We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Seanad

Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›

Student Visas

Summary

Laura Harmon warned that visa refusals and delays are costing colleges millions and affecting staffing and local economies, and urged the Government to collect institution-level data and clarify policy. Marian Harkin said visa decisions rest with the Department of Justice, acknowledged reported impacts, and said officials would meet higher-education bodies and continue cross-departmental engagement.

Malcolm Noonan Acting Chairperson Green Party

I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Harkin, to the House.

Comment on this

I welcome the Minister of State to the Chamber. I want to ask questions about visa rejections and delays when it comes to colleges and universities across the country. It was extremely alarming to hear at the committee on further and higher education two weeks ago from the chair of the governing authority in UCC that they are down €3.7 million this year because of international students being unable to take up places in the college. As their visas were either rejected or delayed, they did not get to come to UCC to study. I know anecdotally, because I have been speaking to colleges off the record, that this problem is being replicated in other institutions across the country. The Technological University of the Shannon is on record publicly as saying they have had to adjust some of their master's courses because of changes in international students taking up places.

What is happening in terms of the policy here? When I spoke to officials in the Department of further and higher education, they told me that this is a matter for the Department of justice, that they do not have the figures and that the Higher Education Authority, HEA, will not be collating them until the end of the year. Why can the Minister, Deputy Lawless, not write to the colleges to find out how much of a problem this is and what it is like in every college across the country? I have had journalists contact me to ask questions about this. It is a sorry state of affairs that a journalist might have to go looking for this information and that the Minister cannot provide it.

If UCC is down €3.7 million, it raises serious questions. If that figure is replicated in other universities and colleges, we could be talking about tens of millions that they are down in funding. Colleges are already down in terms of funding over many years. I hosted a briefing recently with the Irish Federation of University Teachers; the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, ICTU; and other trade unions calling for a better injection of funding into colleges. They are down millions of euro in funding. I also hear that this is potentially an issue that will affect staffing in colleges. When we refuse or delay visas and when that policy is not clear, and colleges are down money because international students cannot take up places, it not only affects the college environment and the college funding but it also affects staffing. I am hearing that staff in many colleges are not being replaced when people retire. Colleges are not hiring new staff members. People are on precarious contracts or part-time contracts. PhD workers are not being paid properly. There is an overall workers' rights issue here as well. Many of these workers in the universities will be going on strike again next Thursday.

This has an impact not only on the educational make-up of the college and the funding of the college, but also on the workers in the college and on the local communities as well. We know that international students and the international education sector in Ireland contribute over €1 billion to the economy in terms of the money they pay in fees, what they are paying for accommodation and the cost they pay to live here as they are going out spending. Many of them work part time as well. They are working in retail, nursing homes and lots of different sectors so they are contributing to the economy in that way.

This is a very serious matter. Have there been policy changes? I am tired of hearing that it is the problem of one Department and not the other. I am not just talking about the Palestinian students who were refused visas, as I know that is a separate matter; I am talking about visa policy in general.

I understand that there are questions for the Minister for justice as well but I would ask that the two Departments link up and provide some clarity to the public in relation to this. It should not be up to a journalist or to me to go away and collate these figures for the Departments.

Comment on this
Marian Harkin Minister of State at the Department of Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science Independent

I thank the Senator for raising this important matter. We all know that international students make a significant contribution to our institutions, research ecosystem, economy and wider society. They enrich the experience of all learners in our institutions and play an important role in supporting Ireland's internationalisation ambitions, as outlined in Global Citizens 2030.

As the Senator said, I am taking this matter on behalf of the Minister, Deputy Lawless, who has responsibility for higher education. The Minister is very much aware of the concerns raised by the higher education sector regarding visa refusals and processing delays. These have been raised directly with him by both the Irish Universities Association, IUA, and the Technological Universities Association, TUA, and he has met with both bodies to hear their views. He recognises that where institutions experience lower than anticipated international student enrolments, whether due to visa refusals, processing delays or other factors, there may be financial implications for those institutions. International student fee income forms an important part of the funding mix for our higher education institutions and fluctuations in student numbers can have an impact on projected income. However, as autonomous bodies, the higher education institutions are responsible for their own financial management and reporting.

The Department of Further and Higher Education, Research, Innovation and Science does not collect data on projected versus actual international student fee income or institution-level data on the country of origin of individual applicants. Consequently, the Minister is not in a position to provide the specific breakdown requested by the Senator. As part of the Higher Education Authority's statutory oversight and governance rules, institutions submit annual financial statements and accounts to the HEA. However, these returns do not include a breakout of international student fee income from the overall student fee income figure.

The assessment and determination of visa applications, as the Senator has already said, is a matter for the Department of Justice, Migration and Home Affairs. The Department of higher education has no role in individual visa decisions. Visa applications are considered in accordance with the relevant immigration legislation and on the merits of each individual case. That said, officials in the Department of higher education engage regularly with officials in the Department of Justice, Migration and Home Affairs on issues affecting international students and researchers, including those concerns raised by the sector, and will continue to do so.

The latest information provided by officials in the Department of Justice, Home Affairs and Migration indicates that up to 30 September 2026, the three largest source countries for long-stay type D visa applications and refusals were India, China and Pakistan. However, it is important to note that these figures relate to all type D visa applications and include those associated with English language education as well as higher education. Consequently, they do not provide a direct measure of visa outcomes for students intending to enrol in a higher education institution. While he is not in a position to provide the specific financial breakdown sought by the Senator, the Minister recognises the importance of this issue and will continue to engage with both the higher education institutions, their representative bodies and the Minister for justice to better understand the impacts being reported and to ensure that Ireland remains an attractive destination for talented international students and researchers.

Comment on this

I appreciate that the Minister of State is taking this matter on behalf of the Minister, Deputy Lawless, this morning and I acknowledge the information provided in relation to some of the countries that have been affected.

It should be a priority for the Minister to know this information. I understand that this is a matter for the Department of justice but that Department is deeply affecting other Departments with the lack of transparency in its decision-making. Given that the two Ministers are in the same party, I assume they talk to each other. The Minister, Deputy Lawless, should make it his business to understand these figures because they are affecting colleges. If he does care about the figures, he should make it his business to know what they are. The HEA might not provide a breakdown but I am sure it is within its capacity to find out this information. It would not be unusual for a Minister to write to colleges to get information that is in the public interest and in his own interest to effectively run his Department. I hope that the Minister of State can bring that concern back to him. This information is going to have to come to light one way or another and the figures themselves could be quite stark.

Comment on this

I thank the Senator and I hear what she is saying but we both agree that ultimate responsibility for visa processing rests with the Department of justice. The Minister, Deputy Lawless, and his officials meet with officials from that Department on a regular basis regarding student visas.

One of the issues that the Senator raises this morning is funding for higher education. She will be interested to know that the Minister will be bringing a memo to the Cabinet on higher education funding in either December or January.

Officials in the Department are meeting with the IUA and the TUA this Friday to discuss this matter. The Minister is very well aware of it and is working on it. He recognises that there is an issue here and is trying to find solutions.

Comment on this