An tOrd Gnó - Order of Business
- Order of Business 2 speeches
The Deputy Leader sets out the scheduled business. The Chair welcomes the Deputy Foreign Minister and offers condolences following the death of former Minister Gerard Collins.
Garret Ahearn, Mark Daly
- US election outcome 1 speech
Senator O’Loughlin welcomes the Democratic victories in the US elections, saying they signal rejection of Trump’s policies and could shape global affairs.
Fiona O'Loughlin
- Home care packages in Donegal 1 speech
Senator Boyle highlights the shortage of carers and a hospital patient waiting ten weeks for a home care package, calling for a plan and clear timelines.
Manus Boyle
- Safeguarding election integrity 1 speech
Senator Boyhan welcomes a report on digital threats to Irish elections and calls for a debate on protecting the integrity of the electoral process.
Victor Boyhan
- US sanctions on Cuba 1 speech
After visiting Cuba, Senator Andrews describes the hardship he attributes to the US blockade and sanctions and calls attention to their impact on ordinary Cubans.
Chris Andrews
- Planning for Ireland’s constitutional future 1 speech
Senator Black welcomes a Government body to examine the island’s constitutional future, including legal, social and economic preparations for a shared future.
Frances Black
- Respite services in West Cork 1 speech
Senator O’Donovan thanks CoAction and the HSE for engaging with families on respite provision and welcomes an upcoming public meeting to work toward a plan.
Noel O'Donovan
- Garda working hours and morale 1 speech
Senator O’Reilly raises Garda dissatisfaction over working hours and breaches of the working time directive, noting that 4,182 officers are prepared to take industrial action.
Joe O'Reilly
- Deaths among people experiencing homelessness 1 speech
Senator McCarthy raises recent deaths involving homeless people, including two bodies found at a Clondalkin recycling facility, and highlights the dangers faced by people without safe shelter.
Aubrey McCarthy
- Rural telephone connectivity in Mayo 1 speech
Senator Duffy warns that removing copper-wire landlines could leave vulnerable residents in Keenagh without reliable emergency alarms during outages or severe weather.
Mark Duffy
- Child protection failures at Tusla 1 speech
Senator Keogan cites court revelations involving children in State care and condemns Tusla’s handling of their protection, arguing the agency is unfit for purpose.
Sharon Keogan
- US election implications 1 speech
The Deputy Leader responds to Senator O’Loughlin, noting the Democrats’ gains and hoping the result creates an opportunity to reset and strengthen Ireland’s relationship with the United States.
Garret Ahearn
I, too, welcome the Deputy Foreign Minister to the Seanad Chamber. This is the first Chamber in the world where Ukrainian MPs addressed a Chamber post the war in 2022. This whole House, on all sides, is hugely supportive of Ukraine, the Ukrainian people, the ambassador and the work she does.
The Order of Business is No. 1, report on the Committee of Selection, to be taken on conclusion of the Order of Business without debate; No. 2, statements on Food Vision 2030, to be taken at 1.30 p.m. and to conclude at 3 p.m. if not previously concluded, with the time allocated to the opening remarks of the Minister not to exceed ten minutes, group spokespersons not to exceed eight minutes each, all other Senators not to exceed five minutes each and the Minister to be given no less than ten minutes to reply to the debate; No. 3, Media Regulation Bill 2026 - Report and Final Stages, to be taken at 3.20 p.m. and to adjourn at 4 p.m. if not previously concluded; and No. 4, Private Members' business, Harassment, Harmful Communications and Related Offences (Amendment) (No. 3) Bill 2026 - Second Stage, to be taken at 4 p.m., with the time allocated to this debate not to exceed two hours.
Comment on this
Before I call on the Deputy Leader, I wish to mention the passing not of a Member of this House but of the former Minister, Gerard Collins, who served for 30 years as a Member of Dáil Éireann. His father, James Collins, served prior to that. Mr. Collins served as foreign affairs Minister during the reunification of Germany and played a key role during Ireland's EU Presidency in 1989 and 1990 with regard to the reunification of Germany. Helmut Kohl praised Ireland and the then Minister, former Deputy Collins, for his support for that particular initiative. We offer our condolences to his wife Hilary and all the Collins family, and of course his nephew, the Minister of State, Deputy Niall Collins, a Member of the other House who continues that long family tradition. In fact, at this moment in time, I believe it is the longest continuing family service in Leinster House, with the Andrews family close behind.
Comment on this
I add my voice of welcome to our distinguished guests, who have just left us.
This morning, it was great to wake up to news of a very decisive blue wave right across America and to see the Democratic Party taking full control of the US Senate and the House of Representatives. This can be seen as a very clear rejection of President Trump's domestic and, most importantly for us, international policies. This shows us the importance of democratic checks and balances, and this development will undoubtedly shape global political and economic dynamics over the years ahead.
I wish to raise the transfer of responsibility for the Multi-Unit Developments Act - it is called the MUD Act - from the Department of justice to the Department of housing. The necessary legislation to facilitate the move was passed months ago but the transfer of functions has not been executed. This is a critical governance issue. This transfer needs to be completed so that a dedicated regulator can be established to oversee owner management companies. We need a very clear timeline for this and clarity on it. I ask for a debate on this transfer of functions, to make sure that many thousands of frustrated apartment owners across the country will get clarity on it.
I commend the excellent partnership between the GAA, the Gaelic Players Association and Movember on their Ahead of the Game initiative. I also take the opportunity to congratulate Sarsfields on a very decisive victory in the Kildare county final last Sunday. In regard to Movember Ahead of the Game, this evidence-based youth sports mental health literacy programme is making a really profound difference by equipping young athletes, parents and coaches around the country with very practical tools to build resilience and to recognise the signs of poor mental health. Already, it has had over 17,500 attendees across 449 clubs. It is a really fantastic example of a community-led network. I strongly encourage all local clubs in Kildare and right around the country to engage with the free workshops that are on offer this winter to help break the silence and stigma around mental health. Having said that, because November is the month of men's health and men's mental health, we should have a debate in the Seanad on both.
Comment on this
I want to talk about carers. They play a vital role in my county of Donegal, looking after our people. Every week since I have come here, I have been inundated with calls from people looking for carers for their loved ones. To be honest, we seem to be hitting a brick wall. Last night, I was contacted by a lady's family. She has been in hospital for ten weeks and they cannot get a home care package in place. That is holding up beds in emergency departments, community hospitals and every other place around Donegal. We need to get a plan in place here.
There has to be a timeframe from when a person goes into hospital to the care package being rolled out. I have been asking colleagues about this issue and the situation has been replicated around the north west. We need the Minister to come in here and have a debate on carers for the north-west region, if not the whole of Ireland. It is something that affects every family. It is great that people are living to an older age but we must look after them. The families are stressed out. They are trying to work. They have children of their own and they are trying to look after mammy and daddy, do their long hours, sit up at night and look after mammy or daddy. There is nothing coming in.
Another problem is that people will get a letter to say the package is in place. They take mammy or daddy or the aunt or uncle home and the help is not there. We really need to take a fundamental look at carers, how we can help on it and how we can sustain people living at home. They are far happier at home, if they can do it at all. I ask the Leader to call for the Minister to come in and have a dedicated debate on carers.
Comment on this
There are a few issues I want to raise here this morning. First, I welcome the publication of the report of the Centre for Justice and Law Reform, titled Safeguarding Irish Election Integrity in the Era of Emerging Digital Threats, which may have arrived on some Senators' desks today. This was commissioned by the Law Society of Ireland. It makes for extraordinary reading and we should have a debate on it. We talked about elections and there are elections all over the world but the integrity of our electoral process is very profound and important. We have to safeguard it at all times. We are moving to a new generation in terms of digital threats, technology and how elections will be conducted into the future. It is an evolving space and a space that is moving faster than we can move ourselves and our limited capacity for understanding it. We should at an appropriate time, possibly in the new year, take this report as a central theme and have some sort of engagement on it. I like the way the Seanad is now embracing having external people come in to talk to us. We do not always need to be talking to ourselves. That is part of this new reform of our Seanad. We have this facility here and this issue is an important one for us to look at. I ask the Leader to consider that.
This morning, I also want to welcome the Animal Welfare Strategy 2026-2030 and commend the Minister for agriculture, Deputy Martin Heydon. What is important is that this strategy sets out reasonable, fair and objective targets. The important thing is that it will empower and fund local authorities in their pursual of the animal welfare strategy. The funding is the critical point. I acknowledge the work the Minister, Deputy Heydon, has done and the collaborative way he conducted the work on this strategy. That was very important and he worked very effectively with the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food. It is important that we acknowledge that. I also thank the Leader and his office for agreeing to facilitate the Minister of State, Deputy Grealish, to come here this afternoon to speak about Food Vision 2030. That is central to our food security and I look forward to a meaningful engagement on that later this afternoon.
Finally, I thank Teagasc, which gave a breakfast briefing to Oireachtas Members this morning in relation to its remit as Ireland's agriculture and food development authority. Critically, it spoke about farm succession. We know that 50% of all farmers are now 59 years of age or older. Succession and inheritance are critical in agriculture. Coupled with that is taxation and taxation policy. We are now in the last quarter of the year but this is the UN year of the woman farmer and I do not think we should let the year go without having one more debate about women in agriculture and women who are central to rural life in our country. Before the year ends, we should have a meaningful engagement on that and perhaps ask some of the Ministers who are involved across the sectors of rural development and agriculture to come to the House to discuss that important topic.
Comment on this
Last week, I was part of a delegation that visited Cuba, along with Jonathan and Aaron Smith. We met with assembly members and visited hospitals to see for ourselves the dire situation facing ordinary Cubans due to the US blockade and sanctions.
Ireland and Cuba have a lot in common. Both of us have big, powerful neighbours and both of us have a real desire for unity and self-determination. It is clear from what we saw that Cuba is facing a genocide. It is a silent genocide but a genocide none the less. So many Cubans are starving in the street due to the US sanctions. There are no bin collections and rubbish is piling high. Residents are picking through the increasingly large piles of rubbish on every street corner. There is no public transport. Water treatment is limited. There are severe medicine shortages. There are long power cuts that impact everybody. The power cuts are severely damaging the hospitals and their equipment. In the neonatal units we saw baby incubators that cannot be used, which means doctors have to make harrowing decisions about those newly born children. Many spare parts cannot be got for vital medical equipment. Scanners and X-ray machines are left unused and stored away because of the shortage of spare parts. Cuba has plenty of doctors and nurses but they have no medicines, so when you visit a doctor or a hospital, they can tell you what is wrong with you but they cannot give the medicines to cure that or fix you. They can only tell you how long you will be in pain or how long it will be before you die. That is the reality in Cuba today. We visited a soup kitchen that feeds 12,000 starving children every day. This is all because of the fuel sanctions and decades of a US blockade. Young children are emaciated and old people are dying. That is the reality for increasing numbers of Cuban people.
I acknowledge that the Government voted against the blockade at the UN General Assembly. This is really important and welcome, as is the aid. I would like it to be more but it is important that the vote every year is supported by Ireland. Equally, Ireland needs to build on that vote and challenge the blockade - not simply go in every year and vote against the blockade. We need to do more, be more active and challenge that narrative and the fact the blockade somehow continues. The Cubans have incredible resilience and a determination to protect their self-determination. The revolution will continue long after Trump and the blockade are gone. Ireland needs to up its activity and support for Cuba and support ordinary Cubans who are suffering as a result of the US blockade.
Comment on this
I warmly welcome the Government's decision to establish a new body to examine the constitutional future of this island. I particularly commend the Taoiseach on taking it. This is the most significant decision taken by an Irish Government since partition on the question of our shared future. For the first time, the State will do the serious work of research and preparation, for which we have been calling for a very long time. It will involve preparation on the law, the Constitution, health and education, the economy and costs, security and flags and symbols. That is exactly the kind of careful, honest groundwork people have been asking for. It really sends a positive message to everyone on this island who hopes for a new Ireland. It sends an equally important message to those who do not yet share that hope, including our unionist and Protestant neighbours. By placing every option on the table, including the status quo, the Taoiseach is saying clearly their voice matters and they are invited in. I welcome that.
I would like to mention a few people who played a role in bringing us to this point. I thank Ireland's Future and the many civic voices who kept this conversation alive and continue to do so. I thank colleagues across all parties, including the Minister of State, Deputy Neale Richmond, and the Cathaoirleach, who has done phenomenal work on this. I thank Deputy Rose Conway-Walsh, Senator Patricia Stephenson and other members of the Good Friday committee whose July 2023 report and other reports have set out a very thoughtful pathway towards a new Ireland. I particularly thank the secretariat of the Good Friday implementation committee. I also give a huge thank you to those from civic unionism and the Protestant community who have had the courage to step into this debate.
People like Reverend Karen Sutherman, Claire Mitchell, Ben Collins and the Belfast Women's Assembly, as well as the trade union movement, brought the voice of working people to this conversation. This decision is a huge opportunity to reshape our national conversation. It moves us from slogans to substance and is future-focused, which matters most of all to the young people, North and South, who will live longest with whatever we build on this island. The challenge now is to make space for everyone - unionist and nationalist, Protestant and Catholic, people of every faith and none, as well as the new communities that have chosen Ireland as their home. A new Ireland, if it comes, must belong to all of them. I ask the Leader to arrange a debate in this House on the new body so that the Seanad, which has always had a voice for the North, can play its full part in this conversation.
Comment on this
I have raised in this House a number of times the provision of respite for people with disabilities across west Cork, which has been a very topical issue in recent weeks. We have seen peaceful walks and a real outcry on the need for solving the respite issue once and for all in west Cork. I put on the record my appreciation to CoAction, to the board and leadership team, and to the HSE for its engagement with myself and families in recent weeks to try to solve this, once and for all, and put a clear plan in place. I am delighted that a town hall-type meeting is taking place tomorrow night in Bantry with the HSE, CoAction and parents who are directly affected by the provision of respite in west Cork. I am aware of a structured positive plan that is going to be put in place to deliver respite across properties in west Cork. This is a real sign of positive movement for CoAction, an organisation that has brought great care to the people across west Cork and has a positive future in engaging with the HSE. In particular, I thank all those involved. However, the time for talking is nearly finished. We need to see delivery on these projects. I am aware that a number of these projects will make asks of the HSE at a national level, of Departments and of the Government. When these asks come, it is important that they are supported. We have had years of lack of respite in west Cork and parents have had enough. I have mentioned how solicitors' letters had to be sent to provide this level of action. The time for delivery is now. It is about listening and engaging, and that is what tomorrow night's meeting in Bantry is going to be about. I welcome this and urge action thereafter. I thank the House for listening to these matters when they have been raised. I am hopeful that after tomorrow night we will see real action.
Comment on this
The Leader will agree, as will colleagues around the House, that it is very important for our well-being and the security of our State that we have a highly motivated and satisfied An Garda Síochána at any given time. I was very disturbed to learn from the recent Garda Representative Association, GRA, conference that there is quite a high level of discontent, to the extent that 4,182 gardaí are prepared to take industrial action around breaches of the working time directive and the number of hours they are being asked to work. They have appealed to Commissioner Kelly to deal with this. I ask the Leader to speak with the Minister for justice to convey to him the need for this matter to be rectified by him and his good offices. We do not want the threat of work to rule by gardaí from 10 November to 14 November, which I believe are the dates in question, to transpire. More importantly, we do not want this underlying discontent and demotivation to exist. We need our gardaí to feel highly valued at all given times and not feel they are being abused. They allege and state that the working time agreement and the European working time directive are being breached.
Comment on this
I raise today the number of people who are dying in the homeless community. Last week, I was contacted by RTÉ about another body that was found in a recycling facility in Clondalkin. That is the second body to be found at the facility since July. I spoke in this House previously about Andrew Haire, who had been using homeless services and was found at that facility. From the investigation, Garda believe he climbed into a bin to get some sleep and to be safe and dry. We also recently lost a homeless lady who was a former librarian from Dún Laoghaire. She ended up homeless on the street due to circumstances out of her control. When you hear about these deaths, you realise that the statistics we talk about are nearly 100 nationwide, but they are individuals. The Dublin Region Homeless Executive, DRHE, has said that 46 people using homeless services have died so far this year. The problem here is that reporting is not mandatory, so the real number is likely higher. In 2021, Dr. Austin O'Carroll, who is a champion of homeless services from the medical side, wrote a report for the DRHE on deaths among homeless people. He recommended a review after every death so that we could learn whether it could have been prevented. The follow-up research was dropped, and that report is sitting somewhere on a shelf. In five years, we have done nothing with it. I have mentioned several times before my work at The Lighthouse. Every day, I see 200 to 500 people looking for hot food, clothes, a doctor and somebody who knows their name. Prevention starts with services like this. I ask the Leader to invite the Minister for housing into the House to explain why Dr. O'Carroll's recommendations have not been implemented, and to commit to a proper review of every homeless death. They are vulnerable, marginalised people and many of them are and were my friends. Many of these deaths could be prevented, so we should stop treating them as inevitable.
Comment on this
Today, I raise the issue of connectivity in rural areas of Ireland, particularly in my home county of Mayo. Keenagh in County Mayo is a rural area that has had ongoing challenges relating to cellular and landline connectivity. There are concerns among residents there about the proposed removal of copper wire landline connections. The worry and risk in this community is that in the event of a storm, outages, extreme weather events or different faults, there would be vulnerable users in houses who are reliant on panic alarms and different alarms that are there to help in a time of emergency. This is causing grave concern and risk. I have worked with residents in Keenagh to address different faults and try to improve cellular connectivity. I have raised cellular and landline connections regularly. We must ensure our vulnerable users and residents across rural Ireland are connected in a resilient fashion, and not just with fibre. I welcome the opportunity for a discussion here in the House on cellular and landline connectivity and resilience for rural Ireland. It is important that areas like Keenagh are protected and that vulnerable users in particular are protected and connected.
Comment on this
I rise to address the absolute horrors exposed in the High Court this week regarding Tusla. We heard of a 16-year-old boy vomiting up nearly 40 bags of crack cocaine, who is still missing, and a 17-year-old girl who was subjected to an industrial scale of sexual exploitation, with taxis picking her up directly from the front door of her State care placement. This is no longer a crisis of funding; this is a total moral collapse. Tusla's budget has climbed to an unprecedented €1.4 billion.
It is a wake-up call that this agency is completely unfit for purpose and entirely rotten and that it must be abolished and remade from the ground up. Tusla's own audited accounts prove that it has become an administrative monster. It spends over €70 million a year just on office and administration costs. This includes over €13 million that is handed to commercial landlords in rent. A staggering €43.8 million is siphoned out of child welfare annually to fund skyrocketing legal fees. Meanwhile, the safety net has collapsed. Half of our 26 special care beds are locked shut because Tusla cannot safely staff them. Instead, this agency pours €38 million into private landlords and hotels through special emergency arrangements alongside €359 million for independent for-profit placement providers. Tusla has openly admitted that it has no idea how much of that €359 million is being pocketed by private executives as corporate profit while children are left to the wolves. We are starving the front line to enrich external asset holders, legal teams and private care companies. This is State-sanctioned neglect.
Children do not consent to chaos. They should not be subjected to a system that acts as a conveyor belt for exploitation. We do not need another review, committee or policy tweak. We need a Minister who will come into this Chamber. The Minister has not appeared in this Chamber for a Commencement matter since the start of this new Seanad. The Minister needs to step up. She needs to dismantle this failed privatised bureaucracy and build a child protection system that actually protects people. The testimony that Senator Aubrey McCarthy gave this morning about homeless people dying on our streets should be enough to bring down this Government. The neglect of our children in State care should be enough to bring down this Government. However, it is not because the Government does not care.
Comment on this
I thank all of the Senators for their contributions. Senator O'Loughlin spoke about the US elections that happened overnight. There was obviously a massive wave of blue right across the country, including in states such as Texas that no one would have predicted going Democrat a number of months ago. I hope this will be an opportunity to reset and enhance our relationship with the US. It is obviously a real success for the Democrats but we have to wait to see how the President will react. Elections in America obviously have knock-on effects and importance for our country.
The Senator also spoke about the transfer of functions with regard to the Multi-Unit Developments Act. I will speak to the Minister to see if we can get some timelines on that because, as the Senator herself outlined, it is important and people are waiting for it.
With regard to the GAA's Movember Ahead of the Game initiative, it is another one of those things that the GAA does very well to support people, particularly young people, in relation to their mental health. That is always to be commended.
Senator Manus Boyle spoke about the importance of carers and the lack of carers in the north west. It has a huge impact on families and puts them under pressure. If carers cannot be found or sourced, it is very hard for families to put a plan together to care for their loved ones. I will ask the Minister to come in for a debate on carers, as the Senator has suggested. The Government has made a lot of commitments for the next five years. Some have already been done but more needs to be done and will be done. A debate on that matter would be timely.
Senator Victor Boyhan spoke about the report that the centre for justice and law reform has just published on integrity in our electoral system. I have not read the report yet but I plan to. It is important because, across the world, we see how elections can be vulnerable to outside acts. We are no different and we have to take that seriously. Obviously, we potentially will not have elections for a number of years. We certainly will not have local or European elections for a number of years. There will be changes. We have had discussions regarding the local democracy task force. There is an opportunity to have a debate on the digital aspect.
I thank the Senator because, in fairness to him, he has been pushing for a debate on Food Vision 2030 for a while now. In fairness to the Minister of State, Deputy Noel Grealish, as well, he is always very accommodating and good. He will be in here this afternoon to discuss that.
Senator Chris Andrews spoke about his visit to Cuba and outlined the harsh reality of what sanctions and blockades did to innocent individuals. As the Senator said, Ireland has always voted the right way, if that is the way to put it, at the UN General Assembly and will continue to do so but that does not mean we cannot do more. We can and should do more in terms of diplomacy. Every time we go to America, we need to talk about these things. I know the Minister for foreign affairs and the Minister of State with responsibility for the diaspora and overseas aid, Deputy Neale Richmond, always do. We send overseas aid to Cuba. I know the Senator's concerns are genuine. Visits like his are always very helpful because having seen an issue at first hand gives us credibility when talking about it when we come home. I will take that on board and speak with the Minister.
Senator Frances Black spoke about the constitutional future of Ireland. I spoke about this yesterday as well because it was raised by Senator Conor Murphy. This is an opportunity not to talk about division within our country, but to talk about possibilities and opportunities, not just for the Six Counties of Northern Ireland, but also for the Twenty-six Counties in the Republic, and about how we see that future. The Fine Gael Party is publishing a report on a unified Ireland at the weekend; the Tánaiste will be publishing that report. As the Senator has said, what is really important is that everyone is starting to come on board with the idea of having a realistic conversation about what a unified Ireland would be. It is not simply about a vote but about what we actually want to represent a unified Ireland as. I will speak to the Minister and see if we can have a debate on that.
Senator Noel O'Donovan spoke about respite for people with disabilities in Cork, particularly west Cork. He has been a huge advocate for this for a long time in this House. He has spoken weekly about the challenges people are facing. That co-action group has put in an awful lot of good work. It is important that people be heard. That meeting with the HSE in Bantry is a real opportunity for everyone to have their voice heard and for action to be taken on the back of that. I know the Senator will make sure that that meeting will not just amount to people talking but that there will actually be delivery on the back of it. I know he is hugely passionate about delivering much-needed care for people with disabilities in west Cork.
Senator Joe O'Reilly spoke about Garda confidence, well-being and motivation. That has been a challenge not just this year, but over the last number of years. We have seen a number of gardaí, particularly young gardaí, leaving the force because of challenges in the workforce, conditions and difficulty in moving from one place to another. We have an almost record number of gardaí across the country. They are coming through Templemore. I see it every 12 weeks in Tipperary. We have record numbers coming through Templemore. It is certainly not for lack of investment but the Senator is right - they are working long hours. There are reasons for that, especially this year with the EU Presidency and the Trump visit. They will always do it because it is the right thing to do, but we have to remember that it is a real challenge for them. I will speak to the Minister on the matter, as the Senator requested.
Senator Aubrey McCarthy spoke, as he always does, about homelessness and people dying on the streets. I will speak to the Minister about coming to the Chamber, that report on preventing homeless deaths, and doing an individual report on each homeless person who dies in the street and how that death could have been prevented.
Senator Mark Duffy spoke about cellular and landline connectivity. Anybody who lives in rural Ireland will understand the challenges with this but it is a real challenge for vulnerable people, particularly those who live on their own. The Senator spoke about Keenagh in Mayo, where there can be extreme weather, which has a huge impact. In the last ten years, the Government has invested hugely in broadband at a time when most people were not in favour of doing so. That has made a huge difference in terms of connectivity, particularly in rural Ireland. However, there are spots across the country, including the one the Senator highlighted in his own constituency, that need to be supported, prioritised and invested in. I will see if we can have a debate on that.
Finally, Senator Keogan spoke in relation to Tusla and outlined a lot of money that is spent by Tusla on what could be perceived as money that could be put somewhere else. We have a committee on children which the Senator is on, and I am not saying that we should set up another one. I presume that Tusla gets invited into that committee on a regular basis to be held accountable for the decisions it makes and the money it spends. I will speak to the Minister and ask her to come into the Chamber, and we will see if we can have a debate on that. What the Senator is saying is genuine in terms of supporting vulnerable kids, and we should be doing that. Just to be clear, some of us do care, and I will see if I can get a response from the Minister to see if a debate is possible on that.