British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly debate
Blaney sought time for a House discussion on the Assembly’s work, saying Members across parties supported the request. The Chair welcomed visitors.
Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit, an Teachta Brophy, agus gabhaim buíochas leis agus leis an Aire, an Teachta O’Callaghan, as ucht teacht isteach chugainn chun na hábhair seo maidir le frithsceimhlitheoireacht idirnáisiúnta a phlé.
On behalf of the Fine Gael group, I welcome the three proposals before us today. They follow on from our enactment of the Criminal Justice (Terrorist Offences) (Amendment) Act last year. They are very important for the reasons outlined by the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan, and Senator Murphy O'Mahony, as well as Senator Keogan in her contribution.
At a general level, international co-operation is crucially important for Ireland in the area of security, justice and counterterrorism. As somebody who once spent time working on a task force in the European Commission on bioterrorism and the threats posed to Europe a little over two decades ago, the importance of international co-operation and having co-ordinated national responses to threats cannot be understated.
The proposals before us are a logical progression. For the reasons outlined by Senator Murphy O'Mahony, the possible implications for us with regard to continuing with Eurojust are of crucial importance. That is not an area we want to go down. On balance, the three legislative instruments being proposed are steps in the right direction with respect to closer international co-operation in the area of counterterrorism. On behalf of the Fine Gael group, I recommend and support the proposals.
Comment on this
Sinn Féin also supports the motions, but I have to register some significant concerns. First, with regard to the manner in which they have been brought forward, we have had two days' notice to consider measures arising from significant EU instruments and, once again, we are told they must be dealt with as a matter of urgency. Measures with implications for our criminal justice system, our sovereignty and our relationship with the EU institutions deserve proper scrutiny, but instead, the Oireachtas has repeatedly presented complex proposals and asked for them to be simply waved through.
We occupy a unique position in this area. Unlike most other EU member states, Ireland secured, under Protocol 21 during the Lisbon treaty negotiations, the right to choose whether to participate in measures relating to justice and home affairs. That safeguard was presented to the Irish people as an important protection of national sovereignty and it gave Ireland the ability to decide on a case-by-case basis whether participation was in our interest. The measures before us relate to a 2017 directive on combating terrorism and strengthening counterterrorism laws by creating offences relating to terrorist training and travel for terrorist purposes. However, they also expand the concept of public provocation to commit terrorism and clarify that in certain circumstances, the glorification of terrorism could constitute a criminal offence. While prosecutions remain a matter for national authorities, and Eurojust does not prosecute cases itself, these measures undoubtedly increase interdependence between member states and EU agencies in the area of criminal justice.
There is also a broader point. Across Europe, there are differing approaches to questions of political expression, national liberation movements and the definition of terrorism. Different states can take different views on where legitimate political advocacy ends and unlawful support for terrorism begins. Given that the 2017 directive deals with public provocation or the glorification of terrorism, it is entirely reasonable to ask how such provisions might be interpreted in different jurisdictions and what safeguards exist to ensure legitimate political expression is protected.
These are important questions and they deserve debate, scrutiny and more than a rushed process justified on the basis that urgency leaves us with no alternative. To be clear, my concern is not with the objective of combating terrorism or facilitating international co-operation; my concern is with the process of the Oireachtas repeatedly asking that we consider significant EU measures at short notice without the levels of scrutiny such matters warrant.