimed at them. I have been raising the issue of nitrous oxide since 2020. It is only in the past year or so that we have come to understand the drastic impact on health that nitrous oxide abuse has. Again, the packaging is designed to appeal to people aged 18 and under. It looks like a fun product to try. As a non-smoker, I look at vapes and think they seem quite harmless and pretty and not as dangerous to health as they are. I fully understand where Senator Keogan is coming from on the harmful product being sold but I do think it is the packaging of the product is what attracts people.

Comment on this

I am disappointed that the Minister of State is not accepting the amendment, even just to open the door to flavours. I would like to think that down the line, when this goes belly up, the Minister of State would open the door and add in some flavours. It is great for those aged over 45 who like tobacco flavour but it is unfortunate for those aged under 45 who do not. I am sure they will find something else, perhaps from outside the State. I am sure they will figure it out. Will the Minister of State give us a timeline? I am thinking not only of people who will bulk buy and stock up on flavours but also of vape shop owners and the staff they employ with regard to giving them some idea as to how long they will be employed. This will shut down a lot of businesses. By no means am I saying that I feel more sorry for one sector than another but it will close an awful lot of shops. Will the Minister of State give us a timeline as to when this will be finalised and fully enacted? I am disappointed that the entire measure is being centred on not selling to kids when it is already against the law to sell to kids. It is being dealt with wrongly, using the idea of not getting kids vaping as a mask. There is already a law whereby they should not be vaping. Having a flavour should not make a difference.

Comment on this

Senator Keogan's amendment does not regulate ingredients. This was not part of the amendment so when she brought up the ingredients, I was thinking that it was not part of the amendment. The Bill has nothing to do with the ingredients. We are working with our EU counterparts and expect some updates on ingredients from the EU by December. I will know more for Senator Keogan then. I thank her for raising the issue of ingredients because it is something we know we need to address.

On the timing, the main purpose of passing the Bill is to have the restrictions on the pouches and other products quite quickly. Within a few weeks we could have a prohibition on selling pouches or other products to those aged under 18, which is very important. The Minister for Health will then decide on a lead-in period of perhaps six or 12 months. There is no question but that there will be a lead-in period. The main thing is to deal with the pouches and other products first, as quickly as possible, and have a legislative measure to prohibit selling them. There will be a lead-in period for the other measures and the Minister, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, will sign off on this. I will come back to the Senators on this but it will be at least a few months, if not longer.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:

In page 34, to delete lines 2 to 8 and substitute the following:

SCHEDULE

PERMITTED FLAVOUR WORDS FOR NICOTINE INHALING PRODUCTS AND NICOTINE CONSUMPTION PRODUCTS

Flavour Name in the English Language | Flavour Name in the Irish Language

Tobacco | Tobac

Unflavoured | Gan Bhlas

Mint | Mionas

Menthol | Meantól

Apple | Úll

Banana | Banana

Berry | Caor

Cherry | Silín

Citrus | Citreas

Coconut | Cnó Cóco

Grape | Fíonchaor

Lemon | Líomóid

Lime | Líoma

Mango | Mangó

Melon | Mealbhacán

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:

In page 34, between lines 5 and 6, to insert the following:

Menthol | Meantól

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put

Tá 7
·
Níl 28
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

When is it proposed to take the next Stage?

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

When is it proposed to take the next Stage?

Comment on this
Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this