Industrial Development (Amendment) and Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2026: Committee Stage
Senator Alice-Mary Higgins proposed safeguards for grants supporting environmental protection and digital and technological consultancy, including independent climate expertise, exclusions for fossil-fuel and military-related businesses, and priorities such as just transition, nature-based solutions and digital sovereignty. Minister of State Niamh Smyth rejected the amendments, saying the grants were designed to streamline enterprise support, comply with EU state-aid rules and operate under existing agency oversight. She confirmed that support could cover defensive technologies such as cyberdefence, counter-drone systems and maritime surveillance, while undertaking to provide further details on specific grant scenarios. Higgins pressed her concerns about reduced Government oversight and the risk of public funding supporting harmful or unlawful activities.
No. 42 of 2026 ›
I welcome the Minister of State, Deputy Smyth, to Seanad Éireann for Committee Stage of the Industrial Development (Amendment) and Miscellaneous Provisions Bill 2026.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 2 is in the names of Senators Higgins and Black. Amendments Nos. 2, 3, 6 and 13 are related and may be discussed together by agreement. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
To clarify, we are not going with the previous grouping on amendment No. 1 but are moving to amendment No.-----
Comment on this
We are going to the Senator's amendment No. 2, together with amendments Nos. 3, 6 and 13.
Comment on this
But if amendment No. 1 is moved-----
Comment on this
Has it been agreed that amendment No. 1 is not moved?
Comment on this
I just wanted to clarify because my amendments are grouped with that amendment. That is why I am seeking clarity.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 4, lines 27 and 28, to delete “Enterprise Ireland or IDA, or both Enterprise Ireland and IDA, as the case may be” and substitute “Climate Change Advisory Council”.
Amendment No. 2 and the grouping of amendments Nos. 3, 6 and 13, all relate to the climate aspects in the legislation and the very serious climate concerns that are raised by the legislation. Amendment No. 2 provides that the Climate Change Advisory Council would determine whether an environmental protection initiative is suitable to be funded under the proposed section 21A. At the moment the Bill allows for Enterprise Ireland and IDA Ireland to define what constitutes an environmental protection initiative. I really need to question this. What are the qualifications or the expertise within those bodies in terms of determining whether something is an environmental protection initiative? What resources, staffing, skills or expertise is to be provided if they are making those kinds of determinations? Will they lean on, as I suggest here, the Climate Change Advisory Council or the Environmental Protection Agency as another substitute? I am quite open to suggestions as to other forms of public expertise they could be tapping into in that regard.
The proposed section 21A(3) states these initiatives should be "designed to protect the environment" and outlines in further detail the meaning of initiative "which includes, but is not limited to" actions or activity designed to reduce or prevent pollution, negative environmental impacts or other damage by human activities, as well as to minimise vulnerability to climate impacts. These all seem like positive things and there is nothing wrong with those positive endeavours. There is a concern, however, when we put it alongside other areas and sections of this Bill such as, for example the amendment of the Dangerous Substances Act, which defines certain fossil fuels as alternatives to fossil fuels. Within this Bill, it suggests that certain fossil fuels, which have been signalled as particularly intensive and as accelerants in relation to climate change, should be designated as alternative fuels that have the potential to enhance environmental performance. In that context, the Minister of State can see why I am concerned that those who have been given that kind of completely illogical and factually wrong definition to work with would then be tasked with deciding whether something was an environmental protection initiative. This is why it is important to have the very long expertise in either the Climate Change Advisory Council or the Environmental Protection Agency to determine whether something is actually an environmental protection initiative. Literally they are the Environmental Protection Agency. I will signal now that on Report Stage I may come in with that agency as a possible body but I am interested in the Minister of State's perspective as to where the appropriate expertise might sit. Those bodies should be able to give that expertise in a way that is neutral and that draws on a very established mandate and a well-established set of expertise.
As currently worded, the proposed section 21A gives significant flexibility to Enterprise Ireland and IDA Ireland to fund environmental protection initiatives, which could in fact be the promotion of LNG. That is what is provided for here. It is a subversion of language. It is dangerous and it is literal gaslighting when we go to the idea of what we are being told. It would make far more sense for the Minister of State to ensure, at least in relation to those environmental protection initiatives, that the appropriate expertise was drawn on.
Similarly, amendments Nos. 3 and 13 emphasise that grants awarded under the proposed sections 21A and 21B should not or must not be given to the fossil fuel industry. The proposed section 21A allows for grants of up to €15 million to be awarded without any prior approval from the Government and without any oversight from bodies that have expertise in the area of climate change. Similarly, the proposed section 21B allows for the granting of consultancy grants up to €7.5 million without any Government oversight.
We hear big alarm bells being raised over quite small amounts, such as this week with the people who are long-term unemployed and all of these things. Yet we are seeing these kinds of figures here and we are talking about very large amounts of money that will be separate from Government oversight and have the potential to be routed into fossil fuels like LNG, which will directly undermine our climate goals and our climate targets. There is a question here about where section 15 will be applied in terms of the public duty? How is section 15 going to be reflected in relation to this for ensuring that the issuing of these grants is in line with the duty to all of our collective goals under the climate Act? One of the issues of my being here for three terms is I can see how the last Government failed to take the steps to build on from where we had been.
If I look to three terms ago, we see the Fossil Fuel Divestment Act was brought in by a backbencher, Thomas Pringle, but it was significant. It was a significant thing for which Ireland received and accepted plaudits across the world for moving away from fossil fuels. I look back to a Fine Gael backbencher who took the initiative in terms of the ban on fracking. Again, the Government both received and accepted plaudits from right around the world saying, "Here is a country that showing leadership." We are banning fracking because liquified natural gas from fracking is devastating for the local and international environment. We are not going to invest in fossil fuels any more and we are moving away from them. Not only did we accept all the plaudits, but our Ministers went abroad and sold green bonds across the world, generating billions for our national finances on the back of Ireland's new green agenda. That was three terms ago.
In the previous term, we saw the failure to properly shut the door. We had temporary moratoriums on data centres. We had temporary moratoriums as suspensions in terms of LNG. The previous Government failed to shut the door properly on these, but we were told not to worry because there was so much goodwill there. This Government is, frankly, full steam ahead on moving back into fossil fuels and dragging us back into LNG. Looking to Ireland, the narrative in the previous terms was that we would only ever see LNG being used in this complete emergency scenario for our energy security. I sat through the climate committee hearings where this one hypothetical scenario of a cable being broken was being used to justify the significant expense around this national LNG terminal. Now, we have industrial policies, which are literally saying not only do we want to start talking about LNG again and we want to relabel it, absurdly, as being a transition from fossil fuel when it is a fossil fuel, and we also do not want the Government to have to know about it. The provisions there - the ones that I am trying to address - allow that these grants that could be going to liquified natural gas can happen without the Government's approval or prior approval at all. If it is an attempt to wash our hands on fracked gas, it will not fly.
I am worried the amendments in this Bill dig us deeper into this hole. The grants that may be awarded under this section could go towards the promotion of the use of liquified natural gas and other fossil fuels that are being labelled as transition or cleaner while disregarding the very wide environmental impact of the processes around their extraction, storage, the wider dependency on fossil fuels and their accelerant process. We think about climate change and the tipping points. I came from the climate committee this morning and we heard all the modelling and what 1.5°C means versus what 2°C or 2.5°C means. Will we see a metre of sea level rising in Ireland or two metres as the experts say? This is what is being discussed. That is how urgent it is for us, leaving aside those for whom it is literally life and death already.
In that context, LNG is not just one of the dirtiest fossil fuels when we look to fracking and how it is extracted, but it is also an accelerant because it involves impacts, which may not last quite as long as certain other carbon and may be gone in 120 years. I do not want to give the figure inaccurately and I am going to check for when I come in during my next intervention, but it could be a many times greater short-term impact. The methane hits harder, higher and faster in terms of accelerating climate change. That is what LNG is. Right now, we are looking at it being labelled as a potential environmental protection measure and giving Enterprise Ireland - I do not even know if it wants this - the brief to potentially go out and give grants in relation to that without checking with the Government. Where does section 15 kick in here? Is it the Departments that can answer on the section 15 piece? Where is that going to be captured?
Section 21B also provides for consulting. I am going to my other amendment. Again, this is a positive amendment. It is one that can improve and strengthen Bill. If we take section 21B at its best possible interpretation, it is to provide for consultancy grants to be made in respect of environmental protection and sustainability, as I have already outlined. There are concerns. There is less clarity on this in relation to section 21B. What does it mean? Amendment No. 6 seeks to provide a little bit more detail on what we might mean by sustainability. It specifically suggests areas. Again, I am coming straight from the climate committee to this. I have actually just left the committee. The scientist experts this morning were telling us that we needed nature-based solutions and just transition measures, which means supporting different kinds of enterprises that move us away from enterprises that are driving climate change. When we talk about sustainability, let us start drilling into things like why should Enterprise Ireland and IDA Ireland not be supporting just transition initiatives and nature-based solutions. Maybe we need to start naming those, especially since we are going to the trouble elsewhere in this Bill of specifically naming LNG as one of the only environmental protection measures getting highlighted.
Comment on this
I apologise. I missed the beginning. Can I speak to amendment No. 1?
Comment on this
No. They are grouped together. When we get to amendment No. 8 - amendments Nos. 8, 9, 11, 12 and 1 are all related - the Senator can speak to the amendment.
Comment on this
That is perfect. I thank the Cathaoirleach for clarifying. I apologise for the-----
Comment on this
I just want to speak to the amendment briefly.
Comment on this
We will get to it. Does anyone else wish to speak on amendment No. 2? No. I call the Minister of State.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for her very heartfelt contributions to the amendments and this Bill.
While I thank the Senator for her proposal, I cannot accept amendment No. 2. The purpose of the Bill is to streamline the activities of the enterprise agencies and to make grants for carbon abatement easier as part of the national effort to meet climate targets. It would appear that the effect of this amendment would be to make grants dependent on an assessment of a third party rather than on the enterprise agencies in each case. It is the role of the enterprise agencies at the operational level to administer and assess these grants, not external third parties. This is the governance process. This amendment is not practical and runs entirely counter to the purpose of the section and the Bill as a whole, which is to simplify and speed up the process around assessing grants aimed at objectives such as carbon abatement. To be clear, the granting authority will be the agencies. They must assess the specific activity proposed. What is important is that the definition used in relation to this grant mirrors the language used in the general block exemption regulation. It is important as the enterprise agencies must also comply with state aid rules when assessing these grants.
I am also not able to accept amendment No. 3. IDA Ireland provides grants to eligible client companies that have gone through an onboarding process. The role of the IDA in this area is attracting and supporting foreign direct investment in internationally traded goods and services rather than exploring or extracting fossil fuels. Equally, Enterprise Ireland operates under national legislation, EU state aid rules and Government policy, particularly policy set out by the Department of Enterprise, Tourism and Employment. Consideration of potential supports for sectors or companies takes place within this framework. Enterprise Ireland supports companies that are engaged in eligible industrial activities, which is broadly understood to be manufacturing, or which sell certain services internationally as defined under the services order.
In broad terms, the current legislation does not permit Enterprise Ireland to support areas of primary production, which the fossil fuel sector might be considered to be. The context of manufacturing requires an alteration to the nature and composition of raw materials to produce a new product. In this context, Enterprise Ireland is not permitted to provide funding to companies that produce only primary products or that are involved in primary production.
Industrial undertakings are being incentivised to take actions which have a positive impact in terms of carbon abatement. It has to be borne in mind that only actions beyond the statutory requirements under EU regulations would be eligible under this grant, as otherwise there would be no state aid basis for it. Therefore, enterprises are being incentivised to take action that they would not otherwise be required to take from a statutory perspective. Furthermore state aid rules, specifically Article 36 of the General Block Exemption Regulation on investment aid for environmental protection including decarbonisation, set out specific conditionality to ensure such investments do not result in the expansion of production capacity or higher consumption of fossil fuels. Naturally, our enterprise agencies cannot provide support where no state aid basis exists for it. Therefore, while I thank Senators Higgins and Black most sincerely for their engagement, I cannot accept the amendment.
I will not be accepting amendments No. 6 or No. 13 either because the purpose of the consultancy grant is quite clear and well defined. It is to aid enterprises in relation to the green and digital transition. The language referred to in these amendments by the Senators relates to the proposed consultancy grant and to section 21B of the 1986 Act. Their amendments would change section 21B(2), which sets out the purpose of such grants. The purpose and the associated conditionality have been framed very carefully, in consultation with the enterprise agencies, to facilitate specific identified business cases. Therefore, wording which departs from those specified, well-defined objectives should not be dealt with as part of the amendment or this Bill, which is quite specific in scope, as initiated. It is important that the amendment properly enables the enterprise agencies to achieve the objectives they were tasked with, following what was a very lengthy policy development process regarding the green and digital agenda and transition. These objectives for enterprises are strongly reflected in the programme for Government and the action plan on competitiveness and productivity. The results of these changes would be to create ambiguity and make it more difficult to interpret what the grant is actually for. Again, I thank the Senators for their engagement but I cannot accept the amendments for the reasons outlined.
Comment on this
I ask the Minister of State to elaborate on the bespoke scenarios in relation to this. If she could give us three examples, that would be useful.
Comment on this
I ask the Senator to forward that request in writing and I will liaise with my Department officials to provide three examples of bespoke scenarios.
Comment on this
I will do so. Lots of small and medium businesses across Ireland have shown incredible leadership in relation to climate action, as have lots of community initiatives and community enterprises. They have shown initiative and have tried to drive best practice. However, they have seen that, rather than be rewarded for best practice, they are, in fact, very often penalised. So much of the policy seems to be geared towards facilitating the greenwashing of very large enterprises, rather than rewarding and actually supporting the smaller ones. With respect, there is a degree of concern here. We already know what kinds of scenarios we believe these grants are designed for. I know of many projects.
Just transition is about the reality that businesses will have to change. Lots of businesses that are currently in carbon intensive situations and industries may need to pivot. Communities who may have been employed by Bord na Móna or similar companies may wish to have new enterprises coming through. Is the Minister of State confirming that is not in the mix? That is all we were looking to do - to add in just transition as one of the scenarios.
In terms of nature-based solutions, I do not know whether it was the IDA or the consultation process that decided to fine-tune it this way. Will any climate experts be involved in the process for these new, very large grants that are to be issued, with substantial public resources getting routed through it? Every climate expert who has appeared before the climate committee, not just over the last year two years but for the last ten years, has talked about nature-based solutions. If we are worried about those two things being in the mix because there are other things in mind, that is a signal of concern in itself. It is a disappointing message for communities trying to drive just transition and those businesses trying to develop nature-based solutions, which the experts tell us will actually be one of our best protections environmentally.
To go back to the question of hiding behind the European piece, am I correct in saying that the Minister of State is looking to the EU bloc's framing of LNG within transition fuels? Is the Minister of State saying that is the EU piece coming through or is that happening here in Ireland? I just want to be clear because it could very plausibly be either. What we have seen, sadly, in Europe in the last two years was, frankly, a despicable grovelling to the United States. Sadly, we know that Ireland has not been immune to that process of saying that we are willing to buy things in an attempt to curry favour. I ask the Minister of State to clarify whether that definition is being driven by a shift in the EU definition. We can see that what is actually being changed is our national law. We are changing our national definition. We are creating a brand-new definition, so I would like to know exactly where that new definition is coming from. I respectfully suggest that if it is coming from us internally, it needs serious reflection. If it is coming from the EU's shift in direction, then Ireland should be taking a stand, in line with its previous position on fracking and fossil fuel divestment, especially at a time when the geopolitical calculations might be and should be shifting again.
Comment on this
Again, I thank the Senator for her observations and contributions. I reiterate the point that the definition used in relation to this grant mirrors the language used in the general block exemption regulation. This is important as the enterprise agencies must also comply with state aid rules when assessing these grants. As regards the consultancy piece, that is around heat pumps, solar panels, insulation, manufacturing and so on. If I can provide the Senator with any more detail, I will do so. I will speak with officials later and see if we can do that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 5, between lines 9 and 10, to insert the following:
“(3A) An environmental protection grant granted under this section shall not be made to an industrial undertaking that is, in part or wholly, a fossil fuel undertaking as defined in the Fossil Fuel Divestment Act 2018.”.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 4, 5, 7 and 10 are related and may be discussed together, by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 4:
In page 5, line 30, before “technological” to insert “ethical and sustainable”.
In terms of this set of amendments, amendment No. 4 would insert "ethical and sustainable" in advance of the word "technological". Amendment No. 5 would replace "digitalisation" with "digital sovereignty", while amendment No. 7 would insert the category of "cooperatives and social and community enterprises". Amendment No. 10 relates to a "consultancy grant for the engagement of consultants to provide advice or studies granted under this section shall be made in line with domestic and international law."
These amendments are trying to refine the grant-making process so that it would be more effective and contribute better to the national needs. Amendment No. 4 seeks to ensure that any consultancy grants made under section 21B for technological innovation consider the ethics and sustainability of those endeavours. When people hear "consultancy grant", they think it is a few hundred thousand euro for a consultant. It is up to €7 million. These are big grants. The section reads "A consultancy grant may be made for the engagement of consultants to provide advice or studies in [terms of] ... technological innovation and digitalisation". It is left as wide as that. The Minister of State will be aware that not all technological innovation and digitalisation are equal, of equal benefit or of equal value to the public, particularly given that these grants, as set up, will not be made in engagement with the Government. It is important that there would be a little more guidance in their respect at this point to ensure they genuinely serve our collective policy purposes.
Amendment No. 4 is similar to the one we submitted to the Regulation of Artificial Intelligence Act 2026 and it is in the same spirit. Our concerns about the AI Office were related to the dual functions of the office where it is being required to regulate the development of AI in Ireland and promote AI innovation. These are the dual functions and this is the tension that is clearly there. At a minimum, there is tension and potentially also direct contradiction at times between these two roles. Similarly, in this Bill, Enterprise Ireland and the IDA are being given the power to grant consultancy grants of up to €7.5 million for the purposes of technological innovation and digitalisation. This provision is concerning when we look alongside other provisions of the Bill, for example, the deletion of section 8(5) of the Science and Technology Act, which is the one that prohibited Enterprise Ireland and the IDA from giving grants to military firms, or at least said that if they were to give grants to military firms, it had to be done in consultation with the Government. Having this wide framing of technological innovation and digitalisation without having any of the caveats there begs the question whether under this consultancy will be given to those companies developing military technologies or, as other Senators talk about, defence, security or resilience industries.
We have seen technological innovation. One of the places we have seen it really at work is in Gaza where new forms of killing have been invented. This is happening in terms of autonomous and decision-support systems and the role of technology in allowing for far greater lethality with far less accountability. There are companies in the military space that are investing in technological innovations in the area of drones and we have had Ministers - not the Minister of State, I would say, but others - talk about wanting to get more access to the money in this sector because it is one of the fast-growing areas for making money. Fossil fuels and weapons are the big money spinners and there are real questions here. That is why a very small act that might give some sense of assurance to people is if the Minister of State were to accept our amendment No. 4, because that would at a minimum include the phrasing "ethical and sustainable technological innovation". Why not put the caveat "ethical and sustainable" in front of "technological innovation" because it certainly would go some way towards giving us a future ground to challenge if we see these exceptionally large grants used in appalling ways?
Similarly, digitalisation is moving apace. Frankly, some of the companies who are involved in digital, the big international companies or major companies, may benefit and we could come, maybe on Report Stage, to look at what size of company gets to benefit from these grants. That is something that may be worth examining. However, the very large companies do not need Government grants. They are currently, perhaps temporarily, awash with cash. Where there is a gap, and it has been recognised at European level, is in digital sovereignty, digital development that allows us to be independent of the largest international digital actors, digital sovereignty that creates new kinds of payment systems, and digital sovereignty that allows for new kinds of search programme and new kinds of processing, the kinds of work that we need to happen within Europe and within the European Union. Given that digital sovereignty is now being named as a priority at an EU level, I would suggest this is a clear opportunity to say that if we are routing money and if this large flow of money is going to go towards developing things, let us prioritise where it goes and ensure that it is going not simply to company farming or supporting the very largest established actors, some of which have been acting in ways that have been egregious, but towards our digital sovereignty and the digital tech that will allow us independence and, in that way, coming into line with what is acknowledged as an EU priority concern. That is amendment No. 5. It would be another opportunity for this Bill to route money away from the big multinational businesses and towards the kind of indigenous businesses which we really need to be resourcing. That is coming with my finance committee hat on in terms of our exposure to large multinationals. At present, we need that second string to be coming through.
Amendment No. 7 would allow that consultancy grants could be for the "development of cooperatives and social and community enterprises". I mentioned those at length in my previous contribution but this is part of what gives us a protection against the overdependence that Ireland has, which is acknowledged by economists, on FDI. Social and community enterprises are the kinds of activities that circulate money back into the community. That would be a really interesting area for more grants and for more money to be routed into.
Lastly, amendment No. 10 looks to ensure that grants under this section would be compliant with international law. I am very concerned, as I mentioned, that the provisions in the Bill could lead to State investment of public moneys in military activity or of consultancy towards the development of military activity that contravenes international law. Domestically, as amendment No. 11 references, we have strong provisions in terms of the investment of State moneys in military industries. We have the cluster munitions divestment. We have measures in respect of cluster munitions and other kinds of munitions, but it is not clear where any of that is in this. Also, we can look to the two International Court of Justice, ICJ, judgments, one which says that states should not be investing money in any way that contributes to the maintenance of the illegal settlements, that same one that we used when we passed the Government's diluted version of the occupied territories Bill, which the Government has given weight to and put into a preamble to its own legislation and which also applies here in terms of this kind of investment, and the ICJ judgment of the January previous, which reminds all states of their duty to take every possible step where there is a risk that they could contribute to or fail to prevent genocide. I am worried that we could see military technologies because we know there are partnerships. We need to look to Galway and what is happening with the very concerning partnership between University of Galway and Technion and others.
I am worried grants could be given under this legislation for the development of military technologies that could be used in breach of international law more widely and of those specific ICJ opinions.
I would like to know two things. First, will the Minister of State accept this amendment to create a safety net in relation to that matter? Second, if there is a breach and we discover IDA or Enterprise Ireland money has contributed to technologies used in this way, who will be responsible? Will Enterprise Ireland or the IDA be considered responsible for the breach of international law or will the Government be responsible? Later in the Bill, the Government attempts to remove - it is literally like "Don't ask, don't want to know" - the requirement for the IDA or Enterprise Ireland to check with it before giving these military grants. Is this an attempt to create deniability?
I say this in the context of a triple lock debate where we are being lectured by the Government about its perspective of "Don't you trust the Dáil, don't you trust the Government, why do you want to have these safety nets in place in our legislation?" Meanwhile, the Government is removing itself from the accountability structures in relation to military technologies and how they are used. Government members do not want to be in the room when the money goes flowing towards weapons. Will this be like Shannon Airport, but hidden inside our grants system? Will we say who they choose to give money to is an independent matter for those enterprise bodies, even though the decision is being made in this legislation to remove the current accountability structures?
It does not ring very authentically, even from a cybersecurity perspective, which is another thing we hear a lot about. If there are technologies with military, hybrid military or cybersecurity implications, should the Government not want to be kept in the loop if it is providing money for these technologies? This Government is telling us all we have to grow up and take cybersecurity seriously. I take it very seriously. That is why I take data regulation very seriously. The single greatest contribution Ireland, as a neutral country, could make to our EU colleagues and globally is by holding large tech platforms accountable. We do not need to remove the triple lock to do that. We just do not really choose to do it as yet. Similarly, this is a whole area of military activity on which the Government is, in this Bill, choosing to turn its back.
I apologise for having to press these concerns but they are significant. I note again the specific question I asked on international law: if international law breaches are found in areas the development of which has been funded through these grants, where will culpability lie?
Comment on this
I appreciate the Senator's heartfelt and well-founded observations and amendments. However, amendments Nos. 4, 5, 7 and 10 also relate to the consultancy grants and I will not be accepting them.
In relation to amendments Nos. 4, 5, and 7, I repeat the rationale I previously articulated on how this grant has been defined in the amendment. It is to aid enterprises in the green and digital transitions. I apologise if I am repeating myself but the rationale is the same in these cases. The purpose has been framed carefully in consultation with enterprise agencies to facilitate specific identified business cases. Therefore, wording which departs from those well-defined objectives should not be dealt with as part of this amendment or this Bill, which is quite specific in scope, as initiated. It is important the Bill properly enables the enterprise agencies to achieve the objectives they were tasked with following a lengthy policy development process regarding the green and digital transitions.
The proposed wording changes either provide no enhancement in terms of meaning or actually depart from the intended purpose, for example, by substituting "digital sovereignty" for "digitalisation". There are specific operational reasons for the language used. Digitalisation is a recognised process which enterprises undertake and it must be assessed strictly on that basis. The result of these changes would be to create ambiguity and make it more difficult to interpret what the grant is for.
In relation to amendment No. 10, the agencies are subject to ministerial direction under the Industrial Development Acts and overarching policy. Of course, the agencies must also act in accordance with the law. Furthermore, they are subject to robust governance and oversight procedures, as statutory bodies.
The Senator asked about the precedent for setting the threshold at €7.5 million. That threshold reflects the long-standing governance structure which operates regarding grants under the 1986 Act. Grants under this threshold are evaluated by the agencies through their robust analysis and governance procedures. This is the role of the agencies under existing legislation. They have demonstrated their capacity to perform this work effectively over decades. Where a grant above the threshold is proposed, a further governance step is required - it must be approved at Cabinet level. This is an appropriate process in terms of governance. This already exists in the legislation regarding other categories of grant, including training and employment grants under the 1986 Act - for example, sections 25 and 28 - as amended. In other words, this financial threshold is not a departure. It is a governance process which has operated for a very long time.
State aid under EU frameworks is a separate matter. IDA Ireland supports consultancy for digitalisation under the business development programme. These grants are capped at €300,000 to comply with state aid rules. The business development programme is a scheme approved under section 8(c) of the Industrial Development Act 1993, rather than the 1986 Act. Such schemes are time-limited, burdensome and time-consuming to establish from an administrative perspective. The purpose of this new grant under the 1986 Act is to streamline these processes so enterprise agencies can act more dynamically in the area, cutting red tape as they develop client supports and compete for investment in a highly competitive international market.
Comment on this
I welcome former Member of this House, Deputy Sherlock, with a group from Cabra and Finglas who are here to remember a friend of theirs and a Labour Party activist, Margaret McKinley, who passed away during the summer. It is nice to have the former Senator back, even temporarily. Ar dheis Dé go raibh a h-anam dílis for Margaret. I acknowledge her and all her work for the Labour Party down through the years.
Comment on this
It is a good day for Labour Party activists. There has been progress. I very much welcome those who are here today.
The Minister of State is talking about the specific case scenarios that are envisaged. Is the development of technology for military purposes one of the use case scenarios that has been considered? She said these are being developed for a specific use. Is that one of the scenarios that has been looked at? If it is, can we have an example? If it is not, does the Minister of State believe it would be appropriate to put a specific exclusion in relation to military technology into that section? If it is one of the scenarios being looked at, in what circumstances is it envisaged that research on military technologies has to happen at such a speed that it is unduly burdensome for the Government to be consulted?
Comment on this
I am advised by the officials here that the enterprise agencies are subject to ministerial direction and overarching Government policy. They must be compliant with all applicable laws and regulations.
Furthermore, the enterprise agencies must exercise their statutory functions in a way that is consistent with the obligations of the Irish State under international law.
Comment on this
With respect, I asked three direct questions. We have been told that specific use case scenarios for this €7.5 million grant scheme have been envisaged. Given the specific scenarios that the Minister of State outlined in respect of climate, retrofitting and so forth, I am asking, in relation to technological innovation and digitalisation, whether potential military technologies were considered as one of the use case scenarios. With respect, I know the answer is telling us that, overall, these bodies answer to the Government. However, a choice is being made in this legislation to specifically remove a layer that required that were there to be investment in our promotion of military technologies, Enterprise Island or the IDA would have to check with the Government. Why is that layer being removed?
Comment on this
I want to be accurate in my answer to Senator Higgins, and I cannot give her that accuracy while I am on my feet here. I would need to liaise with the officials more closely and with the Minister, Deputy Burke. I have to stick to the line that we cannot accept the Senator’s amendments. To answer her specific question, I will come back to her on this.
Comment on this
I would like to ask one further question. Regarding the ethical and sustainable aspect specifically, I am wondering why those provisos seem to be an issue in terms of adding them in with technology and the areas of technology investment. I would like the Minister of State to comment on the digital sovereignty issue, which I specifically addressed, and whether she thinks that could or should be inserted as a specific area within digitalisation.
To come back to the question of investment in military technologies, it is a very simple thing. I accept that the Minister of State will engage with me on another occasion, but I want to flag now that I will be looking to put forward a specific exclusion of military technologies from the areas of potential investment with these grants. I do not want to be told on Report Stage, which is our final Stage, that there is a technical issue with how that amendment has been drafted, so I am signalling this now to the Minister of State. I will, of course, receive information from her as to whether military technologies are being envisaged as potential receivers of these €7.5 million grants. It is disturbing that a denial is not possible at this point, but I understand the Minister of State is seeking to be accurate.
As it stands, it is clear that they possibly can receive this. If that is possible, I will be sending to the Minister of State’s office language to explicitly exclude military technologies from these grants in relation to research. If there are technical issues with how that amendment is worded, I would appreciate it if the Minister of State’s officials could engage with me so we are clear that there is no technical issue and that it is purely going to be a decision, a matter of policy, on Report Stage as to whether the Government is facilitating the direction of public money towards military technologies while, as it does later in this Bill, removing the requirement that the promotion of military technologies requires Government approval. I look forward to that further engagement.
Comment on this
I am sure the Senator can appreciate that I am taking this Bill on behalf of the Minister, Deputy Peter Burke, and that is why I want to be accurate in my responses to her.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister of State for her engagement.
Comment on this
I have been informed by the officials that, increasingly, the Defence Forces have procurement needs related to the defence and security technologies required to protect the infrastructure on which our economy and prosperity depend. The landscape is changing, in terms of both the operational needs of the Defence Forces and the opportunities available for domestic and European funding. My ministerial colleagues and I have very clear priorities relating to defence, security and resilience opportunities, and streamlining these procedures facilitates that. The agencies remain subject to ministerial direction under the Industrial Development Acts. Deletion of section 8(5) of the 1987 Act, as proposed, will streamline the work of agencies in supporting the innovative SMEs and enterprises involved in cutting-edge technologies of strategic importance to Ireland, such as cybersecurity, which I know the Senator has a keen interest in, network defence, counter-drone technology, sensors, data analytics, hybrid threat monitoring and, of course, maritime surveillance.
The European Union is significantly expanding the scale and scope of initiatives such as these. The European competitiveness fund, expected to begin operation in 2028, will consolidate and build on the existing EU-level investment instruments designed to strengthen European industrial capability, including in relation to defensive technologies and space.
I fully accept the Senator’s bona fides on this. Our paths have crossed in relation to the AI office, and there is crossover between the two. As I said, I want to be accurate in my responses, so if the Senator can bear with me, we will refer to her specific questions after this discussion.
Comment on this
I look forward to engaging with the Minister of State on the specific questions on ethical, sustainable and digital sovereignty. I have no doubt she will engage - she has been very good at doing so - but we have our answer on the military technology. The answer is “Yes”. Frankly, this Government is trying to have it both ways. On the one hand, it refers to our procurement, our Defence Forces, our cybersecurity and all of these national interest pieces, but on the other hand, it is removing this. As I said, and want to say again, yes, of course, these bodies ultimately have oversight, but the point is that the Government is not choosing that. If these military technologies are of significant national strategic importance, be it to our own armed forces, to our cybersecurity, to the question of hybrid threats and all the rest, then they are of strategic national importance and require national oversight at every point.
The other thing we are hearing is that there is a lot of money out there. My question is this. If it is really about national oversight, national interest and all of these things we get told - we certainly get told about them in the frankly trumped-up piece of trying to remove our triple lock - or if it is really about strategic sovereignty and taking it all very seriously, then we would want to be looking at what kind of military technologies were being developed within Ireland. That is what a government that is serious about national strategic interests would be doing.
It does not have to remove the triple lock to do that, by the way. It already had that provision because we were a neutral country that took its neutrality very seriously and took these issues very seriously. What we are now seeing is a Government that does not want to take that seriously. It does not want to be responsible for it at all. It wants the money. It wants people making money from military technologies and it wants deniability on that. It is the exact opposite of a country stepping forward in a serious way in terms of sovereignty. It is trampling on the promises in respect of our active neutrality and our global work on disarmament. I was in Croke Park when Ireland secured a global ban on cluster bombs. This was the first country to sign the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. We have had a more positive impact in situations of conflict, as a neutral country that abides by the UN and has a triple lock in place, than many other countries across the world. Right now, there is a push to throw that away.
By the way, the little subtext here is that we will also throw away our work on disarmament because, now, the arms industry and military technologies are an opportunity.
There is all that EU money. By the way, the EU competitiveness fund is where they are putting things like the LIFE programme, which farmers up and down the coast here in Ireland have relied on. They are putting social cohesion and climate action in to compete against military technologies in that competitiveness fund, but that is where we seem to see an opportunity.
I want to be really frank. Sadly, the hunger for making money from military technologies predates the current push on the triple lock. It goes back to when the then Minister for Defence, Simon Coveney, spoke at an arms fair in the Aviva Stadium, which was the very first time an arms fair had been held in Ireland, and sent our naval ships to arms fairs. It was a scandal at the time, as it should have been, and it continues to be a scandal. That was well before Russia invaded Ukraine, by the way. I recall the same Minister tweeting at the time about a company manufacturing military ships, saying it was a company making waves. We should be very frank that there are those who are hungry to make money on the tools of death. I know this is the area of the Minister, Deputy Peter Burke, and not that of the Minister of State, Deputy Smyth. I hope the Minister will be here for Report Stage to answer these questions. It is a minimum that if we are funding the development of technologies that can be used to kill and maim more effectively, we would have the grant-issuing bodies check with the Government and that we would not specifically remove the section. I would like to know what the scenarios are that require the removal of that section. Do we need to invest in and promote military technology so quickly that the simple requirement to check with Government in relation to it is unduly burdensome red tape? That does not make a whit of sense. However, it does point to a deep contradiction.
I say this as somebody who is passionate about what Ireland has done in the world. I am incredibly proud of what Ireland has done for disarmament and accountability in relation to the arms industry globally, and now we do not even want accountability within our own State about our own money. No amount of changing-environment and new-opportunity language and whatever it says in that dreadful speech the Minister of State was given to read out justifies it. I mean no offence to the Minister of State, Deputy Smyth.
I will be pushing these amendments. I will be coming back with more amendments and I will specifically and explicitly be looking for military technologies to be excluded from this new grant scheme. I ask the Government to very strongly consider its hypocrisy in relation to this matter, especially in the context of the current triple lock debate.
Comment on this
I welcome the Minister of State. In relation to this section, I wish to echo some of the concerns highlighted by Senator Higgins. I have introduced an amendment which proposes:
Within 24 months of the commencement of this Act, the Minister shall produce a report detailing how IDA and other state agencies have supported dual-use, security, and defence projects following the passing of this Act.
I think it is clear that will form a component of this architecture in terms of what we are promoting. The amendment further states: "The report shall include information about which countries Ireland assisted with exports along with [relevant] economic analysis." The reason I submitted this amendment and want to discuss it is-----
Comment on this
I apologise for interrupting. I was not in the Chair when debate on this section started. The Cathaoirleach said to me at the beginning that, unfortunately, Senator Clonan did not move his amendment. Senator Clonan can speak to the wider piece at the end. Is that okay? I am not being awkward.
Comment on this
I absolutely understand. I apologise.
Comment on this
As I have said, I absolutely know where Senator Higgins is coming from. I know it is very heartfelt and coming from a very well-intentioned position. I do not wish to patronise that and I also wish to say the reason the Minister, Deputy Burke, is not here is because he has other Government business to attend to. It should not suggest in any way this is unimportant. I am sure he will be present for Report Stage. I will speak to the officials afterwards and ask them to be specific in writing to Senator Higgins in these responses.
At the beginning, I should have said that this Bill is specifically around defensive technologies and not offensive. Senator Higgins may say that is a mixing of words but, to me, there is a very different intention with that. The Bill will also allow the enterprise agencies to better support enterprises which play a role in strengthening our defence capability and, more broadly, the field of defence, security and resilience.
I am sure like me, Senators Higgins and Clonan, who may speak about it later, heard the news this morning about our primary schools. One in my county has been affected by a bomb threat. This is ringing through our heads. This is a very important debate and topic, and it crosses over so many of the debates we have had in the Dáil Chamber about the triple lock. I do understand Senator Higgins's concerns, and I know they are coming from a very well-intended place. However, to me, the difference between offensive and defensive is very important. We have to think about that, because it is what the Bill is specifically about.
It is about enterprises working in the field of defence, security and resilience, which is of critical strategic importance to Ireland in a rapidly changing global context. That is pretty obvious. As the Department of Defence has noted to me, the field of defensive technologies has developed to include areas such as cyberdefence, space domain awareness and maritime surveillance as well as hybrid threat monitoring. That covers everything the Department has requested. As I said, I can come back to Senator Higgins if she needs further detail.
Comment on this
We will be coming back to these topics in the next section, so I will not dwell on it. With respect, if it is strategic, it requires oversight, so why would we remove oversight? On the question of defence and offence, if we are talking about the technologies and how they can be used, it is very clear we are talking about military technologies. Simply hoping about how they might be used is not a policy.
Comment on this
Before I move to the next amendment, I welcome the guests of Senator Patricia Stephenson, who are European human rights students from Trinity College Dublin. They are very welcome to Seanad Éireann. I also welcome the guests of Deputy Michael Lowry. I assume they are from Tipperary. They are very welcome this afternoon.
We now move to amendment No. 5, which was already discussed with amendment No. 4.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 5, line 30, to delete “digitalisation” and substitute “digital sovereignty”.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 5, line 31, after “sustainability” to insert “, including just transition and nature-based solutions”.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 8, 9, 11 and 12 are related and may be discussed together. Is that agreed? Agreed.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 5, between lines 32 and 33, to insert the following:
"(2A) A consultancy grant granted under this section for the engagement of consultants to provide advice or studies shall not be made to an industrial undertaking involved in any activity of military relevance.".
These amendments address the same issue whereby the Bill is giving cover to pleading ignorance in respect of the funding of military technologies under this legislation. The Minister of State has said the provisions will give Enterprise Ireland and IDA Ireland flexible legal powers to move fast. She used the words "defence", "security" and "resilience".
Let us be clear that the technologies we are speaking about are military technologies that can be adapted to multiple purposes. It is not credible to suggest that funding technological military innovation is somehow separate from military activity. This is a Bill that has extraordinarily counter-intuitive - in fact, not just counter-intuitive but counterfactual - definitions for things like liquefied natural gas. This is another example of that. It is counterfactual to suggest, when we are talking about military function, that it is about supporting defence, security and resilience, which is a new mean-everything phrase. Perhaps "competitiveness" was not flying with the public, whereas "resilience" implies people have a stake in this. It is a word that is used for everything now.
The horrendous application of novelty military technologies in Gaza was framed by the Israeli Government under the auspices of defence. That is what it called it. The Israeli army is the Israel Defense Forces. I have raised multiple times in the House the issue of AI-assisted weapons technologies like Lavender, which creates kill lists, and Where's Daddy?, which alerts Israeli forces when targets have returned to their family home and initiates a killing that is triggered by a child's voice greeting his or her father with "Welcome home" or "Hello". The Gospel tool is accelerating the generation of physical strike locations.
More is required from us than saying, "Oh, isn't it terrible what is happening over there?". It was useful that when Ms Francesca Albanese was here, she was very clear and blunt in her words. Ireland is one of the largest trading partners with Israel in the world. In fact, I understand we are the second largest importer of Israeli goods and services, at a value of €3.8 billion in 2025. If it is just about chasing the money and the opportunities, it is not plausible or credible to suggest that we are not talking about deepening our already shameful links with the actions taking place in Gaza.
There are no guardrails here to ensure the money is not spent on the development of technologies that have military applications. If we look to the things the Government already could be doing, such as in terms of export licences, we see there has been a sevenfold increase in our export of dual-use technologies to Israel. That happened at a time that directly mapped onto the assault on Gaza. We are already exporting technologies. Sadly, the University of Galway, which is in the place I come from, is linking with the Technion - Israel Institute of Technology, which, in turn, has links to abusive military practices and technologies such as drones. There is already a distasteful - not just distasteful, indeed, but damaging and appalling - set of links there. We also know about the many recorded instances of weaponry being moved through Shannon Airport and directly or indirectly finding its way to Israel.
The Government has allowed all those compromises to take place. They are not just against international law but also very strongly against the will of the Irish people. Anytime a light gets shone on any one part of that complicity, the public is revulsed, reacts against it and, sometimes, a small door gets shut. There is a real question here as to why we are opening the door to another flow of money and, what is more, public money. We are not just being asked to continue turning a blind eye to the export of technologies, to what is happening through Shannon and to what some of the Horizon Europe partners and technology partners are doing in our underfunded universities, which are wrongly forced to make those kinds of compromises. With this Bill, the Government is also saying it now wants to create a mechanism for turning a blind eye to where the public's money is going. The rationale is a strategic rationale about the importance of our national defence, but the mechanism is something that will be used for moving money fast in a way that is separated from proper national oversight.
We will discuss later how the Minister is proposing to remove the Science and Technology Act 1987. Heretofore, and rightly so, that Act has required Government approval before any engagement with, or promotion of, activity of military relevance. That is what is being taken out. I know my colleague has amendments to this section, so there will perhaps be further opportunity to discuss this. As a serious neutral country, we have an explicit legislative provision that says Government approval is needed to engage with or promote activities of military relevance. That provision is being removed. How can the Government justify doing so? It cannot justify it on the basis of a strategic military importance argument. That does not stand up because if it is so important for our national security, more Government engagement, not less, would be desirable.
The only way it can be rationalised is that it creates deniability and allows more money to move in an unaccountable way. Having sat on the finance committee, I watched the Central Bank fail to act again and again as its representatives told us they are simply about the money and where the money moves and other matters are nothing to do with them. Meanwhile, the Government said it is really up to the Central Bank and that it was in charge of that bit when it came to the bonds. I do not want to be sitting here in three years' time with some Minister telling me it is so regrettable what Enterprise Ireland and IDA Ireland have done but, really, it was all within their purview. To be clear, the Government is not just removing the triple lock, which is our safeguard to ensure that Irish forces will only ever be engaged in military activity based on UN principles. It is also removing the safeguard that our money will only be used for military purposes with Government oversight. Removing that little safeguard here in this Bill has to cast a shadow over the attempt to remove the very large and significant safeguard represented by the triple lock.
Amendment No. 9 addresses the rebrand the Government is engaged in with the use of "defence, security or resilience industries". They are military industries and should be named as such. We have strong provisions, as I mentioned, in the Cluster Munitions and Anti-Personnel Mines Act 2008. Sections 13 and 14 of that Act explicitly state that public moneys shall not be invested directly or indirectly in munitions companies. I would like assurances as to exactly how the provisions in the 2008 Act are reflected in this Bill. Do they apply in this instance, and if so, how will they be applied and how will their application be checked, particularly when we do not have a scenario whereby Enterprise Ireland will be checking with the Government?
Amendment No. 11 seems to strengthen that. Amendment No. 12 also seeks to prohibit the awarding of consultancy grants to industrial undertakings that are involved in the development of lethal autonomous weapons. The Minister of State will be aware there are currently global negotiations happening next week around a potential prohibition and regulation of lethal autonomous weapons. I want to give credit to Ireland's disarmament unit, which has continued to do extraordinary positive and good work, sometimes undermined by other aspects of the Government. The disarmament unit within the Department of foreign affairs will be pushing for a strong regulation and strong action around autonomous lethal weapons. That discussion as to whether a new instrument will be created is happening next week.
What time is the debate to be adjourned?
Comment on this
Apologies. I will leave my others because I am very conscious Senator Clonan wanted to get in. I will just state that amendment No. 12 mentions lethal autonomous weapons. I have many more points but I will leave them as they are and pass to Senator Clonan. I believe his amendments related to the same section here.
Comment on this
I thank Senator Higgins. I will be very brief. In the broad sense, this legislation is passing at a moment in history. To give some context to that, the senior fellows at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace have said we are on the point with artificial intelligence - the Minister of State knows more about that than I do - of what they are calling a fourth industrial revolution. In that, they say one of its key features will be civil and military fusion. It will be very difficult to disentangle investment, development, innovation and so on to take out the dual-use systems. They will become almost indistinguishable from one another.
A number of years ago, the United States had a very small number of principal defence contractors in groups like Lockheed Martin, Boeing and Raytheon. During Trump's first presidency in 2016, and he has now accelerated it in the first two years of his second term, the US Secretary for war got Silicon Valley to disavow its previously neutral status. Silicon Valley was referred to as digital Switzerland. All of the big tech companies decided they would not get involved in dual-use or military applications. That changed in 2016 and now there has been a proliferation of military tech companies in what is now called the military tech gold rush. They include groups like Palantir, heading up by Peter Thiel, Anduril, headed up by Palmer Luckey, Helsing in Germany, Shield AI, Hermeus and Epirus. The programmes that Senator Higgins referred to, such as Where's Daddy, Lavender and Gospel, are being used to escalate and to lead to ever greater levels of lethality in places like Gaza and Lebanon. We are not remote from that because the absolute high-compute data they need is from hyperscaling data centres. The Israelis are actually reaching back into our data centres to scrape the internet for things like pizza deliveries, something ordered through Amazon or something on the equivalent of DoneDeal, to identify and geolocate members of Hezbollah. Some of those members, before the escalation, were told they would be killed. They were told they could go outside the apartment block and they would be killed there or if they wanted to remain in their apartments they would kill them and their family together. If they were travelling in a vehicle they might get a mobile phone call saying "if you step out of the vehicle onto the footpath we will kill you there, but if you insist in remaining in your car we will kill you in the car with your family." That kind of compute is facilitated not only by the number of data centres we have but the hyperscaling of the data and the internet scraping to facilitate these weapon systems. We have to be very careful that we understand or are able to quantify our level of involvement in this. That is why I had suggested the amendment, which I failed to move. It is not to point a finger at anybody or to suggest that there is any kind of a conspiracy. A lot of these things, unfortunately, in the rapid technological development it is organic to what is happening. I do not think anybody may have predicted this or planned to harness this but it is happening. We are one of the world's leading digital centres with so many multinationals headquartered here that have related to these. It is not a coincidence that Peter Thiel from Palantir and Palmer Luckey from Anduril hoped to bring the milltech, what they call the Dialog group, to the Powerscourt Hotel this autumn. They recognise that Ireland plays a principal role in this. I put those concerns on the record. In that amendment there was a suggestion that we might record or quantify the level of dual-use and military applications in which we are being involved.
Comment on this
They say every day is a learning day and this certainly has been today. I thank the Senators most sincerely for their amendments, interventions, observations and their very detailed research on these really important matters. The officials here have taken numerous notes on the requests and observations and I have no doubt they will be happy to engage with Senators into the future on this particular Bill.
Regarding amendments Nos. 8, 9, 11 and 12, concerning the new consultancy grant, I will not be accepting this amendments but I thank the Senators for their engagement on this aspect of the Bill. I have been very clear that the purpose of the consultancy grant is in relation to the green and digital transition. It is not appropriate or reasonable to attach a range of entirely unrelated conditionalities to grants aimed at specific defined purposes. These grants are designed to incentivise businesses to invest in actions that drive decarbonisation and incentivise businesses to invest in the enhancement of their digital maturity in a way that supports long-term job creation. They are aligned with this Government's goals as set out in the programme for Government to support quality jobs, mitigate climate change and drive competitiveness. Assessment of these grants should be sharply focused on the objectives. Adding an entirely unrelated conditionality serves no purpose rather than to confuse the approval process and would likely slow turnaround times when we are striving to achieve objectives in relation to climate targets and other matters.
As ministerial colleagues have also stated, this Government continues to support Irish-owned companies to grow and scale, along with providing direct investment towards each step of their decarbonisation journey. At the same time as global competition for foreign direct investment intensifies, Ireland needs to remain agile and ambitious to win investment. The purpose of the Bill is to support these objectives. Applying exceptionally unrelated conditions on targeted supports in a piecemeal manner is not coherent from a policy perspective. It undermines the ability of the enterprise agencies to carry out their mandate in relation to economic development in an efficient and timely matter. For that reason I will not be accepting the amendments.
However, as I said, it has been a very interesting debate. I appreciate the contributions of the Senators. It has certainly given me food for thought in my own role with digitalisation and AI. We talk about AI sovereignty quite a bit too but also about the more sinister aspect. "Sinister" is not the right word but as Senator Clonan said, it is about how these things are merging together perhaps with no specific agenda and it is very hard to disentangle the motivation of the technology as it develops. Gabhaim buíochas le gach éinne. I thank them for their contributions.
Comment on this
The debate is being adjourned, is it not?
Comment on this
We can come back to the final points and I look forward to engaging with the Minister in the interim period. I am sure Senator Clonan would be happy to as well. I thank the Minister of State for her engagement and also look forward to further engagement with the Minister, Deputy Burke, in relation to these matters.