We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›

Health Services

Summary

Senator Teresa Costello called for better access to pain relief, including nitrous oxide or sedation, and clear information before coil insertion. The Government said pain-management choices should be agreed between women and clinicians, local anaesthetic is available where appropriate, and HSE initiatives are working to improve preparation and care.

I want to raise an issue that I feel very strongly about, one that I know will resonate with women right across the country. It is about the pain that women can experience when having a Mirena coil fitted. I want to know why, in this day and age, women are still expected to put up with what can be a very painful procedure without being offered adequate pain relief.

First, I acknowledge the investment that the Government has made in women's health, particularly through the free contraception scheme. It has made a real difference and I welcome that.

The Mirena coil, along with other hormonal coils like Kyleena and Jaydess, is what is known as long-acting reversible contraception, LARC. These coils are highly effective forms of contraception. For many women, they can be life changing, particularly for those dealing with heavy periods, but getting a coil fitted can be an entirely different experience. Some women will say that the fitting was uncomfortable but manageable while other women will say it was the most painful experience that they have had, which is what concerns me. We hear stories of women being told to take a couple of paracetamol before their appointment and that they will feel a little pinch that will be over in a few minutes. For some women, the pain is more than a pinch and that reality should not be dismissed.

There are pain relief options available, including nitrous oxide. This will be the first time ever that Members will hear me talking about the legitimate uses of nitrous oxide, because as many people know, I have a huge issue with the illegal use of nitrous oxide in our communities. Nitrous oxide is commonly known as gas and air, which can help people manage pain and anxiety while remaining awake. There is also intravenous sedation, which can make a woman more relaxed and sleepy during the procedure. Finally, there is general anaesthesia, where a woman is completely asleep. I do not suggest that every women needs to be put asleep to have a coil fitted but I am highlighting what is available. Surely if a woman is extremely anxious and has experienced a traumatic insertion previously or knows that she cannot tolerate the pain, there should be a proper pathway for her to access additional pain relief or sedation.

I want to make a point about local anaesthetics because this issue has been raised with me. A local anaesthetic can be used but it can involve injecting the cervix, which can be very painful. For a woman already frightened of a procedure, that may not be an acceptable option for her.

I want to know why we are not looking more seriously at alternatives such as gas and air. Why should women have to seek a private clinic or, potentially, pay out of their own pockets to access a procedure with appropriate pain management? We have made contraception free for women, and rightly so, but what is the point of removing a financial barrier if the woman is then afraid to have the procedure because of pain? In particular, I am thinking of younger women, women who have never had children and women who have already had a bad experience. I genuinely believe that if a man had to undergo this procedure, we would already have had the conversation. He would not be dismissed and told to take two paracetamol and to get on with it, so I do not see why women should have to either.

First, I want the Minister for Health to engage with the HSE and look at how we can make gas and air and appropriate sedation more accessible to women having coils fitted, with general anaesthesia available where clinically necessary. Second, I want to know what is currently available in public hospitals and clinics and why access appears to vary depending on where a woman goes. Third, I want women to be given the proper information about their options before they arrive for the procedure and not when they are lying on the examination table.

We have made great progress in women's healthcare and I am particularly proud of the progress made within Fianna Fáil. I am a great advocate for women's health and I always commend my party for listening when I raise issues and for supporting them. Women should not have to suffer unnecessarily when accessing contraception.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator for raising this important matter, which I am talking on behalf of the Minister for Health, Deputy Carroll MacNeill, who cannot be here this morning.

The Minister has asked me to say the following. The HSE has the national women and infants health programme, NWIHP, has advised - of course, it is medical advice that the Department is getting on this - that the procedure is commonly performed in outpatient settings, as women know, both in the community and in hospitals.

Of course, all experiences are different and pain can vary considerably between patients - between women - and can be influenced by a range of individual and clinical factors.

The NWIHP advises that women should be fully informed and supported before undergoing Mirena coil insertion. This should include a discussion about pain and discomfort, recognising that experiences vary considerably and can range from little or no pain to much more significant pain. Local and general anaesthesia can support pain management, but of course there are risks and potential side effects which should be discussed in advance. The advice internationally is that general anaesthesia is not recommended as a first-line approach for routine coil insertion. Where an anaesthetic option cannot be provided locally, alternative referral pathways are available, if required. Decisions should be made jointly by the woman and her doctor.

The NWIHP has also introduced a range of initiatives to better support women accessing ambulatory gynaecology services, including measures to improve preparation for procedures, pain management and the overall patient experience. In 2024, the NWIHP completed a national review of ambulatory gynaecology services, with a strong focus on improving women’s experience of care. The review recommended strengthened approaches to pain relief and anaesthesia, better information for women in advance of their appointment, access to local anaesthetic where appropriate and clear reassurance that a procedure can be paused or stopped at the woman’s request.

In late 2025, the NWIHP conducted the first national ambulatory gynaecology patient experience survey, which provided important insights. The survey found that 81.17% of respondents reported mild to moderate discomfort, while approximately 10% reported severe pain and 9% reported no pain. It also found that 85.6% of respondents had received advice on pain relief in advance of their appointment. These findings provide an important national baseline. In particular, the experiences of women who reported severe pain underline the importance of continuing to strengthen patient preparation, communication and access to appropriate pain relief. The survey will be repeated to help to monitor progress and inform ongoing improvements in ambulatory gynaecology services.

Through the continued implementation of the model of care for ambulatory gynaecology and the development of specialist women's health services, we are committed to improving women's experience of gynaecological care. This means ensuring that women are listened to, appropriately supported and provided with timely, high-quality care that reflects their individual needs and circumstances.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister of State. I would appreciate if he went back to the Minister to highlight the benefit of the nitrous oxide option. It is a case of giving them a little whiff and letting them on their way. There is nothing more effective than lived experience. When I see the percentages of women who are giving feedback, I always think the numbers may be a little bit out of whack. Not everybody responds to such feedback requests, so you are dealing with low numbers. The coil, as it is referred to, is a localised hormone so it is probably one of the safest and most effective forms of contraception. I would hate to think that any young woman who might want to avail of it would not do so because of pain. I spoke to a few young women and when I mentioned its application, they winced and they all said it was pretty painful.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator. Of course I will bring her comments back to the Minister for Health. Every woman undergoing coil insertion should feel informed, supported and listened to throughout their care. While the procedure is routinely undertaken in community and hospital outpatient settings, experiences of pain and discomfort vary considerably. It can be very painful for some women.

The HSE has advised that local anaesthetic can be offered, where appropriate, as part of the pain relief options available. Ultimately, every woman should feel supported to discuss her individual needs, concerns and preferences with her healthcare professional. Decisions around pain management and coil insertion should be made together, ensuring that the approach reflects each woman’s individual circumstances and the care that is most appropriate for her.

The Government's three women’s health action plans focused on delivering practical improvements in healthcare for women and girls across Ireland. I thank Senator Costello for recognising that and for her work on informing them. We can see the impact of that investment in the free contraception scheme which is available to women between the ages of 17 and 35. We have expanded ambulatory gynaecology services, with 19 clinics established and another two under development.

The women's health action plan, which was published on 8 July, has a focus on embedding and expanding services and strengthening research and innovation. Improving women's health services is about listening to women and ensuring their experiences inform the design and delivery of services. We will continue to listen and ensure that women receive high-quality, compassionate and responsive care.

Comment on this
Malcolm Noonan Acting Chairperson Green Party

I welcome the pupils from Tullamore Educate Together National School and the members of the Killeigh visual arts group who are guests of Deputy John Clendennen. They are very welcome to Leinster House and I hope they enjoy their visit today. It is customary for schoolchildren to have no homework tomorrow as well. Their teacher is with them so I want to notify them of that.

Comment on this