We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›

Crime Prevention

Summary

Senator O’Reilly called for stronger protection for women councillors facing targeted harassment and online abuse, including clear reporting procedures and laws that enable action against digital abuse. Minister of State Brophy acknowledged the problem, encouraged public representatives to seek security advice from Gardaí and undertook to relay the call for further action to the Minister.

Mark Daly An Cathaoirleach Fianna Fáil

I welcome the Minister of State, Colm Brophy.

Comment on this

I thank the Cathaoirleach for selecting this item. I welcome my colleague, the Minister of State, Deputy Brophy. It is the first time I have had the opportunity to address him here. I acknowledge his proactive work in his Department on a number of fronts. The Minister of State, like colleagues in the House, will be aware of the publication of the local democracy task force report and how that has given rise to a discussion on local government, the role of our councillors, their powers, and so on. Specifically, it brings into focus the question of female representation, the number of women councillors and their treatment.

In recent months, at least 80 of our women councillors fell victim to repeated, highly inappropriate phone calls. These calls were undoubtedly targeted to intimidate. They were accompanied by a constant undercurrent of online abuse, which remains. It was disturbing for me, as a fellow public representative, to witness this. Our women colleagues responded with great grace, remarkably so given the disgusting and despicable nature of the calls. A direct attack on our women councillors is unacceptable. Ireland champions equal rights, which is a core value for us. I am proud that my party, when then Minister, Mr. Hogan, was in office, created the quota system to break the glass ceiling for women entering public life. For that reason, we feel much concern about this.

A survey conducted in 2011 found that one third of all women councillors had experienced harassment and sexual misconduct in office. This shows that the recent phone calls were only part of a pattern. The local democracy task force has a role in strengthening local government and transferring responsibilities. However, dealing with abuse and intimidation has to be a central first step. We as a party have produced safety guidance, training and support for our women councillors and all candidates to deal with that.

In the context of digital abuse, we have traditionally had a code for the print media for years, but we have not yet dealt adequately with digital platforms and digital media. I would be interested in the Minister of State's response on that. Councillors must have access to clear reporting procedures and support when incidents of harassment occur. We must consider the safety of councillors, including appropriate digital security measures. More needs to be done. There has been work on youth recently, and that needs to be stepped up, as does digital surveillance in general.

Online abuse, intimidation and threatening activity need to be dealt with. There must be proactive and positive encouragement of women to enter politics and to feel that it is a safe space for them, not just the avoidance of this type of activity. As an aside, the abuse, including a death threat, that one of our women colleagues here in the Seanad, Senator Keogan, received over recent months was shocking. I am specifically addressing the question of women councillors. I am interested in the Minister of State's response on what he sees his Department being able to do about online abuse and protecting our women in their role as representatives.

Comment on this
Colm Brophy Minister of State at the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration Fine Gael

I thank the Senator for raising this important issue. I am here to respond on behalf of the Minister, Deputy O'Callaghan.

The right to free and fair elections is a fundamental part of our democracy. It is important that people feel they can participate safely. That includes women and people from the new communities who have come and settled in Ireland and are thankfully now a vibrant part of our local democracy. We should never be willing to ignore or fail to take seriously intimidating behaviour and threats against people participating in public life. The culmination of that is to deter people who are future leaders in our community. Every form of abuse, including verbal abuse, intimidation and harassment, has no place and cannot be tolerated. People have a right to object, to voice dissent and to hold public representatives to account. I fully understand that. However, there is a collective responsibility to do that.

I take on board the comments the Senator made about further measures we can take. The Minister, Deputy Jim O'Callaghan, engages with An Garda Síochána. An Garda Síochána has a proactive engagement procedure for public representatives. It will talk to and engage with public representatives about their personal security, including any particular threat or issue they wish to raise. I encourage anyone having an experience as a public representative, be it at local or national level, to engage with An Garda Síochána and its relevant officers.

I take the Senator's point on the digital side, however. I know the Oireachtas has been looking at addressing this issue. The Government has looked at this across a range of areas because it is an important issue, particularly when it comes to the interaction in that newer element of social media, which is, effectively, an unregulated space compared to the traditional media. It is particularly sad - the Senator is right to highlight this point - to see the level of vitriol and abuse directed at almost every utterance and comment of female public representatives at all levels. It is a greater level than that directed at male colleagues. It is an unfortunate testament of our society in so many ways that keyboard warriors hiding many kilometres away think they have the right to carry out this level of abuse and intimidation. At the heart of it, we need to work with An Garda Síochána and make sure that people feel safe in their roles as public representatives.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Minister of State’s positive response. First, he accepts there is an issue. That is an important section of his response. Second, he accepts the need and willingness of his Department to react proactively. As I said, and as the Minister of State acknowledged in his remarks, in essence, it boils down to the fact that were a woman councillor – it could be any councillor but I am using the example of a woman councillor in this context - to be abused in the traditional print media in any shape or form, it would be immediately actionable. We have to arrive at a similar situation for the digital platforms, social media, etc. A woman must be able to walk into a Garda station and show the material to a garda, and that garda then must have the legislative back-up and laws to act on it. It has to be a given that it is treated as reprehensively as it would be if it were to be in the traditional media.

I welcome the Minister of State’s response. It is a good first step. I hope he can follow it up with actions and controls.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator. I know it is something he feels strongly about. He has raised this issue with me previously. I completely take on board what he has said. To reiterate, I will feed back what the Senator has said here today to the Minister, Deputy O’Callaghan. It is vitally important that we recognise the need to have a broader base of participation in public life, particularly at local level. We need to foster and encourage people to get involved in politics and contribute to their communities and society. At the heart of it, people must feel safe to do that. Not only must women feel safe to do so, but people from our newer communities, as well as men, must also feel safe in that regard. It is particularly important that we establish boundaries around what is said and put up on social media because the impact of the type of abuse and unacceptable behaviour we have seen in recent times can be hugely traumatic, not solely on the individual but on their families too.

Comment on this