Nithe i dtosach suíonna - Commencement Matters ›
Greyhound Industry
Senator Andrews called for an independent review and updated cost-benefit analysis, citing declining participation, outdated industry figures and inadequate accountability for State funding. Minister Heydon defended continued support for the sector, saying increased funding would be linked to welfare and integrity reforms, and that Greyhound Racing Ireland should lead an updated assessment of its economic contribution.
Last week, the Parliamentary Budget Office published a damning new report which raises serious questions about the justification for the continued funding of the Irish greyhound industry. This industry is completely reliant on State handouts, with public funding accounting for 45.9% of Greyhound Racing Ireland's revenue in 2024. Despite the hundreds of millions of euro gifted to the industry, racetrack attendances have plummeted and the visibility of the industry across the country has nearly faded away. Average attendances per meeting fell to just 235 during the period in question and the total number of people attending meets across the State has fallen dramatically.
The industry's figures tell the same story. Since 2011, industry reports have shown that attendances have fallen by 54% and jobs by 60%. The industry's estimate of its economic impact shows it has decreased by 53%. Over the same period, State funding has risen by a massive 71%. Every economic justification for Greyhound Racing Ireland's funding continues to rely almost exclusively on a 2021 report using data from 2019. The Government has stated that there are no plans to commission a new report.
Since 2019, the decline of the greyhound industry has clearly continued. The conditions have changed, yet the Government seems opposed to obtaining any new information on the current conditions in the industry. Even if the Government's intention was to better support and invest in the greyhound industry, surely the Minister would want a clear view of the realities on the ground. If accountability and efficiency are a priority, a blank cheque does not make sense. The Department of agriculture told the public accounts committee in November 2022 that it had never audited the 2021 Power report. No formal spending review of greyhound funding has ever been carried out. I find it extraordinary that so much money has been provided with no audit or review having been carried out.
The Government seems determined to keep its head in the sand when it comes to the future of the greyhound industry. It simply does not want to acknowledge the obvious fact that greyhound racing is cruelly operated, wildly unpopular and only succeeds in squandering taxpayers' money. The existing information shows a sector reliant on public funding, falling operating surpluses, persistent welfare concerns and a lack of a clear policy rationale.
The Parliamentary Budget Office report last week raises serious questions about whether there are sufficiently strong policy justifications for continued State support for the greyhound racing industry. Central to this lack of justification is the fact that the figures the State relies on are seven years old and come from a clearly biased and misleading report commissioned by Greyhound Racing Ireland. It is like getting the Garda to investigate gardaí. That does not work in any walk of life. Independent analysis of the report shows that the value of the industry was overstated by upwards of €60 million. This is a result of dogs outside the State being included in the calculation, dead and exported dogs not being excluded, the career length of racing greyhounds being overestimated and hare coursing being included in costings for breeding and rearing puppies.
The current State policy of unconditional funding for the greyhound industry undermines efforts to improve transparency and welfare standards or value for money in the industry.
It encourages waste and deception and it is doing nothing to build a sustainable and economically viable domestic industry. There is a clear need for an independent review of Greyhound Racing Ireland to assess its economic viability and provide some transparency as to how it is spending public money, as opposed to writing a blank cheque every single year with no expectation of accountability.
Comment on this
I thank the Senator for raising this matter. I welcome my newly elected colleague Senator McAdam to the Upper House. I have no doubt his contribution will be a great one. I congratulate him on his election.
An important pillar of Government policy is to ensure that the greyhound racing industry achieves its maximum potential and, in so doing, contributes to economic and social development over a wide geographic distribution. This funding is, of course, dependent on the sector meeting the highest standard of greyhound welfare and this objective underpins much of my Department's engagement with Rásaíocht Con Éireann, RCÉ.
RCÉ receives financial support from the State through the horse and greyhound racing fund. In budget 2027, a further €2.9 million has been allocated to the fund, bringing its total to €102 million. This funding is distributed in line with the Horse and Greyhound Racing Act 2001, with 80% allocated to Horse Racing Ireland, HRI, and 20% to RCÉ, meaning that, subject to Oireachtas approval, RCÉ will receive €20.4 million.
The report referenced by Senator Andrews is a recent publication from the Parliamentary Budget Office. The report made a number of useful points, which my Department will consider. In particular, it highlights the importance of continued progress on animal welfare and traceability to ensure the highest standards of greyhound welfare throughout the sector. I am acutely aware of the importance of greyhound welfare. Following a recommendation from the Committee of Public Accounts, my Department commissioned an independent review of our governance of the horse and greyhound racing fund. This included consideration of the efficacy of the fund in ensuring the highest standards of greyhound welfare. The review was carried out by Indecon International Economic and Strategic Consultants in 2025 and a copy of the final report has been sent to the Committee of Public Accounts.
One of the report's key recommendations is to increase, over the medium term, the share of the fund ring-fenced for welfare purposes. The proposed increase under the fund to RCÉ will be linked to the implementation of the recommendations contained in the Indecon review in respect of greyhound welfare and integrity. This will form part of my Department's overall animal welfare package and is in line with the programme for Government commitments on greyhound welfare and with RCÉ's own strategic plan. My Department is engaging with RCÉ to implement this and other recommendations contained within the report.
The Parliamentary Budget Office report also highlights the sector's reliance on public funding, which is already well understood by the Government. The State supports RCÉ and HRI in a whole host of areas and activities because of the economic value of those activities in rural areas and to support what are strong social, cultural and pursuits in rural areas and beyond. The reality is that the industry requires Government support to remain viable but it is not unusual in that regard. There are many instances where the State provides interventions and supports. I have in mind, for example, Horse Sport Ireland and the challenges it is going through right now in respect of showjumping, dressage and three-day eventing. We all get very excited when Irish athletes compete in those sports at the Olympic Games. Horse Sport Ireland, like RCÉ, is in a position of being dependent on State funding and we see the viability challenges it faces. RCÉ is not unusual in needing State funding; it is not the only body in that position. The Government supports it for very good reasons. I can say more about that in my supplementary reply.
This is a sector that is very important to a lot of people across rural Ireland. The Government has been very clear in its support for the sector, as set out in the programme for Government, and I followed through on that in the most recent budget.
Comment on this
I thank the Minister. He mentioned important pillars of Government policy. I would say that transparency and accountability are important pillars. An organisation receiving €19 million or €20 million every year from the State should have a workable, clear, transparent and sustainable plan of operation. That is clearly not the case without a massive injection of Government funding.
The Parliamentary Budget Office report has called for an updated cost-benefit analysis of the economic and financial impacts of Greyhound Racing Ireland's activities to be commissioned by an independent body. I would be grateful if the Minister would confirm whether he will support an independent review or if he thinks taxpayers should simply continue to take the organisation's word for everything and the Government should continue to give it a blank cheque. Its animal welfare record is lamentable and shocking, as shown by the number of greyhounds killed every single year. It is completely unacceptable. The talk about welfare is nonsense. There must be some sort of accountability on the part of Greyhound Racing Ireland. It is just unacceptable that it receives a cheque every year but is never audited. The Government talks about making sure taxpayers' money is spent right. This is not a case of money being spent right.
Comment on this
Government funding includes the provision of financial support to the Irish Retired Greyhound Trust and to a programme for the rehoming of greyhounds. It is also worth noting that RCÉ allocated €4.2 million in 2025-----
Comment on this
The organisation is grossly inefficient.
Comment on this
-----towards traceability, care and welfare matters. A total of 2,636 welfare inspections were conducted in 2025 and up to the end of October, 67,611 greyhounds were subject to traceability checks. These are important activities that necessitate Government funding.
The Senator asked about future analysis. The Parliamentary Budget Office report points towards the need for an independent, objective cost-benefit analysis as an update to the Power report. RCÉ is the statutory body responsible for the oversight and development of the sector and I expect it to take the lead in addressing the need for an updated assessment of the sector's economic contribution. I understand that RCÉ is currently considering how best to give effect to that recommendation.