Fuel Costs: Motion
Sinn Féin called for an extra 10-cent-per-litre cut to petrol and diesel excise, removal of carbon tax on home heating oil, and further targeted support for households and fuel-dependent sectors. Senators argued that current measures were inadequate amid soaring costs, especially for rural households with few transport alternatives. The Government’s amendment defended its €1.7 billion support package, fuel allowance increases and extended excise reductions, while citing EU tax rules and the need to reduce dependence on fossil fuels. The exchange became acrimonious; no vote outcome is shown in this section.
The time limit for the combined speeches of the proposer and seconder shall not exceed 16 minutes. All other Senators will have six minutes. I call on Senator McCormack to move the motion.
Comment on this
I move:
That Seanad Éireann:
notes that:
- workers and families continue to face severe cost-of-living pressures, with rising petrol, diesel and home heating costs placing an enormous strain on household finances;
- petrol and diesel prices have reached over €2 per litre in parts of the State, placing significant additional costs on workers, families, commuters and small businesses;
- hundreds of thousands of workers and families, particularly in rural Ireland, depend on their cars for work, education, childcare and essential everyday journeys, with limited or no access to reliable public transport alternatives;
- approximately 700,000 households rely on home heating oil, with the cost of filling a home heating oil tank reaching as much as €1,600;
- Budget 2027 extended existing temporary reductions in excise duty of 27 cent per litre on petrol and 32 cent per litre on diesel until the end of February 2027 but failed to introduce any further reduction in the price of fuel at the pumps;
- the Government intends to begin restoring these excise duties from February 2027, with full restoration by the end of June 2027, exposing motorists to further increases in fuel costs;
- Budget 2027 reduced carbon tax on home heating oil from €63.50 to €48.50 per tonne of carbon dioxide, delivering an estimated saving of €43 on a 1,000-litre fill, while families continue to face substantial heating bills;
- despite the strength of the State’s finances, Budget 2027 failed to deliver the level of immediate relief required by households struggling with the cost of fuel and home heating;
- Sinn Féin proposed an additional 10 cent per litre reduction in petrol and diesel prices, the removal of carbon tax from home heating oil, and a reduction in the price of green diesel at the pumps to support sectors such as agriculture and construction;
- people who rely on the fuel allowance will be worse off this winter despite the €5 increase due to the fact that the fuel allowance season will be short this winter;
- despite commitments from the Tánaiste on budget day that there will be no increase at the pumps this winter, the reintroduction of the National Oil Reserves Agency levy at the end of December means that people will face higher prices this winter;
recognises that:
- access to affordable transport and home heating is essential to the daily lives of workers, families, older people and communities across the State;
- high fuel costs disproportionately impact rural households, lower-income workers, people with disabilities and those who have no realistic alternative to private transport;
- temporary extensions of existing fuel tax reductions provide some relief but do not address the immediate financial pressures caused by persistently high fuel prices;
- the transition to cleaner and more sustainable energy must be fair and must not leave workers and families carrying unaffordable costs;
calls on the Government to:
- introduce an immediate additional 10 cent per litre reduction in the price of petrol and diesel through further reductions in excise duty;
- commit to maintaining existing reductions in petrol and diesel excise duty and not proceeding with their planned restoration while fuel prices remain exceptionally high;
- remove the carbon tax from home heating oil to provide further immediate relief to households facing substantial heating bills;
- introduce additional targeted supports for households experiencing fuel poverty, particularly older people, low-income families and those dependent on home heating oil;
- provide the maximum reductions in the cost of agricultural diesel and support measures for hauliers, farmers and other sectors particularly exposed to high fuel costs;
- publish an assessment of the impact of high fuel prices on workers, families, rural communities and small businesses, together with proposals for further targeted relief; and
- develop a long-term strategy to reduce household dependence on expensive fossil fuels through investment in affordable public transport, home energy upgrades and renewable energy, while ensuring that workers and families are protected from excessive costs during the transition.
Comment on this
We have brought this Sinn Féin motion to the Seanad because we recognise the frustration for families and workers. They know that the budget two weeks ago did not do anything to help with the costs of petrol, diesel, gas, electricity bills or home heating oil. Petrol, diesel and home heating oil costs are placing an enormous strain on household finances. Petrol and diesel have reached well over €2 per litre in some places. Ordinary people, particularly in rural Ireland, depend on their cars for work, education, childcare and everyday essential journeys, with limited or no access to reliable public transport alternatives. Approximately 700,000 households rely on home heating oil, with the cost of filling a home heating oil tank reaching as high as €1,600.
This motion calls for a number of things the Government could do to ease the burden as the cost-of-living crisis continues. I am not happy with the amendment put forward that basically wipes out the full motion we have put forward but I am still going to speak to the motion we have put forward. One of the measures in our motion would have introduced an immediate additional 10 cent per litre reduction in the price of petrol and diesel through further reductions in excise duty. Another measure we are calling for is to remove all carbon tax from home heating oil to provide further immediate relief to households facing substantial heating bills - basic heating bills.
This Government told us its budget is about making work pay. I ask the Minister of State one very simple question: how is work supposed to pay when people can barely afford the diesel to get there? Recently, a good friend of mine who is a nurse sent me a picture at the petrol station with a photograph of the pump. She had just filled her car and the diesel cost €138. The caption under it read, “Beans on toast for me for the next month.” That is €138 to fill her tank. I looked at that photograph and thought this is exactly what is wrong with the cost-of living in this country. Here is a woman who goes out to work, looks after sick people, contributes to our health service and pays her taxes. Before she can even earn a day’s wages, she has to find money to get to work. This is what the Government is failing to see, the struggles people are under. This woman is not driving around for the fun of it or living some extravagant lifestyle; she is going to work. That €138 has to come out of the same wages that pay her mortgage, electricity, groceries and everything else, and she is not alone. There are thousands of nurses, healthcare assistants, carers, factory workers, retail workers and tradespeople facing the exact same thing. We saw them on our streets last week. It is shameful how the Government is responding to this.
I come from County Laois and I can tell the Minister of State that, for many people living in rural Ireland, a car is not a luxury, it is a lifeline. People need a car to get to work, bring their children to school, get to hospital appointments and do the weekly shop. They do not have a bus outside the door like they do in the big cities, we do not have a train that gets us to work, and we certainly do not all have the option of leaving the car at home.
When the Government representatives talk about making work pay, I want them to remember my friend, the nurse, standing at that diesel pump, putting €138 into her car and having that disappear from her bank account. Before anyone across this House criticises this motion, I want them to think of my friend, who is a nurse, putting €138 into her car. How is she supposed to make work pay? That is the reality of working life for so many people.
There is something else that happened in the budget that I am particularly angry about: the fuel allowance. I want people listening to understand exactly what happened here. On budget day, the Government proudly announced a whopping €5 increase in the weekly fuel allowance - €5 extra a week. I am sure there were pensioners and families watching at home thinking at least that is something. However, what the Government did not talk about is that, last season, the fuel allowance was extended by four weeks. People received €1,216 in total. Under this new budget, the weekly rate goes from €38 to €43 - sounds like an increase, does it not? - but the payment goes back to 28 weeks. You really tricked the people, but they see it. Minus those four weeks, people will now receive €1,204. You actually screwed the people by trying to tell them you were increasing the allowance by €5 but you cut the four weeks off. That is €12 less than they got last time. The Government will tell us that last year's four-week extension was temporary. Fine, but that does not change the reality for the person trying to heat their home, and things have not got better since last year, they have got worse. You cannot heat your home with a headline, and that is what the Government was trying to do. You cannot fill an oil tank with a budget announcement, and you certainly cannot tell people they are getting more money when the total going into their pocket is actually less than they received last year.
We are talking about some of the most vulnerable people in our society who receive the fuel allowance.
They include older people living alone, people with disabilities, families already struggling to put food on the table and people who are watching the oil in their tank drop and are genuinely frightened about how they will afford to fill it again. We have approximately 700,000 households depending on home heating oil. The Government tells us that it has reduced carbon tax on home heating oil, with an estimated saving of €43 on 1,000 litres. Does the Minister of State know how much it is to fill a tank in Laois at the moment? It costs €1,600. Does he really think that getting €43 off that will make any difference to an elderly couple or someone living with a disability? What about the €5 increase they were tricked into thinking they were getting but they are not getting because the Government has really taken it away from them?
There is then the price at the pumps. The Government has extended the existing excise reductions until February but it has refused to deliver the additional ten cent per litre reduction that Sinn Féin proposed. From February, those existing reductions are due to start being reversed. By the end of June, the Government plans to have restored them fully. What happens then? What happens to my friend who is already paying €138 to fill her car? What happens to the farmer trying to keep the machinery running, the haulier transporting our goods, the small business owner who depends on a van? Let us not forget the reduced rate of the National Oil Reserves Authority, NORA, levy that is due to expire at the end of December. The Government needs to explain how that fits with its assurances about protecting motorists from further increases in winter because it does not make sense.
I fully support moving towards cleaner energy but the transition has to be fair to the people who live here. You cannot tell a family in rural Laois to stop driving when there is no reliable public transport available to them. It is different when you are in a big city but people forget about us in rural Ireland where things are very different. You cannot tell a pensioner to spend thousands of euro upgrading their heating system when they can barely afford to put oil in the tank that they already have. We need investment in public transport, home energy upgrades and renewable energy before we think of doing these things.
People need help now. That is why we have moved this motion. It is about something very simple, namely, giving ordinary people some breathing space by reducing fuel costs at the pumps and taking the carbon tax off home heating oil so that people do not get sick in their homes this winter and can actually afford to heat their houses. It is about supporting farmers, hauliers and working families and making sure that older people can heat their homes without fear.
The Government said that this budget was about making work pay. Work should do more than just about pay the bills. People should be able to work hard, provide for their families and have something left over. That is something very few people living in this country can do any more. Older people should be able to heat their homes without worrying about what they will have to sacrifice to pay for it. People should not have to make sacrifices in order to survive. We need to stop announcing increases that leave people with less and stop telling families how well the economy is doing when they cannot see any prosperity in their own bank accounts. We need to start giving people the relief they actually need.
I am so angry with how the budget has left people. I was only talking with my elderly aunt and trying to explain the budget to her. I was explaining the disability payment of €500 but because she turned 66 in July and moved onto the pension, she will not get this disability payment. The Government believes that when you have a disability in Ireland, it disappears when you turn 66. There is all this tricking that has gone on out there on the people and it is just not fair. I am not happy with the proposed amendment. We will be opposing it. I would like some serious, proper discussions about how we can help the likes of my friend who is a nurse putting €138 of fuel in her car and how she is supposed to sustain life in Ireland like this? Will she go to Canada like my other friends?
Comment on this
I completely echo everything Senator McCormack has said. The cost is scandalous at the moment. It is not just the cost of home heating oil, but also the cost of petrol and diesel on top of the everyday costs that everybody has, particularly someone from rural Ireland. The cost of groceries, electricity and everything else has gone up. On top of that, you get smacked with going to the pump and having to put that amount of money into your car, truck or van. It is scandalous.
We have moved motion, which makes very reasonable calls on the Government. They include further reductions in the excise duty on petrol and diesel and removing carbon tax on home heating oil, given that it is a punitive tax. These people have no choice but to put home heating oil in their homes. Their homes were built with boiler systems and cannot be upgraded to heat pumps because they are not insulated or airtight enough. It will cost an absolute fortune in electricity if they change from boilers right now. There is so much that has to be done to those houses to be able to move away from home heating oil.
Those people are being punished every single day by having to pay that much money. It is the carbon tax that is raising it. The Government could very easily take the carbon tax off the heating oil. We have been calling for that since February, but until the budget's €43, not one cent came off home heating oil. When the €43 came off, the cost went up again two days later by €150. That €43 was swallowed up within two days.
We looked for the maximum reduction in agricultural diesel. This is huge. When it comes to agricultural diesel, you are looking at taxing the production of food. When you tax the production of food, that eventually lands on the customer. The farmer cannot absorb every bit of that cost. The contractor cannot absorb all of that cost. It eventually goes into the supermarket and it is the customer paying for it, pushing up the cost of food. This is hitting every single house.
Affordable public transport was another request. That is not a big ask. Surely, affordable public transport should be in the programme for Government. We have public transport in County Limerick and I am trying to get a route extended by one stop to help college students go from County Limerick down to Munster Technological University, MTU, in Kerry. I have not got a reply yet. Students from Newcastle West actually dropped out of college last year because they could not get public transport and could not afford to drive. The Government is not helping the transition away from cars and fossil fuels. It is hindering it and stopping people from making this transition, given that there is not public transport.
On home heating upgrades, the Government talks about the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, SEAI, grants. Yes, some of them are great. If you are on a certain social welfare payment, they are fantastic. However, I know someone who is not on a social welfare payment and is getting insulation in their house. It costing them €24,000. They are getting a grant of €6,000. Where do they come up with the other money? It is great if they can afford it, but most families cannot afford to take out a loan. The bank would laugh at them. Every penny they make is literally going on living. They cannot do anything outside of their everyday. It is work, home, heat their home, put diesel in their car, back to work and home. Nobody is getting to properly live in this country.
I find the amendment and its requests of the Government quite pathetic. It says that the Government "will continue to keep the situation under review" and "will continue to respond in a way that protects those most vulnerable". What is protecting the most vulnerable? is it the fuel allowance that the Government cut by weeks? The fuel allowance has barriers in the way because if you are not on certain social welfare payments, you do not get it. If there is a husband or wife out working and the other parent stays at home, they are staying at home because they cannot afford to go to work, given that childcare is too expensive. They are not on a social welfare payment, so they do not get the fuel allowance. They are still low income but they do not get it because they are not on social welfare. There are deterrents everywhere when it comes to any bit of protection against the cost of fuel.
The amendment says that the Government "remains deeply concerned about the ongoing conflict in the Middle East and Gulf". Ireland is putting tax on petrol and diesel. I know that the Government cannot bring the price of the barrel down but it can reduce the taxes on it. The Government cannot keep saying that the situation in the Middle East is doing this. The Government of Ireland is doing it. The Government is putting tax on petrol and diesel. Every time the price of petrol and diesel goes up at the pump, the Government makes more money. The Government can take five cent off it and then, when it goes up by 15 cent, it gets more money. I cannot understand why the Government does not see this. I cannot understand how its members offices are not filled with people. I am around a lot of hauliers and every single one of them tells me that there are businesses going out of business. There are farmers who cannot afford to work the land. They cannot afford to produce food. There are contractors selling their machinery, yet the Government is sitting on its hands. I am sorry but what was given in the budget was sweet "F" all. It was nothing compared to what people needed. However, the Government gave something to the banks and private developers, but it did not give it to the people. The Government never gives it to the people. They just have to suffer on.
Let them pay the taxes so the banks can have a lower rate and no wealth tax is being put on the elite. The problem is the Government surrounds itself with the elite and does not speak to the people this is affecting. It does not see the damage that is being caused in this country every single day. Shame on the Senators with that amendment.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
To delete all the words after "That Seanad Éireann:" and substitute it with the following:
"recognises that the Government:
- remains deeply concerned about the ongoing conflict in the Middle East and Gulf and recognises that de-escalation will have the single greatest impact on reducing prices on home heating oil and other oil-based fuel products;
- continues to monitor increased energy prices that are felt across Europe and the globe;
- fully understands the pressures on households that have arisen due to rising petrol, diesel, and home heating costs and has continuously acted to allay these pressures;
- notes that successive Budgets have provided targeted support to help households with cost-of-living pressures and re-affirms that energy affordability is a priority for this Government;
- remains committed to decarbonising our society, increasing investment in renewable energy sources and recycling carbon tax revenues to protect those most vulnerable to fuel poverty through targeted welfare interventions;
- recognises Ireland’s obligations in respect of EU legislation pertaining to fossil fuel taxation and that abolition of the carbon tax may result in Ireland losing a derogation under European law;
- recognises Ireland’s obligations in respect of the EU Energy Taxation Directive;
- continues to use the funding from carbon tax to help farmers, businesses and households with increased energy prices;
- continues to monitor the economic impacts carefully, having already taken actions to mitigate energy increases, and provide certainty for families and businesses against the backdrop of global instability;
- continues to invest in retrofitting, boiler scrappage, wind energy and many other measures to help alleviate costs in the medium term;
notes that:
- the Government has delivered one of the largest support packages in the EU per head of capita, amounting to over €1.7 billion in supports from March 2026 to June 2027 to assist households and businesses;
- excise reductions have been extended until end February 2027 thereby maintaining, until then, a 30 cent per litre reduction in diesel and 25 cent per litre reduction in petrol;
- Budgets 2026 and 2027 have expanded fuel allowance payments to 50,000 more households and increased the weekly payment;
- the trajectory of the carbon tax has been altered to ease pressure on households with the rate on home heating oil and gas reduced and paused for the lifetime of the Government;
- a series of new schemes have been developed to help people make the transition away from fossil fuels;
confirms that the Government:
- will continue to keep the situation under review in the time ahead; and
- will continue to respond in a way that protects those most vulnerable to fuel poverty."
We could nearly call Private Members' motions from Sinn Féin the Marvel section of the Seanad. It is almost CGI economics at this stage because they are literally making it up as they go along. It is highly disrespectful. Nothing is grounded in facts. I am going to take issue with all of it. The Senators said they made respectful asks but they asked for nothing respectfully. They came in here and threw out every slur and every argument against the Government. The most hurtful thing of all is that they have set themselves up as the experts on fuel. In fairness, they have tradition in fuel. They laundered fuel for years. They terrorised the Border - the Senator need not smirk. They terrorised this country; small retailers like my family were terrorised.
Comment on this
Chairperson, can we stick to the motion, please?
Comment on this
I am accepting the Senator's capacity to speak to the fuel issue but what is the most hurtful of all-----
Comment on this
On a point of order, he is not discussing the motion.
Comment on this
He is not. He does this every single time he comes in here. He is not discussing the motion.
Comment on this
Same as Sinn Féin came in with a diatribe about the Government, I am going to give it.
Comment on this
Senator Flaherty without interruption, unless Senators want to use the Standing Orders.
Comment on this
I accept the Sinn Féin Senators' bona fides to speak about fuel but I cannot accept that they move a motion this week, the anniversary of the week that Paul Quinn was battered to death. That was 20 years ago yesterday by the Senators' cohorts, the fuel smugglers who are still associated and affiliated with their party. Even to this day they will not put their hands up and say what happened to that man, beaten mercilessly to death.
Comment on this
On a point of order, that is untrue. He should withdraw his comments now.
Comment on this
It is a statement of fact that young man was murdered and murdered in your heartland.
Comment on this
Are you accusing Sinn Féin of being involved in that murder?
Comment on this
Murdered in Sinn Féin's heartland and they know he was murdered.
Comment on this
I am taking nothing back. It is a statement of fact. The audacity of the Senators to mention fuel in the week of his 20th anniversary.
Comment on this
What about his family? What is he going to think of the Senators this week? And they set themselves up as the experts in fuel. They know a lot about fuel, all right, and they know an awful lot about terrorising.
Comment on this
Would the Senator speak to the motion? For God's sake.
Comment on this
They tell us we are the demons and we are the people who are wrong but we are not. We can stand proudly over our track record and what we did. We do not hide behind anything as Sinn Féin does.
Comment on this
Sinn Féin hides behind everything and tries to pull out a mask. Its position is slipping as the Opposition party. Its Members see everybody eating away at them and they are panicking. They are reaching out now to populism and anything that will help them regain ground.
Comment on this
That is why Fianna Fáil went into government with Fine Gael. Your popularity is slipping too.
Comment on this
Sinn Féin has no concept whatsoever of global commodity markets. It is oblivious to them and does not take any account of them at all. The Senators fail to recognise that the driving forces of home heating oil price increases are global in nature and accordingly it is not possible for us or any nation in Europe or elsewhere to fully absorb the impact of fuel increases. Sinn Féin also fails to take into account the obligations set out in EU legislation. I can accept why it does not because it did not believe in the EU for a long time and did not want it.
Comment on this
If other EU countries can go against the regulations then we can do it.
Comment on this
It was only when those in Sinn Féin realised the benefits it was giving to Ireland that suddenly they decided the EU is great and they would join it. For a long time they were going around in their woolly hats and their balaclavas, saying Europe is the big bad enemy. It was not and they knew well, but they have accepted it now. However, I can see that they still do not want to take account of some of their legislation.
Comment on this
I am not a gobshite. Chair, did you hear that? Did you hear what she called me?
Comment on this
As Senators are aware, the Standing Orders only allow interruption when the Senator in possession allows it. I ask Senators to respect the Standing Orders and allow the Senator in possession-----
Comment on this
He is supposed to speak to the motion.
Comment on this
I am speaking to the motion, very eloquently and very competently.
Comment on this
He is spending his time bashing Sinn Féin. It shows what he thinks of the public.
Comment on this
I am not reaching out to populism or making a diatribe as Sinn Féin usually does. The problem is that the Senators are getting lessons in facts.
Comment on this
Senators are not allowed to interrupt the Senator in possession unless he allows them.
Comment on this
Nor is she allowed to call me names. If I called one of them names there would be hysteria over there - hysteria. There would be a social media pile-on.
Comment on this
He is making false allegations here that have nothing to do with this motion.
Comment on this
I am not making false allegations. It is a well-known fact that Paul Quinn was battered to death in your heartland.
Comment on this
We have representatives from all over this island.
Comment on this
I am not making personal charges. I am making a statement of fact.
Comment on this
What I am speaking most vociferously about is the audacity, the sheer nerve and the sheer disrespect for the Quinn family that Sinn Féin moves a motion on fuel in the week of his 20th anniversary.
Comment on this
I remind Senators not to interrupt the Senator in possession unless they have the permission of the Senator, as per Standing Orders. Senator Flaherty, please, without interruption.
Comment on this
Sinn Féin does not give any account of the cost of €128 million; they just plucked it from the sky. Deputy Pearse Doherty was driving down from Donegal one day and he decided €128 million had a ring to it and they would go with that. The motion makes no allowance and does not tell us how this is going to impact on the Exchequer at all. The motion would actually negatively impact those households most at risk of fuel poverty. That is a fact but Sinn Féin ignores the facts. It does not deal in the facts and never did. All it dealt with down through the years was hatred.
The Sinn Féin motion does not reflect the range of measures introduced in budget 2027. According to the Senators, nothing happened. It was probably one of the most progressive budgets this country has seen. Nor does the Sinn Féin motion take into account the Government's decision earlier this year to pause the carbon tax on home heating oil at 2025 rates, or that the Government has delivered on a reduction of €43 in the price of a 1,000-litre fill of home heating oil. I know they are experts on the prices because they were at it down through the years. They drove the prices down and put loads of small retailers out of business as well because they were selling the contraband stuff. The reality is that we have a progressive approach to the property tax and we are tackling the property tax.
The Sinn Féin motion does not state that further increases in the carbon tax rate on home heating oil has been paused at 2023 levels because Sinn Féin does not like the facts. It is not convenient to state the facts, or to measure, announce or even support the steps we are taking. No matter what is done in this country, if it is in any way progressive, helpful or of assistance to the public, Sinn Féin will rally against it because it does not support its narrative that it is one for Sinn Féin, all for Sinn Féin. That does not work. They are seeing in the polls that people are kicking back at them and they do not like it. They can stay on the phone and text head office, and text them in Belfast and tell them they are having a problem down here, but I am telling them the facts. They came in here 20 years to the day that Paul Quinn was murdered over contraband fuel in Northern Ireland in the heartland of Sinn Féin. On the week of his anniversary, Sinn Féin has the audacity to come in here and move this motion. I respect the Senators' right to move the motion but for God's sake, have some conscience, some sense of responsibility and some respect for a family that lost their son in the vilest of circumstances.
Comment on this
I second amendment No. 1.
I welcome the opportunity to speak on the supports the Government has introduced to benefit the hard-pressed and those most in need of support. Over the past years and particularly the last 12 months, we have seen a pronounced shock in the price of fuel. It has affected home heating oil, the haulier industry and every single one of us, in particular those most hard-pressed and most vulnerable in our society. That is why earlier this year, the Government introduced a reduction of 27 cent per litre of petrol and 32 cent per litre of diesel, which has caused a marked improvement in reducing the cost of fuel for those who need help and support the most.
As a member of the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Climate, Environment and Energy and spokesperson for climate, energy and environment for Fine Gael here in the Seanad, I was very pleased to lead a Private Members' Bill a few weeks ago just ahead of the budget that called for specific measures, which were listened to by Government. I would like to acknowledge the support that we received on it. It is important to be clear with everyone that this fuel crisis has originated because of war in the Middle East, the Strait of Hormuz, the ongoing Russian aggression and war in Ukraine.
They have caused a shock to prices across the globe and Ireland is no different, but because of strong fiscal management as an economy, a Government and a country, we have been able to introduce a range of supports. That must be acknowledged on the public record. The warmer homes scheme is a 100% funded programme that provides retrofits, and supports full upgrades, for those who are most vulnerable and in receipt of the fuel allowance. That same fuel allowance has been increased in this budget and benefits 470,000 homes across the country. The most vulnerable, who are feeling the pinch because of the increase in costs, are eligible and will benefit from those improvements.
The Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, SEAI, earlier provided a briefing in the audiovisual room here. It has received €654 million. That will allow people to become more energy independent and be less exposed to the shock of increases in electricity costs through residential battery storage, PV panels, improved grants for insulation and other measures that can make sure households are not exposed to high energy bills. This needs to be acknowledged and recognised across the House by all parties because these targeted measures and effects can reduce electricity and home heating bills and benefit those most in need.
A Senator mentioned her friend who is a nurse and complained about the high cost of a fill of petrol. It is very high. No one disputes that cost, but the Government has introduced measures and interventions to reduce the cost of that bill. For that nurse, who is obviously under pressure, the budget has made a marked improvement with tax band changes. While I do not the full circumstances of that nurse, she could stand to benefit by at least €700 because of the tax band changes. It is not all one-way traffic. There definitely has been a huge challenge and crisis in the costs of electricity and fuel, but the Government is proactively responding from a position of strength.
I too call for more support for public transport as a way to allow people to be better connected and reduce their reliance on their car, if they have the ability to do so. The NTA has introduced 140 routes and different proposals that will connect towns, villages and cities, which can afford more options for those using public transport. There is an investment in public transport. This morning, at the Joint Committee on Transport, representatives of Irish Rail updated us on how it has increased passenger numbers by 20% in the past two years, with 55 million passenger journeys, which is an incredible uplift in connectivity. It is important to recognise on the public record that it is not all bad news and that a lot of improvements are being made. Many governments and jurisdictions would love to be in the economic position we are in to be able to respond and help those most in need. It is the most vulnerable and most in need who have schemes and measures to help support them, and long may that continue.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis an gCathaoirleach agus cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit. The motion calls for both short-term and long-term measures. The price of fuel, petrol, diesel and home heating oil has skyrocketed in the last year or so, and I acknowledge this is because of wars that are outside the control of this Government. We obviously could not have stopped President Trump imposing an illegal war on Iran, which has driven the cost of oil sky high, but more should have been done before now to insulate the country against such terrible shocks. We are reliant on fossil fuels that we have to import very expensively and when something that drives up the cost of them happens, all of the people in this country feel the pressure of that. We should be doing far more, and should have done far more, to look at more sustainable energy sources over the years. Fine Gael has been in government since 2011 and Fianna Fáil has been supporting them in government, or has been in government with them, since 2016, yet very little work has been done. I acknowledge some things have been done, and there are some great grants and so on, but a lot more needs to be done to have foresight and planning around our energy sources. We should be looking at wind, solar, hydrogen and wave energy, for example, and battery storage. We should be improving all of those systems to make sure people in this country will have the pressure taken off them and will have cheap energy, which, in turn, will reduce the cost of food because the cost of producing food is affected by the cost of fuel, as is the cost of the transportation of food. We should be doing this anyway to play our part in reducing carbon emissions and addressing climate change, and even to avoid possible hefty fines being imposed on us by the EU if we do not reach our set targets by 2030.
In rural areas in particular, people have no choice but to use their cars and the public transport system needs to be improved. It is not reliable. We need far more investment in both bus and rail, and greater connectivity using Local Link. In Cavan, for example, we have no rail service. The bus service from Cavan to Dublin is regular but unreliable. It is regularly late and sometimes buses do not show up. People have to be able to rely on a service that will get them to work or wherever they are going on time every day.
There has been a lack of ambition and foresight by successive Governments in preparing the country to absorb the shock caused by rising fuel prices. We propose that we introduce some immediate measures. As well as improving energy sources and re-examining the public transport system, we need immediately to introduce a 10 cent reduction in the price of diesel and petrol at the pumps. Last January or February, at one petrol station in Cavan, petrol cost €1.60 per litre. It now costs €1.94, and that is at one of the cheaper petrol stations. They all charge different prices. In this instance, there has been an increase of at least 30 cent per litre and people are having to absorb that increase along with any reductions the Government has already made in the excise duty.
We have also called for the removal of carbon tax from home heating oil. This measure does not have to last forever but just while the cost of kerosene is so high. If you ordered 1,000 litres of kerosene today, you would pay €1,646. If you had ordered that in May, it would have been €1,440. In January, it would have cost €936 and this time last year, it would have cost €906. That is an increase of 55%. How are people supposed to absorb that? Anything that was given in the budget has been minuscule and will not put a dent in that price. Again, a lot of people rely on using kerosene to heat their homes and are not in a position to change over to heat pumps and so forth at the moment because the cost is so high. The warmer homes scheme is brilliant but not everyone qualifies for that. There are also other grants but a lot of money has to be invested upfront and that is not always affordable for people either. We need to look at some ways to help people get through the current situation. It cannot, we hope, last forever.
I want to discuss the road transporters support scheme. I recently talked to a businessman who told me that he has ten vans on the road, but he does not qualify for the scheme because each van has to be 3.4 tonnes or 3.5 tonnes in weight. His vans are 2.9 tonnes. He is a food producer and he delivers the food. He cannot avail of the scheme, which means his fuel costs have gone through the roof. He is paying thousands of euro extra every month for fuel, even since the beginning of this year, and he is looking at possibly having to lay off people. That is how serious this is. If the cost of fuel, including the cost of green diesel, could be reduced at the pumps, everybody will benefit.
We are just asking for a number of measures to be introduced for the moment to absorb some of the shock that ordinary people are facing in trying to pay the increased cost of petrol, diesel and kerosene. We also need to look at introducing longer term measures that will prevent that form of shock from ever occurring again.
Comment on this
The Minister of State is welcome to the House. I support the Private Members' motion set out by Sinn Féin. It is an opportunity for us to discuss and rehearse what is likely to be a difficult winter.
Some things are outside of the Government’s control. The unilateral and illegal action taken by President Trump and Prime Minister Netanyahu in their attack on Iran contradicted all the laws of international armed conflict and all the conventions and laws of war. While I do not lament the passing of the ayatollahs or members of the Iranian republican guard – I have no sympathy in any way for them – I lament the passing of the international rules-based order. Members will recall Colin Powell pleading in front of the UN Security Council for a resolution to sanction the declaration of war on Iraq. Twenty-three years later, we have moved to a point where full-spectrum powers no longer make any reference to international law.
What has happened in the Strait of Hormuz is completely outside of the control of the Irish Government. I accept that 100%. It is difficult to navigate or predict what is going to happen next, given the febrile and disinhibited nature of the US Presidency. Directly connected to that, the Iranians have decided to pull back somewhat on their support for Hezbollah and Hamas and concentrate all of their support on the Houthis, who have come out of the northern highlands and moved down into the coastal plains along the Red Sea, where they are in a position to deploy direct-fire weapons at shipping in that area. We have a perfect storm.
What is in the Government’s control, however, is how it reacts and responds to this crisis. The principal reason I rise to speak is to ask, as a veteran of the Defence Forces, that the Army not be deployed in an aid to the civil power role in the event of renewed civilian protests. I wish to make a clear distinction in this regard. I have served and commanded aid to the civil power operations, which are armed support operations to An Garda Síochána involving arrests, surveillance, escort of prisoners and guard duties at Portlaoise hospital. I have had command of those operations. They have their place. Thankfully, with the ceasefires and the Good Friday Agreement, they are much less frequent, but aid to the civil authority is an entirely different matter. That involves unarmed troops providing support, for example, during disputes involving the fire service. In the late nineties, I was involved in one such operation in the Ballymun towers when the lifts were no longer functioning and we spent weeks carrying buggies and people with mobility issues up and down the stairwells. That is a different matter. It is called aid to the civil authority.
I was concerned to note that during the fuel protests earlier this year, the various Ministers involved tasked the Defence Forces under an aid to the civil power mandate. We have never done that in the history of the State, not during the burning down of the British Embassy, the riots that accompanied the H-Block protests or at the height of civil disorder and disruption throughout the Troubles. The Government of this Republic has never ever set our troops against civilian protests in an aid to the civil power role. It has never happened. Across Europe, other European Union powers have a graduated level of force. They do not put their troops on the street against civilian protests. If we look at France and the appalling civil unrest there, troops are not put on the street.
In Ireland, what differentiated the Twenty-six Counties from the Six Counties was the concept of police primacy. At no point in the Troubles were people stopped by members of Óglaigh na hÉireann and asked for their name, address and date of birth or questioned about their business. In Northern Ireland, however, the British army, in a very provocative deployment posture, was allowed to carry out checkpoints and cross-examine, question and, indeed, detain people. What happened earlier this year was a revocation of our long-held tradition of police primacy. No matter how tough things get over this winter – the things outside of the Government’s control are outside of its control - I implore the Government not to use the Defence Forces in an aid to the civil power role in relation to fuel protests or any other civil disturbance. A country that deploys the army against its own citizens is a failed state.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Flaherty for moving the Government’s counter-motion. The Government is fully aware of the challenges facing households in light of increased energy costs. As a small, highly open economy and a net energy importer, Ireland is naturally exposed to movements in international energy prices. Crude oil is the globally traded benchmark commodity that serves as the main input into refined products, such as petrol, diesel and home heating oil, which we all use. The disruption to commodity flows through the Strait of Hormuz has had a particularly large impact on some of these refined products, particularly diesel and kerosene.
Sinn Féin’s motion, however, does not reflect the reality of global commodity markets, nor does it fully recognise that the drivers of energy inflation are global in nature and, accordingly, it is not possible for this State or any state to fully absorb all of these costs. Having said that, the Government is acutely aware of the impacts increased prices have had on the basic need to heat one’s home. That is why, in budget 2027, the Government reduced the carbon tax rate to 2023 levels on the two main home heating fuels, at a cost of €130 million; increased the fuel allowance by over 13% to protect those most at risk of fuel poverty; introduced a €1.3 billion personal income tax package to put money back in people’s pockets, which was completely ignored by Sinn Féin contributors; and extended the temporary excise reduction in petrol, diesel and green diesel in full until the end of February 2027. This is why we cannot accept the Sinn Féin motion and are proposing a counter-motion.
The Sinn Féin motion does not fully take into consideration the array of supports implemented by the Government due to increased energy prices as a result of the conflict in the Middle East. As the Opposition knows well, although it usually chooses to ignore it, the Government has delivered one of the largest support packages in the European Union per capita. The package totals €1.7 billion and is targeted at households and businesses. By the way, it has been possible for the Irish Government to deliver and support people through these measures without having to borrow, unlike other European countries. With this €1.7 billion targeted package, Ireland’s fuel prices have fallen from being one of the highest in the European Union to the middle-to-lower end.
The changes proposed in today’s Sinn Féin motion would cost an additional €540 million on an annual basis. Some of what is proposed is also in direct contravention of the EU energy taxation directive, to which Ireland must adhere. I presume that is either because of Sinn Féin’s historical disregard for the EU or Deputy Pearse Doherty has simply decided he is no longer interested in observing the things to which Ireland must adhere.
Since the beginning of this crisis, the Government has not been found wanting. We committed to monitor the situation and act where possible to reduce the pressures on households and motorists caused by increased energy prices. On 1 May, the Government paused the carbon tax increase to home heating fuels to 2025 levels, reduced the NORA levy and extended the winter period by four weeks to ensure those in receipt of fuel allowance were protected. This built on measures introduced last year to shield households from rising energy costs. Budget 2026 provided an extension until 2030 of the 9% VAT rate currently applied to gas and electricity bills; enhanced social protection payments, including the fuel allowance rate; expanded the fuel allowance eligibility rules benefiting approximately 50,000 households; and there was a €400 income tax disregard for households involved in microgeneration, which was extended for a further three years up to 2028.
Two weeks ago, in budget 2027, we took further decisive action. As a result, the fuel allowance will increase by €5 to €43 per week from January 2027, meaning a payment of €1,204 for some 463,000 fuel allowance recipients in 2027. This is an additional €140 in the fuel season. It should be noted that over the past two budgets, this Government has increased the weekly rate of fuel allowance payable by 30%. From January 2027, the income limit for a single person aged 66 or over will increase from 50% to 60% of the income limit for a couple, allowing more older people to qualify for the fuel allowance. In addition, means thresholds for those aged 66 and over will increase in line with core social welfare payment budget increases from January 2027. This means that a couple's means threshold will increase to €1,088 and for a single person aged 66 and over, it will increase to €653.
Two weeks ago, in budget 2027, we also announced the living alone payment will increase by over 13%. It should be highlighted that previous expansions to the fuel allowance have resulted in a significant increase in the scheme spend. In the past six years, this expenditure has nearly doubled, rising from €290 million in 2020 to over €557 million in 2026. The result is that thousands of more families are now benefiting from this important support.
Budget 2027 also recognised that it is those on low to middle and middle incomes that can often feel the squeeze - earning too much to qualify for State support but too little not to notice the rising cost of living. Through budget 2027 and future budgets, we want to change that. That is why budget 2027 included a personal income tax package of €1.3 billion. The budget increased the standard rate cut-off point by €2,500 to €46,500, with proportionate increases for married couples and civil partners; increased the main tax credits - the personal, employee and earned income credits - by €125; increased the home carer tax credit by €100; and increased the entry threshold for the USC 3% band by €1,600 from €28,700 to €30,300.
The Government also further extended the full temporary excise reductions until the end of February 2027, saving motorists 30 cent per litre of diesel, 25 cent per litre of petrol and green diesel users 5.4 cent per litre. The further reduction of the National Oil Reserves Agency Levy, NORA, levy until the end of the year is an additional 2 cent per litre saving on each of those fuels. We must also acknowledge that the primary role of the NORA levy is to provide funding to maintain and replenish strategic oil reserves, helping safeguard against supply disruptions, geopolitical instability and global market shocks. The cost of maintaining adequate emergency reserves is small relative to the economic consequences of fuel shortages, disruption to transport and industry or difficulties securing oil during an international crisis.
As the Members of this House will be aware, fuel taxation in the EU is governed by the energy tax directive, ETD, to which Ireland must adhere. The ETD sets minimum tax rates for fuel products. The minimum rate for diesel is 33 cent per litre. The current rate of mineral oil tax on diesel is around 37 cent. Were Ireland to introduce a further reduction on diesel of 10 cent, we would be well below the stated minimum rates, thus breaching EU law.
We are liaising with the European Commission to renew our derogation in respect of those hauliers and bus operators that receive a diesel rebate via the diesel rebate scheme and thus are currently paying less than the stipulated minimum rate. This is a relatively small cohort that is receiving a state aid in accordance with the EU's general block exemption regulation. A derogation to go below minimum rates for the whole country would not be permissible. We and the Opposition need to be realistic and honest about what is and is not possible.
Budget 2027 was about putting money back in people's pockets to ease the burden of cost-of-living pressures. This Government will continue to do that. Our need for society and the economy to decouple from fossil fuel dependence is even more apparent in recent times given the levels of volatility in international fuel markets. The best way to achieve energy security and insulate our economy and society from fuel price shocks is to reduce our dependence on fossil fuels. The carbon tax is an important long-term policy tool in helping to achieve energy security. This Government remains committed to decarbonising our society, increasing investment in renewable energy sources and recycling carbon tax revenues to protect those most vulnerable to fuel poverty through targeted welfare interventions.
Between budget 2020 and budget 2026, additional carbon tax revenues have been allocated incrementally each year to programmes to insulate the most vulnerable from the increases in the carbon tax and to support decarbonisation and energy efficiency programmes across buildings, agriculture and transport. As part of budget 2027, a total of €1.114 billion from carbon tax revenue is being allocated to climate measures and to ensure the most vulnerable are protected. This approach maintains the important principle of applying carbon tax revenues to areas that prioritise just transition spending. Budget 2027 also includes a record capital allocation of over €650 million, with €647 million being allocated from carbon tax receipts for the SEAI home energy upgrade schemes. This means that more funding than ever will be available to make homes warmer this year.
In examining changes to the carbon tax system, it is the job of Government to take into account our obligations under EU legislation and the conditions of the derogation from the emissions trading system for buildings, road transport and additional sectors, which this Government negotiated with the European Commission. Sinn Féin’s motion completely ignores these EU obligations. Any changes must be carefully calibrated.
The Government has listened and we have responded in the most comprehensive way possible. While no Government can fully shield all households from all the impacts of this crisis, this Government has acted to mitigate the impacts of the crises time and again. The Government proposes to adopt the counter-motion we have tabled.
Comment on this
Regarding the earlier exchanges in the Seanad, we expect robust debate but we also expect respectful debate. Standing Order 40 allows people to intervene in a debate. It allows the person in possession to give way. While political charges are part of what politics is about, when they drift beyond that, that is obviously a concern and is not part of what is allowed in the Seanad. Personal charges should not be made and there should be no unparliamentary language. I want to make sure we do not drift into that. I did not hear it because there was so much going on but if unparliamentary language was used, I ask people to be mindful of not using unparliamentary language in the House. I ask Members to adhere to the rules of the House. Standing Order 40 allows a Member to intervene in a debate. The Member just has to ask the Member in possession to give way, which the Member can do if he or she wishes. Members do not have to give way if they do not wish to. I ask Members to adhere to the rules of the House and refrain from drifting from them.
I welcome the CEO of Siemens Ireland, Joe Walsh, to the Public Gallery. He and his team are very welcome to Seanad Éireann. Siemens has a long relationship with Ireland, starting with Ardnacrusha. I thank the company for the electricity for the past 100 years and for all it has done for Ireland over those years. I thank Mr. Walsh and all those from Siemens Ireland for being here today.
Comment on this
If I may, I will make a point of order. I know the Cathaoirleach addressed the issue of robust debate but it was very clear that unparliamentary language was used. There are very clear rules in this House and the Lower House regarding what language can and cannot be used. I have no issue with what I am called but I do have an issue when a party that has always played fast and loose with the rules breaches those rules. It is very clear that there was a breach of the rules. It was heard and Members here can substantiate that it was heard. I am no water lily. I can take anything but I will not take it from Sinn Féin and I expect it to be withdrawn and an apology given.
Comment on this
I am asking the Cathaoirleach to ensure that it is withdrawn. It is very clear that unparliamentary language was used in the House today. This House is the bastion of democracy.
Comment on this
This House is the bastion of democracy. I know Sinn Féin played fast and loose with democracy for many years and does not fully accept it but today, the Senator besmirched the reputation of this country through the language she used in this House. I expect that, at the very least, the Senator would withdraw it and apologise because, believe it or not, there are people who do listen in. She did speak and it was quite clearly heard. It will be on the record of the House. I expect the Cathaoirleach to pursue this robustly.
Comment on this
Some very serious allegations were made by the Member across the floor. Will he withdraw those allegations?
Comment on this
I most certainly will not because those allegations are well-founded and substantiated.
Comment on this
The Senator knows that her own leader already had to issue an apology in relation to Paul Quinn-----
Comment on this
-----for saying he was a criminal. I am not lecturing the Senator; I am telling her the reality. Today, the Sinn Féin Senators let themselves down.
Comment on this
I do have a clue. I know plenty and there is plenty out there that knows Sinn Féin's track record as well.
Comment on this
We know what they did and we will not forget what they did.
Comment on this
I ask Members to use the Standing Orders. Standing Order 40 is the one that should have been used on that occasion. If they do not do so, we will spend a lot of time in the Committee on Parliamentary Privileges and Oversight and at meetings here talking about the use of language and debates in the Chamber. That is not what we are about. We are about respectful debate. I ask people to take notice of that.
Anois, I call on Senator McCormack to reply. She has five minutes.
Comment on this
Gabhaim buíochas leis an gCathaoirleach agus an Aire Stáit. I will end where I started, talking about my friend, who I will not name. She is a nurse who is putting €138 in her car just to get to work. I am going to leave people in the House with that one.
I want to explain that Sinn Féin put forward a fully costed alternative budget, which is available for everyone to see on the Sinn Féin website. It sets out clear proposals to cut fuel costs, support working families and put money back into people's pockets. It allows people to see for themselves rather than listening to sometimes untrue things spoken in the Chamber. They can actually look at the budget for themselves. I urge people to do it so they can see our alternative budget and how different life would be under a Sinn Féin Government. That is the reason we brought forward this motion today. We are listening to the people. We understand the pressure they are under, even if people in the Government fail to realise that.
All I heard in the Minister of State's speech was an announcement of what she did in the budget. It was like Groundhog Day. That is not what today's debate is about. It is about supporting struggling people with fuel, which the Government has failed to do. We have tried our absolute best.
Comment on this
Amendment put
Do you agree with this result?
Question put: "That the motion, as amended, be agreed to".
Do you agree with this result?