Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
Forestry Sector
Senator Nessa Cosgrove questioned whether the required consultation with the Forestry Appeals Committee took place before €200 appeal fees were introduced, arguing the charge burdens local environmental groups. Deputy Niall Collins said the Department consulted publicly and met the committee in 2019, and defended the fee as a reasonable contribution to costs; Cosgrove disputed his account and promised to send supporting correspondence.
I also pass on my condolences to the Minister of State.
My Commencement matter concerns County Leitrim, which is the most afforested county in Ireland, with over 20% of the county under plantation. County Leitrim has already done more than its fair share. It has reached the Government's target of 18% of a county's land being under plantation by 2050, and it is well above the national average of 11.5%.
Save Leitrim is an environmental, non-governmental organisation that was formed in 2018 out of a concern about the heavy plantation of County Leitrim, largely with non-native Sitka spruce. I have raised this issue many times in the Chamber. It was and is having a disproportionate impact on the local environment and socio-economic life of the county. It is a fantastic group. I have many good friends who are members of this group. It is keen to emphasise that it is not anti-tree in any shape or form.
It is actually pro-tree but it knows the right tree must go in the right area. Sitka plantations, when allowed to dominate an environment, create what has been described as a green wall. We saw how these green walls stood up to the ravages of storms Darragh and Éowyn over the winters of 2024 and 2025, when 27,400 hectares of timber was toppled, causing road blockages and power cuts that lasted for weeks. In the peaty, wet soil of Leitrim, these shallow-rooted non-native trees fell - the analogy was they fell like ten-pin bowling. For those who said Save Leitrim's concern was unfounded, these two storms in such a short timeframe proved the wrong trees were planted in the wrong place, making it not only an environmental and social but also an economic disaster. I will get to the point of the Commencement matter now.
The 2014 Forestry Act was actioned in 2017. This established the forestry appeals panel, an independent body that could hear and judge appeals against a decision made by the Department. Initially, there was no fee for submitting an appeal. Fees were introduced by way of two statutory instruments on 6 October 2020. One was for the landowner making an application to plant trees and the other was for any other person wishing to appeal that decision. The fee for an application was set at €20 and the fee for an appeal was set at €200, ten times the application fee. They were under two statutory instruments: SI 417 and SI 418.
It is apparent that the fees for appeals were set at ten times the level of an application not only to discourage appeals on an individual level, but also to discourage appeals on an organised level from environmental NGOs like Save Leitrim. While the differing views of the Department and the environmental community may involve matters of complexity around the competing demands of carbon targets versus biodiversity, and it is okay to have those differences, my question is very simple. It involves the legal status of fees introduced under these two statutory instruments. Section 14F(1) of the Forestry (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act says the Minister may prescribe fees under certain circumstances. It states, "The Minister may, having consulted with the chairperson of the Forestry Appeals Committee, prescribe fees that may be charged for an appeal, and different fees may be prescribed for different appeals or classes of appeal".
Did this consultation ever take place? If so, are there any memos or minutes relating to the consultation? I have seen communication from the forestry appeals committee dated 24 March 2025 in response to access to information on the environment request that says the information requested did not exist as there was no consultation between the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine and the chairperson of the forestry appeals committee on the prescription of fees. I can send on the emails and response to the Minister of State. A subsequent email dated 2 April 2025 confirms the first chairperson of the forestry appeals committee, Des Johnson, also reported he had no records relating to any consultation regarding the implementation of fees.
Did the consultation take place, and does any documentation exist which proves this consultation took place?
Comment on this
I thank Senator Cosgrove for raising this important matter relating to the consultation process undertaken by our Department in advance of the introduction of the €200 submission fee for appeals to the forestry appeals committee. I will address the legislative basis for the fee, the consultation undertaken with relevant stakeholders, including the forestry appeals committee, and the considerations that informed the decision to introduce the fee at this level.
The forestry appeals committee was established to provide an independent appeals mechanism in respect of decisions on forestry licence applications, including applications for afforestation, felling, forest road works and aerial fertilisation. This provides applicants and third parties with an independent avenue of appeal without having to resort to the considerably more expensive option of seeking a judicial review before the High Court. The legal basis for the establishment and operation of the forestry appeals committee, including the introduction of fees, is provided for under the Forestry Act 2014, the Forestry (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2020 and the associated Forestry Appeals Committee Regulations 2020. In particular, section 14F(1) of the Agriculture Appeals Act 2001 provides the Minister with the authority to prescribe different fees for different classes and types of appeal.
The Forestry (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2020 was introduced as part of wider reforms to the forestry appeals process, with the objective of bringing the process more closely into line with comparable statutory planning and appeals mechanisms.
In determining the appropriate fee, my Department had regard to the fees applying to comparable appeals processes, including those administered by An Coimisiún Pleanála. At the time, the relevant fee for an appeal against a non-commercial development was €220 with an additional charge of €50 where an oral hearing was requested. The proposed forestry appeals fee of €200 was considered in this context. It must be noted that the actual administrative and operational costs associated with processing appeals were significantly higher than the proposed fee, particularly given the volume of appeals being received at the time. The fee was therefore intended to make a contribution towards the costs of administering the appeals process rather than to recover the full cost from appellants.
In relation to consultation, our Department undertook a public consultation process as part of the legislative development of the reforms during which nearly 9,000 submissions were received and assessed. This process also included engagement with the forestry appeals committee. A meeting took place on 1 October 2019 at which the proposed introduction of fees was discussed. My Department's consideration of the fee was informed by this consultation and also took account of the need to maintain an accessible and effective appeals process while recognising the considerable administrative costs associated with the operation of an independent appeals mechanism. In this regard, the Department has had due regard to its obligations under the Aarhus Convention, which seeks to promote public participation in environmental decision-making and ensure effective access to environmental justice.
I am satisfied that the current fee arrangements operate within the relevant legislative framework and that the fee of €200 represents a proportionate contribution towards the cost of administering the appeals process. I recognise the importance of ensuring that the forestry appeals process remains transparent, effective and accessible to those who wish to exercise their statutory right of appeal. In this regard I believe the current fee structure is appropriate. I thank the Senator for raising this issue. I hope that reply explains the situation satisfactorily.
Comment on this
It does not really. It appears there are two different understandings of consultation. Regarding the involvement of the forestry appeals committee and the Department of agriculture, why does the forestry appeals committee have no record of this? The chairperson might have had it in even his own notes or his diary but he has no record of it all. I will send the Minister of State the email. I would love it if he would review it, if possible.
Environmental groups such as Save Leitrim and BirdWatch Ireland have been accused of sending in appeals just to be awkward. They are not. Approximately 92% of appeals submitted by Save Leitrim were successful. It has genuine concerns about the unsuitability of land and that is fair. It has said that environmental harm can be done to peatland, which dries out when it is disturbed by the planting of Sitka spruce. It is not fair on this group that it has had to spend €22,000 on appeals since 2020. That is money that was raised locally. Communities, especially communities in Leitrim where the population is not enormous, do not have that kind of money. A lot of that money could be spent on better environmental projects locally. It seems very unusual that the forestry appeals committee has said it has no understanding that any consultation took place. I will send the Minister of State the email and the corresponding document we got and perhaps he could view them. There are other issues regarding the levy and how high it is. Why should groups like this be exposed to such a big levy when everything they have sent in has been successful? I can follow up on that.
Comment on this
The Senator can send it on but it is the job of the forestry appeals committee to hear appeals. It is not the job of the chairperson of the appeals committee to set the fee. The legislation prescribes who can set the fee. I outlined to the Senator how that decision was arrived at. I also outlined to her that it is less than what would be paid in the equivalent process in An Coimisiún Pleanála. It is a contribution towards the cost. I met with the forestry appeals committee chairperson recently. It is a very busy organisation. It gets a great volume of appeals. The advent of AI has presented it with huge challenges as regards the volume of submissions it receives.
That is a consideration also, I think. It is something we have to look at going forward to try to make the whole system more efficient. However, I will be straight up with the Senator. I do not think €200 is an excessive fee; I think it is a reasonable fee. It is a contribution towards the costs. I ask her to send on the email.
Comment on this
I disagree with the Minister of State and I will send him a copy of the email.