Food Vision 2030: Statements
Food Vision 2030 sets out four missions for a sustainable, resilient and innovative agrifood sector, with the Minister reporting that 91% of its actions are complete or substantially advanced. A stakeholder-led mid-term review is under way to update the strategy while preserving policy stability. Senators broadly welcomed its ambitions but stressed farm viability, fair incomes, CAP support and generational renewal, alongside food security, climate resilience and protection of agricultural land. They also called for greater support for horticulture and small producers, innovation, and access to international markets.
Gabhaim buíochas leis an Chathaoirleach Gníomhach agus na Seanadóirí. Tá áthas orm a bheith anseo don ócáid speisialta seo. Mar a dúirt mé, I am pleased to be here in the Seanad to contribute to this important and timely debate on Food Vision 2030. Ireland's approach to delivering sustainable agriculture and food is set out in Food Vision 2030, Ireland's stakeholder-led strategy. Food Vision 2030 provides a strategic framework for a dynamic, sustainable and innovative agrifood sector. Its vision is for Ireland to be a world leader in sustainable food systems with environmental, economic and social sustainability at its core. Food Vision 2030 was developed and is being implemented for the sector by the sector using a food-systems approach, recognising the requirements for greater policy coherence across agriculture, food and the environment.
Stakeholder engagement is a key characteristic of Food Vision 2030. It is only by working together collaboratively with all stakeholders playing a role and having a voice that we can meet our challenges and make the most of our opportunities. Food Vision 2030 builds on a long-standing tradition of participative policymaking through stakeholder-led strategies for the agrifood sector with the emphasis on foresight, long-term planning and evidence-based policymaking.
The Food Vision strategy consists of 22 goals grouped into four high level missions. Mission 1 is to progress a climate-smart, environmentally sustainable agrifood sector with an overall target of climate-neutral food systems by 2050 with variable progress to be achieved by 2030. There are seven goals in this mission, encompassing emissions reductions, carbon sequestration, improvements in air quality, restoration and enhancement of biodiversity, improvements in water quality, development of diverse forests, enhanced seafood sustainability, exploring the bioeconomy and strengthening Origin Green.
Mission 2 is for viable and resilient primary producers with enhanced well-being. This mission places primary producers, our farmers, fishers and foresters, at the centre of Food Vision 2030. Its focus is on improving the competitiveness and productivity of primary producers; embracing the creation of value and distributing it fairly; introducing greater diversification in production systems and incomes; improving the social sustainability of primary producers across areas such as renewal, gender balance, health and safety, mental health and well-being; and wider rural development.
Mission 3 is for food that is safe, nutritious and appealing, trusted and valued at home and abroad with a particular focus on the importance of trade. Food Vision looks to protect and build on Ireland's global reputation as a trusted supplier of high-quality, safe, sustainable food to consumers at home and abroad, built on sustainable steady value growth. This mission aims to prioritise coherent food and health policies for better health outcomes, enhance consumer trust in our food system, and create added value through insight, innovation and product differentiation.
Mission 4 is for an innovative, competitive and resilient agrifood sector, driven by technology and talent with key enabling goals around research, innovation and talent.
Speaking to my remit as Minister of State with responsibility for research and development, Food Vision recognises the potential of emerging technologies across the value chain. However, it also recognises the challenges of the equitable diffusion in science technologies and innovation across stakeholders, and the uncertainty associated with technological and social change. It recognises the importance of technology being end to end in scope, linking primary producers, intermediary producers and retailers to address real consumer needs to drive sustainable growth.
The success of any strategy depends on effective implementation and oversight. My colleague, Martin Heydon, the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, chairs the high-level implementation committee whose key task is to monitor the delivery of the four missions through stakeholder collaboration. The fourth Food Vision annual report was recently launched in September at the National Ploughing Championships in Offaly. The report details good progress on implementation, with 98 actions, representing 91%, either complete or having had substantial action undertaken. A further 20 actions, representing 9%, have commenced. That is tangible, measurable progress. This year's report demonstrates the commitment of our farmers, fishers, foresters and food producers to sustainability, innovation and collaboration. The results achieved in 2025 show the progress possible when we work together to build a strong, sustainable and resilient agrifood sector.
Food Vision 2030 continues to provide an effective overarching framework for the agrifood sector. Since the publication of Food Vision 2030 in August 2021, important sectoral strategies and strategic plans have been developed under its remit. Some key publications and achievements across the four missions highlighted in the fourth Food Vision 2030 annual report include publication of the agriculture, forestry and seafood climate change sectoral adaptation plan; the report of the commission on generational renewal and farming; and the national prepared consumer food centre strategy. Other significant developments include the publication of the mid-term review of the national strategy for horticulture, the mid-term review of the forest strategy, expansion of the Origin Green programme, continued investment in farm safety initiatives, the launch of the third one health national action plan on antimicrobial resistance, the continued investment in research, development, innovation and knowledge transfer, including the new Teagasc education strategy 2025-2030, and the opening of the national centre for brewing and distilling.
The 2024 annual report detailed progress on environmental sustainability such as the publication of the national biomethane strategy, the launch of the farming for water European innovation partnership, and the better farming for water campaign.
There were enhanced supports for farmers such as cattle and sheep welfare support, continued roll-out of the national genotyping programme, implementation of the dairy calf to beef action plan, and the launch of the action plan on women in agriculture.
This is the International Year of the Woman Farmer as well, which we need to acknowledge.
The highlights of 2023 and 2024 included the launch of the €1.3 billion forestry programme, the national strategy for horticulture, the national bioeconomy action plan, the national strategic plan for sustainable aquaculture development, the launch of the agri-climate rural environment scheme, better known as ACRES, as well as the development of sustainability plans for the dairy and beef sectors. Other important achievements include the establishment of the Agri-Food Regulator, the launch of the national fertiliser database, and the introduction of the national genotyping programme and the suckler carbon efficiency programme. This gives just an overview of how much has been achieved under Food Vision 2030.
An excellent resource, the Food Vision 2030 dashboard, is now publicly available online. The dashboard is a key component of the implementation and monitoring of Food Vision 2030. It displays baseline environmental, economic and social data for several key performance indicators, KPIs, and provides for a transparent tracking of implementation.
A mid-term review of Food Vision 2030 is ongoing. As we enter the second half of this decade, it is timely to reflect on what has been achieved and formally consider how Food Vision 2030 can evolve further to ensure it remains ambitious, focused and responsive to evolving challenges and opportunities. We decided to commence a mid-term review of Food Vision 2030 rather than begin a new strategy process because its core mission and ambitions are as relevant to the agrifood sector's challenges and opportunities today as they were four years ago when it was published. A mid-term review will allow us to update anything that requires updating while ensuring overall policy stability. The sector needs clarity and stability. It needs to know that long-term strategies will be followed through and not replaced before they are fully delivered. After the post-2027 Common Agricultural Policy, CAP, is agreed, it will be timely to consider the period after 2030. Consultation with stakeholders has been a key part of the review process. The mid-term review is expected to be published shortly.
The Irish agrifood sector has faced challenges and uncertainty in the past, but it has always shown resilience and agility in responding to them. Under the framework of Food Vision 2030, the agrifood sector will continue to contribute to national and global food security while also continuing to provide a viable way of life for our farming and fishing communities. Together, we are building an Irish food system that is sustainable, resilient and trusted, one that delivers for farmers, rural communities, consumers and the environment.
I am delighted to have had the opportunity to outline briefly what the Department is doing. I thank the House for the invitation and look forward to the contributions of my colleagues in the Seanad. Go raibh maith agat.
Comment on this
Go raibh maith agat. Anois, before we proceed, I welcome to the House guests of Councillor Noel Thomas and Kyle Lohan. They are very welcome from County Galway. I did not see Deputy Richard O'Donoghue. I call Senator Paul Daly.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister of State. Without starting a mutual admiration society, I compliment him on his work since assuming this role.
I have been mapping his progress, travels and trade missions. The entire sector, including the Food Vision 2030 strategy and our food exports and food production, depends on our markets. It depends on the quality and quantity of our markets will always be determined by the quality of the product we are bringing to market.
The Minister of State has been on trade missions, along with Bord Bia and Teagasc, from which we got a very good briefing this morning. Teagasc does a great deal of work behind the scenes to enhance production and its quality here at home. As was said this morning, the greatest problem for producers and farmers at present is input costs. Teagasc is working diligently to try to help farmers and producers reduce those input costs so we remain competitive in the world market.
This is a good news story. Every few years we get a chance to talk about our Food Vision 2030 strategy. I welcome that there is a review. We are talking about it and the ongoing process now. As the Minister of State said, Food Vision 2030 is a stakeholder-led strategy. It is not imposed by the Government, Teagasc, Bord Bia or the Department of agriculture. The vision and plan for the ten years are stakeholder-led and this is vital. Stakeholders know what they need, what they can do, the targets they can achieve and the targets they need to set to push themselves to achieve them over the ten-year period.
From its inception, the period from 2020 to 2030 was always going to be tricky because it came on the back of Brexit. As we are all aware, we exported food from the agriculture sector worth €20.8 billion in 2025. That represents 10% of total exports. The vast majority of those exports, though, had been going to the United Kingdom market. When this strategy was being prepared, it was hard to predict, to say the least, what direction trade was going to go in and what proportion we could retain of the market in the United Kingdom after it left the European Union and could open itself to other world markets. That is what we are competing with and this is the job the Minister of State and Bord Bia are doing. It is appreciated.
I want to raise a few issues that we must keep our eye on between now and 2030. The Minister of State mentioned in his opening contribution the ongoing negotiations on the MFF and CAP. The success of our food and agriculture industry over the past 60 years was based on one thing and that was the inception of CAP. It was introduced as a cheap-food policy. It subsidised Irish farmers' incomes so they could produce cheap, affordable, traceable and high-quality food. That was what it said on the tin, as the saying goes. That was the reason the CAP was introduced and that was what it was meant to be. It has changed a lot in the meantime. Even if we keep receiving the same volume of money from the CAP - we will not even mention the possibility of a reduction in the funding because the debate about fighting hard to maintain the CAP budget within the multi-annual financial framework is one for another day - many other constraints have been put on spending the CAP money.
These include environmental measures, which are all good because the food we produce needs to be sustainable too. I am not knocking environmental schemes or anything, but these obligations do put more pressure on farmers to achieve a margin when they are selling their product. If there is no margin, succession will be a major issue. The Minister of State mentioned encouraging more women to go into farming. We will find it very difficult to get females or males of any age, young and up and coming farmers, into the sector if there is no margin. It will be very hard for us to be competitive in the world market and have a margin on our food production without having it subsidised. The CAP is vital, therefore. The success story of this whole sector was based on the foundation that was the formation of the CAP in the 1960s. We have to fight hard for that.
I also mention the Minister of State's colleague, Deputy Timmy Dooley. As the Minister of State is well aware, he passes my little village each morning and evening when travelling to and from Galway. Fisheries are not a major issue for me, living in Kilbeggan, County Westmeath. The Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, though, also established the Food Vision seafood sector group in February. It is vital for coastal communities because fishing is as important to those people as beef production is for me living in the midlands. I welcome the work of that group is running hand in hand with the review of Food Vision 2030 that the Minister of State mentioned.
We need to keep our eye on a couple of things, and part of this is land-use strategy. We have to have the debate about land use, land-use change and forestry. There are many constraints applying to our land and that is putting serious pressure on farmers' capability to produce food. We have energy targets to meet. Unfortunately, these include something I am very worried about, namely, solar farms being put up on what I would call good quality agricultural land. Every solar farm put up on good quality land means a reduction in our ability to produce food.
In a similar vein, we need to produce or plant more trees. That is part of our plan going forward. This is more land that has gone out of food production.
Pressures are being put on food producers, particularly the tillage sector with regard to crop yield, because of the change in climate. Climate is changing and that is why it is so important that we can produce our food sustainably. It is very obvious to anybody who was in Ireland this summer that the area from Port Laoise to the south and the south east was burnt up. Some of our crops are not able to handle the change in climate. They will be able to do so eventually because nature is brilliant. Nature will eventually evolve the seedlings and crops to adapt to the new climate, drought, excessive rain, wind and storms but it is not going to happen quickly enough and we really need to have a debate about gene editing. I am not talking about gene modification. I am talking about gene editing to help and enhance the strength of the crop to be able to withstand the change in the climate for the sake of food production.
That is basically it. The review will be interesting. People are already thinking of 2030 to 2040. Much of what is in 2030 to 2040 will be dependent on CAP 2027 and the availability of land. I cannot stress enough that we need to have the whole food security debate. They all have to be done but we cannot keep putting houses, forests and solar farms on good land, or growing grass on good land to put it into anaerobic digesters. I sound like I am contradicting myself because I am pro-anaerobic digestion but it grieves me to hear of silage grass being drawn into an anaerobic digester instead of being drawn into a shed to feed cattle to produce beef or milk.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister for agreeing to come in to talk about Food Vision 2030. We shared a table this morning at the Teagasc breakfast briefing of Oireachtas Members. From the feedback of the Members with whom I spoke as I was leaving, I can tell the Minister of State that they were highly impressed that he should give the time, listen from beginning to end and do a summary of the engagement. I want to pass on that feedback because it was really important. A variety of stakeholders were at that briefing. Without recapping too much of it, one of the really strong messages was about farm succession. The Minister of State heard it himself. I also raised the issue of horticulture and how horticulture is getting somewhat lost in the bigger remit of agriculture and forestry and that is critically important. I said this morning - the Minister of State was there and heard it himself - that there are now only nine registered commercial carrot growers in Ireland. That is a shocking situation and a real pity. We talk in here about a lot of the technical aspects of agriculture, food production and food security but, for the average punter outside the Houses, one thing is certain, namely, that we are going to die and, in the meantime, we have to eat. Everyone needs to eat food so there is no division between rural and urban that some people might suggest but there are major challenges in a country with a climate like ours where we cannot extend the growing season.
I acknowledge also the Government's commitment to the horticultural energy supports that have been put in place. I am thinking particularly of soft food producers, which require energy for water and irrigation. We know that even carrots need irrigation. From potato growers, we know about the importance of bringing water to the crops along with whatever energy diesel engines use to pump water so our major challenge is about resilience and climate resilience and how that is evolving so fast. It is going way ahead of us so fast. It involves how we can bring irrigation to crops, how we can embrace innovation in terms of horticulture and food production and how we can address the issues around food security. That is really important.
I acknowledge, as did Senator Paul Daly, the importance of Teagasc and its work. It is the Irish agriculture and food development authority. That is what its main focus is. We have to look at training. Have we the necessary training skills for people in forestry, agriculture and food production? One does not have to be an academic to be a farmer. That is not to say it will not help but I am making the point that there are people who learned the practices of agriculture from the age of 11, left school at 12 and 13 and have owned hundreds of acres of very sustainable and proper farms. They have to be commended so let us not shift a gear such that it becomes a major academic subject. Agriculture is a science but there are places for apprenticeships in farming. There are places and opportunities in further and higher education for agriculture too but as we seek to progress policy for agriculture and horticulture, let us not leave people behind. There is a place in every facet of agriculture and food production and our educational system must respond to that important need, so I thank Teagasc for that.
What is the aim of Food Vision 2030? Its aim is for us to become a world leader in sustainable food systems. We are not there yet. It is progressive and we are making great strides and over the next decade, that is what the vision sets out to do. The vision has to be fully adhered to and the temptation of course is that we go off track because of other considerations. I am really encouraged today by the Minister of State's contribution to the debate here and the fact that there has been ongoing review. As Senator Paul Daly said, this is bottom up. The stakeholders have been involved in this vision and that is clever. Everyone is a stakeholder in Food Vision 2030. We have to stay focused and deliver on the significant benefits of Food Vision because farmers are businessmen, businesswomen and families and they have to be able to see the benefits. Irish agriculture has to see the benefits.
I am also conscious of the environmental considerations and sustainability. It is important that at the very core of this vision, we remember economic sustainability, social sustainability and environmental sustainability. They carry equal weight in my book and that is what a sustainable future, sustainable food and a sustainable vision have to be about. Our sustainable food system has to demonstrate very clearly that it is profitable throughout but benefits society generally. The stakeholders - the farmers, who are the primary producers - need to see benefit in terms of their pockets and their investment. Somehow I think with all our policies, we sometimes lose the ability to have clarity and simplicity in our communication strategy. When the Minister of State speaks to his officials again about this, let us always strive to keep the message simple and give absolute clarity.
I suggest four areas that the next review might look at in more detail. They are already included in the strategy but I would like to see a greater focus in the next 12 months. They are the climate smart environmental sustainable agri food sector; viability and resilience for primary producers, which is critical; and food and safety in terms of nutrition because that is the key aspect. When one talks to people about food, be they producers, consumers or retailers, they will all talk about the importance of safety. The Irish public and people abroad who consume our food want to know our food is safe and nutritious and that they can trust the suppliers of our food and the value both home and abroad. We saw through the controversies in Bord Bia that people's confidence was slightly shook and it was a difficult area. Let us not shy away from it. There were significant issues of communication and messaging around Bord Bia and its brand. I always like to stick to the topic rather than the personality and, at this point, I acknowledge the very significant and positive contribution of Bord Bia in promoting our food. I also acknowledge the Minister of State's very significant commitment to trade missions in terms of all of our foods but particularly in the meat sector. I know he addressed the Asia Matters conference in Galway recently and again the feedback from that was very positive. There are international markets. We tend to look at European markets and, critically, our market in the UK, which is phenomenal. The UK is our nearest neighbour and there are enormous opportunities there that we need to look at but the Asian market matters, particularly in the areas of pork and beef, and there is great potential for expansion.
We also need to support our own poultry production. There are serious concerns about poultry production in Ireland. We know the amount of poultry, particularly chicken meat, that is imported into this country. If organised, supported and structured, this country is quite capable of upscaling its poultry production.
The Minister of State will have heard Senators clearly on farm succession. Women in agriculture is something I have spoken on numerous times in recent months. We have another two months to go before the end of this year, which is the UN designated international year for women in farming. We have to acknowledge the very significant role of women in agriculture. The Minister of State mentioned that this morning in his own presentation. It is very significant.
I will finish on horticulture. The Government should keep the focus on Irish horticulture, its marketing and the wonderful success that is Irish mushrooms. I will say well done. It is a good news story. There is a lot to be told. We should keep it simple, keep the messaging clear and keep the focus on quality Irish and the potential for greater collaboration between North and South on the island of Ireland in marketing our good, nutritious, safe and healthy food.
Comment on this
The Minister of State is very welcome to the House. I am very glad to have a debate this evening on food, particularly food safety and the Food Vision annual report. It was launched at the National Ploughing Championships by the Minister, Deputy Heydon. It is one of the biggest days in the calendar year for our farmers. It is a spectacle to behold to see so many farmers turn out to show that we are proud of what we produce in this country. I commend our farmers in every sector from fishing to our drinks and food. Without them we would not have the industry we have here. As the Minister of State said, we export over €20 billion and that is thanks to our indigenous farmers.
I welcome the report. Agriculture has seen huge challenges since I came in here. I did not think there were as many problems in agriculture and food. Briefly, we had a TB crisis, which we have dealt with and I welcome that; a fuel crisis which affected all our farmers; a drought crisis during the summer; issues with fertiliser and fodder; and, as our colleague referred to, the bluetongue crisis. We had a number of crises through the agricultural sector. CAP negotiations have to be the number one item going forward. A strong CAP means we show our farmers we really believe in what they do. Horse Sport Ireland is in the sector. That affects everything that goes on. We have live exports now which are very important to the whole sector. Our live exports to a number of countries have ceased and it is important that we get them open to other countries because our suckler farmers depend on high-quality end weanlings which are highly sought after all over the world. It is something we have to look at and try to open new markets that are safe. Then there is cybersecurity. We have seen refrigeration attacked in a number of stores in recent weeks. It shows the challenges around the agricultural sector and the geopolitical landscape and where we fit in the world.
I welcome the continued success of the agrifood sector, which is one of Ireland’s greatest national success stories. It supports thousands of jobs and sustainable rural communities, and makes an enormous contribution to rural Ireland. We cannot forget the contribution that Irish farmers make. Ireland’s reputation as one of the world’s leading food-producing nations has been built over the generations through quality, innovation and a commitment to high standards. However, it cannot be taken for granted. Around the world our competitors are investing heavily in research and technology. Someone here mentioned Asia. On a visit to Taiwan last week I saw first hand exactly what innovation really and truly means. We need to see an acceleration in investment in innovation in the agricultural sector if we intend to sustain Ireland as a global leader in food. We need to invest in research, in technology and in training our young people, whether it be women or young people in agriculture more generally.
That leads to my next point about succession and the increasing age of our farmers we have seen in recent years. People will not take up farming at a younger age, whether that is due to the farmer not giving up their rights at home or otherwise. We must invest in younger people and have supports for succession and generational renewal. That has to be key in the next CAP. If our intention is to support the agri sector, which is worth €20 billion and will grow in the future, we have to support the people going into the industry. That is our younger people and younger farmers both male and female.
Someone touched on the growing area of water quality and derogation. Our product is sought after all over the world. I know that in the Asian market, especially Taiwan where we were last week, they are mad to come here and do business with us because they see the quality of our beef, pork and lamb and the high standards we produce them to. It is a market that I hope we will look to in the future. Having met the president and vice president last week, I know they are very keen to come and do business with us. We need to look at this and open it now.
We have to support our young farmers with new initiatives. There are Irish companies which are growing with supports, but we need to see a greater emphasis on supporting these companies into wider markets. That includes the UK and also America and further afield. I welcome the Food Vision report. I would emphasise a point made by Senator Daly. Food Vision is stakeholder led. It has to come from the ground up from the farmers and the primary producers back up the whole way to the processors and everybody else.
Someone else mentioned Bord Bia. It plays a significant role internationally in what happens regarding our exports. I compliment it on the work it has done. Yes, we have seen challenges within Bord Bia and that is reflected in the latest report but there is a standard, Origin Green, which is visible on the global market. It is a world standard that nobody else can match. The way we produce food here is seen across the world as a green, grass-fed system. I can say here that nobody else has the same passion and know-how passed on from generation to generation about how we produce our food.
After being in Taiwan, I am really proud to be a farmer in this country. It gives me great pride to say we have a product that is so sought after all over the world. It is something we need to grow. We need to have an organic label for our system in world markets. Organic, and chemical free, seems to be something everyone is looking at now.
There is a niche market for us in Ireland in respect of organics globally. I hope we can open up some of those other markets with trade missions. I thank the Minister of State for coming in here.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister of State. I too support the ambition behind Food Vision 2030 and the fact that it is making Ireland a world leader in sustainable food systems. However, we need to ask ourselves a fundamental question when it comes to this, namely, what does sustainability mean if the people producing our food cannot afford to make a living out of it and if the next generation cannot see a future for itself in it? There is a theme across the floor today, which seems to be on viability of farms and generational renewal. The viability of the family farm and regeneration of Irish agriculture must be at the heart of this strategy. Food Vision 2030 recognises the importance of viable and resilient primary producers. The commitment is very welcome but we must look beyond the commitment. We need to see beyond commitments on paper and examine the reality facing family farms in this country today and into the future.
The Minister of State is aware that the OECD's report in 2026 looked at the 2024 Teagasc national farming report. Only 43% of those farms were found to be economically viable. It is quite scary when you think there are that many who are farming in this country but who will not be viable into the future. We need to seriously look at the costs that are being put on the smaller farms and not just pump our resources into the economically bigger farms. We need to keep our family farms.
We have an agrifood sector that generates billions of euro in exports and enjoys a strong international reputation. As has been heard, Bord Bia does a fantastic job representing us abroad, yet export success does not automatically translate into a fair income for the farmer. We must ask whether the value generated throughout the food supply chain is being shared fairly with the people who do the hard work throughout the process of producing the food.
Farmers are facing significant input costs - a point we have heard throughout the House today - uncertainty around markets, increasing regulatory demands and the practical challenges of running a modern farm. For many in farming, it is not just a business. It is a family commitment, a way of life and a responsibility passed down from generation to generation. We cannot take that commitment for granted.
The second issue is to highlight generational renewal. If we are serious about the future of Irish agriculture, we must make it possible for our young people to enter farming and actually make a viable business out of it. You can see it; it is being said every day and it was said in Buswells Hotel today. You see somebody coming out of school or college and they get a guaranteed income from a job. Then you see that they might have a family farm at home. They are weighing up which one they can live off. It is unfair because in their heart, it is the family farm, but their pocket is telling them to get that secure job with a guaranteed income. We need to look at that when it comes to generational renewal.
The Teagasc figures that were published show that 4% of Irish farmers were under the age of 35. It is actually shocking when you think of it. Some 38% are over 65. A lot of that 38% over 65 probably have no option to retire so they are going to keep working, because the farm needs to be worked. If they do not have somebody to take over, they are going to be pushing themselves further every year. Who is going to produce the food in 20 or 30 years if we do not have that generational renewal?
Young farmers face real barriers and that includes access to land, the cost of investment, access to finance and the complexities of transferring the family farm. Even where the family has a willing successor, financial and practical obstacles can make that succession difficult. The Commission on Generational Renewal in Farming made 31 recommendations addressing issues such as taxation, the CAP - as we have heard - pensions, access to land, supports and collaborative farming. I welcome the Government's recent budget 2027 measures to strengthen the succession farm partnership tax credit. That is very important because we need to look not just at the young farmers coming in but we need to take care of the farmers who are retiring. It cannot just be a cliff edge. We need to make sure they can retire, whether it is retiring full stop or coming out of it slowly but surely. We need to make sure there are supports there for them because it can be quite difficult. What came out in the budget is a positive step but it must form part of a much broader effort to tackle the barriers for young farmers.
The issue of women in farming is very important, considering it is the year of the woman farmer. Women in agriculture do an awful lot of hidden work that is not always seen. They are doing the books in the background and are out on the farm. We need to acknowledge what women do when it comes to farming.
The third issue is the future of the family farm itself, which is just as important, if not more important, than the big industrial farms because family farms are in every single community, town and county around the country. They are not just economic units. They sustain the rural communities and veterinary practices in the area. Co-ops would go out of business without the farming community, as would the local shops and pubs. It keeps the local area vibrant and alive. In counties such as Limerick, agriculture remains essential to our economic identity and to keeping our rural towns alive and busy. If you take out the rural and farming side, you are left with a shell. That seems to be happening around places. You see it when a shop or a post office closes. A certain number of people come out of the village and you do not seem to have that hustle and bustle any more.
When the family farm becomes unviable, the consequences extend beyond the farm gates right across the community. Therefore, we must ensure that Food Vision 2030 supports farming systems of different sizes and types, including beef, sheep, dairy, horticulture and tillage. The future of Irish agriculture cannot just solely depend on the expansion of our bigger farms and larger operators. We need fair and predictable farm incomes. I have heard that a lot. We spoke about that a lot in the agriculture committee. For not just the farmers who are farming but for the next generation, we need to have an income they can survive on. I know a lot of farming is part-time. That seems to be the future but would it not be nice for somebody to get into farming and not have to do it part-time but where he or she could do it full-time?
Ultimately, we must judge Food Vision 2030 not just by the value of our exports. We need to judge it on whether it delivers for the people actually working the land, who are at the heart of this review and the project. If we want to protect Irish agriculture for the future, we must make farming viable for the people who are farming today and achievable for the next generation who are coming into farming.
Comment on this
I thank Seanadóir Collins. I welcome Seanadóir PJ Murphy and his guest to the Gallery. Anois, an Seanadóir Noonan. An mbeidh sé ag roinnt ama?
Comment on this
Yes. Trí nóiméad agus cuig nóiméad.
Comment on this
Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit. I also welcome to the Public Gallery my friend and colleague, Paolo Negro, who is a councillor from the Emilia-Romagna region in northern Italy. If you want to see co-operative and organic agriculture, go to Emilia-Romagna. It is a really wonderful place that has self-sufficiency at its heart. That is something I want to speak about briefly in the three minutes I have.
In particular, I wish to talk about the horticulture sector. There are significant challenges there, as the Minister of State knows. I have been engaging with Talamh Beo. I ask that the Minister of State tries to meet it at some point because it has brought forward a scheme to extend the basic income scheme to small-scale growers. I would say we should be extending it to small-scale island fishers as well. It is hugely important that we look towards food sovereignty. The point has been made about the cyberattack on the SuperValu refrigerated units. That is something that is co-ordinated and is going to affect us all right across Europe over the next number of months and years. It is critically important for our growers in Ireland. Some figures say that there are only 70 of them left; there are actually quite a lot more. A lot of them are operating in very small-scale operations and could do with support. They are vulnerable to the weather impacts. We see it with polytunnels blowing down. They are vulnerable to the heatwaves we have had and to lots of other susceptibilities of the market.
We should have access to small markets like they have in northern Italy and we should be shortening our supply chains. That is critically important. I ask the Minister of State to give consideration to what the sector is looking for more broadly, not just the large growers but the small horticultural producers in Ireland.
We should have more abattoirs. We should have small, independent local abattoirs all over the country and I say that as a vegetarian. We should have a market for venison in Ireland. We need to cull deer in significantly higher numbers than we are and we need a marketing strategy for what is the finest organic meat a country can offer consumers. It would ultimately bring down prices for families if we were not importing food on the scale we are.
Looking towards regenerative models of agriculture, soil health and how we can over time improve water quality through regenerative practices is important. I ask the Minister of State to take that back with him and to give consideration to supporting an indigenous horticultural sector, food sovereignty in Ireland and reducing the food imports we have.
Comment on this
Cuirim fáilte roimh an Aire Stáit. I am delighted to be having this discussion. The Minister of State is welcome to this House, where you pick up so much information.
As a party we welcome the four key missions of Food Vision 2030. I appreciated being invited to the Teagasc briefing. This is the year of the woman farmer and I have been in contact locally with Macra na Feirme. Young women are driving a lot of the work to be seen throughout the country and it is great that we are celebrating that and having conversations about it. As someone who is not from a farming background, I genuinely believe farmers are the custodians of our land. We see the hard work of generations of farmers and it is great to hear the expertise about farming and from an environmental point of view.
We are looking to increase our markets and develop opportunities like the sale of venison. I live in the north west, where there is a huge number of deer. We need to think creatively outside of the box to ensure our food security. We can see the work farmers are doing to promote nature and farming alongside our natural world and not fighting against it and they deserve to be commended on that. In my own area, farmers make space for the hare's corner, for the curlew and for the corncrake. While these are creatures on the brink of extinction, farmers have really stepped up to the plate in this regard and moves like this need to be rewarded. We need to not just meet costs incurred but to provide payment for climate actions because we can see that climate chaos is getting worse. Farmers need to be supported in any possible way they can mitigate the affects of climate change.
Farm income from counties Sligo, Leitrim and Donegal, where I live, is standing at €38,500, which is well below the national average. From speaking with my local IFA group, farmers in these areas depend so much on the areas of natural constraint, ANC, payments. When the ANC payment originally came in, it was for areas along the west coast in particular. It was originally set up for that region because farmers are hampered in areas of natural constraint. There was a reduction in that payment in 2008 that was never fully restored. Farmers need that payment. In my locality, as we do not have access to a big city, they spend their money locally. They spend in co-ops. That money is spent in our local economy when kids are going back to school or college and there are extracurricular activities. We are not near any big cities. I have been involved in politics for the last three or four years and ANC payments are a huge issue that comes up year after year. The concern coming back to me around the CAP negotiations is about the ANC payments.
There has been a lot of talk here about a horticultural centre and looking at organic markets. The straw incorporation measure has seen the quality of more than 67,000 ha of land improved and the planting of more than 800,000 native trees is to be commended. We have seen the other side of that in the plantation of Sitka spruce and how that has destroyed the quality of both water and soil. It is great that we are reflecting on what does not work and recognising that we need to concentrate on native plants.
I agree with Senator Brady that there is a huge appetite for organic food. We are all so proud of our food. When you travel abroad you realise nothing compares to Irish food and we are so proud of that. We are in a unique situation in that we are an island and not only is our climate great for producing vegetables and supporting livestock but we are also surrounded by the sea. We have a great opportunity here but subsidies are needed to ensure that when people go into a supermarket, Irish produce is always cheaper at source. I do not know how we make that happen but Irish produce should always be cheaper.
In a cost-of-living crisis of course people are going to choose something cheaper that has been imported hundreds of miles or could be covered in pesticides. If Irish produce is cheaper, however, people will buy it. As Senator Noonan said, we need to reduce our over-reliance on imported food and grains.
I thank the Minister of State for this discussion. I am delighted we had this debate at which I have learned a lot. While the Minister of State loves Gaeilge, ní he lá na gaoithe lá na scolb. Now is the time we need to prepare to make our island and food security more sustainable as we can see the climate chaos is continually getting worse.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State and welcome this opportunity to take part in this debate on Food Vision 2030. I have listened very carefully to the contributions of all of our colleagues and we are all singing from the same hymn sheet. The mission set out in Food Vision 2030 is very important. Senator Cosgrove spoke about thinking outside the box and we need to do that. There are plenty of opportunities to do that. I wish to point out that the only commercial fisherman out of Rush Harbour, which is in north County Dublin, is catching whelk off Lambay Island for the markets in Japan and Korea. There is not much of a market for it here in Ireland but they love it in Japan and Korea. There are huge opportunities, along with venison and other items, and we need to think outside the box.
We have excellent innovators in our farmers and they have adapted. As the Minister of State said in his opening statement, they are very resilient and adaptable to change. They have embraced the environmental requirements we have placed on them and implemented changes in their farming methods. They are to be commended on that. I live in north County Dublin and my constituents are the commercial vegetable growers, glass house innovators, and multigenerational farmers who have fed Ireland for generations. It is the market garden of Ireland. Farmers are the lifeblood of rural communities in Dublin. We have a sizeable and thriving rural population in Dublin. That comes as a surprise to many people but these farmers are keeping alive both those rural communities and the unique heritage of the rural part of north County Dublin.
It is very important that we support our farmers. I particularly point out the young farmer of the year 2026, namely, Shane Halpin, who is a constituent of mine in north County Dublin and is a great young man from Lusk. He grows cucumbers and Brussels sprouts through Welgro Produce in north County Dublin. He is an example of a young man very open to innovating and adapting. We need to support our farmers who are coming under tremendous pressure from many different sources. My colleague, Senator Paul Daly, spoke about the CAP process and how it is nearing completion and the importance of making sure farmers have a margin. I acknowledge that the Minister of State and his colleagues in government are very aware of this but the pressures facing farmers are completely unprecedented. The energy costs, in particular for the soft fruit growers who grow under glass - I have many of them in my own area - are huge.
They are facing huge pressures. I appreciate the energy support scheme, particularly for the horticultural sector. It is really welcome.
The severe lack of rain during the summer put pressure on potato growers. I was helping them to do a couple of rain dances across north County Dublin at one stage looking for rain. Thankfully, a bit of rain did come towards the end of the summer. Our tillage farmers are under similar pressure with fuel costs they face. Again, the Government support is welcome but there are other pressures that my colleagues have referred to, particularly around land use. In north County Dublin, there are a number of pressures from housing. We are absorbing the housing needs of Dublin. We need houses and I am supportive of houses but a lot of farmers are coming under huge pressure to sell their land for housing. Once that land is gone, it is gone. That impacts our resilience as a nation.
Senator Daly referred to the solar and wind farms coming around the country. I understand the position of some landowners who may opt to go this way but we need to make sure farming families have good decent incomes from farming so they do not opt for the solar farms as we are seeing across the country. I am very much in support of renewable and solar energy but we need to ensure our own food security. We have seen climate change impacts across the globe reducing the amount of arable land, the disruption to our supply routes due to war and conflict and flooding and wildfires. We need to make sure we secure our land and that we can look after ourselves because we cannot trust the rest of the world to feed us. We have the best of land and produce here. We need to look at it from a wider security point of view. We look at our energy and border security. Food security needs to be spoken about in the exact same terms because it leads into our resilience as a nation.
We are also at risk of losing our land through many other risk factors. I pointed out the housing risk factor. I know that is not just in north County Dublin; it is in a lot of other urban areas. I appeal to the Minister of State to remember the horticulture producers in particular but all farmers are doing the State some service. They have kept us going through good times and bad. We rely on them to secure us and the health of the nation. I would appreciate all the Minister of State can do to help the farmers.
Comment on this
I thank Senators Paul Daly, Boyhan, Brady, Collins, Noonan, Cosgrove and Clifford-Lee for their contributions. Some of the issues mentioned are not under my remit but I will speak about those that are.
CAP is important; we all know that. CAP has been very good to Irish farmers down through the years. The EU has been exceptionally brilliant too. When we joined the EU back in 1973, 80% of Ireland's exports were live cattle. This Government is fully committed to the agricultural sector as well as the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine along with the Minister, Deputy Heydon, who is doing excellent work on CAP. We are under pressure. The CAP budget is under pressure. Europe is changing. There are a lot of demands on the budget. The Minister gave an update at Cabinet on Tuesday. He is fighting a hard battle on that. I hope we can get more scope and move it around a bit to go into more projects but that is a matter that has to be agreed between the EU agriculture ministers. The Minister is doing a lot of work on that. The EU has been very good to farming. At the moment, the total agricultural export is 9% of all exports from Ireland. That export is in excess of €21 billion. We export to 190 countries. We produce enough food to feed 36 million people.
I go abroad and meet my colleagues around the world. I was at the SIAL food show in Paris only last week. The Senator spoke about cybersecurity. I met representatives of Albert Heijn. It has 1,258 supermarkets in the Netherlands. It was hacked. Its whole business is computerised. It can change prices up and down with a push of a button. Some 30% of its sales are online. It was hacked and the whole computer system went down. It lost millions upon millions of euro. Then we saw what happened with SuperValu only recently. I spoke with the chairs of Tesco Ireland and the UK. They told me they have put billions of euro into cybersecurity to try to keep their systems safe. That is the world we are heading into now. We are very proud of what we have achieved. The Minister is working on CAP. He is doing a good job.
The Senator spoke about the Asian market. I was in Vietnam; it has only 30% food security. I was also in Cambodia. The most important thing my counterparts there kept bringing up with me when I met them and the various food distributors we supply to was security of supply and quality of the product we supply. That is where I can bring up Bord Bia, Teagasc, farm to fork, traceability and Origin Green. They are fascinated that we have an organisation called Bord Bia. The work of Jim O'Toole, Larry Murrin and his team within Bord Bia is excellent. We know the Asian market is a very important market. I was in Cambodia and Vietnam, the Minister was in Japan and South Korea and the Taoiseach was in China. He will lead a very high-powered delegation to India in January. We are concentrating a lot on the Asian market. I spoke at the Vietnamese national day, Chinese national day and I will speak at the South Korean national day this year. My influence in my role as Minister of State for food is that I speak at these events proudly of what we produce and the quality product. Stakeholders are the most important people from the farmer up to the distributor. We can trace all of that. It is stakeholder led which is crucially important.
Succession is an issue. It is not just an issue in Ireland. I attended the G20 conference in South Africa; my colleague Sean Bell was with me. In the session on the Friday afternoon with the G7 - we were a guest nation of South Africa - the debate was on farm succession. It is an issue worldwide. It is not just an issue in Ireland. The agriculture Commissioner has made it his top priority. Women have a very important role to play in that. Senator Daly attended the Teagasc briefing this morning when this story was told. A woman stood up who was the only daughter on a farm. She farmed the farm but at the end of the day, it was not left to her; it was left to her nephew because a woman should not get a farm. Going back 50 or 60 years, that was a thing at the time. It is changing now. In 2024 and 2025, the winners of the young farmer of the year were women. I had the pleasure of presenting the 2025 award to a lady. They have a huge part to play. They are very interested in farming.
Talking of succession, I did the Mountbellew Agricultural College awards last year and will do so this year as well. I hope to have good news for Mountbellew Agricultural College and Gurteen College. We have to support the colleges. They teach the young people and bring them in. Young farmers are changing. They are not like the old traditional farmer. They are using new technology. When you visit a farm run by a young person, he practically runs it from his iPad. It is amazing. The Senator spoke about at the Teagasc event this morning about getting up at 2 a.m. to see if a cow was calving or if a cow was sick. You just look at your device now and it will tell you about the cow. That is technology. That is why we have to make farming attractive and viable.
The Senator spoke about the small farmer. When I was growing up, there were 17 dairy farmers in my area to the east of Galway city.
Now there is only one dairy farmer. He milks over 400 cows. At that time, the 17 farmers used to milk about 25 to 30 cows and while it was viable at that time, it is not now. The Senator talked about trying to keep the family farm. As I said at the Teagasc briefing this morning, these two young brothers have taken over a lot of the small family farms. They have not bought them but have rented them. The farm is still being farmed. Unfortunately, it has gone to the stage where it is not viable on small farms for a wife and kids or a husband and kids or whatever to be reared. They have to work. That is what happening with the small farmer. The Government is fully supportive of the small farmers and is doing a lot of work on the farming.
Organics is a new thing. I was very interested. I presented the organic awards at the Bord Bia head office recently. Dunnes Stores won an award. A few other companies won awards as well. I am always impressed when I go into Dunnes Stores. They have the organic section. I always go to that section. I actually think that organic food is a lot nicer than the other food. I mean no disrespect to the other producers of food but I always buy the organic food. Dunnes Stores won an award. I like the organic carrots. I know the issue of the carrot farmers was raised in this House. There were ten of them and it is now nine. I think we are producing enough carrots in Ireland at the moment to keep the Irish market going.
We have put in a lot of supports. Horticulture is not under my remit but under that of the Minister of State, Deputy Collins. We gave grants of €15 million last year to the horticulture sector. We know there are challenges out there. We know that there is pressure there. We brought in the fertiliser support scheme, which is worth €40 a tonne. I believe it is from 1.5 tonnes up to 100 tonnes. We have brought in the fuel support scheme. The National Strategy for Horticulture 2023-2027 provides a roadmap to facilitate the further development of the sector. As I said, agriculture is critically important. I was also present in Cork where I gave the keynote address for the European meeting on organics. As Senators know, we hold the Presidency of the European Union. I was delighted when Kay O'Sullivan won the European organic farmer of the year award. I had a good discussion with her.
I will look back on the transcript and read what the Senators have raised. Some of them are under my remit and some are not, but I will pass them on to the Minister of State, Deputy Collins. Fisheries is important. Other Senators have mentioned that. I have been in Donegal fairly regularly and I have seen a lot of these massive trawlers tied up. It is a challenge. It is mostly dealt with through Europe. I know the Minister of State, Deputy Dooley, has done an awful lot of tremendous work on that in Europe. It is important for the coastal communities that we keep the fishing industry alive.
I thank everybody for their contributions. Since my appointment as Minister of State, I have learned a lot on agriculture, Bord Bia and Teagasc. I forgot to mention Teagasc. Teagasc does excellent work. Senators have seen that this morning. I think most of the Senators were at the presentation this morning.