Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
Rail Network
Flooding at Ballycar has repeatedly disrupted the Ennis–Limerick rail service, prompting calls for a lead agency, funding and a timeline for the proposed long-term engineering solution. The Minister of State said short-term drainage or flood-defence measures were being considered and officials were working with stakeholders on an enduring fix, but gave no timetable.
I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Buttimer, to the House and thank him for coming in to take this Commencement matter, which is connected with his Department. It is an issue that has been exercising a lot of political activity and conversation over recent years. We all know how popular train travel is now. In 2023, 86,000 people travelled by train from Ennis to Limerick. In 2024, that increased to, I think, 101,000 or something, which was a significant increase in the number of passengers using the Ennis-to-Limerick railway line. I have no doubt that when the 2025 figures become available, we will see an increase in that.
As people know, as regards travel by train from Ennis to Limerick and from Limerick to Ennis, if you are travelling from Limerick to Ennis, you can continue on to Galway as part of the western rail corridor project. Some 250,000 people use the train between Ennis and Galway each year. If you were to accumulate all the figures between Limerick and Galway, you could be talking about anything up to 1 million.
There is, however, a significant problem, which is that on a number of occasions over the past decade, services have had to be suspended from Ennis to Limerick because of flooding in Ballycar, which is outside Newmarket-on-Fergus, for those who may not be aware where Ballycar is. We have been lucky so far this year that the line has not had to be closed because of flooding, but it causes serious difficulty for people commuting between Ennis and Limerick and between Limerick and Galway, particularly because people have to use buses for already-congested roads, particularly at peak times, going into Limerick city. To have to have a fleet of buses going from Ennis through Sixmilebridge and on to Limerick is not acceptable.
As I said earlier, this has been a political issue for some time. There was an interdepartmental group set up comprising officials from the Department of Transport, the Minister of State's Department, Clare County Council and the OPW. Thankfully, an engineering solution was identified to resolve this issue. The price of this solution is in the region of €15 million to €20 million, which is not insignificant but, when you look at the overall transport budget, is small money to resolve permanently a problem on a line that will get busier and will have more train carriages on it. The problem is that since that interdepartmental report was published, little has happened. No agency has been appointed as the lead agency and no funding has been provided to deal with the problem. I have to agree with Roderic O'Gorman, who criticised the slow pace of this recently.
When will we see this work commence? When will we see the engineering solution activated? When will we see a lead agency appointed to step up to lead on the project? When will we see the funding provided to alleviate it? Even if it were to happen unannounced tomorrow morning, we know that it will take some time before the work has concluded. The people who travel by train regularly between Ennis and Limerick deserve the reassurance that there will not be periods when the service is suspended due to flooding.
I await the Minister of State's reply with interest.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Conway for the opportunity to speak to the Seanad on this important issue. I am taking this debate on behalf of the Minister of State, Deputy Canney, who is taking Topical Issue Matters in the Dáil. I thank Senator Conway, who is a long-time advocate, a regular train user and a user of public transport, and his insights are critically important. As he outlined, the rail line between Ennis and Limerick is an important public transport link in the mid-west and is seeing growth in passenger numbers.
The Government has demonstrated its commitment to continuing to invest in transport in the west and mid-west. I am pleased that earlier this month, Iarnród Éireann published a tender for the construction of platform extensions on the sections of the western rail corridor between Limerick and Athenry, which will enable the use of longer trains on the service. Farther north, as part of the national development plan, funding is being provided to advance the reinstatement of the western rail corridor between Claremorris and Athenry, which will significantly boost regional connectivity. That feeds into the Senator's point about more people using it. In the shorter term, the work on the reinstatement of the Foynes freight line is nearing completion, and freight services should be operational early next year. The opening of this line also gives us an opportunity to run trains from Limerick Junction to Adare on a temporary basis to support the hosting of the Ryder Cup.
As Members of the House will know, investing in our infrastructure is important, but so too is protecting our existing infrastructure and ensuring that it is resilient to hazards such as flooding. I am well aware of the issues the Senator outlined regarding the section of the line near Ballycar, which has caused profound difficulties and the suspension of rail services in the past. These have persisted despite works in which Iarnród Éireann raised the track level at Ballycar to mitigate the effects of flooding. The Department of Transport is engaging with Iarnród Éireann and the National Transport Authority to identify any works that can be put in place to help address the threat of flooding in the short term over the coming winter months, including any drainage or flood defence works that can be supported through the infrastructure manager multi-annual contract. This is a contract between the Minister for Transport and Iarnród Éireann that provides for the protection and renewal of the rail network, including the maintenance and delivery of drainage works on the network. For the four-year period 2026 to 2030, €2.1 billion in funding has been provided to help ensure the protection and renewal of the rail network under the contract.
Officials from the Department of Transport are also engaging with all relevant stakeholders on how best to address the long-term issue of flooding on the railway line, which is likely to require significant engineering works given the earlier investment to raise the track bed. In identifying the preferred solution, the Department of Transport, together with Iarnród Éireann, may also seek to engage with the Office of Public Works to seek its advice and engineering expertise on potential solutions. The Ministers in the Department and officials are all keen to see this issue addressed and a cost-effective and enduring solution identified that supports the ongoing safe operation of the railway line today and for years to come.
Finally, as the Senator knows better than most, Ballycar Lough and its environs lie within a geological and hydrological environment that causes potential issues. In doing any works, it is important that we understand the topology of the area, but also that, for the travelling passengers the Senator mentioned, we provide certainty to the people who use the line, whether through infrastructure manager multi-annual contract work or through further engagement.
I thank the Senator for raising the matter. I urge him to engage further with the Minister of State, Deputy Canney, on the matter.
Comment on this
I welcome the reply. I acknowledge the environmental sensitivities around the solution, but there is a proposed engineering solution, which I have no doubt was developed with consideration for the environmental challenges that exist there. I welcome the fact that short-term work is being undertaken to reduce the risk of services being suspended this winter. Those short-term measures are welcome, and I thank the Minister of State for confirming in the House today that they are ongoing.
However, I believe an agency needs to be appointed to step up and deliver a long-term solution. We also need a timeline for that solution. Perhaps the Minister of State might articulate those points to the Minister.
Comment on this
I again thank Senator Conway for his ongoing commitment and interest, not just in this particular matter but also in public transport in general. As already stated, this is a critically important railway line. It is contributing to mobility and, as the Senator said, to economic opportunities for the people in the mid-west region and beyond. I assure the Senator that the Government is committed to investing in rail and public transport infrastructure in the west and the mid-west and to ensuring that the flood risk at Ballycar is mitigated, particularly the line is an important part of the infrastructure. As I said to the Senator, given the karst landscape at Ballycar, the flooding issue is complex and may require significant engineering works to develop and implement a long-term solution. The Senator is well aware of the report on the flood relief options prepared by the consultant group RPS for Iarnród Éireann, Clare County Council, the OPW and the Geological Survey of Ireland. We must develop and implement a long-term solution, given that past efforts to raise the track have probably not been sufficient to mitigate all flood risk, as the Senator outlined.
Officials from our Department are engaging across the board on this to identify an enduring and cost-effective solution to the flooding issue. In the short and medium term, departmental officials are engaging with Iarnród Éireann to assess the viability of providing short-term relief while also ensuring that works are provided for under the infrastructure manager multi-annual contract to reduce the potential impact of flooding. I will bring the Senator's concerns back to the relevant Minister of State, Deputy Canney.